Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother in Law uses our London home as a crash pad often

158 replies

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 14:36

Just wondering if I'm being unreasonable. My brother in law lives rurally with my father in law. Since we bought our new home he asks about once a month ( sometimes more) to crash at our house for 1-3 nights. He would sometimes do this for the odd work meeting but he's doing it now to socilize and meet up with London friends and women.

Me and my husband are exhausted with demanding jobs, 2 children one of whom is almost a teen and we just like our space some weekends and midweek.

My father in law does this as well frequently although he is inclined to book a hotel in Central London.

I like the idea of visitors but it is entirely o their terms and they don't end up seeing us and the children much at all.
Husband feels cornered and so do I.
We don't actually have a guest room but a sofa bed in a room which the children use for games and for their sleepovers and having out.

It just gets a bit much. I resent his life, he's my age, has an easy job, air bnbs his home ( which was pretty much bought for him) while he makes use of his family house ( my in laws hosue). We are always exhausted and always feel we are needing space to recuperate or time together as a family.

OP posts:
MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 31/05/2023 17:25

You know what you need to do

blueshoes · 31/05/2023 17:25

Just Say No. End of!

Unabletocatchup · 31/05/2023 17:24

You talk about him never having responsibility, being a grown up etc but also that he was doing a lot of care for his mother. Did your husband step up and do his fair share of care or just leave it to his brother?

I wondered this too @Scienceadvisory

@Needspace2023 have you ever been at the coal face with someone who is dying? Do you realise how tough it is?

If your brother in law was doing this, it is very unfair to say he has never had to take on any grown up responsibilities Hmm

Thelastofbus · 31/05/2023 17:24

Every month is too often. And 3 nights is too long! It’s perfectly fine for you to say ‘no’ sometimes. He probably thinks he is great company, and no trouble because he isn’t expecting to be fed and entertained.

There was a time when a relative needed to stay in my house for a night a month. At the end of the year they bought us a weekend away at a lovely hotel to say thank you. I’d definitely be asking your BIL when you can stay at his lovely air b and b.

Newspeaker · 31/05/2023 17:23

Aquamarine1029 · 31/05/2023 14:50

My greatest wish on MN is that so many posters would stop being such complete and utter doormats. It does my fucking head it.

SAY NO. Him being offended or not is not your problem. He's a cheeky arsehole and he needs to be told no for once.

I have a second greatest wish - that people would stop making up elaborate lies and excuses when they should be honest - it's not convenient for us so we won't be able to put you up for two weeks... we want to have more quiet time as a family so we won't be visiting you every Sunday... we are looking forward to having this holiday for the 4 of us to do things together, so won't have much time for days out with you... etc etc...
Instead it's "Tell him that your daughter's best friend's mum had to go into hospital because she's sprained a brain cell so we've just got to have best friend for more sleepovers to help out - because after all they do look after our cat while we're away and cook us a nice meal once a month - and that means there just won't be room for him as well."

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 17:19

Thinkwhat · 31/05/2023 17:16

It’s probably getting out of hand because when he comes in you say a normal pleasantry like “it’s so nice to see you” etc and he has no idea that he has overstepped. Just tell him

Honestly no. I've been tired, moody, stressed a few times in front of him. Husband's been tired and gone to bed nor engaging because he needs an early night.
He's immune to figuring it out.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 31/05/2023 17:19

Next time he asks just say sorry it is not convenient that night as DD is having a guest stay over then. I'd say yes about once a month.

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 17:17

goldfinchfan · 31/05/2023 17:15

Your Bil might think that you don't have a problem with him stayin because YOU have never said anything!
I hope you will return to tell us what his response was.......please

I will do! It's coming to a head. Me and husband are exasperated and just need to do it.

OP posts:
Thinkwhat · 31/05/2023 17:16

It’s probably getting out of hand because when he comes in you say a normal pleasantry like “it’s so nice to see you” etc and he has no idea that he has overstepped. Just tell him

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 17:16

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 31/05/2023 17:13

Totally sympathize with you; he's being rude and obnoxious by presuming to crash in your home. I hope you can fend him off.

Don't really understand the resentment, though. We all make our life choices. Presumably there is pleasure in being a parent that a childfree person won't experience. You had to know that becoming a parent would come with trade-offs in other areas, such as finances, leisure time, energy, juggling work/life balance, etc. That's not his fault, nor are the pleasures he enjoys as a childfree person something to be resentful over. We all start out with the same blank slate.

I kind of explained the resentment in another post. I don't like the feeling at all and it's not really me. I've always been pretty chilled and felt jealousy is a horrible emotion and the root of a lot of evil.

OP posts:
goldfinchfan · 31/05/2023 17:15

Your Bil might think that you don't have a problem with him stayin because YOU have never said anything!
I hope you will return to tell us what his response was.......please

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 17:13

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 31/05/2023 17:07

Not exactly the same but I have a 13m old and a 24m old. My auntie who lives about 15mins away has asked if she can visit us every single Thursday. My guess is because she’d like to see us and the kids and be involved in their lives.

Unfortunately, I work three days a week. My youngest has a genetic disorder so has weekly appointments and I’m just too fucking tired to commit to weekly visits. So guess what? I said ‘sorry no that doesn’t work for us for X reasons. I don’t want to commit to seeing you weekly and then I always cancel.’ She actually apologised for being slightly inconsiderate as she can forget all that goes on with my son.

I didn’t have to start any threads saying, ‘Auntie comes round every week and I hate it.’ Just use your words and enjoy your home. If someone came round to stay at my house multiple times a month and I didn’t want them too, I’d be so irritated

There's just too much going on, isn't there?.. I think they think raising kids is a breeze.. it really isn't!

OP posts:
ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 31/05/2023 17:13

Totally sympathize with you; he's being rude and obnoxious by presuming to crash in your home. I hope you can fend him off.

Don't really understand the resentment, though. We all make our life choices. Presumably there is pleasure in being a parent that a childfree person won't experience. You had to know that becoming a parent would come with trade-offs in other areas, such as finances, leisure time, energy, juggling work/life balance, etc. That's not his fault, nor are the pleasures he enjoys as a childfree person something to be resentful over. We all start out with the same blank slate.

varsitychic · 31/05/2023 17:13

I would say keep it simple and take the sofa bed out of the playroom, and turn the room into a teenagers den / study space. "Sorry BIL, but now she's 13 DD needs her own space to have friends over and study, as will DS soon enough. Hopefully there'll be a nice easy Air BNB you can use".

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 17:10

I remember one time I was so stressed in the morning trying to get son ready for school ( breakfast club).and get to work on time and BIL was just sloping around in the kitchen and using the shower when we needed it and I lost my temper with my son because I felt my BIL was slowing us all down ☹ and kind of watching me like I was a mad woman.

OP posts:
CantGetDecentNickname · 31/05/2023 17:10

No need for a showdown or anything, just a simple "sorry we're not going to have any more visitors for the meantime as we're exhausted from work and want to spend time quality time with our children". When he ignores this polite request, a simple "no, it isn't convenient thanks" every time he asks. Don't give reasons if asked as you don't have to. If he asks if he's done something, just say "no, it's not you, it's us. We're just too tired to host people at the moment." Keep repeating it.

I've had a similar situation and at one point when I was busy washing all the bedding for the umpteenth weekend in a row, thought to myself that it felt like I was running a B&B without getting the income. It occurred to me that I could do Airbnb and that I just didn't want to. That was when I started to say "no thanks" to visitors. I turned the spare room into a home office style workspace. A good space for teenagers to do their homework/studying and for anyone who is homeworking and importantly, there is now no room for a bed for guests. Your DD will soon be of an age where they have exams each year and will need peace and quiet and no visitors while they revise. It is your house so should be arranged to suit your family's needs.

Alternatively, you could tell him that you are doing Airbnb and what you are charging (the going rate) and that of course, it is already reserved for the weekend he wants to visit.

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 31/05/2023 17:07

Not exactly the same but I have a 13m old and a 24m old. My auntie who lives about 15mins away has asked if she can visit us every single Thursday. My guess is because she’d like to see us and the kids and be involved in their lives.

Unfortunately, I work three days a week. My youngest has a genetic disorder so has weekly appointments and I’m just too fucking tired to commit to weekly visits. So guess what? I said ‘sorry no that doesn’t work for us for X reasons. I don’t want to commit to seeing you weekly and then I always cancel.’ She actually apologised for being slightly inconsiderate as she can forget all that goes on with my son.

I didn’t have to start any threads saying, ‘Auntie comes round every week and I hate it.’ Just use your words and enjoy your home. If someone came round to stay at my house multiple times a month and I didn’t want them too, I’d be so irritated

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 17:07

Thank you @blackpearwhitelilies
I'm aware a part of being a grown up is learning to say "no". I was really bad at it as a young woman and got so much better with this. But because its a family member it's difficult and I just wanted validation for my feelings.
Also don't want to be the evil SIL.
My BIL is sexist - he expects a woman to be a supermodel, highly educated, either posh or super sexy and exotic. This is why he is single. He is also good looking and well off regardless of his lack of salary which is why he can get away with this.

All this used to make me laugh but the too frequent visits are why I'm starting to resent his life and my husband definitely foes but he is a stoic and doesn't have a mean bone in his body.

I do love my house and living in London
It's hard work but there are a lot of plusses to being here , including the fact we don't have to commute long and that I'm a born and bred Londoner. I don't hate my life at all or question my life choices ( love being a parent). Just exhausted 😴

OP posts:
forrestgreen · 31/05/2023 17:01

I wouldn't send that previous message it seems to nice. And why should you be treating him to a meal. It seriously should be the other way round!

I'd ignore it until he asks
'Hi, nope sorry, it's not convenient'
If he asks why
'We need some family/quiet time this weekend/dd is planning a friends weekend/your visits have become more about you crashing here, rather than spending time with us and the kids-any time you're up here let us know and we'll meet up (bet he won't!)

blackpearwhitelilies · 31/05/2023 16:56

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 31/05/2023 16:52

Yes, yes and yes.

I don’t understand how something can bother you to the point where you’ll complain on the internet but can’t speak up and put a stop to things? It’s actually quite ridiculous

Because she's nervous about the conversation potentially sparking a family row and wants other peoples' perspectives about this before going ahead with it. I don't see why this is ridiculous - she's already said that the thread has clarified how she feels.

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 31/05/2023 16:52

Aquamarine1029 · 31/05/2023 14:50

My greatest wish on MN is that so many posters would stop being such complete and utter doormats. It does my fucking head it.

SAY NO. Him being offended or not is not your problem. He's a cheeky arsehole and he needs to be told no for once.

Yes, yes and yes.

I don’t understand how something can bother you to the point where you’ll complain on the internet but can’t speak up and put a stop to things? It’s actually quite ridiculous

Goldbar · 31/05/2023 16:51

I would be tempted to wind him up a bit.

"Hi BIL, I think DH mentioned the kids crashing at yours for a week in the summer. Will be great for them to escape London for a bit... they're super-excited to stay with their favourite uncle, especially since we're going to be very busy with work. They don't need much - I'll send you a list of their favourite breakfast foods and what they like for dinner. Will be lovely for them to visit you for a change."

Nanny0gg · 31/05/2023 16:48

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 16:14

No, he has father in laws key here 🙄

Change the locks!

Nanny0gg · 31/05/2023 16:45

Needspace2023 · 31/05/2023 14:58

Yes you are right. I would 100 percent be like this with my own siblings and them with me. Brother in law was definitely the over indulged child. Now in his mid 40s he is just used to doing as he pleases.

He's your husband's brother - why can't he tell him?

TedMullins · 31/05/2023 16:44

YANBU to say no (and I agree with others you need to be assertive and stop being doormats) and he sounds like a bit of a sexist twat from his comment about his friend’s wife.

But you YABU to resent/be jealous of his life choices. You chose to get a house with a massive mortgage in London and to have kids. If you wanted more time for yourself to live more indulgently you could’ve chosen differently!