Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shared ownership as an option for the ‘squeezed middle’

84 replies

lousong · 31/05/2023 17:29

We’re in our 20s trying to start out
For some reason shared ownership works out as cheaper than buying on the open market but we’ve been warned against it because of the fact you’d be buying a leasehold property
Our wages are likely to go up in the future but not anytime soon. Some lovely shared ownership 3 bedroom houses have come up locally. The area is convenient, family orientated and safe, and house prices are rising in this area quite fast (so would likely gain equity). We are going to struggle to purchase outright - we would meet repayments but it would be very tight and to the limit of the stress test. We would be paying about 500-550 mortgage a month and 250 rent. Could it be worth it to gain equity? It’s unlikely to be a house we could stay in forever, but a place for the next 5-10 years. We have secure employment but I am trying to think for the future in terms of taking maternity leave possibly in the future and dealing with reduced income, we wouldn’t be able to pause an 100% mortgage but we could potentially get help with the rent element of a shared ownership.

YABU - avoid
YANBU - worth it

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 01/06/2023 11:45

It has its downside but upsides too- and a biggie is it can give some security. Works well for many divorcees too on lower incomes but big deposits who couldn't get a large mortgage or older people who have cash but can't get mortgages but want security . Not everyone is obsessed whether it's a great investment- they just want more security of tenure. Many would be quite happy with a good quality HA fkat or council house but as they are in humongously short supply - especially if you are working and have a decent income then at least this is an option. Many poo pooing it probably live (like one of my sons) were you can still get a 3 bed semi with a good garden for £185k. Not everyone has those options for varying reasons or is happy to live somewhere they know no one or opportunities are low.

Twiglets1 · 01/06/2023 11:33

Gooberthefirst · 01/06/2023 10:24

That's great if you live in an area that'll allow this! 😀

However in our area, 2 good incomes can only buy you a mouldy 2 bed mid terrace with no garden or parking.

Whereas shared ownership can give you 3 double bedrooms, a garden and a double driveway. In a safe area.

I get what you're saying but if you read a few books you'll realise that the UK housing market wasn't created equally 😉

It would make better financial sense to buy the mouldy 2 bed mid terrace as you will own all of it and won't have to share any profit plus the Victorian terraces are more likely to appreciate in value than new builds.

But I think what you mean is, you would prefer a 3 double bedroom new build with other advantages. That is ok if it makes you happier as long as people understand who make that choice that it is not the best investment wise, in most cases anyway.

Twiglets1 · 01/06/2023 11:25

Teder · 01/06/2023 09:54

Oh I agree with you in the OP’s case.

It’s the blanket “oh it’s the worst” when some people have only the option of renting or shared ownership. I know which one I would choose!

Same - if it was a simple choice between renting or SO I would choose SO.

But also I would be prepared for the value of the property to likely fall in the short term (first few years) as new builds do tend to, quite apart from the fact that SO properties can be harder to sell.

I would still do it for the security over renting, though.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 01/06/2023 11:04

I would buy a house absolutely, especially if I knew I was going to live in it mid to long term.

I would not buy a flat in a town/city - my friend is trapped in a shoebox in outer London and she cannot sell it and is desperate to relocate.

Hoppingroo · 01/06/2023 10:45

They also check my boiler every year at no cost to me.

Hoppingroo · 01/06/2023 10:39

I bought my shared ownership in 2020 it got delayed as I had put down a reservation fee in Feb then lockdown happened and could not move in until August. This was also due to the no inspectors available to issue the cladding certificate needed for the bank to go ahead and ok it. I got the cladding signed off ( which I understand is an issue if you want to sell and don’t have one).

My mortgage is low and my rent has increased by £50 a month since 2020 and is been very gradual with an annual increase every April since 2020.
pros: I have a balcony - building is maintained - they refunded me overpaid service charges- I pay £25 for heat and hot water every month as my flat is incredibly warm even in winter -heating not on until December - £24 a month for a fixed electricity and I have a big amount of credit I have built up according to British Gas. My bills are low and have been low for the last three years.
I live 3 min walk away from an Elizabeth line service and it takes me 15 min to get into central London. I also work a 35 min walk from job.

I get this is due to the size of my flat and area is not totally rough but not totally trendy either. However I think it’s an incredibly large size for a one bed flat.

2 massive parks nearby. Lots of shops and amenities a 2 min walk away.

cons: I am aware that owing a full flat mortgage would be better however this suits me for the next 5 years. I also think I would sell it quickly if I needed to as the area is popular as it’s low cost and there is a demand even for shared ownership in my area.

I only had to pay for two repairs in last 3 years - washing machine door and oven.

Any other repairs like my door not locking properly was fixed by management as it was on a communal hallway so was considered their responsibility.

Crikeyalmighty · 01/06/2023 10:25

@YaWeeFurryBastard it definitely isn't aimed at lower earners in areas of high demand like the south east or south west - you often need£60k plus earnings to fit the affordability stress test.

I wouldn't say that is low earners.

Gooberthefirst · 01/06/2023 10:24

KingOfThieves · 01/06/2023 10:21

It’s not for the “squeezed midddle”. It’s usually those who want the luxury of a newer home but can’t afford a new home.

personally I’d buy something I can afford

That's great if you live in an area that'll allow this! 😀

However in our area, 2 good incomes can only buy you a mouldy 2 bed mid terrace with no garden or parking.

Whereas shared ownership can give you 3 double bedrooms, a garden and a double driveway. In a safe area.

I get what you're saying but if you read a few books you'll realise that the UK housing market wasn't created equally 😉

Gooberthefirst · 01/06/2023 10:22

Just to add another perspective. I work in architecture and the construction of shared ownership properties in recent years has been getting better and better with new building regs.

Just a decade ago, shared ownerships had poor building materials and silly layouts. They were often very different compared to the 100% private houses on the same estate. More likely to hear next door, smaller bedrooms, poor quality turf and kitchens etc

These days they are in such demand that the quality of each build is much better than ever before and building material quality has improved too so better sound and heat insulation!

KingOfThieves · 01/06/2023 10:21

It’s not for the “squeezed midddle”. It’s usually those who want the luxury of a newer home but can’t afford a new home.

personally I’d buy something I can afford

StaySpicy · 01/06/2023 10:18

I had a SO flat for about 6 years. The rent and service charge went up every year, from about £500/month to about £900/month, so bear that in mind.

I did sell it quickly, though, and made around £60k equity, so worth it in that respect. Selling does depend on the person being accepted for SO by the scheme owner, though, which could delay things or make it difficult to sell.

Gooberthefirst · 01/06/2023 10:14

I don't think Shared Ownership is for low earners. You still have to pass affordability checks, be mortgageable and have good credit scores (the Housing Association still have their own affordability checks and an interest rate stress test)

Mine was £300k ish full value and my neighbours was £600k full value.

I think the bad reputation seems to come from people who remember shared ownership plans from the 90s.

Gooberthefirst · 01/06/2023 10:09

We had a shared ownership on a lovely estate. We had it for 3 years and made £19,000 on the property value (pre covid)

We were allowed to do anything we wanted to the property despite it being leasehold. We had to ask permission first. They even allowed a conservatory but we decided to move instead.

The best thing was that when we came to sell up - there was a queue of people wanting it and we could sell privately without estate agents. And to a FTB. So we saved thousands in estate agency costs!

They'll always be in demand!

Like you, we were wary of them before buying. But it was the best decision we ever made as the equity we made and the profit allowed us to buy the most beautiful home :)

YaWeeFurryBastard · 01/06/2023 10:07

It doesn’t really sound like you’re in the “squeezed middle” bracket to be honest as shared ownership is aimed at lower earners. Do you think you’ll be able to afford to buy a full property in the future? You’re only young so if so I’d suggest waiting and saving up a bit more and buying your own place outright, which will give you more freedom. It’s very hard to say without knowing you income/deposit/average prices in your area.

lionsleepstonight · 01/06/2023 10:01

I also love that on these threads the negative comments generally come from people who've not actually used the scheme and have a limited (often incorrect) understanding on how SO works. Each scheme is very different and the OP needs to research and go in with eyes open.

I'm assuming their income allows the choice to buy outright. Bully for them, but not helpful when for some, it's the only option available to buy.

Teder · 01/06/2023 09:54

Twiglets1 · 01/06/2023 05:37

If it’s the only option other than renting, then I agree it can work ( better than renting).
However, this is not OPs situation - they are looking to buy a 3 bed SO as their first home, which makes no financial sense in my opinion.

Oh I agree with you in the OP’s case.

It’s the blanket “oh it’s the worst” when some people have only the option of renting or shared ownership. I know which one I would choose!

ILikePizzas · 01/06/2023 08:02

It looks like the worst of both worlds to me.

Also, the property won't increase in value like other ones might as anyone looking at it will think "It's surrounded by other part buy/part rent houses" - ie people on special schemes/at the lower end of the earnings ladder.

lousong · 01/06/2023 08:00

MRex · 01/06/2023 06:27

It can be helpful, but it can also have pitfalls. There is a price premium when they are new, so look to buy one that isn't new to avoid that. Some things to check:

  1. Local authority text on reclaiming the property for non payment; you need them to commit to telling your lender so that you get your deposit back of the property is taken for non payment of rent: https://gatehouselaw.co.uk/protection-for-lenders-under-shared-ownership-leases/. Related - pay rent before mortgage if there's any issue.
  2. % you can buy and staircasing: work out total costs to buy and look at common local area sales; you might struggle more to sell 75% than 25%, because people decide to just get a smaller full home.
  3. Sales; check number of sales, time on the market for anything still on and sale prices in the area carefully, to ensure it's not too hard to sell on when you've saved money and want to buy somewhere outright instead of buying the proportion.
  4. Other tenants; visit all days and times of day, plus speak to neighbour. You don't know what noise issues there might be if you don't check.

Thank you this is very useful!

OP posts:
treenu · 01/06/2023 07:47

We lived in our flat for 8 years at a 45% share. We had our ups and downs but it was a lovely flat and repairs were all covered, as it was a new build. We took care of it, built up equity and were able to buy a house at the end.

Our only frustration was that the HA had lots of requirements for buyers when we came to sell, however we eventually found one.

MRex · 01/06/2023 06:27

It can be helpful, but it can also have pitfalls. There is a price premium when they are new, so look to buy one that isn't new to avoid that. Some things to check:

  1. Local authority text on reclaiming the property for non payment; you need them to commit to telling your lender so that you get your deposit back of the property is taken for non payment of rent: https://gatehouselaw.co.uk/protection-for-lenders-under-shared-ownership-leases/. Related - pay rent before mortgage if there's any issue.
  2. % you can buy and staircasing: work out total costs to buy and look at common local area sales; you might struggle more to sell 75% than 25%, because people decide to just get a smaller full home.
  3. Sales; check number of sales, time on the market for anything still on and sale prices in the area carefully, to ensure it's not too hard to sell on when you've saved money and want to buy somewhere outright instead of buying the proportion.
  4. Other tenants; visit all days and times of day, plus speak to neighbour. You don't know what noise issues there might be if you don't check.

Protection for lenders under shared ownership leases - Gatehouse Chambers

Caoimhe McKearney discusses the considerations which arise when acting for a lender in relation to shared ownership leases.

https://gatehouselaw.co.uk/protection-for-lenders-under-shared-ownership-leases

silverlentils · 01/06/2023 06:13

I am in shared ownership and it worked out OK for me. I could never have afforded to buy otherwise. The rent and mortgage combined is still half what I would pay for a private rental. Ignore the post about some of your payments going to rent and only a little bit to the mortgage repayment, they are totally separate. I have my mortgage on 50%, and I pay rent and service charges on the other 50%
I am very lucky in the house I have, it's lovely.

If I was still renting I would not have the security of a long term home.

Drawbacks:
I cannot sublet (but I can have a lodger).
If I wanted to go elsewhere for a couple of years I would be very unlikely to be allowed to (and cannot rent my house out while I'm away).
I have to fund improvements and repairs myself, but if they lead to any increase in value the housing association benefits from 50% of that when I finally sell.

Unless I buy the house outright I will be paying rent on retirement. Note that some housing associations have a clause that you can never buy outright, only a max 90%.
If I want to get any significant work done eg an extension or solar panels, I need the housing associations permission. They have been known to not agree to owners borrowing money to improve the home - eg they might give permission for a mortgage increase for a new boiler but not to renovate a bathroom.

If it's for a few years to get you on the ladder it's a good idea.

All the shared ownership homes where I live sell very quickly, they are snapped up.

Twiglets1 · 01/06/2023 05:37

Teder · 31/05/2023 21:18

It may not be the best idea for you now but for those warning against it, sometimes “look cheaper and smaller” just isn’t an option. It really is the only way to get on the property ladder and it offers more security than renting forever.
I have a couple of single friends (professionals - think teaching or nursing) They can’t go smaller than a one bed flat and they’re tied into the area for various reasons. In these situations, shared ownership is the only option. It can work.

If it’s the only option other than renting, then I agree it can work ( better than renting).
However, this is not OPs situation - they are looking to buy a 3 bed SO as their first home, which makes no financial sense in my opinion.

Leo227 · 31/05/2023 23:14

Read up on the new model of Shared ownership. its removed most of the issues anyone has mentioned on here.

lousong · 31/05/2023 23:06

lionsleepstonight · 31/05/2023 21:22

I also owned one, started at 25% and staircased to full 100% in 5 years. Sold on open market, was snapped up and made 70k equity.

Even if I'd remained at 25% I still would have walked away with some cash.

Totally recommend it.

Sounds fab

OP posts: