Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dentist wants 95 pounds to register child as an NHS patient

110 replies

surreyisik · 30/05/2023 20:27

Hi all,
Just wanted to get some views here. High street dentist wants us to register as a patient first to take DS as an NHS patient. It's fine until this point, but they say they can only do this if we register as a private patient ourselves (£95) and get checked regularly with at least something basic such as teeth cleaning (£75)
Do you think this is acceptable? Why do we have to pay to make sure our son can become an NHS patient and not pay?? It feels unfair, especially for families who can't afford it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChristmasCwtch · 02/06/2023 08:01

I don’t think it’s unreasonable. Our dentist does the same, DH and I are private patients and our DC are covered by same dentist under NHS. I’m grateful the dentist does this.

Lollygaggle · 01/06/2023 22:37

I will post another young colleagues post about their work life

ANONYMOUS POST

“I am looking for some career progression advice or guidance.

I am currently working as a full time NHS GDP associate dentist and have noticed month on month a reduction in my pay to the point that I am currently struggling to pay basic household bills. (I took a loan to buy basic food last month!)

My lifestyle is not lavish or extravagant by any stretch of the imagination. I don’t buy new clothes, haven’t done for years, I don’t eat at restaurants, I drive a small car (a necessity to get to work) and use public transport as much as possible. My outgoings are bills (all essential), Lidl/Aldi food and things which I cannot change like travel, insurances and CPD (I rarely go on the courses I would like to due to cost). I haven’t had a holiday in 4 years. I don’t go out, I don’t drink/smoke/gamble. The last time I went out socially with friends was to the cinema around 3 years ago, this is not an exaggeration!

I find myself increasingly envious of what I see on social media, and find my current general quality of life is poor. My feeling is that this is largely financially led. I never envisaged as a dentist that my quality of life would be so abysmal. I appreciate that what is published on social media is not always a true reflection of peoples lives, but it would be nice to be able to go out and buy a pair of shoes without worrying that I can’t pay my rent.

Despite working over 40+ hours a week, my take home at the end of the month is less that of a supermarket sales assistant (I know as I have previously worked as one). I have no financial reserves should something unforeseeable occur. I feel like I am running a charity most days at a detriment to my own health.

I have discussed this with the practice principal and she has not been helpful. I have attended courses by the likes of Ashley Latter which I felt was not applicable to NHS dental care in the UK. I moved practices and enlisted the help of a mentor who turned out to be interested only in falsely acting as mentor to attract a new dentist to their practice.

The purpose of this post is that I feel that this could be my last year in dentistry. I largely enjoy the job, but I cannot continue to survive financially in my current situation. I think I am a good dentist, and my patient feedback is good.

My question is, how can I make life working as an NHS dentist sustainable/profitable? Im not looking to become a millionaire, I just want to wake up in the morning and not worry about my next pay check. What do I need to do to ensure I can carry on working whilst financially surviving?”

YellowDots · 01/06/2023 22:08

I saw my NHS dentist recently for a emergency appointment, it took weeks to get one and I didn't get anywhere with 101 or A&E either. I was in a lot of pain.

He was harassed to death. He honestly looked like he had slept in a bush. The only dentist left where there had been six before.

The phone never stopped ringing, there was a woman in there shouting at the receptionist.

Weeks later I went to register at a private dentist. Receptionist had time to explain everything, dentist was relaxed and chatty. Looked like he had walked out of the pages of a dental uniform catalogue.

I couldn't stop thinking of the poor harassed NHS dentist and wondering how long it was going to be before he was in a private practice too.

Rowthe · 01/06/2023 20:43

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 15:35

Ultimately the government is to blame for the shocking state of NHS dentistry in the UK.

Actually I don't blame the dentists, but the idea we all need to earn loads just is not feasible.

The pay needs to be high enough that it attracts the dentists to work the NHS

Due to the training requirements there isnt a surplus which would mean you could pay less. Or other jobs where you can train on the job. Dentists are highly skilled professionals. The pay needs to reflect this, otherwise you have the current outcome.

Lollygaggle · 01/06/2023 19:11

I doubt many people will want to read this https://apps.who.int/iris/rest/bitstreams/1431126/retrieve

but it is a breakdown of dental care/payment and workforce in EU plus U.K. and Switzerland.

UK is one of the very few to include dental treatment for all as part of NHS without additional insurance payments . In many countries treatment for children is either not free or only check ups and preventative treatment is free . Very few places include orthodontics (braces) , or crowns , root treatment etc.

In most counties the majority of dental spending is out of pocket ie patients pay.

It all points to what U.K. dentists are saying , as a country we need to have a core service for the vulnerable , not pretend we can provide everything for everybody . But that requires a government to be brave enough to admit NHS dental services cannot provide everything for everybody.

https://apps.who.int/iris/rest/bitstreams/1431126/retrieve

So1invictus · 01/06/2023 18:12

Gtsr443 · 01/06/2023 12:03

Italy has 87 dentists per 100k people. Germany 83. Japan 81.
UK has 53 per 100k people.

