Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Phillip schofield scandal is homophobia?

913 replies

ivfregret · 01/06/2023 00:00

Have I missed something in that the guy Philip had the affair with was not a minor?

He was a minor when they met, as was Cheryl Cole and Liam Payne for example and no one has anything bad to say about that relationship.

I'm not sticking up for Philip and really dislike him, and also think even if the runner was above the age of consent is most definitely questionable behaviour but I can't help think of it was a heterosexual affair it would not be treated in the same way?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:06

It's safe to say that a high profile celebrity could also hold major influence over a young persons career and future development

So could literally anyone on any job.

Doesnt mean they go on the Position of Trust list.

I think you are really misunderstanding what that list is about and why certain professions/positions are included on it.

Weallgottachangesometime · 03/06/2023 23:04

I don’t think it’s homophobia that has drawn more attention to it, I think it’s the fact it was seemingly known by so many for so long and attempted to be covered, that has drawn more attention.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:04

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:01

Policy paperPositions of trust: Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 factsheet

1. What are we going to do?

We are extending the “position of trust” offences within ss 16 – 19 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 to include situations where certain activities take place in a sport or religion.
The “position of trust” offences are intended to target situations where the child has some dependency on the adult involved, often combined with an element of vulnerability of the child. Existing positions of trust are directed at those who are employed to look after children under the age of 18, for example those providing care for a child in a residential care home, hospital or educational institution.
Concerns had been voiced in Parliament and society more widely that the current positions of trust were too narrow, and that an extension to them was required to protect a wider range of relationships where adults held a position of influence or power over 16 and 17 year olds.
The further positions of trust were drafted following a Ministry of Justice (MoJ) review which engaged with stakeholders across the youth and criminal justice sectors, including the police, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), sports bodies, victims’ groups, and religious organisations.
Together with the further positions of trust that have been drafted we are intending to include provisions in the Act to allow additional positions of trust to be added via secondary legislation should that prove necessary.

Maybe legally they haven't got around to including celebrities, casting couch type things because the stories that have made the news have been historic.

4.3 Q: Why only those individuals who coach, teach, train, supervise or instruct in a sport or a religion? Did you consider expanding the further “positions of trust” to cover other specific situations?

Those who carry out certain activities in a sport or religion are particularly influential over a child’s development. For example, sports coaches have unique opportunities for physical contact, and can hold major influence over a young person’s career and future development. Similarly, those who carry out certain activities in a religion often have significant influence over a young person’s spiritual and religious development, often against a background of emotional vulnerability or immaturity. Both situations also have very high levels of trust, influence, power and authority and (particularly in the case of those involved in a religion) these figures are well established, trusted and respected in the community.

It's safe to say that a high profile celebrity could also hold major influence over a young persons career and future development, and that in a case such as this there are high levels of influence, power and authority and that the figure is well established, trusted and respected.

So just because the law hasn't got round to it criminalising it when it comes to certain roles it doesn't make it any better.

Also in regards to what you said about twitter, no giving someone advice doesn't automatically mean there was a breach of trust, but giving someone advice on twitter could have had a sinister motive.

The barrel scarping continues.

PS does not work with children in a role that requires safeguarding scrutiny. There will be a safeguarding type person at TM but it ain’t him. tab shows don’t tend to have people educationist or caring for children so I’d be amazed if TV presenters - who spend abo it 5 minutes a day opposite a dozen different people’ ever came onto the ‘Positions lf Trust’ list.

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:01

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:51

Position of trust' is a legal term defined in the Sexual Offences Act 2003. In section 22 it is explained as an adult “caring for, training, supervising or being in sole charge” of a child under the age of 18.

That PS says he was giving advice to him on twitter and mentoring of him sorts, consent at the age of 16 wouldn’t have applied

My god the barrel scraping is deafening me.

Giving someone advice on Twitter is not being in a professional or legal Position of Trust. Those people are those who work directly to care for children - teachers, care home workers, foster carers, social workers etc. not someone randomly tweeting.

Policy paperPositions of trust: Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 factsheet

1. What are we going to do?

We are extending the “position of trust” offences within ss 16 – 19 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 to include situations where certain activities take place in a sport or religion.
The “position of trust” offences are intended to target situations where the child has some dependency on the adult involved, often combined with an element of vulnerability of the child. Existing positions of trust are directed at those who are employed to look after children under the age of 18, for example those providing care for a child in a residential care home, hospital or educational institution.
Concerns had been voiced in Parliament and society more widely that the current positions of trust were too narrow, and that an extension to them was required to protect a wider range of relationships where adults held a position of influence or power over 16 and 17 year olds.
The further positions of trust were drafted following a Ministry of Justice (MoJ) review which engaged with stakeholders across the youth and criminal justice sectors, including the police, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), sports bodies, victims’ groups, and religious organisations.
Together with the further positions of trust that have been drafted we are intending to include provisions in the Act to allow additional positions of trust to be added via secondary legislation should that prove necessary.

Maybe legally they haven't got around to including celebrities, casting couch type things because the stories that have made the news have been historic.

4.3 Q: Why only those individuals who coach, teach, train, supervise or instruct in a sport or a religion? Did you consider expanding the further “positions of trust” to cover other specific situations?

Those who carry out certain activities in a sport or religion are particularly influential over a child’s development. For example, sports coaches have unique opportunities for physical contact, and can hold major influence over a young person’s career and future development. Similarly, those who carry out certain activities in a religion often have significant influence over a young person’s spiritual and religious development, often against a background of emotional vulnerability or immaturity. Both situations also have very high levels of trust, influence, power and authority and (particularly in the case of those involved in a religion) these figures are well established, trusted and respected in the community.

It's safe to say that a high profile celebrity could also hold major influence over a young persons career and future development, and that in a case such as this there are high levels of influence, power and authority and that the figure is well established, trusted and respected.

So just because the law hasn't got round to it criminalising it when it comes to certain roles it doesn't make it any better.

Also in regards to what you said about twitter, no giving someone advice doesn't automatically mean there was a breach of trust, but giving someone advice on twitter could have had a sinister motive.

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 23:00

You're arguing semantics but what's been going on there is more than what's out there at the moment.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 22:59

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:53

No you claimed it was brought in for 16yo a to have sex with people their age. It wasn’t.

No… I claimed it was brought in to align it with laws applying to heterosexuals - it’s right there in black and white. Upthread. I’ve posted it twice.

So that, like heterosexuals, homosexuals could have consenting sex with people the same age. Not so that they would be fair game for people old enough to their parent or grandparent.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:57

‘Position of trust’ is a legal term defined in the Sexual Offences Act 2003. In section 22 it is explained as an adult “caring for, training, supervising or being in sole charge” of a child under the age of 18.
This Act defines settings in which adults would have a position of trust e.g. hospital or an educational institution (section 21). It does not include a list of roles, but examples include:

  • Teachers
  • Care workers
  • Youth justice workers
  • Social workers
  • Doctors

Sexual Offences Act 2003

An Act to make new provision about sexual offences, their prevention and the protection of children from harm from other sexual acts, and for connected purposes.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/section/22

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:56

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 22:54

In the workplace at This Morning PS would arguably be in a position of trust over runners who are the lowest paid and lowest down the food chain on a production team.

In legal terms that’s absolutely not what a position of trust is.

TM does not care for children.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:55

MilitantMommyBFArmy4Life · 03/06/2023 22:26

But there’s no evidence at all it was grooming or that it was illegal.

There's no evidence because nobody's bothered to investigate the claims until now.

And Phil insists it was "legal" (over 16).

Who is investigating? Not the police, as no one had complained. Just some arsehole YTers and dodgy journalists with a track record of bullying. Because in all likelihood it was just a big age gap relationship and nothing more

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 22:54

In the workplace at This Morning PS would arguably be in a position of trust over runners who are the lowest paid and lowest down the food chain on a production team.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:53

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 22:21

Actually it was lowered to 16 in 2001 to that of the heterosexual age after campaigners and MPs brought a challenge proving it was discrimination to keep it higher for gay people.

Er, yes, that was exactly what I said in my first response to your post about the lowered age of consent….? Confused

Here’s my post again:

OK, but that’s to bring it in line with the age of consent for heterosexuals - and so that 16YOs can have consenting sex with other 16YOs?

No you claimed it was brought in for 16yo a to have sex with people their age. It wasn’t.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:51

Position of trust' is a legal term defined in the Sexual Offences Act 2003. In section 22 it is explained as an adult “caring for, training, supervising or being in sole charge” of a child under the age of 18.

That PS says he was giving advice to him on twitter and mentoring of him sorts, consent at the age of 16 wouldn’t have applied

My god the barrel scraping is deafening me.

Giving someone advice on Twitter is not being in a professional or legal Position of Trust. Those people are those who work directly to care for children - teachers, care home workers, foster carers, social workers etc. not someone randomly tweeting.

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 22:47

Did you notice in his interview with the BBC he said "Holly knows everything about me and I know everything about Holly" - is that some kind of veiled threat?

With his brother being convicted of sexual offences the heat around these rumours online became too much and it had to be addressed.

For those comparing Boris and Carrie - for me the key differences are:

  • Carrie was an adult when they met, MM was a child
  • Boris and Carrie met coincidentally at work, Carrie already had a successful career. MM was given his first job because of Phil
  • Phil was exchanging social media messages with a child who he coincidentally ended up in a sexual relationship with after he helped him onto a career ladder out of the goodness of his heart
CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 22:37

Phillip Schofield has form for lying, lying, covering up and lying again. There is no reason why anyone should accept anything he says as truth now.

Clearly the reason this has come to a head now is because Holly Willoughby doesn’t like him anymore, can’t look him in the face, and therefore cannot share a sofa with him any longer.

Therefore, them co-presenting This Morning was no longer tenable. One of them had to go.

We can all be left to wonder why Holly Willoughby - long-time confidante and friend - doesn’t like him any more.

I mean, it’s such a mystery since he hasn’t actually done anything wrong!?

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 22:29

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 03/06/2023 22:19

I agree he's been villified beyond what he should. Is what he did morally right? No.

Just to point out, there is a 23 year age gap between Boris and Carrie Johnson. He was married to his second wife when they started their affair (think she was end of her 20's), and she was a conservative party member. Do you not think he's had a big impact on her career? He wasn't villified at all, in fact he went on to become Prime Minister!

Unfortunately older male boss and very young female apprentice affair is a tale as old as time. None of them are right of course, but I have no idea why this one is getting the level of attention and vitriol it has.

Because people don't believe his version of events, that's why.

MilitantMommyBFArmy4Life · 03/06/2023 22:26

But there’s no evidence at all it was grooming or that it was illegal.

There's no evidence because nobody's bothered to investigate the claims until now.

And Phil insists it was "legal" (over 16).

Billyho · 03/06/2023 22:25

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 03/06/2023 22:19

I agree he's been villified beyond what he should. Is what he did morally right? No.

Just to point out, there is a 23 year age gap between Boris and Carrie Johnson. He was married to his second wife when they started their affair (think she was end of her 20's), and she was a conservative party member. Do you not think he's had a big impact on her career? He wasn't villified at all, in fact he went on to become Prime Minister!

Unfortunately older male boss and very young female apprentice affair is a tale as old as time. None of them are right of course, but I have no idea why this one is getting the level of attention and vitriol it has.

Because not all of us agree with normalising older male v younger female grooming.

you might, but that doesn’t make it right.

So therefore we’re not having more vitriol on this one, it’s the same as any decent person would on the males v female grooming, but many people don’t view that as bad.

ProfessorXtra · 03/06/2023 22:23

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 03/06/2023 22:19

I agree he's been villified beyond what he should. Is what he did morally right? No.

Just to point out, there is a 23 year age gap between Boris and Carrie Johnson. He was married to his second wife when they started their affair (think she was end of her 20's), and she was a conservative party member. Do you not think he's had a big impact on her career? He wasn't villified at all, in fact he went on to become Prime Minister!

Unfortunately older male boss and very young female apprentice affair is a tale as old as time. None of them are right of course, but I have no idea why this one is getting the level of attention and vitriol it has.

Actually, on social media he was. However she was an actual adult when they met. That said it’s is a concerning dynamic.

However, people are less shocked when it’s an older man and a younger woman (as has been mentioned above) is because it’s more common and accepted. Abuse of power, when the woman is on the recovering end is accepted because of misogyny. That’s why less people care when it’s a younger, impressionable female.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 22:21

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:12

Actually it was lowered to 16 in 2001 to that of the heterosexual age after campaigners and MPs brought a challenge proving it was discrimination to keep it higher for gay people.

As for the the rest of your post - well it’s the whole point of what you were saying isn’t it. It’s dodgy and inappropriate (and indeed very ‘unwise’) but it wasn’t illegal. Calls for police action are just ridiculous. A man behaves immorally to his wife is wrong but it’s no one business but theirs. People are acting like they’ve been personally slighted.

Actually it was lowered to 16 in 2001 to that of the heterosexual age after campaigners and MPs brought a challenge proving it was discrimination to keep it higher for gay people.

Er, yes, that was exactly what I said in my first response to your post about the lowered age of consent….? Confused

Here’s my post again:

OK, but that’s to bring it in line with the age of consent for heterosexuals - and so that 16YOs can have consenting sex with other 16YOs?

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 03/06/2023 22:19

I agree he's been villified beyond what he should. Is what he did morally right? No.

Just to point out, there is a 23 year age gap between Boris and Carrie Johnson. He was married to his second wife when they started their affair (think she was end of her 20's), and she was a conservative party member. Do you not think he's had a big impact on her career? He wasn't villified at all, in fact he went on to become Prime Minister!

Unfortunately older male boss and very young female apprentice affair is a tale as old as time. None of them are right of course, but I have no idea why this one is getting the level of attention and vitriol it has.

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 22:19

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:12

Actually it was lowered to 16 in 2001 to that of the heterosexual age after campaigners and MPs brought a challenge proving it was discrimination to keep it higher for gay people.

As for the the rest of your post - well it’s the whole point of what you were saying isn’t it. It’s dodgy and inappropriate (and indeed very ‘unwise’) but it wasn’t illegal. Calls for police action are just ridiculous. A man behaves immorally to his wife is wrong but it’s no one business but theirs. People are acting like they’ve been personally slighted.

Under UK Law would it not be considered grooming if all of the 'grooming' took place when the child was under 18 and the sexual contact occurred afterwards?

I think people want it investigated to see if there were inappropriate messages etc when the boy was under 16.

It's not ridiculous. Especially consider his brother has now been convicted. And Phil knew about it.

ProfessorXtra · 03/06/2023 22:18

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:03

I didn’t say it was, but people are claiming PS waited until this guy was 18 so he was legal. Which is ridiculous

I am not sure it’s quite that clear cut

Position of trust' is a legal term defined in the Sexual Offences Act 2003. In section 22 it is explained as an adult “caring for, training, supervising or being in sole charge” of a child under the age of 18.

That PS says he was giving advice to him on twitter and mentoring of him sorts, consent at the age of 16 wouldn’t have applied.

I don’t particularly believe PS was sat waiting for years for this man to come of age. But consent being 16, isn’t always applicable. Besides which, even if it’s legal, doesn’t make it right. I have no idea when PS decided he was going to sleep with this young man. I don’t think it was when he was under 18. But it’s clear PS was in a position of power when it happened. May not be illegal. But definitely creep and wrong in my opinion.

I am really shocked that no one at any point (agent, ITV, lawyer, family) etc didn’t point out that following a teenager and sending them messages wasn’t the best idea. Forget what came after. But I can’t think of a single good reason why someone, especially, a celebrity would put themselves in that position.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:13

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 22:11

But by all means keeping playing devil’s advocate and trying to justify immoral behaviour. It’s interesting and fascinating watch you twist and turn.

I’m not justifying anything.

It was immoral.

But there’s no evidence at all it was grooming or that it was illegal.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:12

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 22:07

Well, of course 60YOs can have sex with 16YOs, it’s now perfectly legal - but it wasn’t the reason for, nor intent behind, lowering the age of consent.

Cheating on your spouse is perfectly legal.

Financially and emotionally abusing your spouse if perfectly legal.

Being a bully in the workplace is perfectly legal.

Being 58 and sleeping with a 16YO is perfectly legal.

Just don’t be the least bit surprised and go whining when people en mass judge you, and reject you, on the basis of those behaviours.

Actually it was lowered to 16 in 2001 to that of the heterosexual age after campaigners and MPs brought a challenge proving it was discrimination to keep it higher for gay people.

As for the the rest of your post - well it’s the whole point of what you were saying isn’t it. It’s dodgy and inappropriate (and indeed very ‘unwise’) but it wasn’t illegal. Calls for police action are just ridiculous. A man behaves immorally to his wife is wrong but it’s no one business but theirs. People are acting like they’ve been personally slighted.

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 22:12

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 22:03

I didn’t say it was, but people are claiming PS waited until this guy was 18 so he was legal. Which is ridiculous

I think a lot of people mean legal and technically an adult...so that it wouldn't look as bad if it got out, so that he could say he was an adult when he slept with him.