Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's being a CF here?

388 replies

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 30/05/2023 19:08

Ok so help solve this for me please.
DP will be moving in with me & my 2 primary aged DS's later part of this year, date to be confirmed. DP is lovely and both DS's love him.
He has one DD, teens who lives with ex.

Been together 18 months. DP is generally generous. Basic job basic pay, retail.
DP currently living with his dad in his childhood room, only paying £40pw so basically being subsidised to a degree. Dad selling up and moving in with GF soon.
DP has no property, his ex had own house before they met.
I have my own home, mortgaged currently (pretty low payments at this stage) but will be paid off within 5 years or less.

This is also a WWYD.
DP keeps looking at house stuff, ornaments, knick knacks, and furniture etc, yes it's nice he's looking ahead.
Here's the but.
My bedroom furniture will need to be changed, mine is virtually new and I'm happy with it, but DP is tall so he wants to upgrade to a bigger and longer bed (I'm petite) and he also wants a taller wardrobe etc. Fair enough.
He's assuming that I'm going to pay for these?? Or he'll 'chip in' I think where his words when we spoke about it after Xmas. Like it's a favour 🤑.
For context I have a tiny bit of rainy day savings, which I've already eaten into. Struggling like everyone else right now.
I have a low wage p/t job, no means to increase and no support with DSs, no family nearby etc, I get CTC and WFTC, both of which I'll lose once he's moved in.
Should I be telling him he's got to buy the bedroom furniture himself?
I don't feel happy effectively paying for him to move in with me, saving himself maybe 1200pm + in rent and bills he'd have paid once his DF moves away.
Would you expect your shortfall covered at the very least?
Context again, I pay what I can, proportional to my earnings when we go out as a couple, often more than I can afford, but usually less than half.
I don't want to make money from him, but I also don't want to be using any of my own, which I class as for my 2 boys only, to essentially subsidise him moving into my large property cheaply (is-that-even-a-word)
Opinions please MNers!

OP posts:
OttoGraph · 30/05/2023 21:06

Should I be telling him he's got to buy the bedroom furniture himself?

you tell him you're happy with the bedroom furniture and if he wants to change the bed and the wardrobe, thats fine - but he will need to be splashing the cash on it. You've splashed the cash on the furniture that is installed and only recently so its no an expenditure you want or need

PinkyFlamingo · 30/05/2023 21:04

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 30/05/2023 19:13

Oh I've no indication btw that he won't want to pay fairly, re bills etc. We are yet to have that chat. As I said, he's generous mostly.
It's the wardrobe and stuff that has got me a bit mardy!

Of course you have an indication, its this!

EarringsandLipstick · 30/05/2023 21:01

3luckystars · 30/05/2023 20:49

Make him move out by himself for at least a year first. Please do this.

This needs to be a decision made after you have proof that he can afford to pay his way and stand on his own two feet. You need to know this information before you even dream of letting him move into your family home.

This is solid advice.

AfraidToRun · 30/05/2023 21:00

He should live by himself first (but if he turns up for tea every day) kick him out.

Gerwurtztraminer · 30/05/2023 21:00

Reigateforever · 30/05/2023 20:03

Please see a solicitor to have it written that it is your house and your mortgage to protect yourself, so that in a few year’s time when he moves out and needs x amount of the house, he won’t be able to claim. He won’t be the first.

Yes, this is what I was going to post. Please, please, if you do let him move in (don't) then at least get a proper legal arrangement in place so he has no claim on your home in future.

Because when if comes to an end and he can show evidence of financial contributions towards the home (including things like buying materials and doing DIY that adds value to the property) he may be eligible to make a ‘beneficial interest’ claim. And then you're in for a legal fight.

ThatsNotGoodMelon · 30/05/2023 21:00

Bet he's not "generous" enough to actually pay his way when it comes to paying the equivalent of market rent plus bills.

Newestname002 · 30/05/2023 20:59

@Thatleadsingersbiggestfan

My heart just sank when I read your OP, and nothing in your subsequent posts changed that.. there's another thread running at the moment where the OP there has let her boyfriend move into her place. Perhaps you might find it interesting. Check out "Guest every other weekend" in AIBU. 🌹

sheworemellowyellow · 30/05/2023 20:59

Yet another post where I ask myself why the OP is so lacking in self-respect, so desperate for a live-in partner, that she'll actually pay someone and risk her and her children's future to get him.

So depressing.

OP, you are so, so woefully unprepared for this. He saw you coming, and you're blind. This man will take from you and your children financially, emotionally, practically. Given he's on a basic wage, has a daughter himself who would have first dibs on whatever money and time he does have, and seemingly lacks any self-respect himself, there's no amount of goodwill he can have to make up for all that. Even if he's saintly in all his intentions, they will count for nothing in 10 years' time when the courts decide that he's entitled to a share of your home after a decade of you doing the bulk of the house work, you pulling in the lion's share of the household income, having his daughter bunk up with your sons, and a level of resentment you will hate yourself with. It's how these things ALWAYS go. This is so, so imbalanced.

Ask yourself this: are you 100% sure that if anything were to happen to you and, say, you ended up disabled to the extent of being unable to work, he would be there to look after you and your home and help you look after your boys till your dying day? If you're only 99% sure, don't make the huge sacrifices you're about to make.

NatashaDancing · 30/05/2023 20:58

billy1966 · 30/05/2023 20:38

Women like the OP are sitting ducks for men like this.

🙄

So sad.

Dim beyond words because they are so ready to fall for a "loving generous man"......that is desperate for housing.🙄

Give me strength.

And their poor children always paying the ultimate price for their spectacular naivety.
🙄

Funny how these soon to be homeless guys always find a dim woman with a house.

Nothing sadder than a desperate woman who will risk her children's home and security for some waster that has targeted her and her home.

So sad🤷🏻‍♀️

Agreed (in case you get deleted again)

Thesunwillcomeoutverysoon · 30/05/2023 20:56

When my dd's very very tall bf moved in they went to IKEA. Spent 1k and paid 500 each....
Why would you pay for a wardrobe you would need a ladder to reach op?

HatchetJob · 30/05/2023 20:55

Coffeeandanap · 30/05/2023 19:18

Sounds like a hobosexual, run

That’s brilliant.

yeah, I bet your already losing out financially to end up subsidising him as well. Nope. If he’s been paying is dad £40 he should have tons of savings, if he doesn’t, he’s a deadbeat.

cakewench · 30/05/2023 20:55

"He spends on me when he is able and when he has money" Translation, he spends money when it looks generous but (going by the fact that he's living with his DF in his 40s) isn't actually good with planning to a budget. The fact he's already mentally spending your money on new furniture for himself, when you're doing him the favour of moving into your house, says a lot. He doesn't like spending money on boring things like a roof over his head, or a bed he fits in, but he likes the acknowledgment that he paid for a meal out etc.

You really do not want to have this man moving into your house. You need to have a blunt conversation about finances before that happens, but going by your responses, I'm guessing you're reticent to do so.

HaggisBurger · 30/05/2023 20:53

Tell him he can get a Corby trouser press at some Travel Lodges.

Nanny0gg · 30/05/2023 20:53

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 30/05/2023 20:39

This has made my day, hilarious 😆😆😆.
Nearly choked on my cuppa tea 😆.
He's here now unexpectedly and in the loo so apologies if I go quiet.
He has to wear suits for work and likes to hang his trousers full length so he doesn't get knee creases in them.
I didn't know that's a thing either 😆.

I'm definitely taking note MNers.
I did ask for opinions and was prepared.

Hopefully he's not dropped by to ask if I can raise my door frames, but if he does then I promise you all that I'll tell him where to go 😆😆.

That's the most bloody ridiculous thing I've ever heard. He can just buy decent wooden hangers for his trousers

But please take everyone's posts seriously.

You're about to make a big mistake. Big. Huge

chezpopbang · 30/05/2023 20:53

Protect the house because if he lives with you he will have a claim from when he moves in. He needs to definitely make up any money you lost but also pay a portion of the bills because they will go up with another adult. I'd also be wanting him to pay some share of rent. Why should he end up with extra money and as you say save himself £1200 when you need to cover all the bills etc. decide who buys the food and how it is split. You need to have a seriously frank discussion. Also do not buy any new furniture that he wants if you do not want it. If anything ends he will want to take it and you will be left with nothing in your house and sold perfectly good items for a fraction of the actual cost.

pontipinemum · 30/05/2023 20:52

Knee creases! I've heard it all.

If you do go ahead with him moving in make sure you have a very serious conversation about how much you NEED from him weekly. You said you will lose some benefit. He needs to make up that short fall

AMuser · 30/05/2023 20:52

WelshNerd · 30/05/2023 20:49

*DP currently living with his dad in his childhood room, only paying £40pw so basically being subsidised to a degree.

Hard pass.

Wouldn’t you just be MORTIFIED to be doing that. Utterly.

IhearyouClemFandango · 30/05/2023 20:51

Tell him you are more than happy for him to get bigger stuff if he likes. The fact he seems to think he should just be 'chipping in' would have me side eyeing him, as my daughter would say.

He should be contributing fully so you don't lose out.

18 months seems v quick to move in with kids.

BMW6 · 30/05/2023 20:51

He has to wear suits for work and likes to hang his trousers full length so he doesn't get knee creases in them.
I didn't know that's a thing either 😆.

That's not a thing unless his trousers are over 5 feet long.

Which I'm pretty certain they aren't.

Uurrjb · 30/05/2023 20:50

Good luck to you, I’d steer well clear

hes generous…with what?

Tesal · 30/05/2023 20:49

I hope you find this situation as hilarious in the future as you appear to be finding it at the moment judging by all the 😆in your posts. @billy1966 has stated everything that needs to be said - even if some of it was deleted.

WelshNerd · 30/05/2023 20:49

*DP currently living with his dad in his childhood room, only paying £40pw so basically being subsidised to a degree.

Hard pass.

3luckystars · 30/05/2023 20:49

Make him move out by himself for at least a year first. Please do this.

This needs to be a decision made after you have proof that he can afford to pay his way and stand on his own two feet. You need to know this information before you even dream of letting him move into your family home.

Nanny0gg · 30/05/2023 20:49

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 30/05/2023 19:13

Oh I've no indication btw that he won't want to pay fairly, re bills etc. We are yet to have that chat. As I said, he's generous mostly.
It's the wardrobe and stuff that has got me a bit mardy!

FGS! Why are you 'yet' to have the chat?

You should have had it before starting discussing furniture!

You will lose shedloads in benefits - is he going to replace those plus pay for himself and his dc when they stay over?

Stop it right now!

Floofydawg · 30/05/2023 20:48

He has to wear suits for work and likes to hang his trousers full length so he doesn't get knee creases in them.

Errr what?! This alone makes him sound like an arsehole.

Swipe left for the next trending thread