Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's being a CF here?

388 replies

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 30/05/2023 19:08

Ok so help solve this for me please.
DP will be moving in with me & my 2 primary aged DS's later part of this year, date to be confirmed. DP is lovely and both DS's love him.
He has one DD, teens who lives with ex.

Been together 18 months. DP is generally generous. Basic job basic pay, retail.
DP currently living with his dad in his childhood room, only paying £40pw so basically being subsidised to a degree. Dad selling up and moving in with GF soon.
DP has no property, his ex had own house before they met.
I have my own home, mortgaged currently (pretty low payments at this stage) but will be paid off within 5 years or less.

This is also a WWYD.
DP keeps looking at house stuff, ornaments, knick knacks, and furniture etc, yes it's nice he's looking ahead.
Here's the but.
My bedroom furniture will need to be changed, mine is virtually new and I'm happy with it, but DP is tall so he wants to upgrade to a bigger and longer bed (I'm petite) and he also wants a taller wardrobe etc. Fair enough.
He's assuming that I'm going to pay for these?? Or he'll 'chip in' I think where his words when we spoke about it after Xmas. Like it's a favour 🤑.
For context I have a tiny bit of rainy day savings, which I've already eaten into. Struggling like everyone else right now.
I have a low wage p/t job, no means to increase and no support with DSs, no family nearby etc, I get CTC and WFTC, both of which I'll lose once he's moved in.
Should I be telling him he's got to buy the bedroom furniture himself?
I don't feel happy effectively paying for him to move in with me, saving himself maybe 1200pm + in rent and bills he'd have paid once his DF moves away.
Would you expect your shortfall covered at the very least?
Context again, I pay what I can, proportional to my earnings when we go out as a couple, often more than I can afford, but usually less than half.
I don't want to make money from him, but I also don't want to be using any of my own, which I class as for my 2 boys only, to essentially subsidise him moving into my large property cheaply (is-that-even-a-word)
Opinions please MNers!

OP posts:
nonheme · 31/05/2023 02:51

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

YesItsMe44 · 31/05/2023 02:44

My mother she told me after my father left why she wouldn't marry while she still had two daughters at home. When I divorced I understood. Children need normalcy and stability.

Make your budget and breakdown what he would be responsible for. DON'T TELL HIM YOU'VE DONE YOUR HOMEWORK. When you sit down to talk ask to see his breakdown. I doubt he does much and thinks he shouldn't pay much as "it doesn't cost much for one more person." Again, showing you he's just thinking about himself.

If by this point his true colors aren't shining through, show him your breakdown, what he's contribution. Tell him you both will dign an Agreement. He'll pay a deposit of one month's expenses, and first month's expenses. I'm sure Dad didn't ask for that. Don't put him on any accounts.

If it takes this much work on your part, hopefully you'll wake up and not move ahead with letting him disrupting your lives, nor your safe space.

MavisMcMinty · 31/05/2023 02:20

@Thatleadsingersbiggestfan - draw up an itemised non-negotiable bill for your loss of benefits AND half the bills AND a nominal (or otherwise) rent. See what his reaction is, that should help you decide. And if you’re going to have to host his child during his access visits, he should pay for all of that extra expense too.

Not very romantic, I know, but romance doesn’t last long when you live with someone. I'd insist on living separately - love lasts longer, sex happens more frequently, and irritating habits are much less irritating when you haven’t got to endure them 24/7.

I’ve RTFT and haven’t seen a single response that supports your decision for him to move in. One has to ask if either of you would even be considering this massive step if his Dad wasn't selling up?

Fourfurrymonsters · 31/05/2023 02:15

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 31/05/2023 01:47

Thank you @DelurkingLawyer , and everyone else, for the replies.
A lot of assumptions made here by people who've never met DP! But some sound advice also.
I'm certainly having second thoughts.
I'd still like it to happen, but after he's got used to living alone for a while.
I've known DP a little longer than we have been together, so it feels like more than 18 months.
I do hold out hope that he's not only with me for the 'lodging', and the furniture comment was just naive, innocent albeit foolish. Time will indeed tell.
It's not only because his DF is looking to move that we were planning it, he could stay with him longer, his DF loves his company and he helps him out with a lot by living there, he uses DPs car for his own work and social stuff while DP is at work and other things.
DP buys his own food, it's not included in his £40 'rent'.
DP hasn't amassed 'thousands' in savings. He had to drop his hours during COVID and take a big pay cut to keep his job, he kept his CM the same during this period. He'd just cleared his overdraft and gone FT hours when we got together.
MN is full of calls of 'CL' and 'LTB' when that is really quite harsh not knowing the person, they could be lovely. I'm not defending him or being naive, but it's always the first conclusion here.
He'll have to wait a while longer to get his size 14s 'under the table'.
He's not the demanding type, he just likes what he likes, but will certainly be paying for all of it himself.
Yes my wardrobes are lowish but average 🧐.
I like to stack pretty hat boxes on top with my accessories and favourite heels in them, easier to get to and looks eclectic.
I loved the ladder comment 😆.

