Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Phillip schofield scandal is homophobia?

913 replies

ivfregret · 01/06/2023 00:00

Have I missed something in that the guy Philip had the affair with was not a minor?

He was a minor when they met, as was Cheryl Cole and Liam Payne for example and no one has anything bad to say about that relationship.

I'm not sticking up for Philip and really dislike him, and also think even if the runner was above the age of consent is most definitely questionable behaviour but I can't help think of it was a heterosexual affair it would not be treated in the same way?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:31

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:27

Even though YOU named the legal list?

I don’t actually think we should believe all adults are in a position of trust and that’s a dangerous precedent to set.

It is the precedent already fgs 😂

There are laws against grooming for example because ALL adults are in a position of power over children.

And YOU named the list. I just added to it and said sports coaches etc had been included since then, and to explain how most people see this as similar.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:30

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:28

OMG, I know.

You’re the one getting hung up on legalities.

PS has fallen from grace not because he necessarily did anything illegal (although we don’t yet know that for a fact) - but because he did something wrong.

It wasn’t me who brought up the legal argument FFS.

But I agree. He will never work again.

Lucky for him he isn’t some up and coming 25yo, he’s close to retirement age and absolutely loaded so I’m sure he will be fine.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:29

MilitantMommyBFArmy4Life · 03/06/2023 23:26

Who is investigating? Not the police, as no one had complained. Just some arsehole YTers and dodgy journalists with a track record of bullying. Because in all likelihood it was just a big age gap relationship and nothing more

ITV are supposed to investigate and at have no idea if there's more because they haven't investigated anything.

Phillip looked shifty as hell, gave rambling answers and generally looked like a deer in the headlights. Way too early to rule out anything else.

It could be that the remains started at 18 not 20 or the sex was more than 5-6 times.

agree that GB news and others are absolutely loving this. They are riding this for all it's worth. Back to back former colleagues and guests speaking out. Usually rambling about sobering other than the events in question (Phillip was rude to me back in 2018 etc.)

I don’t really know what ITV will investigate except their own dishonesty and public lies.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:28

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:26

The involvement being meeting and following on Twitter? That’s not illegal.

OMG, I know.

You’re the one getting hung up on legalities.

PS has fallen from grace not because he necessarily did anything illegal (although we don’t yet know that for a fact) - but because he did something wrong.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:28

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:26

For God’s sake, once again, @LifeIsPainHighness - ALL adults are ethically and morally in a position of trust.

That’s not what we are talks about though - this has stemmed from a PP suggesting PS has broken the law under the Sexual Offences Act 2002 because it could be argued he was in a legal Position of Trust.

And again I don’t think all adults are in a position of trust at all and find it baffling others think they are

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:27

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:25

No.
I'm saying that all adults are in a position of trust with minors and there is a potential for abuse of that position of power regardless of job or profession or whatever capacity that the adult meets the child in.

Not that they're on the specified legal list.

Even though YOU named the legal list?

I don’t actually think we should believe all adults are in a position of trust and that’s a dangerous precedent to set.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:26

For God’s sake, once again, @LifeIsPainHighness - ALL adults are ethically and morally in a position of trust.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:26

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:25

He was a minor when they met and began any sort of involvement together.

The involvement being meeting and following on Twitter? That’s not illegal.

MilitantMommyBFArmy4Life · 03/06/2023 23:26

Who is investigating? Not the police, as no one had complained. Just some arsehole YTers and dodgy journalists with a track record of bullying. Because in all likelihood it was just a big age gap relationship and nothing more

ITV are supposed to investigate and at have no idea if there's more because they haven't investigated anything.

Phillip looked shifty as hell, gave rambling answers and generally looked like a deer in the headlights. Way too early to rule out anything else.

It could be that the remains started at 18 not 20 or the sex was more than 5-6 times.

agree that GB news and others are absolutely loving this. They are riding this for all it's worth. Back to back former colleagues and guests speaking out. Usually rambling about sobering other than the events in question (Phillip was rude to me back in 2018 etc.)

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:25

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:22

You don't think he did anything illegal because you're believing his version of events. Many of the rest of us do not believe his version of events.

