Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's being a CF here?

388 replies

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 30/05/2023 19:08

Ok so help solve this for me please.
DP will be moving in with me & my 2 primary aged DS's later part of this year, date to be confirmed. DP is lovely and both DS's love him.
He has one DD, teens who lives with ex.

Been together 18 months. DP is generally generous. Basic job basic pay, retail.
DP currently living with his dad in his childhood room, only paying £40pw so basically being subsidised to a degree. Dad selling up and moving in with GF soon.
DP has no property, his ex had own house before they met.
I have my own home, mortgaged currently (pretty low payments at this stage) but will be paid off within 5 years or less.

This is also a WWYD.
DP keeps looking at house stuff, ornaments, knick knacks, and furniture etc, yes it's nice he's looking ahead.
Here's the but.
My bedroom furniture will need to be changed, mine is virtually new and I'm happy with it, but DP is tall so he wants to upgrade to a bigger and longer bed (I'm petite) and he also wants a taller wardrobe etc. Fair enough.
He's assuming that I'm going to pay for these?? Or he'll 'chip in' I think where his words when we spoke about it after Xmas. Like it's a favour 🤑.
For context I have a tiny bit of rainy day savings, which I've already eaten into. Struggling like everyone else right now.
I have a low wage p/t job, no means to increase and no support with DSs, no family nearby etc, I get CTC and WFTC, both of which I'll lose once he's moved in.
Should I be telling him he's got to buy the bedroom furniture himself?
I don't feel happy effectively paying for him to move in with me, saving himself maybe 1200pm + in rent and bills he'd have paid once his DF moves away.
Would you expect your shortfall covered at the very least?
Context again, I pay what I can, proportional to my earnings when we go out as a couple, often more than I can afford, but usually less than half.
I don't want to make money from him, but I also don't want to be using any of my own, which I class as for my 2 boys only, to essentially subsidise him moving into my large property cheaply (is-that-even-a-word)
Opinions please MNers!

OP posts:
CriticalAlert · 31/05/2023 18:05

OP be objective please. I can see you really like/love this bloke. BUT he is a total user - look at what people are saying! COCKLODGER. He can't start to tell you what to buy for the bedroom and expect you to pay for it. It's your new bedroom!!! Seriously just continue dating him - don't have him move in. He'll suck you dry.

viques · 31/05/2023 17:45

Breakingpoint1961 · 31/05/2023 06:43

@Thighlengthboots we don't know if he can't afford it, OP hasn't actually said that, she's perceiving it as he's assuming she's going to pay for it.

It's hard to get every part of a relationship (and a person) over in one of these threads, but to call the fella this that and the other when all he's actually done (according to the OP) is assume he won't be buying the furniture.

OP doesn't sound naive, and maybe some 'gentle' advice on ring fencing her assets, but some of the comments on here are not really called for.

None of us know the dynamics or DP.

To be fair to us all slagging him off there are other indications that he is crap with money.

he had no savings despite his former partner owning the house so no rent/ mortgage to pay

he is only sometimes generous,

he doesn’t always have money available ( despite only paying a pittance to his father)

he thinks £40 covers the cost of a room/ heat/light/ hot water/ Wi-Fi/ wear and tear/ washing because “he buys his own food” and let’s his dad use his car.

he still has no savings (despite Covid being over for some time and many people in many industries being fairly well supported by furlough payments)

he hasn’t raised finances with the OP, OK, she hasn’t either, but I think it’s poor that neither has he, he has a child to support, he needs to know what money is going to be available in his bank balance at the end of the month so should be raising the issue. I find it odd that he doesn’t seem to have discussed the child/ contact time at the OPs house.

he drives a car but doesn’t need to use it for work, if he is that hard up why have a car at all?

SunnyCoco · 31/05/2023 17:20

He buys his own food

🤣🤣🤣

Oh god.

Floofydawg · 31/05/2023 13:53

Oh by the way OP, don't forget to save up to pay for his adult daughter to go on holiday with you. Because y'know, you knew what you were getting into. And you'll need extra legroom seats on the plane on account of his unfeasibly long legs.