Even at minimum wage, if he’s been working ft for 18 months, and with his pitifully low outgoings, how has he not amassed thousands in savings? And if he really hasn’t, why not? You talk about him being generous “when he has money”. When on earth would a grown man in his very fortunate circumstances not have money? What is he doing with it? And if there’s a reasonable explanation for where his money is going, how is he going to afford the enormous increase that he’d need to contribute to your household so that you’re not out of pocket? I can almost guarantee you that he’s not thought about that at all, and you certainly haven’t. I’m not seeing how this is anything other than a great move for him, and a really bad one for you and your young kids.

lemonchiffonpie · 31/05/2023 02:05

DP buys his own food, it's not included in his £40 'rent'.

Oh, he's a big boy now!

HateMyselfToo · 31/05/2023 02:01

Apologies if this has already been mentioned, I've only read the OP's posts.

OP, have you calculated how much worse off you will be by him moving in? Loss of 25% council tax discount, loss of any top ups, (hate to use the word benefits)you currently receive. Increased cost of food, electricity, gas, water if on meter etc.?
He needs to be paying at least this for you to break even.
Is he prepared to contribute around £2k per month when he's only been paying £40?

Would you really be moving him in if he could still live with his Dad?

Make him live on his own for a couple of years first or you'll just end up with another dependant to look after.

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 31/05/2023 01:47

DelurkingLawyer · 30/05/2023 23:20

As a lawyer, here is a piece of free advice:

DO. NOT. DO. THIS.

If you do not have advice from a solicitor and a watertight agreement drafted by them, he may be able, over years of contributing to the household finances to some degree, acquire rights over your house. It can happen whether or not you put him on the mortgage/the deeds.

I am afraid I agree with the PP who said there’s no man who’ll love you like a man who’s looking for a home.

PS my husband is 6 foot 7 and his wardrobe is the same size as mine. This guy is talking absolute drivel about needing a bigger wardrobe. Just wants you to spend your hard earned savings on him. Run.

Thank you @DelurkingLawyer , and everyone else, for the replies.
A lot of assumptions made here by people who've never met DP! But some sound advice also.
I'm certainly having second thoughts.
I'd still like it to happen, but after he's got used to living alone for a while.
I've known DP a little longer than we have been together, so it feels like more than 18 months.
I do hold out hope that he's not only with me for the 'lodging', and the furniture comment was just naive, innocent albeit foolish. Time will indeed tell.
It's not only because his DF is looking to move that we were planning it, he could stay with him longer, his DF loves his company and he helps him out with a lot by living there, he uses DPs car for his own work and social stuff while DP is at work and other things.
DP buys his own food, it's not included in his £40 'rent'.
DP hasn't amassed 'thousands' in savings. He had to drop his hours during COVID and take a big pay cut to keep his job, he kept his CM the same during this period. He'd just cleared his overdraft and gone FT hours when we got together.
MN is full of calls of 'CL' and 'LTB' when that is really quite harsh not knowing the person, they could be lovely. I'm not defending him or being naive, but it's always the first conclusion here.
He'll have to wait a while longer to get his size 14s 'under the table'.
He's not the demanding type, he just likes what he likes, but will certainly be paying for all of it himself.
Yes my wardrobes are lowish but average 🧐.
I like to stack pretty hat boxes on top with my accessories and favourite heels in them, easier to get to and looks eclectic.
I loved the ladder comment 😆.

OP posts:
SparklyBlackKitten · 31/05/2023 01:16

"Oh I've no indication btw that he won't want to pay fairly, re bills etc. We are yet to have that chat. As I said, he's generous mostly."

you haven't talked about how you are going to do things Financially when he moves in..? How naive

You need to protect yourself. And your boys

Talk about EVERYTHING with your partner before you decide to let him in your house.

Smarten up op!!

Stop with laughing and thinking this is all so funny. Because it is not

He is displaying red flags. And you choose to ignore them by sticking your head in the sand

You need to talk to him

What happens if he looses his job. What happens when he needs more money for his Dd . What happens if. Etc etc etc.
Who pays for gass electricity council rates dinner holiday the list is endless

Talk to the man.

VintageBlossomHill · 31/05/2023 01:01

Hmm.. hardly a great role model for your sons
Hey sons mums got a CF free loader moving in and btw We’re going to worse off. 🙄

Trez1510 · 31/05/2023 00:58

Surprised it hasn't been mentioned yet but definitely do not get pregnant by this golden-cocked prince.

