Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shared ownership as an option for the ‘squeezed middle’

84 replies

lousong · 31/05/2023 17:29

We’re in our 20s trying to start out
For some reason shared ownership works out as cheaper than buying on the open market but we’ve been warned against it because of the fact you’d be buying a leasehold property
Our wages are likely to go up in the future but not anytime soon. Some lovely shared ownership 3 bedroom houses have come up locally. The area is convenient, family orientated and safe, and house prices are rising in this area quite fast (so would likely gain equity). We are going to struggle to purchase outright - we would meet repayments but it would be very tight and to the limit of the stress test. We would be paying about 500-550 mortgage a month and 250 rent. Could it be worth it to gain equity? It’s unlikely to be a house we could stay in forever, but a place for the next 5-10 years. We have secure employment but I am trying to think for the future in terms of taking maternity leave possibly in the future and dealing with reduced income, we wouldn’t be able to pause an 100% mortgage but we could potentially get help with the rent element of a shared ownership.

YABU - avoid
YANBU - worth it

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 31/05/2023 22:47

I have a shared ownership and was able to staircase to 100% only with family help and improved salary.
Pros- no risk of landlord kicking me out, have been able to decorate as I please, I could rent out my spare room (covered over 70% of costs)
Con- I almost got stuck at 80% when mortgages stopped covering houses with cladding- 80% would be impossible to sell no one would want shared ownership if they could afford 80%, was so lucky that I managed to get to 100% so can now sell on the open market if I want to. Read the terms and conditions very carefully- basically all the risk and cost is with you, not the HA.

AHM5619 · 31/05/2023 22:01

Is it possible to but it outright after 1/2/3 years etc if so do it and you won’t regret it. If you can’t buy it outright think long about it as if you resell as shared ownership the buyers need to meet area criteria etc so it’s not ‘on the open market’. Good luck!

lionsleepstonight · 31/05/2023 21:31

And before Id bought 100% I was able to get a new bathroom suite via the HA as they covered the building contents insurance and the damaged sink fell under their responsibility.
Rent increases were low, not sure if this due to the HA being charity/socially responsible as they truly did what was best for tenants rather than using them as a profit stream.

Plasticplantpot · 31/05/2023 21:24

It’s a scam in the main, giving the illusion that everyone can afford a property. Agree with @SerenChocolateMuncher Avoid at all costs!

lionsleepstonight · 31/05/2023 21:22

I also owned one, started at 25% and staircased to full 100% in 5 years. Sold on open market, was snapped up and made 70k equity.

Even if I'd remained at 25% I still would have walked away with some cash.

Totally recommend it.

Teder · 31/05/2023 21:18

It may not be the best idea for you now but for those warning against it, sometimes “look cheaper and smaller” just isn’t an option. It really is the only way to get on the property ladder and it offers more security than renting forever.
I have a couple of single friends (professionals - think teaching or nursing) They can’t go smaller than a one bed flat and they’re tied into the area for various reasons. In these situations, shared ownership is the only option. It can work.

Twatalert · 31/05/2023 21:09

@CateringPanic the rent cannot go up at the will of the landlord. Rent increases are capped and this is specified in the lease. There is no way you could compare this with the conditions of the rental market, which is indeed through the roof. Also, you pay reduced market rent on the share you don't own. For my friends property this would be 1,100 for the whole flat compared with 1,900 in the open market.

It probably depends on where you are as well. I wouldn't buy a SO house in London but I would buy a SO apartment there. It would be no trouble to sell. If somewhere quite remote I'd probably reconsider and avoid SO altogether.

CateringPanic · 31/05/2023 20:53

I wouldn’t do it. At your age you are still very young to buy a house compared with average so you have plenty of time to save and buy a whole house yourself.

The cons of shared ownership are:

  • responsible for all the maintenance on a property you only own a portion of
  • “Staircasing” is rarely a reality for most people owing to the fees involved and the fact that you have to buy the next %age at current market value.
  • your rent can go up at the will of the landlord in the same way as renting. If you default on your rent you can still be evicted even though you own some of the property.
  • Even if you did manage to staircase to 100%, the property would still be leasehold which means you always need to pay ground rent and, like all leaseholds, you don’t really own it properly.
  • They are incredibly difficult to sell on as you have to agree the selling price with the housing association who owns the remainder of the property. They often want to price it higher than is appropriate.

Honestly it’s a good option for security for people in more precarious situations eg. Late 30s/early 40s and still not on property ladder, low income and kids but at your age you should just wait a bit longer and buy a whole house

Twiglets1 · 31/05/2023 20:53

Shared ownership is most suitable as a last resort for people who otherwise would have no way of getting onto the property ladder. There are lots of disadvantages to it and new build houses are the ones most likely to fall in value.
It doesn’t sound like you need a 3 bed yet. So I would buy a cheaper 2 bed that is not shared ownership, preferably not a new build so it holds its value better for when you come to sell.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 31/05/2023 20:38

I have a shared ownership house, there's no way I could have afforded to get on the housing ladder otherwise.

For me the pros outweigh the cons, the rent and mortgage combined are around £500 a month which is a lot less than it would cost to privately rent. The house is new and made to be economical for example it has solar panels and it's well insulated.

It is annoying that I'm responsible for all the repairs etc but given it's a new house <touch wood> that's not been an issue so far, bar a few minor things.

I'm in a good area and it meant my dd went to a decent school.

I've been here 7 years and I think in that time I've made around 50 k in equity. My plan is to eventually use that as a deposit on my own home.

My neighbours have all managed to use their homes as a starter home and use the equity to buy their own home so it can definitely work.

lousong · 31/05/2023 20:37

Van34 · 31/05/2023 20:28

I had one as my first house. Had it 5 years. Took no time to sell. 4 viewings 2 offers. Made a 30% profit on my portion when it sold too. I think it's a great idea for those starting out

This is good to know

OP posts:
Van34 · 31/05/2023 20:28

I had one as my first house. Had it 5 years. Took no time to sell. 4 viewings 2 offers. Made a 30% profit on my portion when it sold too. I think it's a great idea for those starting out

Bodgejobvendors · 31/05/2023 20:23

I sold a shared ownership flat last year and made a lot of equity. Selling is more complicated than with outright ownership. But lots of my friends have done shared ownership and only one has had a horror show selling, many had potential buyers biting their hands off (especially as second hand SO is normally better value than a new build).

Unless you need flexibility I think it’s nearly always better than renting. The question is whether you could buy outright with a few compromises. Personally I decided that living in zone 2 by myself was a hundred times better than renting a flat share or buying something crappy in zone 6.

frannyfrannerson · 31/05/2023 20:18

We had an utter nightmare selling our SO home after the council tenants in the next road were awful (drugs, late night screaming, one even had a petrol bomb put though their letter box) and the Housing association didn't want to know. No I'm not a snob but you cannot control who is housed near you in other affordable housing. This was also a lovely family friendly estate in a quiet town btw.
We also missed out on the 50% equity for the half we didn't own. The rent was a waste of money.
I bought it as it seemed more affordable at the time, before I met DH. This was 14 years ago and I'm older and wiser now, no way would I do this if there was anyway I could afford not to.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 31/05/2023 20:16

L1ttledrummergirl · 31/05/2023 20:01

We've advised our dc against. Around here they are crappy new builds that are on the market for far too much when you factor in the cost of buying 100% it's far more than the equivalent cost of other houses.

It's also a piss take that the monthly cost of mortgage plus rent is considered affordable, but the equivalent amount, just for a mortgage isn't. Someone is making a lot of money out of this and it isn't the homebuyers.

True, but many people buy shared ownership because they can save 10% of 30% of a £270k house, but not £27k.

mamaison · 31/05/2023 20:15

I know someone who is looking to sell their shared ownership flat purchased 7 years ago as a new build (zone 2 London). After getting a valuation, it seems it has not increased in value but the rent they pay has increased notably in that time.

lousong · 31/05/2023 20:07

MaverickSnoopy · 31/05/2023 19:20

We did it for 5 years. Made quite a lot of equity and then bought on the open market in a cheaper area. However we sold about 7 years ago when things weren't so dire. I'm not up to speed with the market so not sure whether this is still am achievable possibility, aside from paying down the mortgage.

Thankyou

OP posts:
L1ttledrummergirl · 31/05/2023 20:01

We've advised our dc against. Around here they are crappy new builds that are on the market for far too much when you factor in the cost of buying 100% it's far more than the equivalent cost of other houses.

It's also a piss take that the monthly cost of mortgage plus rent is considered affordable, but the equivalent amount, just for a mortgage isn't. Someone is making a lot of money out of this and it isn't the homebuyers.

Clementineorsatsuma · 31/05/2023 19:35

I know a woman who cannot sell hers after moving out to be with her DH 15 years ago.

Wouldn't touch with a barge pole myself.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 31/05/2023 19:30

Twatalert · 31/05/2023 19:06

@AndIKnewYouMeantIt it depends what someone values. You can sell and go back to renting or sell and take out a crazy mortgage. Or you could stay put and enjoy a period of relatively low housing costs whilst deciding what to do and perhaps enjoy the lack of any financial pressure for a while. Save for a nice deposit and/or buy another share outright whilst house values aren't going up but interest rates do.

I was agreeing with you. It makes more sense to pay off the smaller percentage mortgage then save, rather than staircasing, just like your friend has done.

Most people think it's advisable to own a large majority share. I would only staircase if it was to own 100% of the property.

MaverickSnoopy · 31/05/2023 19:20

We did it for 5 years. Made quite a lot of equity and then bought on the open market in a cheaper area. However we sold about 7 years ago when things weren't so dire. I'm not up to speed with the market so not sure whether this is still am achievable possibility, aside from paying down the mortgage.

Twatalert · 31/05/2023 19:06

@AndIKnewYouMeantIt it depends what someone values. You can sell and go back to renting or sell and take out a crazy mortgage. Or you could stay put and enjoy a period of relatively low housing costs whilst deciding what to do and perhaps enjoy the lack of any financial pressure for a while. Save for a nice deposit and/or buy another share outright whilst house values aren't going up but interest rates do.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 31/05/2023 19:00

Twatalert · 31/05/2023 18:42

SO is a good option as long as your salary is likely to increase and you'll have a chance to buy the rest. I know someone who bought 35pc and has paid off the mortgage for that after a few years. They are now just paying rent and service charge and are able to save quite a bit of money every month to either to buy another share outright or go to 100pc with a new mortgage. It's a nice position to be in during a cost of living crisis. FYI they pay around £400 per month rent and an identical apartment has just been rented out for £1,900. It's crazy.

I'd actually suggest that it's worth selling rather than owning more than 50% of a SO property. There's a much larger resale market for a 40% share than say 75%.

Twatalert · 31/05/2023 18:42

SO is a good option as long as your salary is likely to increase and you'll have a chance to buy the rest. I know someone who bought 35pc and has paid off the mortgage for that after a few years. They are now just paying rent and service charge and are able to save quite a bit of money every month to either to buy another share outright or go to 100pc with a new mortgage. It's a nice position to be in during a cost of living crisis. FYI they pay around £400 per month rent and an identical apartment has just been rented out for £1,900. It's crazy.

shivermetimbers77 · 31/05/2023 18:39

I am in a shared ownership flat as I literally could not get on the housing ladder without it.. It’s fine and more stable than renting BUT if you can buy outright I would do that instead. My rent and service charge are eye watering!