Amybelle88 · 31/05/2023 13:01

So currently, he lives with his dad paying £40 a week whilst you live with and support your two children solo.

And now, at this period where he has extra cash due to such low living costs, he still expects you to chip in on dates?

He's a tight bastard. Leg it.

Jagoda · 31/05/2023 13:00

If you are on CTC/WTC won’t you lose your right to legacy benefits? So if he moves in and you lose them, you won’t get them back if it goes tits up. You will be moved onto UC.

You must be insane or desperate for a man to do this to your DC.

FloweryWowery · 31/05/2023 12:57

Sounds like he's swapping his dad for you, his new mummy. Think you'll be gaining a third child.

GabriellaMontez · 31/05/2023 12:56

Chickapee · 31/05/2023 12:34

MN is full of calls of 'CL' and 'LTB' when that is really quite harsh not knowing the person, they could be lovely. I'm not defending him or being naive, but it's always the first conclusion here.

I agree OP and it seems it is often men who are branded CFs if the their female partner contribute more financially or own the house whereas the men are branded "tight" in the opposite scenario.

The opposite scenario?

How often do we have men on here, who have their 2 young children living with them and move their girlfriend in (from their parents house!) Without discussing finances!!!

Don't make me laugh.

3luckystars · 31/05/2023 12:44

I don’t. I think moving a man into a children’s home is s huge, massive decision and should not be done just to suit him, his small budget and his big needs.

Nanny0gg · 31/05/2023 12:41

Chickapee · 31/05/2023 12:34

MN is full of calls of 'CL' and 'LTB' when that is really quite harsh not knowing the person, they could be lovely. I'm not defending him or being naive, but it's always the first conclusion here.

I agree OP and it seems it is often men who are branded CFs if the their female partner contribute more financially or own the house whereas the men are branded "tight" in the opposite scenario.

So do you think this scenario is a sensible one?

Chickapee · 31/05/2023 12:34

MN is full of calls of 'CL' and 'LTB' when that is really quite harsh not knowing the person, they could be lovely. I'm not defending him or being naive, but it's always the first conclusion here.

I agree OP and it seems it is often men who are branded CFs if the their female partner contribute more financially or own the house whereas the men are branded "tight" in the opposite scenario.

WisherWood · 31/05/2023 10:31

MN is full of calls of 'CL' and 'LTB' when that is really quite harsh not knowing the person, they could be lovely. I'm not defending him or being naive, but it's always the first conclusion here.

I'm sure your DP is lovely in some ways. Most people have their plus points. He may well be good company, funny, intelligent, kind et cetera. However, those things do not get to the fundamentals of who he is. And it's easier for us, at a distance, to say someone is a cocklodger because we're not blinded by the 'lovely' behaviour but instead can get a clearer view of the fundamentals.

Your story rings alarm bells for several reasons. You don't seem to know this man very well. You're moving him in with you and your children after a relatively short relationship. He's not living independently and already has a failed relationship with a co-parent behind him. He just doesn't seem like someone who's great at being an adult and most people are lovely if they think that by being so, they'll get cheap lodgings out of it.

I don't live with my DP. He has a young daughter and for us, it just didn't seem worth the potential disruption to her life to add me into the mix. We're quite happy living separately. If we're still together once she's old enough to move out, we might revisit the question of our living arrangements. But there isn't any hurry, even though financially in some ways it would be easier for both of us. I would suggest you hold off on living together for a while. And if you do insist on going ahead, do as PP have suggested and give him a breakdown of costs and what you're expecting him to pay.

BMW6 · 31/05/2023 10:26

OP you rightly say we don't know him and he could be lovely.

ALL cocklodgers are, of course, absolutely lovely initially.
They have to be otherwise they don't charm the woman enough to move into her home.

He is not "lovely" in his attitude towards YOUR children's financial security is he, let alone yours!

What "lovely" person asks a single parent to buy new furniture, specifically for them, completely unnecessarily, and says they will "chip in"?
Why isn't he proposing to buy his own special trouser wardrobe which he can take with him when he leaves?

Lovely? Really?

Goodoccasionallypoor · 31/05/2023 10:07

MN is full of calls of 'CL' and 'LTB' when that is really quite harsh not knowing the person, they could be lovely.

Op, you've literally asked if he's being a cheeky fucker and we're saying, yes, based on what you have told us, he probably is.

Don't ask questions if you don't want to hear answers.

GoodChat · 31/05/2023 10:06

The guy is clearly just a bum and, as usual, its the kids who will feel the biggest impact.

HatchetJob · 31/05/2023 09:57

I think it’s fine to work in retail but it’s obviously not giving him the income he needs. To pay for his daughter and himself.
Hes had the luxury at living at his dads, maybe he could have used some of that time to get some more training.
If it was just him, I couldn’t give a shit. But he’s going to use this as an excuse why someone else needs fo support him - first his dad, and OP next.

I have numerous friends who work retail, they’ve worked to get supervisory roles, changed palaces of work to get better rates of pay.

AMuser · 31/05/2023 09:47

HatchetJob · 31/05/2023 08:47

How old is his daughter. Would she be coming to yours for contact as well?

The other question is why has he only got a basic job, has he any ambition to do any better at all.

I think apart from all the CF you are going to end up financially very poor I think if you aren’t careful, or he’s going to push you to work more to make up the household income.

Having been pretty tough on OP - well her cock lodger in waiting - I think it’s a bit much to diss the guys job. Plenty of people work in retail. What is wrong with that.

It’s the sponging of his Dad and only just going full time and no assets to speak of that worries me more. Recent debts too. And being generous when he “has money” suggests he sometimes … doesn’t.

I recently divorced and have older kids that live at home. Seeing someone 2 years. Most importantly I’m not moving him in with me or my kids!!
Financially, we are in slightly different places. I own my house outright and have significant assets. My DP works freelance and owns a house worth quite a bit less than mine (he has no kids though so needs a much smaller one) with a small
mortgage. So if / when we do decide to buy a place together after my youngest goes to uni we will need to have an agreement in place and I will have to ringfence my greater share of the house / my assets for my kids etc.

HatchetJob · 31/05/2023 08:47

How old is his daughter. Would she be coming to yours for contact as well?

The other question is why has he only got a basic job, has he any ambition to do any better at all.

I think apart from all the CF you are going to end up financially very poor I think if you aren’t careful, or he’s going to push you to work more to make up the household income.

MeridianB · 31/05/2023 08:29

As others have said, if his Dad wasn’t moving on, would you have even considered living together? Don’t feel obliged to solve his housing challenge.

Mine is another voice saying please don’t move him in. And if he’s the decent man you believe him to be then he will say ‘I totally understand - I will find a place - that’s no problem.’

Breakingpoint1961 · 31/05/2023 08:19

@Thighlengthboots indeed!!

Thighlengthboots · 31/05/2023 08:17

Breakingpoint1961 · 31/05/2023 08:13

@Thighlengthboots 🤦🏼‍♀️

I know right? bad idea all round

Breakingpoint1961 · 31/05/2023 08:13

@Thighlengthboots 🤦🏼‍♀️

Thighlengthboots · 31/05/2023 07:55

Breakingpoint1961 · 31/05/2023 07:45

@lemonchiffonpie maybe I am naive in thinking she has already discussed the monthly finances, that's something that should be done before anything else.

She hasnt though- hence the concerns

Floofydawg · 31/05/2023 07:50

Breakingpoint1961 · 31/05/2023 07:45

@lemonchiffonpie maybe I am naive in thinking she has already discussed the monthly finances, that's something that should be done before anything else.

She's already explicitly said that they haven't had a conversation about finances other than the vague 'chipping in.'

ChaoticCrumble · 31/05/2023 07:49

make sure he knows what you stand to lose in both benefits and extra council tax