At some point (hopefully in the very near future) the scales will fall from your eyes and you'll want to move on to make a life with a genuine man. Do not give this man any anchor in your life via a child.

lemonchiffonpie · 31/05/2023 00:57

Lives with dad. Is only moving in with you as dad is moving out to live with someone else. Prior to dad he lived in his previous woman's house.

He's an adolescent. Of course he's usually "generous" with money when you go out, that's how adolescents spend their spare cash. Consider that also a prepayment or downpayment on his future life leaching off you, rentfree.

Should I be telling him he's got to buy the bedroom furniture himself?

He's a child! Of course he will "chip in", with his pocket money.

RachelGreeneGreep · 31/05/2023 00:45

Clementinesucks · 30/05/2023 23:07

You are better off not moving him in. Raise your standards. These threads drive me mad! Why oh why can’t women see these men for what they are?

Exactly.

KissyMissy · 31/05/2023 00:42

Don't be so daft woman!
Think of your kids.

Hankunamatata · 31/05/2023 00:38

You both need to sit down. Show each other what you both have coming in. Work out all the bills and see what's left over.
I'd say new bed is joint purchase. Most places do 4 years interest free credit.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 31/05/2023 00:35

Floofydawg · 30/05/2023 20:48

He has to wear suits for work and likes to hang his trousers full length so he doesn't get knee creases in them.

Errr what?! This alone makes him sound like an arsehole.

Sorry Floofydawg just made me laugh.

He'll be asking for a Corby Trouser Press next.

OP no one on this thread thinks he's justified in expecting you to pay for his furniture. It just seems like a CF move and it just makes me think it might be the thin end of the wedge.

You have been very clear that your kids' come first - but every single penny of yours that goes towards subsidising the man with the perfectly creaseless knees is a penny that could be benefitting your children in future, paying for the odd treat on days out ect is nice, but its no substitute for acknowledging a fair and equitable contribution to your household, not as a favour either and not as a conversation he has to be pushed into. As the person who is moving in, he should want to discuss this and make everything clear instead of asking you to buy him furniture. Im sorry it sounds like a preamble to taking advantage.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 31/05/2023 00:32

Been together 18 months.

And you're about to move him into your children's home? For fuck's sake.

LittleOwl153 · 31/05/2023 00:28

You need to be really clear to him that you have NO SPARE CASH for such things as different beds and extra tall wardrobes when what you have is perfectly functional. That goes for anything else he decides isnunsuitable. That's one of the joys of living with kids whilst working low paid jobs.

His reaction to that will be telling.

lemonchiffonpie · 31/05/2023 00:28

You will rue the day you invited this pantsman in to your home.

Going to have a chat... Yeah, that will fix everything.

He's a serial cocklodger who wants you to make ammendments for his whims (what is he 12/ tall that he needs a high wardrobe to hang his creasefree pants?) and is, you have already noted eyeing off your nicknacks and other furnishings.

If he's so needy re a bed lenth and a wardrobe height (this is only the beginning), what else will he want to remove and renovate once he gets his feet under your table? Good luck with it all, and get onto the legalities sharpish.

Batalax · 30/05/2023 23:57

You need to replace the benefits first and then still get a contribution to bills.

Newnamefor23 · 30/05/2023 23:56
  1. Sleep diagonal or foetal.
  2. Fold clothes.
FictionalCharacter · 30/05/2023 23:53

Clementinesucks · 30/05/2023 23:07

You are better off not moving him in. Raise your standards. These threads drive me mad! Why oh why can’t women see these men for what they are?

“But I love him!” “He’s a good man really!”
They say love is blind, but it seems it’s also deaf and completely thick at times.

user1473878824 · 30/05/2023 23:49

MrsDrDear · 30/05/2023 19:12

Nobody loves you more than a man who needs somewhere to live.

This is all kinds of wrong. Hope you really reconsider.

Perfectly put.

MsRosley · 30/05/2023 23:43

AMuser · 30/05/2023 19:09

Oh god.

FFS.

Two words.

COCK LODGER

Ha ha, yes. Spot on!

Strawberrydelight78 · 30/05/2023 23:42

Ask him where's all his money he's been saving on living costs while living at his dad's for £40 PW?

HaveSomeIntrospect · 30/05/2023 23:28

@Thatleadsingersbiggestfan at the very least, he should be making up any shortfall in the benefits you lose by him moving in.
This is a conversation you should have asap.
plus he should be paying for any new furniture needed when he moves in, you have perfectly functioning furniture.

he is coming across as a cocklodger/hobosexual