Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dentist wants 95 pounds to register child as an NHS patient

110 replies

surreyisik · 30/05/2023 20:27

Hi all,
Just wanted to get some views here. High street dentist wants us to register as a patient first to take DS as an NHS patient. It's fine until this point, but they say they can only do this if we register as a private patient ourselves (£95) and get checked regularly with at least something basic such as teeth cleaning (£75)
Do you think this is acceptable? Why do we have to pay to make sure our son can become an NHS patient and not pay?? It feels unfair, especially for families who can't afford it.

OP posts:
Lollygaggle · 01/06/2023 07:09

When I started out in dentistry I never expected to do very much private work, no one did.
The last year , as a very experienced dentist , that I worked fully NHS I earned £27,000. I earned less than my newly qualified dental therapist.
My colleague who owned his own practice has now retired but earned £17,000 in one of the last years he worked.
Even now , working mostly privately in a very poor , very high needs area I have never earned enough to pay higher rate tax since the early 1990s.

You have to work at a faster and faster rate just to pay the bills and as someone who trained young dentists coming out of dental school with £80,000 debts , the despair many of them have at realising the mess NHS dentistry is in and their inability to earn a decent living without flogging themselves to death is very sad.

I've known my patients, patients children and grandchildren for decades and am all too aware that there is absolutely no provision for many of them to have dental treatment now almost everywhere is private . The decision to go caused a lot of guilt amongst myself and my colleagues.

However my clinical work is now finished due to ill health exacerbated by the years of mental and physical stress of dentistry , most in NHS. The immense pressure of working throughout covid definitely added to that and has resulted in many of my colleagues of the same vintage retiring absolutely burnt out. We propped up a failing system for years as more and more cost to ourselves and families. No one can expect the younger generation to do the same in a system that is exponentially getting worse.

All of this is without talking about the suicides , addictions and mental health problems plaguing dentists in an already high stress profession without the ridiculous NHS payment system that values you less than a worker at McDonald's.

ArcticSkewer · 01/06/2023 06:36

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 06:22

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee

I totally accept that the government has failed with the NHS dental system. There needs to be a complete overhaul, but no government minister mentions it. I assume they're driving it into the ground.

I feel bitter that I now have to pay, plus my two adult children (MLW) at £129 for our check-ups. PLUS I work for a charity and accept a lower wage as I want to give to my local community. Why can't dentists?

Have you ever asked the heads of charities why they don't accept lower wages? You are a fool if you do while they are employed on £££.

Is it noble to accept a low wage and pay less tax than you potentially could? Let someone else who can't get a better paid job do that job while you earn more. We need taxes to pay for NHS dentistry for example. It's very selfish to deliberately under-earn just to enjoy a rosy glow of do-gooding. Who are you expecting to pay for the NHS? All the wage slaves working for the non charity sector?

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 06:22

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee

I totally accept that the government has failed with the NHS dental system. There needs to be a complete overhaul, but no government minister mentions it. I assume they're driving it into the ground.

I feel bitter that I now have to pay, plus my two adult children (MLW) at £129 for our check-ups. PLUS I work for a charity and accept a lower wage as I want to give to my local community. Why can't dentists?

windowopen · 31/05/2023 22:54

Oops. Forgot to include the extra bit underneath. An "extraction visit" which is another £8.30.
This is only payable for one appointment, so if you take a longer appointment to remove several teeth you can only claim the extraction visit once.

Apologies. It equates to a bit more than the amp but detailed in last post, but even still, you'll get the gist. It's really not possible any longer.
Some tooth extractions are really tricky and take a lot longer and require a lot of skill. we don't receive our degrees lightly I'll tell you that.

windowopen · 31/05/2023 22:50

Here is an example of how NHS dentists in Scotland get paid.
A child requires a tooth extraction. The procedure usually takes half an hour. If poor cooperation, which happens a lot, the extraction might not be able to go ahead, so the 30 minutes is effectively wasted, and the patient reappointed.
But say for example the patient extracts the tooth in 30 mins. In Scotland there is a fee per item system. The practice receives that money, which equates to an hourly rate of £20.30.
The practice keeps half of that ( ratio 50:50) order to pay the nurse ( doesn't cover hourly rate of nurse), materials, sterilisation, admin, utility bills, various insurances, PPE, computer software etc etc...

The associate dentist gets the £10.15 for the hour they work ( normal apportionment is 50:50)

They need to put approximately 25% away to taxman. Then they also need to ensure they have paid for their indemnity, their uniform, their GDC license to practice, their transport costs,

In summary, the dentist who is carrying out the NHS extraction has earned about £5 or £6 an hour after expenses.

The practice is working at a considerable loss.

Of course some items on the NHS are slightly higher remuneration, but generally the the figures aren't stacking up any longer. Every time I make a denture on the NHS it actually costs me money now.

Dentists really have no option but to supplement NHS with private in order to break even.

Dentist wants 95 pounds to register child as an NHS patient
OHEdentalnurse · 31/05/2023 20:58

DepartureLounge · 31/05/2023 17:46

This kind of thing is common practice but that doesn't make it any better. I think everyone should have access to NHS dentistry but at a bare minimum children should, irrespective of their parents' status as patients or not patients, NHS or private. The wider medical problems this country is storing up as a result of not looking after the nation's children's oral health is appalling and very stupid. All of this is a political problem but it isn't helped by the grabby culture in dentistry which at the very least borders on sharp practice and in many, many practices far exceeds it in my experience. I came on to the thread to warn you that there'd be dentists along soon to bleat about how hard they have it but I see I'm too late. YANBU, OP.

Completely untrue statement.

The NHS dentistry is a shambles.

Dentistry starts at home, the only reason a child's oral health would be poor is from poor habits in the home (brushing/diet) not by going to the dentist. You think seeing a dentist twice a year is going to solve 6 months worth of dental neglect?

People are happy to spend £30 on their nails, £400 a month on car payments, £14 on cocktails ..... but spend £25 for a check up for their child. "Oh no, it's far too expensive"
Some of you need to get your priorities straight.

I pay privately £50 once a year because it's necessary.

Most dentists are trying to wade through backlogs of patients that don't visit regularly, are having remedial work due to dodgy company's online or abroad, or simply can't be arsed to brush their teeth.

tourdefrance · 31/05/2023 20:28

I have an NHS dentist and this thread has reminded me that we hadn't been in a while. Booked myself and dc in for check ups in a few months as first available slots. I am obviously very lucky.

Lapland123 · 31/05/2023 18:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lapland123 · 31/05/2023 18:53

tourdefrance · 31/05/2023 17:11

This is a terrible comparison.

Eating out is optional.

Basic healthcare (including dentistry) isn't.

But if no one is paying for that healthcare ( government not funding dentistry) then the comparison is the same - from a private business point of view

Conkersinautumn · 31/05/2023 18:24

I've been unable.to have dental.treatmemt for years because of the cost. Nothing I can do about it. Fortunately my children currently are NHS patients but I registered them when I was still under the.maternity free treatment benefit.

Lapland123 · 31/05/2023 18:19

DepartureLounge · 31/05/2023 17:46

This kind of thing is common practice but that doesn't make it any better. I think everyone should have access to NHS dentistry but at a bare minimum children should, irrespective of their parents' status as patients or not patients, NHS or private. The wider medical problems this country is storing up as a result of not looking after the nation's children's oral health is appalling and very stupid. All of this is a political problem but it isn't helped by the grabby culture in dentistry which at the very least borders on sharp practice and in many, many practices far exceeds it in my experience. I came on to the thread to warn you that there'd be dentists along soon to bleat about how hard they have it but I see I'm too late. YANBU, OP.

This literally makes no sense

Do you bleat about John Lewis not furnishing children’s bedrooms for free, or Tesco not feeding hungry kids for free?

Thought not

knitnerd90 · 31/05/2023 18:16

The reality is, though, if they cracked down on this what dentists would do is stop offering any NHS treatment at all. They don't have any obligation to work for the NHS. They're relying on private fees to subsidise their NHS work.

Complain to your MP - but it will only have any benefit if they start funding NHS dentistry. You can't fix the problem on the backs of dentists.

Geordielass1987 · 31/05/2023 18:08

I have to pay for my child (under 5) as a private patient. Nowhere will see her as Nhs. The check ups are under £20, I know not everyone can do it but I find it really reasonable. Just such a shame this is the situation we’re all left in

Rowthe · 31/05/2023 18:03

DepartureLounge · 31/05/2023 17:46

This kind of thing is common practice but that doesn't make it any better. I think everyone should have access to NHS dentistry but at a bare minimum children should, irrespective of their parents' status as patients or not patients, NHS or private. The wider medical problems this country is storing up as a result of not looking after the nation's children's oral health is appalling and very stupid. All of this is a political problem but it isn't helped by the grabby culture in dentistry which at the very least borders on sharp practice and in many, many practices far exceeds it in my experience. I came on to the thread to warn you that there'd be dentists along soon to bleat about how hard they have it but I see I'm too late. YANBU, OP.

Again in private practice professionals can decide on their own working conditions.

If you dont like it, lobby your MP

I dont see people complaining about big businesses charging for their products???

DepartureLounge · 31/05/2023 17:46

This kind of thing is common practice but that doesn't make it any better. I think everyone should have access to NHS dentistry but at a bare minimum children should, irrespective of their parents' status as patients or not patients, NHS or private. The wider medical problems this country is storing up as a result of not looking after the nation's children's oral health is appalling and very stupid. All of this is a political problem but it isn't helped by the grabby culture in dentistry which at the very least borders on sharp practice and in many, many practices far exceeds it in my experience. I came on to the thread to warn you that there'd be dentists along soon to bleat about how hard they have it but I see I'm too late. YANBU, OP.

tourdefrance · 31/05/2023 17:11

Lapland123 · 31/05/2023 07:07

And the title of this thread is plainly misleading. The dental practice want you, and adult, to pay a registration fee and use their services ( to a minimum level). They are not asking for £95 to register your child.

it reminds me of when Prezzo used to have a kids 3 course meal for £1 if with an adult buying a main. It’s like you’ve gone to Prezzo and just asked for the £1 3 course kid’s meal for your kid, but you don’t want to be a paying adult!!!

This is a terrible comparison.

Eating out is optional.

Basic healthcare (including dentistry) isn't.

Hoppinggreen · 31/05/2023 14:57

The only NHS children my dentist takes on now are ones of Private patients.
They are independent businesses so can decide their own policies to a certain extent I suppose
Its awful how so many people can’t access cheap or free dental care but like most businesses dentists want profitable clients, they aren’t charities

SlipSlidinAway · 31/05/2023 14:54

CannotDoThisAnymore · 31/05/2023 14:03

I was under the impression that me paying NI meant i would have access to an NHS dentist? Is that not the case? Im still under NHS atm and so are my kids. Its all going private in my area. Who can afford £50 check ups? Crazy. There will be a epidemic of bad teeth at this rate as people just cannot afford to see the dentist

No, it's not the case.

And I'm amazed you don't know that there is already an epidemic of bad teeth.

TrishTrix · 31/05/2023 14:11

Those of you getting steamed up about this need to raise your concerns with your MP especially if they are conservative.

NHS dentistry is on it's knees. It is having a huge impact on the wellbeing of children. But dentists aren't charities and can't keep providing care for free.

If we aren't careful GPs will go the same way. I often read threads on here and think that those who are most supportive of NHS privatisation are those who stand to lose the most ....

DOI: NHS consultant who works closely aligned with adult and paediatric hospital dental services. I have a private dentist as my colleagues told me NHS dentistry isn't viable now and I would be unlikely to get a good one locally.

ArcticSkewer · 31/05/2023 14:09

CannotDoThisAnymore · 31/05/2023 14:03

I was under the impression that me paying NI meant i would have access to an NHS dentist? Is that not the case? Im still under NHS atm and so are my kids. Its all going private in my area. Who can afford £50 check ups? Crazy. There will be a epidemic of bad teeth at this rate as people just cannot afford to see the dentist

No that's not the case.

Rowthe · 31/05/2023 14:06

CannotDoThisAnymore · 31/05/2023 14:03

I was under the impression that me paying NI meant i would have access to an NHS dentist? Is that not the case? Im still under NHS atm and so are my kids. Its all going private in my area. Who can afford £50 check ups? Crazy. There will be a epidemic of bad teeth at this rate as people just cannot afford to see the dentist

Dentists dont keep a record of who has or hasnt paid NI.

The provision is the same for everyone regardless of whether they have paid NI or not.

So if you do lose your dentist for whatever reason you may have the same problems getting another as others on this thread.

CannotDoThisAnymore · 31/05/2023 14:03

I was under the impression that me paying NI meant i would have access to an NHS dentist? Is that not the case? Im still under NHS atm and so are my kids. Its all going private in my area. Who can afford £50 check ups? Crazy. There will be a epidemic of bad teeth at this rate as people just cannot afford to see the dentist

ArcticSkewer · 31/05/2023 13:56

beAsensible1 · 31/05/2023 12:40

I cannot believe so many people are excusing this. if they are willing to take on your child as an NHS patient they do have provision. its basically extorting desperate parents and should absolutely be reported.

I have honestly never heard of this shit in my life.

Do no adults have an NHS dentist on here?

It's up to them what they do.

They are obviously a private provider. Their main business is therefore private patients. They don't have to take on anyone they don't want to - including people who register but then don't ever go.

To do people a favour they agree to see children on an NHS basis. It's quite common.

I don't know about everyone else on mn. I've always had a private dentist. Now my kids are adults they are also private. I pay for health insurance that covers dental and optical.

Lapland123 · 31/05/2023 13:12

Rowthe · 31/05/2023 09:30

Yes she should write to he MP.

But why people expect dentists to work for free or out of their pockets mystified me.

Dentists deserve to be paid for what they do. If the NHS wont pay them then they will go private. I'm sure if the NHS paid them properly there would be a lot more NHS places available, it I'm not sure why dentists should be blamed for this. They have bill's to pay just like anyone else, if their work isnt paying their Bill's of course they will make changes.

And yes, if the same happens to GP's then that will be next. Theres already an exodus.

Precisely this

You need to be very ignorant of the current climate to blame dentists.

Sure, all kids should have NHS dentists. But if there are no NHS dentists-because that’s not viable anymore for dentists- then there are no NHS dentists. No matter how indignant you are about that.

JenWillsiam · 31/05/2023 13:05

surreyisik · 30/05/2023 20:37

I feel the same. I understand why we have to register - let's say they have no capacity for adult NHS patients, so not ideal but has to be processed that way. But then why do we have to receive checks twice a year?? This is where it seemed really dodgy to me!

Because if you register and never go what’s the point of registering?

They do it because they make a loss on paediatric patients so your fees offset the cost. If they don’t they just limit further the number of children nhs patients they will take on.