Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother in Law uses our London home as a crash pad often

158 replies

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 14:36

Just wondering if I'm being unreasonable. My brother in law lives rurally with my father in law. Since we bought our new home he asks about once a month ( sometimes more) to crash at our house for 1-3 nights. He would sometimes do this for the odd work meeting but he's doing it now to socilize and meet up with London friends and women.

Me and my husband are exhausted with demanding jobs, 2 children one of whom is almost a teen and we just like our space some weekends and midweek.

My father in law does this as well frequently although he is inclined to book a hotel in Central London.

I like the idea of visitors but it is entirely o their terms and they don't end up seeing us and the children much at all.
Husband feels cornered and so do I.
We don't actually have a guest room but a sofa bed in a room which the children use for games and for their sleepovers and having out.

It just gets a bit much. I resent his life, he's my age, has an easy job, air bnbs his home ( which was pretty much bought for him) while he makes use of his family house ( my in laws hosue). We are always exhausted and always feel we are needing space to recuperate or time together as a family.

OP posts:
Kitcaterpillar · 31/05/2023 16:44

I'm going to go against the grain and say I wouldn't have an issue with a close family member staying 1-3 nights per month. It doesn't seem a big deal and it seems a little churlish to resent someone else having an easy life.

But you do have an issue, so your husband needs to say he can't stay 🤷🏼‍♀️

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 31/05/2023 16:43

No way. But you don’t even have to give a reason. Just say that it’s so often now that you’re feeling a bit put open seeing as it’s your home.m. For people as cheeky as these two I would say this. I would If you really want to start WW3 then mention “you could both use your London flat if it wasn’t being rented out…”

SIL’s DB crashes at SIL and my DB’s London flat when he comes to London for work etc but he also eats with them and owns it jointly with SIL anyway.

AliceOlive · 31/05/2023 16:42

I wouldn't personally make it a big chat. I would just start saying "Oh no, that won't work for us." Avoid any drama and whinging. By the time he figures it out, he will have found other places to stay.

Also, if he did stay, I would make it hell. Get the kids to jump on him and wake him up.

JoeyLin · 31/05/2023 16:39

The fact your husband agrees, makes the situation a lot easier to manage, as at least it doesn't appear you're picking sides or offending your husband or in-laws.

I'm married to someone with a brother 10 years younger - I could easily picture me in your shoes - I have a young family and he comes and visits when he likes but not really when it helps us.

The first thing I'd say is he probably doesn't even realise he is doing anything wrong. Sometimes some people don't understand boundaries and appropriateness of their actions, especially if they are single and not living the same life as you. So it may not even be a bad conversation - he may just get it in one simple conversation.

But i'd let your husband have this conversation with him.

FatCatBum · 31/05/2023 16:38

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:14

No, he has father in laws key here 🙄

Take all the keys away

IglesiasPiggl · 31/05/2023 16:36

Just say that now your DC are older there isn't as much space and you can no longer accommodate visitors. If he stays in a hotel in a business area, they do excellent weekend rates, eg in Canary Wharf.

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:35

blackpearwhitelilies · 31/05/2023 16:30

It doesn't baffle me at all that people find it hard to say no.
Family dynamics can wreak havoc with peoples' heads. I can be assertive and confident at work, and though I'm better than I was, am v prone to being walked over by my family. That's what decade of emotional and physical abuse can do to you. I don't think it's helpful to take an exasperated tone on this. People who get called doormats have often had to deal with and process a hell of a lot.

Thank you.
I would say normally me and husband are very driven and assertive. But this has had me in knots. I like my brother in law a lot but I just wish he had consideration for what life is like for a busy family.

OP posts:
ZombieKettle · 31/05/2023 16:34

His background and lifestyle is irrelevant.

It's your home, you choose who can stay or not.

So just say 'no, not really convenient anymore as we're too cramped/daughter getting older'. Just say no.

WeightInLine · 31/05/2023 16:34

Thesunwillcomeoutverysoon · 31/05/2023 14:49

Haven't your dc got friends staying? Every week end.

I think this is it really. If you don’t want a showdown (and why would you?), just keep saying oh so-and-so is coming (or any other excuse) until you have fully built in the idea that your home is just not available.

Then once he doesn’t see you as de facto crash pad, he might start asking less frequently.

FatCatBum · 31/05/2023 16:32

*My greatest wish on MN is that so many posters would stop being such complete and utter doormats. It does my fucking head it.

SAY NO. Him being offended or not is not your problem. He's a cheeky arsehole and he needs to be told no for once.*

Amen to this. FGS, it doesn't need a million excuses about not having a sofa bed, it just takes a conversation (ideally) or a text to say BIL you are starting to take the piss a bit and sorry but it's got to stop. You need to check with us with plenty of notice and if it's convenient we'll let you know otherwise you'll need to make other arrangements

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:32

Yes I admit I am resentful and so is my husband. He has an interesting job and works on his own terms and not for a great deal of money at all because he doesn't need it. We like his life choices but they wouldn't be possible if he settled down and we are exhausted. 😳 that's why I was asking if I'm being unreasonable because I'm aware we are getting resentful of his free time and space and our lack of

OP posts:
MoiraRoseForever · 31/05/2023 16:32

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 15:53

No, he uses the house to crash after a night out. Then he's there in the morning, might play a bit of ball with my son and then will meet another friend for lunch or whatever. My almost teen has no interest in hanging out with adults which os a drama buy I guess her age. No he is literally using the place as a crash pad, not coming to enjoy my dinner or whatever, I actually wouldn't mind that! He comes to London to eat out and see friends, go to a haoween party etc, not to spend time with us.
Father in law gets a takeaway with us midweek if he stays and to catch up with us but brother in law uses his time in London for his friends. Father in law does get hotels and only occasionally asks. Yes it's a bad siutaion and its a recent thing which has crept up . He was not like this before the pandemic and quite frankly when the kids were younger they would be of more use in entertaining and babysitting. We like going for our for date nights but we can afford babysitters. Last minute offers of date nights don't cut it. We could barely keep our eyes open last time.
I'm going to have to deal with it.
At one point brother in law had a key and was letting himself in. Husband took it back and he did say he wa taken aback when he cheekily asked for it again. He doesn't seem to get the hint so he's going to have to tell him directly.
I don't understand how he hasn't considered that it's annoying for a busy family.

I expect he really doesn’t care that it impacts you and especially your daughter . Expect the does know but puts his needs first .

blackpearwhitelilies · 31/05/2023 16:30

It doesn't baffle me at all that people find it hard to say no.
Family dynamics can wreak havoc with peoples' heads. I can be assertive and confident at work, and though I'm better than I was, am v prone to being walked over by my family. That's what decade of emotional and physical abuse can do to you. I don't think it's helpful to take an exasperated tone on this. People who get called doormats have often had to deal with and process a hell of a lot.

MoiraRoseForever · 31/05/2023 16:30

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 14:52

Yes that happens often. Daughter is nearly 13. I don't mind that at all. Yes him staying over sometimes means she can't do that sometimes.
I've spoken to a few friends and they've said tell him. I don't know why I'm finding it so hard! As is my husband.
We really like him and he's a fun uncle but lately it's been getting out of hand.

Sp
your daughter can’t have her friends over for sleepovers because of him ? You put his needs first ? Surely that should make you say no . For your daughter .

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:29

😂
Thanks I will send that to my DH.
And yes! I would love to stay in his house in area of outstanding natural beauty with teh family. No chance, its always got air bnb guests and when it's free he goes there to write and read potter.
A charmed life!

OP posts:
Farmageddon · 31/05/2023 16:27

TrishTrix · 31/05/2023 15:39

I'm sure he won't be upset if you say no. Or advise him he can only stay for one night.

However, the more you post to justify yourself unnecessarily the worse you come across, so don't do that! You are perfectly entitled to not want him in your space without look ing at his wider living arrangements etc.

Also be aware that there might be advantages. I have a great relationship now with the teens whose family hospitality I abused for several years when I was living out of London. You get to know people better when you stay with them - those informal sitting around conversations can be meaningful - would your kids otherwise spend much time with him? Is them having a good relationship with him valuable?

I agree, the more the OP says, her resentment of his life choices seem to come out. Lots of comments about how hardworking you and your husband are and how feckless he is...you have made different choices than him, that's all.

Surely that's a different issue than him staying at yours - you don't have the room for him, so just tell him it's not convenient for you. End of. If he's gets pissed off, is it that much of a loss? You don't even seem to like him.

Shadowworry · 31/05/2023 16:23

Hi John

Katie and I have had a chat. We love you very much and enjoy seeing you but we work really long hours and have our relationship etc and our DC in our home and recently we have felt that you are using it as a crash pad not to see us or spend time with us - but to date and socialise with others. So can you use a BnB for those times and or a hotel like Dad does from now on and we can plan in advance when you come and see us and we can spend quality time with you and treat you to a nice dinner etc

Also we’d love to come and stay with you over the summer in your house and have a proper break with you.

thanks and love you
Pete xx

ps should be your DH that sends it

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:19

I shall talk to him and husband must as well.

OP posts:
Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:18

*So much time

OP posts:
Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:18

Yes that's when it changed for me. When he said that about his friends wife I just felt really pissed off like he really doesn't have a clue what it's like having children and being exhausted. That's probably when I started truly feeling this needs to stop!
Like I said before I just feel resentful he has such an easy life and has zouch time and space for himself which we and many others just do not.

OP posts:
ThatFraggle · 31/05/2023 16:15

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:13

Quite. I don't understand why he doesn't crash there. Guess he doesn't want to impose there!
What annoyed me recently was him staying over at his schoolnfriends family home. He will slag off how much the house costs in London compared to his. He thinks we are all mugs in London with our boring jobs and big mortgages. I mean yes it is shit in many ways. They have 2 small children. He said the wife looks like she doesn't make an effort and always wears trackie bottoms. Hello?? That's me as well. It made me wince as I don't always make an effort on a Saturday morning.

So people host him, and when they are relaxed at home he slags them off behind their backs for not being more dressed up. What a charmer.

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:14

No, he has father in laws key here 🙄

OP posts:
Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:13

Quite. I don't understand why he doesn't crash there. Guess he doesn't want to impose there!
What annoyed me recently was him staying over at his schoolnfriends family home. He will slag off how much the house costs in London compared to his. He thinks we are all mugs in London with our boring jobs and big mortgages. I mean yes it is shit in many ways. They have 2 small children. He said the wife looks like she doesn't make an effort and always wears trackie bottoms. Hello?? That's me as well. It made me wince as I don't always make an effort on a Saturday morning.

OP posts:
Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 31/05/2023 16:11

Aquamarine1029 · 31/05/2023 14:50

My greatest wish on MN is that so many posters would stop being such complete and utter doormats. It does my fucking head it.

SAY NO. Him being offended or not is not your problem. He's a cheeky arsehole and he needs to be told no for once.

Me too. God, I want to shake some people. OP. Please, just tell him no. Who gives a shit if the freeloader is offended??

Twobyfour · 31/05/2023 16:09

Was he given that key back?

I would say that it’s not convenient due to sleepover plans (be vague). You could casually ask why doesn’t he stay with his London pals if he moans that he was coming up for a social event with them.