We have the fewest number of dentists per 100k people in the whole of the G7.

When will people realise that this shortage is political?
£400 million allocated to dental care went unspent last year.

Bury St Edmunds is receiving its 10th visit from Dentaid charity. People in agony queue for hours in the street to get treatment on their bus.
Burt St Edmunds ffs! In 2023.

That's what 13 years of Tory misrule does for you folks.

Italian statistics give 64 per 100k of which 45% are private.
I live in Puglia, in a town of about 60,000 inhabitants and if I wanted a public dentist I'd have to be referred by the hospital to one on their list. The nearest one to me is about 60 miles away.
Children don't get free dental treatment here and neither do pregnant women.

Lollygaggle · 01/06/2023 16:06

ItsNotRocketSalad · 01/06/2023 15:44

windowopen Don't the dentists also get reimbursed by the NHS a significant time after they carry out the work, creating cash flow problems?

No , in England and Wales dentists are set a target of treatment to carry out , and the payment is divided up into 12 equal payments. The difficulty is the targets are such that the majority of dental practices will not hit them. This is the reason dentists are so busy at the end of the financial year, working extra hours , over lunches etc because when you don't hit the target the money is clawed back from you.

Most dentists (around 78% ) do not own a practice they pay around 50 to 60% of what they earn to the practice to cover some of their expenses. However is they don't hit targets they have to pay 100% back in claw back.

Not only that but if they are not within 2% of their target the practice of contract is reduced the following year.

clawback has reached record amounts this year and that money is not reinvested in dentistry but props the rest of the NHS up.
https://bda.org/news-centre/latest-news-articles/Pages/Clawback-set-to-break-records-and-push-NHS-practices-to-the-wall.aspx

Clawback set to break records and push NHS practices to the wall

https://bda.org/news-centre/latest-news-articles/Pages/Clawback-set-to-break-records-and-push-NHS-practices-to-the-wall.aspx

ItsNotRocketSalad · 01/06/2023 15:44

windowopen Don't the dentists also get reimbursed by the NHS a significant time after they carry out the work, creating cash flow problems?

SpringBunnies · 01/06/2023 15:41

I mean family members of existing patients only.

SpringBunnies · 01/06/2023 15:41

What's the point of complaining. There aren't many dentists around. Even if you are paying private there is a waiting list. It took me a year to get DC onto my private dentist and they will only accept new patients that are already customers.

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 15:35

Ultimately the government is to blame for the shocking state of NHS dentistry in the UK.

Actually I don't blame the dentists, but the idea we all need to earn loads just is not feasible.

ArcticSkewer · 01/06/2023 14:02

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 10:38

ArcticSkewer
Hahhhahhhaaaa that’s the biggest load of tripe I have ever read on MN. My God, so I need to earn more to pay for the NHS!! Also, my managers are not on loads so that blows your theory out the water.

I am entitled , as we all are, to NHS dentistry. But there are none.

So who is going to pay for it then?

People with better paid jobs than you, I guess is your answer. Maybe all those private dentists paying higher taxes?

Lapland123 · 01/06/2023 13:41

Lollygaggle · 01/06/2023 12:50

I read this heart breaking comment from a young colleague this morning . It tells the working reality of NHS dentistry

"I just need to say that I'm really fed up with the NHS dentistry. I've been working so very hard, with no benefits. Nobody cares, my health is going down, feel like on a treadmill.
It also affects my nurse. We can't take it any more. It's inhuman, it's wrong.
I consider myself to be a very good and caring dentist, my nurse is even better, but we’ve reached the point, we're burnt out, and ill.
I would love to move to a practice where I work hard, and I'm still able to pay the bills, and feed my family, where I have time to have a drink and go to the toilet at least once a day.
My nurse and me, we both care about so many people, but it looks like nobody cares about us.
How much can we take?
We're both done.
Not expecting any help, just wanted to say how I feel. Sometimes life it's too much."

That’s absolutely dreadful
In such conditions there will be no NHS dentists left as it doesn’t make any sense to be one.

But some misguided posters blame the dentists instead of the government who don’t fund dentistry for the country.

Pancakefam · 01/06/2023 12:58

No, they aren't allowed to do this. Yes, they do it anyway. The health inequality caused by the current dentistry system is truly shocking.

Lollygaggle · 01/06/2023 12:50

I read this heart breaking comment from a young colleague this morning . It tells the working reality of NHS dentistry

"I just need to say that I'm really fed up with the NHS dentistry. I've been working so very hard, with no benefits. Nobody cares, my health is going down, feel like on a treadmill.
It also affects my nurse. We can't take it any more. It's inhuman, it's wrong.
I consider myself to be a very good and caring dentist, my nurse is even better, but we’ve reached the point, we're burnt out, and ill.
I would love to move to a practice where I work hard, and I'm still able to pay the bills, and feed my family, where I have time to have a drink and go to the toilet at least once a day.
My nurse and me, we both care about so many people, but it looks like nobody cares about us.
How much can we take?
We're both done.
Not expecting any help, just wanted to say how I feel. Sometimes life it's too much."

Lapland123 · 01/06/2023 12:48

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 10:38

ArcticSkewer
Hahhhahhhaaaa that’s the biggest load of tripe I have ever read on MN. My God, so I need to earn more to pay for the NHS!! Also, my managers are not on loads so that blows your theory out the water.

I am entitled , as we all are, to NHS dentistry. But there are none.

Do you think paying dentists appropriately might help the lack of nhs dentists, or is that a thought too far?🙄

Gtsr443 · 01/06/2023 12:03

Italy has 87 dentists per 100k people. Germany 83. Japan 81.
UK has 53 per 100k people.

We have the fewest number of dentists per 100k people in the whole of the G7.

When will people realise that this shortage is political?
£400 million allocated to dental care went unspent last year.

Bury St Edmunds is receiving its 10th visit from Dentaid charity. People in agony queue for hours in the street to get treatment on their bus.
Burt St Edmunds ffs! In 2023.

That's what 13 years of Tory misrule does for you folks.

PaperSheet · 01/06/2023 10:52

Well SOMEONE has to pay for the NHS no?? Why is it always other people? Someone else should get into debt for thousands to become a dentist and give me free treatment while I work cheaply in a nice easy charity shop! Other people should pay thousands in tax to pay for it as well! Not me though as I "give back" to the community and don't earn enough to pay much tax.

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 10:38

ArcticSkewer
Hahhhahhhaaaa that’s the biggest load of tripe I have ever read on MN. My God, so I need to earn more to pay for the NHS!! Also, my managers are not on loads so that blows your theory out the water.

I am entitled , as we all are, to NHS dentistry. But there are none.

Lapland123 · 01/06/2023 09:55

crossstitchingnana · 01/06/2023 06:22

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee

I totally accept that the government has failed with the NHS dental system. There needs to be a complete overhaul, but no government minister mentions it. I assume they're driving it into the ground.

I feel bitter that I now have to pay, plus my two adult children (MLW) at £129 for our check-ups. PLUS I work for a charity and accept a lower wage as I want to give to my local community. Why can't dentists?

I would also presume ‘crossstichingnana’ working a few hours in charity has had her mortgage paid and kids raised, probably has not had a professional job or she would not be talking such communist drivel

ArcticSkewer · 01/06/2023 09:49

PaperSheet · 01/06/2023 09:00

Exactly. Why would a dentist who has been though 5 years of university and has all the responsibility (including the risk of being sued and having to pay thousands for the Indemnity to cover that etc) and pay all other fees associated with their profession agree to be paid the same as their dental nurse who has minimal responsibility and associated fees are much lower etc? (Not slating dental nurses by the way. I was one for years and would happily go back to it if the wages were higher. But you just can't compare the amount of training and responsibility between the two). If my current dental profession wages lowered to that of a dental nurse, I'd quit and go back to that in a heartbeat.

Communist model of work - suits those with no skills

Hoppinggreen · 01/06/2023 09:32

My friend who is a Dentist has sold her practice, it just wasn’t possible for her to earn enough as a single Mum without working in a way she wasn’t happy with.
She now does a bit of locum work, is a sedation specialist and has trained to give Botox.
She works 3 days a week and is raking it in with no stress

PaperSheet · 01/06/2023 09:00

Lapland123 · 01/06/2023 08:41

I’m referring to crossstritching mana’s post about why can’t dentists just work for minimum wage like she does.

why would anyone go to the bother of working hard at school, through university and paying tuition fees in order to work for wages they could get without the hassle of all that

Do you actually want no dentists to exist, crossstichingnana?

😂😂😂😂😂

Exactly. Why would a dentist who has been though 5 years of university and has all the responsibility (including the risk of being sued and having to pay thousands for the Indemnity to cover that etc) and pay all other fees associated with their profession agree to be paid the same as their dental nurse who has minimal responsibility and associated fees are much lower etc? (Not slating dental nurses by the way. I was one for years and would happily go back to it if the wages were higher. But you just can't compare the amount of training and responsibility between the two). If my current dental profession wages lowered to that of a dental nurse, I'd quit and go back to that in a heartbeat.

Lapland123 · 01/06/2023 08:41

Lapland123 · 01/06/2023 08:38

This is so silly I don’t know what to say 😂😂😂😂

I’m referring to crossstritching mana’s post about why can’t dentists just work for minimum wage like she does.

why would anyone go to the bother of working hard at school, through university and paying tuition fees in order to work for wages they could get without the hassle of all that

Do you actually want no dentists to exist, crossstichingnana?

😂😂😂😂😂

Lapland123 · 01/06/2023 08:38

This is so silly I don’t know what to say 😂😂😂😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread