Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shared ownership as an option for the ‘squeezed middle’

84 replies

lousong · 31/05/2023 17:29

We’re in our 20s trying to start out
For some reason shared ownership works out as cheaper than buying on the open market but we’ve been warned against it because of the fact you’d be buying a leasehold property
Our wages are likely to go up in the future but not anytime soon. Some lovely shared ownership 3 bedroom houses have come up locally. The area is convenient, family orientated and safe, and house prices are rising in this area quite fast (so would likely gain equity). We are going to struggle to purchase outright - we would meet repayments but it would be very tight and to the limit of the stress test. We would be paying about 500-550 mortgage a month and 250 rent. Could it be worth it to gain equity? It’s unlikely to be a house we could stay in forever, but a place for the next 5-10 years. We have secure employment but I am trying to think for the future in terms of taking maternity leave possibly in the future and dealing with reduced income, we wouldn’t be able to pause an 100% mortgage but we could potentially get help with the rent element of a shared ownership.

YABU - avoid
YANBU - worth it

OP posts:
Popfan · 31/05/2023 18:37

@SerenChocolateMuncher some of the things you say from your experience are the same eg paying for repairs etc although there haven't been many! We did have an issue in the first few years of a leaking ceiling but this also happened in 2 other houses and as it was a new build it was sorted out well by the HA and everything was paid for as well as a free redecoration.

I had a shared ownership flat prior to this house and was able to buy the whole thing outright in one go rather than staircasing in the way you suggest... in chunks. For this one we don't need to only buy 25% at a time either.

We've never been told to do any upkeep etc, no one comes around to check, in fact the HA are very hands off and we never hear from them apart from the account letters we get sometimes.

I'm sure there are some HA where they are more difficult but we haven't had any issues at all.

MrsDrDear · 31/05/2023 18:33

My colleague had a shared ownership house, took him 4 years to sell. It was a lovely house but it did put people off buying.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 31/05/2023 18:29

I think it's better than renting, despite all the above very good points. But it's unfortunate that of the elements you pay each month, most of it goes on service charge, rent, then mortgage interest with only a small amount towards equity. You'd need to stay there quite a while.

Be aware that if the HA rules you could buy on the open market you may fail assessment.

Blackbyrd · 31/05/2023 18:29

Excellent post from SerenChocolateMuncher, remember also that you cannot sublet part of, or rent out a shared ownership property. They really offer very few of the genuine advantages of home ownership

SerenChocolateMuncher · 31/05/2023 18:24

I used to work for a housing association that built homes for shared ownership. Things might have changed since I gave up work, but if they haven't, I would not recommend this type of tenure for anyone unless they had no other options.

This is how it was then (and might still be):

Shared owners enjoy none of the benefits of home-ownership while shouldering all the disadvantages.

  1. You are still a tenant, but
  2. You pay full market rent on the portion of the property you don't own and
  3. You are responsible for paying the full service charges, including on the portion if the property you don't own.
  4. You are entirely responsible for short-term, long-term repairs and improvements. Including on the portion of the property you don't own.
  5. You are likely to be limited in any changes you want to make to your home while it is part-owned by the housing organisation.

You also have none of the benefits of being a tenant such as responsive and maintenance repairs and general improvements carried out without any additional cost to you. Nevertheless, you will be expected to carry out and pay for anything that needs doing in a timely manner. The housing organisation will take swift enforcement action against you if you allow upkeep to slide (for example, if you don't have enough money to pay for work).

If at some stage your financial status improves, you can buy more of the property. However, don't expect to buy it all at once. Many (if not most) housing organisations only allow you to buy in bits. They call it staircasing. You will probably be limited to buying in several stages (25% of the value at a time, for example). Each step is a long and costly process and you will have to pay the housing organisation's legal costs as well as your own at every step. You will then have to wait a set period of time before you can buy another "step".

This means, if the housing organisation uses 25% per step staircasing and you buy 50% of the house at the start followed by two staircasing "steps", you will go through three purchasing stages and have to pay six lots of legal fees (yours and theirs) before you become homeowners.

At each step of the staircase you will have to share any increase in equity with the housing organisation, so you would pay 25% of the market value at the time you "staircase". If the value of the property goes down you will still have to pay 25% of the original purchase price for each step so the housing organisation doesn't lose out.

I would definitely suggest you look at other options (cheaper area, smaller house) if you can. This is a very expensive way of buying a house.

lousong · 31/05/2023 18:04

Popfan · 31/05/2023 17:53

Not forever, I don't want to be paying rent on a house when we are retired (quite a long way off still!) but it's been great for bringing up DC and getting on the property ladder in some way.

If it works it works! So nice you’ve been able to buy in a nice village too

OP posts:
Popfan · 31/05/2023 17:53

Not forever, I don't want to be paying rent on a house when we are retired (quite a long way off still!) but it's been great for bringing up DC and getting on the property ladder in some way.

lousong · 31/05/2023 17:46

Popfan · 31/05/2023 17:37

We live in a shared ownership house in a lovely village we couldn't afford otherwise. Been here over 10 years. The rent side has gone up a fair bit but with our mortgage is still far cheaper than renting on the open market and we've built up a decent equity in the house. It's worked really well for us.

That’s so great, are you planning to stay there forever?

OP posts:
Popfan · 31/05/2023 17:37

We live in a shared ownership house in a lovely village we couldn't afford otherwise. Been here over 10 years. The rent side has gone up a fair bit but with our mortgage is still far cheaper than renting on the open market and we've built up a decent equity in the house. It's worked really well for us.