Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with my siblings for insisting our mum gets a Samsung phone?

82 replies

Smangsung · 30/05/2023 21:02

Namechanged for this and swapped a few details.

I am one of 3 siblings. Our dad died last summer which means our mum is now on her own a lot more and using a mobile more than she did. My dad was a massive Apple fan and they both have/had iPads and my mum has an iPhone. My dad had a very old Nokia.

Anyway, my mum's iPhone 6 doesn't retain battery charge very well now as it's old so sibling A suggested that we club together for a new phone for her birthday at the end of February. Great!

We talked about budget and agreed £100 each so I researched refurbed iPhones for that sort of price. Sibling A said that actually it would be much better for mum to have a Samsung as £300 will buy a pretty good new phone. As our mum is in her 80s I thought learning how to use a new phone would be a bit tricky but both siblings overruled me and said Samsung was loads better than Apple.

I have an Apple and they're both Samsung users so I backed down and agreed that we should get her a Samsung.

On her birthday, sibling A said they would stay after the birthday lunch and set the new phone up. After several hours, they gave up as actually it seems it's not that simple to transfer content from an iPhone to a Samsung. They said they'd come back and do it another time.

They were visiting again this weekend. Apparently they were 'too stressed' to do it this time too.

So I've spent £130 (it went up) on a present for my widowed mother on her first birthday after her husband died which is sitting in a drawer. Our dad was a really thoughtful and considerate gift giver. I know our mum will be sad and disappointed.

I don't think AIBU to be pissed off but I'd like suggestions on what to do. I don't want to have to learn how to use the new android phone but is that the only thing I can do?

OP posts:
BillyNoM8s · 30/05/2023 21:48

WhatsApp is linked to the phone number. You do a backup within whatsapp on the current phone then should be able to restore everything when you log in on the new device.

GwinCoch · 30/05/2023 21:48

X6hfyib4ms · 30/05/2023 21:47

Agree I only do tech support on devices I know so always buy parents the slightly older version of the Samsung I've got.

Agree sell the Samsung. BUT I think your mum needs to take some responsibility here, ie she's an adult, not a teen who's been given her first phone.

If she can afford it I think she needs to pay the balance to get a new iPhone (I wouldn't do refurb after loads of issues). Then you set it up.

In future, she budgets for new phones or goes on a contract yo pay it off monthly.

It’s a birthday present though…

X6hfyib4ms · 30/05/2023 21:47

Agree I only do tech support on devices I know so always buy parents the slightly older version of the Samsung I've got.

Agree sell the Samsung. BUT I think your mum needs to take some responsibility here, ie she's an adult, not a teen who's been given her first phone.

If she can afford it I think she needs to pay the balance to get a new iPhone (I wouldn't do refurb after loads of issues). Then you set it up.

In future, she budgets for new phones or goes on a contract yo pay it off monthly.

GwinCoch · 30/05/2023 21:41

Good luck!

Smangsung · 30/05/2023 21:41

Just asked sibling B and they've said they'll sort it this weekend. I still think it's a terrible idea as she's going to find using a new system difficult but it's two against one!

@weathervane1 I would have done that happily!

Fingers crossed it all works out.

Thanks all Smile

OP posts:
Somanycats · 30/05/2023 21:40

I love my own android and bloody hate my work iPhone. Because I've always used android I guess. I would hate to be your mum's age and have to change -that was very short sighted of your siblings. Give her back an apple!

CarryOnThen · 30/05/2023 21:36

I went from iPhone to Samsung and now Google and I really like androids now. But it does take getting used to and for the first week I struggled. Transferring data is definitely a challenge and it took me a few goes to sort out WhatsApp, you have to make sure it’s been recently backed up and then attach the two phones by a cable. When my mum talked about switching to android I told her not to as I didn’t think she’d find the process easy enough.

ChiChaNaYubi · 30/05/2023 21:32

I feel your pain. I went from iPhone to a Samsung a few years ago and I lasted 2 days and got another iPhone. I find them so awkward to use and the operating system just really inferior.

underneaththeash · 30/05/2023 21:31

She's far too old to change now. Get her an apple.

PS I couldn't be arsed changing either.

weathervane1 · 30/05/2023 21:30

I had a similar choice a year or so ago. My iPhone 6+ (old, I know bit it works perfectly well and it's mine, no contract and Tescos charges me £9 a month for everything - unlimited). Anyway, £18 later via Amazon and twenty mins with the supplied screwdriver set, and I've installed a brand new battery and it's holding its charge really well. It may not be everyone's idea when compared to a shiny new phone, but it made sense to me.

