Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

cfs or family in need?

192 replies

Sheruns · 30/05/2023 18:58

More of a wwyd than an aibu but not sure where to post.

I've lived in a new estate for a while with dp and dc. We were one of the first families in but as the weeks have passed a few other families have moved in. There are two kids across the road and a few doors away similar age to my two and they've been playing out a lot together.

Not sure it makes any difference but their mum appears to be by herself with these two and two older dc. Haven't spoken to mum other than a brief hi.

With the weather being good the kids have been having lots of fun playing out and especially now it's half term but these two children are becoming a bit of an issue. At first I thought mum was a bit of a cf because the kids always seemed to be in my garden and running in and out of my house but my younger one struggles to make friends and they seem like nice kids so we accepted that. As time has gone on, we've become concerned with how much food her kids are asking for and taking without asking for.

At first it was the odd thing like they were calling round to play just as we finished dinner so our kids we're finishing up a yoghurt or piece of fruit and they requested one. One night I ordered takeaway pizza and their kids helped themselves. My dp caught one of them in our snack cupboard helping himself with chocolate. I've seen them both just take fruit from our fruit bowl. I was out yesterday late morning when my two requested eggs on toast for brunch and they asked for some too. So my partner said something like you better ask your mum in case she's started making your lunch thinking once they asked their mum she'd tell them to stop asking for food at ours. They came back and she'd said it was fine. Last night asked them to go home while mine had dinner. They were really difficult to get them to leave, asking if they could play in our garden while they waited. In no time at all they were circling our table like vultures, asking for a piece of cucumber or a chip and then devouring my youngests left overs the minute he stood up.

Tonight I've been to the gym after feeding the kids and one of them has asked dp for dinner!

We've tried to ask about meals at their own house and at one point the other week one told us that mum would feed them when it was dark.

Do you think they're trying it on and just greedy kids? Do you think mum is a Cf just happy to let me deal with them? Do you think mum is struggling?

I kinda want to say something to mum because I'd be horrified if my kids did this (although I will say they're very polite when they do ask), but I don't want to embarrass her if she is struggling. If she was struggling though I'd try to help perhaps.

So wwyd?

OP posts:
AbraKedavra · 31/05/2023 00:28

Sheruns · 30/05/2023 20:03

The last three posters have hit my dilemma on the head. I do think they're hungry and I don't like the idea of leaving them hungry. I'm not loaded but it's not going to kill me to cook an extra few eggs and toast.

They're lovely kids in every other respect. Really well mannered. Take their shoes off at the door to come in and play. Brought my younger one home when he cut his knee. Nice kids. It's just about the food that I think the behaviour is a little odd.

I'm going to have to try to engage mum in discussion. I'll try this week

Honestly it does sound like they're truly hungry and struggling. Remember that whatever you put out into the world will one day return. It's better to be in the position of giving than receiving.

SarahDippity · 31/05/2023 00:18

Next time (tomorrow!) I’d walk them home and say to the mum ‘I’m dropping these guys home for their tea, maybe we could have them over again after lunch on Thursday, lovely to meet you’ and ask if you can swap phone numbers. You’ll be able to make a fair guess from her reaction what the story is.

Jellifulfruit · 31/05/2023 00:05

Sheruns · 30/05/2023 20:03

The last three posters have hit my dilemma on the head. I do think they're hungry and I don't like the idea of leaving them hungry. I'm not loaded but it's not going to kill me to cook an extra few eggs and toast.

They're lovely kids in every other respect. Really well mannered. Take their shoes off at the door to come in and play. Brought my younger one home when he cut his knee. Nice kids. It's just about the food that I think the behaviour is a little odd.

I'm going to have to try to engage mum in discussion. I'll try this week

Yeah I’d say do this, you might be able to gage their situation better having met and spoken to her properly

quiettimes · 30/05/2023 23:40

Also I get that it might take time for social services for example to step in, but she is presumably entitled to benefits which are designed to cover food costs? Child benefit etc.

There’s also local support from the council, alongside food bank schemes. This is not your problem to solve - there’s help out there.

My thoughts are: where’s her money going if she can’t afford a 40p tin of beans or something to prevent her kids from being hungry? It’s more likely that she has basic supplies at her home, but your house has more fancy food which the kids get tempted by. Eg the takeaway pizza. This is why you need to speak to the mum and nip this in the bud. She might be unaware.

quiettimes · 30/05/2023 23:34

I would knock on their door and speak to the mum and let her know this cannot continue. It’s not your responsibility to feed them

TomatoSandwiches · 30/05/2023 23:29

We've all read horrible stories of children going hungry and then eventually suffering worse fates, if you can feed a child whilst you and yours are not going without then why wouldn't you?

Getting them real help from offical services can take a bit of time, they're children.

MumblesParty · 30/05/2023 23:19

AllOfThemWitches · 30/05/2023 22:46

Yawn.

You seem very ready to tell people to spend their money on others.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 30/05/2023 23:04

OP if you don't mind me asking, are the houses on your estate bought, or rented? The reason I ask, is that if they've only just bought a new house, I wouldn't imagine their parent/s to be too hard up to feed them, of course I could be wrong about that, but most people don't buy a new house and then literally not have enough money in the pot to feed the kids. If that's the case, then I think they're just being cheeky, possibly even encouraged by Mum as while you're entertaining and feeding them, they're not under her feet. Like others have advised, I think you need to be firm with these kids, rather than being overly nice, particularly as your kids aren't being invited back. I vote the Mother is a CF!

caringcarer · 30/05/2023 23:01

If they are very slim and happy to eat leftovers off your children's plates I'd bet they are really hungry. I couldn't let a child go hungry, I'd have to offer them food.

caringcarer · 30/05/2023 22:53

When I was a child my younger sister had a friend Linda, who was always at our house around meal times. My Mum was a softy and just offered her to eat with us. We later found out she was neglected at home and barely fed. She was taken into care and I know my Mum cried. After that she still came at least twice a week after school because she went to swimming club with my sister and Mum took them both there, watched them swimming, brought them both home and fed them before dropping back to the children's home she had to live in. She had to leave the children's home at 17. If you can afford to feed these hungry children do so. Without my Mum feeding Linda she would have been starving. She was almost 9 and afraid to tell anyone she was not fed in case her Mum got into trouble.

AllOfThemWitches · 30/05/2023 22:46

MumblesParty · 30/05/2023 21:56

Can you give your address so other MNers can send you their grocery bill please?

Yawn.

Dibbydoos · 30/05/2023 22:38

I would def speak to their mum (I'd have done it way before now).

Stop feeding these kids. If the family needs help, they can get help.

Good luck.

Dutch1e · 30/05/2023 22:35

Definitely have a casual chat with the mum.

I noticed my daughter was off her food for a while and after feeling worried she was sick I cottoned on and knocked on a few doors in our small neighbourhood. Turned out that she'd been scrounging at another kid's house, much like these kids are doing to you. Devious little blighter just preferred what they ate!

Needless to say, I asked them to shoo their own kids out to my house right along with my DD so I could 'repay' the dinners.

NortieTortie · 30/05/2023 22:19

There's no excuse for letting your young children out of your sight all hours of the day with a family you've never had a chat with, but this scenario: 'So my partner said something like you better ask your mum in case she's started making your lunch thinking once they asked their mum she'd tell them to stop asking for food at ours. They came back and she'd said it was fine.' makes me think they ran to mom, said 'X and Y's dad asked if you've started our lunch, if not can we eat with them?' and she said sure, thinking it was an invite. That kind of thing is a bit too subtle and relies too much on children relaying the message perfectly, imo.

Hellno45 · 30/05/2023 22:06

Sheruns · 30/05/2023 21:02

I honestly don't think they're fussy. They saw dp eating beetroot pasta one time and mackerel gratin and asked him for both of those!

If they are eating beetroot pasta and mackerel gratin they must be fucking starving.

I imagine it's worse during school holidays. Most school have a breakfast club and they are eating lunch at school. They are at least getting a meal. On the holidays they might be having significantly less.

I'd you can afford it i would provide a warm but cheap lunch, scrambled egg on toast, beans on toast, jacket potato and a filling. I'd have some cheap cereals avaliable for snacking. I think the snack bowl is a good idea. Allowing them to take snack from there and only there. I wouldn't let them stay for dinner or come back after dinner. It's good to have family time, catch up and eat together without company. I think you need to decide what your boundaries are and stick to them.