Actually that’s exactly what it means - if organisations require no safeguarding scrutiny of children then that’s because they don’t hold the same kind of power over children. Safeguarding isn’t randomised, it’s implemented carefully to organisations that have a duty of care to children. TM is not one of those.

That's just ridiculous. Any adult could potentially have that kind of power over children for various reasons, fame, charisma etc. but you think 'oh they're not on the list therefore it's not possible for any abuse of power'.

Er - both those professions are specific led positions of trust and are in no way comparable to being a TV presenter

The wrong example but you should understand what I mean regardless.

I don’t understand what you mean at all, and I don’t think you understand what a Position of Trust even is and why it doesn’t actually apply to every adult.

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:25

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:18

‘Where are you going with this’

😂

YOU are the one suggesting PS was legally in a Position of Trust. I’m arguing that he was categorically not.

I’m not ‘going’ anywhere with it, I’m explaining why your argument that he’s in the same position as a teacher is a load of old shite.

No.
I'm saying that all adults are in a position of trust with minors and there is a potential for abuse of that position of power regardless of job or profession or whatever capacity that the adult meets the child in.

Not that they're on the specified legal list.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:25

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:24

The runner want a minor.

We are not talking about ethics but about the legal term for a position of trust as defined by the Sexual Offences Act 2002

He was a minor when they met and began any sort of involvement together.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:24

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:22

ALL adults are in a position of trust (small ‘p’, small ‘t’), even if they’re not in a Position of Trust, when it come to minors. That’s not up for debate.

Or, at least, I didn’t think it was….

The runner want a minor.

We are not talking about ethics but about the legal term for a position of trust as defined by the Sexual Offences Act 2002

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:23

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 23:20

The Position of Trust is not related to their job, (eg accountant) it's more about the relationship and contact an influential adult could have over a young person. So an employer or influential boss/ mentor like PS would be arguably a position of trust over a young employee.

Of course it’s related to their job/volunteering position. What did you think it was related to?! Unless an accountant was volunteering with children in their spare time why on Earth would they be in a Position of Trust.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 03/06/2023 23:22

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:18

‘Where are you going with this’

😂

YOU are the one suggesting PS was legally in a Position of Trust. I’m arguing that he was categorically not.

I’m not ‘going’ anywhere with it, I’m explaining why your argument that he’s in the same position as a teacher is a load of old shite.

ALL adults are in a position of trust (small ‘p’, small ‘t’), even if they’re not in a Position of Trust, when it come to minors. That’s not up for debate.

Or, at least, I didn’t think it was….

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:22

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:14

I don’t think what he did wasn’t bad.

I just don’t think he did anything illegal and this desperation to label him a pedophile is bizarre.

I also think it’s absolutely barrel scraping to suggest he held the same power as a teacher or youth worker because he followed someone on Twitter and gave them advice.

Just because it doesn't require safeguarding scrutiny does not mean that there's no risk or that no abuse of position of power can take place. It's not that difficult to understand.

Actually that’s exactly what it means - if organisations require no safeguarding scrutiny of children then that’s because they don’t hold the same kind of power over children. Safeguarding isn’t randomised, it’s implemented carefully to organisations that have a duty of care to children. TM is not one of those.

It's not less bad if an adult who wasn't in a (specified) position of trust grooms or abuses a child.

Sports coach is on the list. Guitar teacher isn't. The guitar teacher could still exploit a vulnerable child.

Er - both those professions are specific led positions of trust and are in no way comparable to being a TV presenter

You don't think he did anything illegal because you're believing his version of events. Many of the rest of us do not believe his version of events.

Actually that’s exactly what it means - if organisations require no safeguarding scrutiny of children then that’s because they don’t hold the same kind of power over children. Safeguarding isn’t randomised, it’s implemented carefully to organisations that have a duty of care to children. TM is not one of those.

That's just ridiculous. Any adult could potentially have that kind of power over children for various reasons, fame, charisma etc. but you think 'oh they're not on the list therefore it's not possible for any abuse of power'.

Er - both those professions are specific led positions of trust and are in no way comparable to being a TV presenter

The wrong example but you should understand what I mean regardless.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:22

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 23:18

All of the charities PS was associated with have dropped him as a patron.

They’d be fools to keep him on. He had an inappropriate relationship, he has a nonce brother whose crimes he knew about and he’s an adulterer. They don’t just cut criminals loose, they cut people loose who will damage their image.

Though I thought it was rich for the Prince’s Trust to drop him when the RF roll out Uncle Andrew again and again.

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 23:20

The Position of Trust is not related to their job, (eg accountant) it's more about the relationship and contact an influential adult could have over a young person. So an employer or influential boss/ mentor like PS would be arguably a position of trust over a young employee.

WoolyAndYug · 03/06/2023 23:18

All of the charities PS was associated with have dropped him as a patron.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:18

‘Where are you going with this’

😂

YOU are the one suggesting PS was legally in a Position of Trust. I’m arguing that he was categorically not.

I’m not ‘going’ anywhere with it, I’m explaining why your argument that he’s in the same position as a teacher is a load of old shite.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:16

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:11

Do you think that only people who are on the position of trust list have obligations and can be the only ones who can abuse children?

Or where are you going with this?

I'm not misunderstanding anything.

<Bangs head against brick wall>

Did I say that?

I’ll try and say this in simple terms - do you understand why specific people are in a Position of Trust like a teacher and not for example an accountant?

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:15

In terms of patronages, charities will DBS check patrons. It’s of course not fool proof, as is the case with any DBS checks, but it’s the closest thing to ensuring safeguarding protocols are correctly observed and children are protected.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:14

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:09

It's not barrel scraping.
You are just trying to find technicalities to make what he did sound less bad.

Just because it doesn't require safeguarding scrutiny does not mean that there's no risk or that no abuse of position of power can take place. It's not that difficult to understand.

It's not less bad if an adult who wasn't in a (specified) position of trust grooms or abuses a child.

Sports coach is on the list. Guitar teacher isn't. The guitar teacher could still exploit a vulnerable child.

I don’t think what he did wasn’t bad.

I just don’t think he did anything illegal and this desperation to label him a pedophile is bizarre.

I also think it’s absolutely barrel scraping to suggest he held the same power as a teacher or youth worker because he followed someone on Twitter and gave them advice.

Just because it doesn't require safeguarding scrutiny does not mean that there's no risk or that no abuse of position of power can take place. It's not that difficult to understand.

Actually that’s exactly what it means - if organisations require no safeguarding scrutiny of children then that’s because they don’t hold the same kind of power over children. Safeguarding isn’t randomised, it’s implemented carefully to organisations that have a duty of care to children. TM is not one of those.

It's not less bad if an adult who wasn't in a (specified) position of trust grooms or abuses a child.

Sports coach is on the list. Guitar teacher isn't. The guitar teacher could still exploit a vulnerable child.

Er - both those professions are specific led positions of trust and are in no way comparable to being a TV presenter

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:11

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:06

It's safe to say that a high profile celebrity could also hold major influence over a young persons career and future development

So could literally anyone on any job.

Doesnt mean they go on the Position of Trust list.

I think you are really misunderstanding what that list is about and why certain professions/positions are included on it.

Do you think that only people who are on the position of trust list have obligations and can be the only ones who can abuse children?

Or where are you going with this?

I'm not misunderstanding anything.

Boomshock · 03/06/2023 23:09

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:04

The barrel scarping continues.

PS does not work with children in a role that requires safeguarding scrutiny. There will be a safeguarding type person at TM but it ain’t him. tab shows don’t tend to have people educationist or caring for children so I’d be amazed if TV presenters - who spend abo it 5 minutes a day opposite a dozen different people’ ever came onto the ‘Positions lf Trust’ list.

It's not barrel scraping.
You are just trying to find technicalities to make what he did sound less bad.

Just because it doesn't require safeguarding scrutiny does not mean that there's no risk or that no abuse of position of power can take place. It's not that difficult to understand.

It's not less bad if an adult who wasn't in a (specified) position of trust grooms or abuses a child.

Sports coach is on the list. Guitar teacher isn't. The guitar teacher could still exploit a vulnerable child.