GwinCoch · 30/05/2023 21:29

Apple aren’t better/superior/magic but if you are used to one operating system and set up then it can be hard to transition. I think I would volunteer to sort it out but only on the understanding that the phone goes back. I couldn’t be an Android helpdesk, but I am pretty good at being an Apple one.

Alongtimelonely · 30/05/2023 21:29

My mum would never have coped with the switch to Android at that age.

If your mum is ok with an iPhone then don’t change.

My mum found the screen glare and touch- screen approach too hard in her 80s, even though she was fine on an iPad. I think it all gets harder with age.

tell your siblings to return the phone and once that’s done you’ll source a new iPhone. I have a reconditioned iPhone 8 that was cheap and is fine

Smangsung · 30/05/2023 21:29

chupachucks · 30/05/2023 21:26

Not exactly hard to learn how to use an android phone. Your over reacting and it sounds like your just pissed off because they did not by an apple phone.

So my hyperbole. Might good for you to sit down and actually have a play around with it and do something useful if it's sat in her draw, take it and learn how to use it, it will only take you a couple of hours.

You never know you might get over the fixation on Apple products, after all there is nothing special and no magic apple dust that makes them magical devices.

It's nothing to do with magic. It's familiarity.

OP posts:
INeedAnotherName · 30/05/2023 21:28

Android phones and tablets are very good however swapping between apple and android is a nightmare.

Once you've found one that suits you then stick with it imo.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 30/05/2023 21:27

My rule is, if I’m going to be tech support I get to choose. Along with that if I choose that means I’ve signed up for tech support.

Yeah your sisters screwed up and let them sort it out.

chupachucks · 30/05/2023 21:27

EdinaCrump · 30/05/2023 21:24

the top-end android phones my brothers get always seem to die after 12-18 months so I’d get rid of it pronto

Tell him to stop dropping them then 🤣, Utter nonsense.

chupachucks · 30/05/2023 21:26

Not exactly hard to learn how to use an android phone. Your over reacting and it sounds like your just pissed off because they did not by an apple phone.

So my hyperbole. Might good for you to sit down and actually have a play around with it and do something useful if it's sat in her draw, take it and learn how to use it, it will only take you a couple of hours.

You never know you might get over the fixation on Apple products, after all there is nothing special and no magic apple dust that makes them magical devices.

EdinaCrump · 30/05/2023 21:24

the top-end android phones my brothers get always seem to die after 12-18 months so I’d get rid of it pronto

ShandaLear · 30/05/2023 21:24

I’d cut my losses, return the phone or take it to somewhere like CEX and trade it in for a used/refurbished iPhone XR or 11 - or there are online companies that do this. She already happily uses an iPad and an iPhone so it’s easy to set up and for her to use.

ChicoryDip · 30/05/2023 21:24

We made this mistake and bought DM a Galaxy tablet rather than an iPad as it seemed like a much better deal and my thinking was 'how different can it be?'

Turns out it was very different, we weren't good at supporting DM and consequently she rarely used it as we couldn't help her easily over the phone. Bit the bullet, sold the tablet on Marketplace and bought a reconditioned iPad. Just wish we'd done it to start with.

Smangsung · 30/05/2023 21:23

It's WhatsApp which is a particular issue apparently. You can't just transfer stuff across easily it seems? My sibling had to go and buy a thing yesterday morning but still didn't manage to do it.

OP posts:
coldiris · 30/05/2023 21:23

If your siblings find it too stressful or time consuming, then it will be even more complicated for your mum. I agree with those who suggest returning the phone and if the siblings say anything, then perhaps they can devote appropriate time to setting it all up and making sure your mum is comfortable with using it!

My mum's first phone was a Samsung and for that reason I never change the brand. She is used to it and there is no way I can easily get her to get used to something else. So I fully understand your reasoning and frustration.

CatsOnTheChair · 30/05/2023 21:22

I was all set to say there is nothing wrong with Samsung. But in your case, I'd be sticking firmly with Apple.
Your siblings messed up. See what you can do about returning or selling the Samsung. And get the best iPhone you can with the proceeds.

TrishTrix · 30/05/2023 21:18

Sympathies. I only provide tech support for oldies on devices I own.

I told my aunt if she bought an android phone she could no longer rely on me.

She bought an iPhone (to go with her two iPads. Because obviously you need two when you can barely use one).