Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did you do a double think on the grammar here?

116 replies

Awumminnscotland · 31/05/2023 10:06

My 7 yr old was reading the "blub" as she calls it on the back of her reading book and tells me that her teacher said this was wrong, that it should be "strongest". I'm afraid my eyebrows couldn't get any higher on my head and my mouth dropped. But maybe my expectations are too high?
I'm 52 and in primary didn't get taught much grammar but I knew this...
Not a teaching bashing thread just a v surprised mum and I know most mums of 7 yr olds are younger so just looking for perspective really.

Did you do a double think on the grammar here?
OP posts:
DuringDuran · 01/06/2023 08:46

Strongest is absolute.

Stronger is relative to others in a group.

The strongest is also always the stronger, but the stronger is not always the strongest in absolute terms.

sanityisamyth · 01/06/2023 08:24

ClaraThePigeon · 31/05/2023 10:35

I may just have forgotten alot!

Is anyone else thinking the same thing that I am?

A lot is two words?

Alot really annoys me and I had to override the autocorrect then which annoys me even more!

SnuggleBuggleBoo · 01/06/2023 08:22

I have to dash off to work in a minute so haven't read the full thread, so sorry if this has already been shared!

Anyone else remember 'Spy Watch'? It was fab! Almost worth going to school for!

spywatch three sisters for 'bethAndemilyy'

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVf8JvXErPs

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 21:53

mathanxiety · 31/05/2023 21:49

I disagree that children would be confused by use of 'the stronger' when learning to use 'stronger' or 'strongest' in a sentence - I'm sure they would be capable of understanding "Who is the strongest?" in a context of three or more being compared. I think it would actually reinforce the lesson.

Correct. Children actually like learning properly. But hey, don’t let that stop the posters who think they can’t deal with anything too difficult.

mathanxiety · 31/05/2023 21:49

RitaFires · 31/05/2023 16:05

I think it's worthwhile pointing out to a 7 year old that they are unlikely to encounter many people using that phrase. Learning "who is the stronger" might complicate some children's understanding when they're learning how to use stronger/strongest in sentences. It's not wrong but people don't really use it so I would expect a teacher to tell a child most people would say "who is stronger". At 7 I expect the focus is on phrases they are likely to use themselves.

I disagree that children would be confused by use of 'the stronger' when learning to use 'stronger' or 'strongest' in a sentence - I'm sure they would be capable of understanding "Who is the strongest?" in a context of three or more being compared. I think it would actually reinforce the lesson.

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 16:50

RitaFires · 31/05/2023 16:05

I think it's worthwhile pointing out to a 7 year old that they are unlikely to encounter many people using that phrase. Learning "who is the stronger" might complicate some children's understanding when they're learning how to use stronger/strongest in sentences. It's not wrong but people don't really use it so I would expect a teacher to tell a child most people would say "who is stronger". At 7 I expect the focus is on phrases they are likely to use themselves.

Yes yes yes 🙌

CharlottenBurger · 31/05/2023 16:45

mathanxiety · 31/05/2023 14:55

'The stronger' is correct.

Contrary to the opinions of others here, I wouldn't consider it archaic or even old-fashioned.

I feel the same. If 'the stronger', 'the bigger' etc are old-fashioned, it is only to the same extent that formal English is old-fashioned. Definitely not 'archaic', which I would reserve for completely obsolete usages like 'betwixt' or 'thine' which you generally only encounter in proverbs of certain fixed expressions.

RitaFires · 31/05/2023 16:05

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 14:42

“It would be legitimate of the teacher to say it's not commonly used rather than tell a child that it's wrong.”

What a pointless thing to say. I think the child would be more interested in what was correct. Children are like that.

Anyway the woman was clueless and was trying to be smart. Lol

I think it's worthwhile pointing out to a 7 year old that they are unlikely to encounter many people using that phrase. Learning "who is the stronger" might complicate some children's understanding when they're learning how to use stronger/strongest in sentences. It's not wrong but people don't really use it so I would expect a teacher to tell a child most people would say "who is stronger". At 7 I expect the focus is on phrases they are likely to use themselves.

ididntwanttodoit · 31/05/2023 15:06

The book is correct, the teacher is wrong. However, common usage differs - it would sound a bit pedantic (and old-fashioned) if someone said "the stronger" of two in daily conversation. Grammatical rules, like most things, move wit the times. Let's not get too hung up on it. That said, a teacher should know better - but then, who would've told her/him?

akkakk · 31/05/2023 15:00

ThatOnePlease · 31/05/2023 13:06

The comparative is correct. The use of 'the' is not.

wrong :)

to say who is stronger is a comparison, but doesn't define what is being compared, so for example you could have the sentence:

Bob couldn't open the jar of honey, so the teacher said, Mary, Jo, come here and let us see - who is stronger

stronger because it is a comparison between two - either child and Bob (and the answer could be both of them - whereas who is the strongest is an absolute and only one of the three could be the strongest...)

but not 'the stronger' as it is not specific which two

if instead we had:

The teacher said, Bob, Mary, come here and let us see who is the stronger

then that defines the strength comparison directly as being between those two

so this is correct in saying 'the stronger'

mathanxiety · 31/05/2023 14:55

ThatOnePlease · 31/05/2023 13:06

The comparative is correct. The use of 'the' is not.

'The stronger' is correct.

Contrary to the opinions of others here, I wouldn't consider it archaic or even old-fashioned.

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 31/05/2023 14:48

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 14:42

“It would be legitimate of the teacher to say it's not commonly used rather than tell a child that it's wrong.”

What a pointless thing to say. I think the child would be more interested in what was correct. Children are like that.

Anyway the woman was clueless and was trying to be smart. Lol

We haven't taught grammar prescriptively for at least 30 years so I'd imagine most teachers (the ones I train are certainly trained to use descriptivist teaching techniques and would be unlikely to pass their module on grammar if they insisted on teaching with prescriptivist "rules") would (or should) be doing exactly that. Telling the child that they won't see many examples like that, except in older, more formal texts, and to keep a lookout for them.

mathanxiety · 31/05/2023 14:48

@CoffeeCantata
You're my kind of teacher.

mathanxiety · 31/05/2023 14:46

Stronger is correct if comparing two.

Strongest is used if three or more are being compared.

Piglet89 · 31/05/2023 14:44

@Awumminnscotland

OP and her child’s teacher: she is the intelligenter of the two.

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 14:43

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 31/05/2023 14:38

No, it isn't. That's why I didn't say "which is wrong".

Jolly good. I knowed that.

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 14:42

RitaFires · 31/05/2023 14:30

The stronger is a bit archaic, most people would say who is stronger or who is the strongest. If a small child was talking about who is the stronger some might think they're wrong or a bit pretentious in their choice of language. It would be legitimate of the teacher to say it's not commonly used rather than tell a child that it's wrong.

“It would be legitimate of the teacher to say it's not commonly used rather than tell a child that it's wrong.”

What a pointless thing to say. I think the child would be more interested in what was correct. Children are like that.

Anyway the woman was clueless and was trying to be smart. Lol

Elphame · 31/05/2023 14:41

Strong
Stronger
Strongest

The book is correct. The teacher is wrong

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 31/05/2023 14:38

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 12:43

Formal is not wrong.🙄

No, it isn't. That's why I didn't say "which is wrong".

Awumminnscotland · 31/05/2023 14:31

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 12:42

What would your mil think of this:

“… teachers written communication.” ?

🤣🤣🤣🤣

OP posts:
MasterBeth · 31/05/2023 14:30

"Who is the stronger" is formally correct, if a little old fashioned.

I wonder if anyone on the thread has had their judgment affected by the proximity of the half-rhyme between "contest" and "strongest" in the text?

RitaFires · 31/05/2023 14:30

The stronger is a bit archaic, most people would say who is stronger or who is the strongest. If a small child was talking about who is the stronger some might think they're wrong or a bit pretentious in their choice of language. It would be legitimate of the teacher to say it's not commonly used rather than tell a child that it's wrong.

MercyChant66 · 31/05/2023 14:22

Awumminnscotland · 31/05/2023 10:33

Interesting. I'm also child of the 70s but in Scotland so completely different here but I may just have forgotten alot!

Child of the 60s here, also in Scotland but that makes no difference to this - OP you are absolutely correct, stronger is used to compare 2 , strongest for 3 or more. I was brought up in a family of English teachers and grammar was taught from early on in primary school.

Cam22 · 31/05/2023 14:10

In England, perhaps.

RockGirl · 31/05/2023 13:58

I don't know why you are surprised.

You can get on a PGCE with a 2:2 and GCSE Maths and English at grade C.

The skills test requirement was removed in 2019 (though it was pretty basic anyway).