MumblesParty · 30/05/2023 22:04

Anyone saying it’s your job to feed other people’s kids every day OP is talking crap.

If anyone genuinely thinks kids are being starved then they should report to SS. otherwise you are simply enabling shit parenting . People with a social conscience and spare cash can donate to charity.

I’ve fed multiple kids of rich parents who couldn’t be arsed. It caused no end of trouble and made me feel that my house wasn’t my own.

in my experience, the ones who are genuinely skint (and not just rich/lazy, or spending all their money on alcohol and cigarettes) will always return the favour. The ones who happily delegate all feeding and care without offering anything in return are usually just crap parents.

TomatoSandwiches · 30/05/2023 22:04

Well, mum hasn't been round to introduce herself and seems to think it's OK to let her two young children out and around strangers houses ( could be other homes they go to as well as yours ) so she's not given the best impression whether she's struggling or not she is definitely a cf.

It wouldn't be a hardship for me to feed them a few sandwiches, fruit and biscuits once a day although I'd knock the stealing on the head keeping my doors locked.
It's not a long term solution to a potential problem though so I'd find out what school they go to and phone them, let their family liaison officer know about your concerns.

determinedtomakethiswork · 30/05/2023 22:00

I think it's very unusual for kids to do this. I think you should say to them each time no, sorry, I don't have enough for everyone, you'll have to go home. Come back when you've had your dinner. Having said that if you say that and they go home and come back and don't seem to have eaten anything then this is obviously a bigger problem.

Mum2jenny · 30/05/2023 21:57

Fed up to 4 different families kids, but in return all fed mine. Truly free range kids in our close many years ago and it was good fun and never any real issues.

Antiquedisco · 30/05/2023 21:57

You need to be firmer. They are CFs and their mum is just being lazy and letting it happen. Food at other peoples houses is always more exciting to kids. My DD has a friend who comes round a lot. She is a sweet girl but would eat everything if I let her. One of mine is the same. I have to remind her to be polite and not constantly nag for snacks when she goes to friends houses. Children need to be taught manners. Don’t let them walk all over you.

MumblesParty · 30/05/2023 21:56

AllOfThemWitches · 30/05/2023 21:32

For fuck's sake, it's kind of common knowledge that many people are seriously struggling and some of you think the answer is to just tell hungry kids to bugger off because they're a slight inconvenience. Wow.

Can you give your address so other MNers can send you their grocery bill please?

Neodymium · 30/05/2023 21:55

I’ve had friends before who had their kids on weird strict diets. Like one who decided they were all gluten and dairy intolerant (they weren’t) and made them all stop eating those. Then decided to go full vegan for awhile. At one stage she even told the school they were ‘allergic’ to sugar. It is never genuine - they last 6 months and then next thing she’s posting photos of them eating fish and chips at the beach. Her kids used to be constantly hungry and hanging round for food because their diet was so restricted, vegan food is expensive and they are growing kids so they want to eat a lot. At gatherings and stuff her kids are intensely motivated by food. Hanging round the platters eating everything they are allowed, fighting over the last slice of vegan cake, and yes finishing leftovers. I think when you restrict and withhold food kids start to act this way.

SnugAsA · 30/05/2023 21:54

If you don't know they're actually in need you're just as likely to be feeding them because they like to eat at yours and their own mother doesn't give a crap about how much they may be imposing.

I wouldn't automatically assume that she can't afford to feed her own children without more evidence, and even if that does prove to be the case, it's still not your responsibility to feed them all the time, but rather the mother needs to seek help. Your feeding them is not a long-term solution.

AllOfThemWitches · 30/05/2023 21:53

x2boys · 30/05/2023 21:50

No.im.suggesting that not everybody can afford to.feed two.extra kids three meals a day plus snacks I certainly can't I can well afford to.Ffeed my own kids but I can't afford to feed random kids ,if you can may be you should take your head out of your privileged arse,and look around 🙄

OK but OP has indicated it isn't causing her financial issues so...

Thepossibility · 30/05/2023 21:53

We've got a CF 9 yo boy near us.
At first I didn't mind feeding him but now he's making requests like he'd prefer the biscuits or lemonade he's had at ours before. My DH told him to go home once and he said he couldn't because his mum is out for the day.
These two don't sound too bad, probably a school holiday thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread