Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

cfs or family in need?

192 replies

Sheruns · 30/05/2023 18:58

More of a wwyd than an aibu but not sure where to post.

I've lived in a new estate for a while with dp and dc. We were one of the first families in but as the weeks have passed a few other families have moved in. There are two kids across the road and a few doors away similar age to my two and they've been playing out a lot together.

Not sure it makes any difference but their mum appears to be by herself with these two and two older dc. Haven't spoken to mum other than a brief hi.

With the weather being good the kids have been having lots of fun playing out and especially now it's half term but these two children are becoming a bit of an issue. At first I thought mum was a bit of a cf because the kids always seemed to be in my garden and running in and out of my house but my younger one struggles to make friends and they seem like nice kids so we accepted that. As time has gone on, we've become concerned with how much food her kids are asking for and taking without asking for.

At first it was the odd thing like they were calling round to play just as we finished dinner so our kids we're finishing up a yoghurt or piece of fruit and they requested one. One night I ordered takeaway pizza and their kids helped themselves. My dp caught one of them in our snack cupboard helping himself with chocolate. I've seen them both just take fruit from our fruit bowl. I was out yesterday late morning when my two requested eggs on toast for brunch and they asked for some too. So my partner said something like you better ask your mum in case she's started making your lunch thinking once they asked their mum she'd tell them to stop asking for food at ours. They came back and she'd said it was fine. Last night asked them to go home while mine had dinner. They were really difficult to get them to leave, asking if they could play in our garden while they waited. In no time at all they were circling our table like vultures, asking for a piece of cucumber or a chip and then devouring my youngests left overs the minute he stood up.

Tonight I've been to the gym after feeding the kids and one of them has asked dp for dinner!

We've tried to ask about meals at their own house and at one point the other week one told us that mum would feed them when it was dark.

Do you think they're trying it on and just greedy kids? Do you think mum is a Cf just happy to let me deal with them? Do you think mum is struggling?

I kinda want to say something to mum because I'd be horrified if my kids did this (although I will say they're very polite when they do ask), but I don't want to embarrass her if she is struggling. If she was struggling though I'd try to help perhaps.

So wwyd?

OP posts:
YouJustDoYou · 01/06/2023 05:22

Sheruns · 31/05/2023 16:55

To be fair I didn't say anything as I was just a bit too shocked. I know I should have but I'm crap at telling people no. Especially kids. They've been round this afternoon but only for the past hour as we were out until then. I'll see what happens when I cook dinner. They will of course be told to go home before I plate up tonight

God I would've too, takeaway pizza can be bloody expensive!

Judgyjudgy · 01/06/2023 03:45

potniatheron · 31/05/2023 10:04

This is exactly it. When my kids were younger I would absolutely give their friends a bag of crisps or an apple if they asked. I could not afford to casually give them dinner unless I had planned for them to come to dinner as I was budgeting and measuring food amounts very carefully at the time for financial reasons. And i certainly would not have tolerated my kids' friends stealing my food without permission - on moral as well as financial grounds.

Some folks on this thread are virtue signalling because they are wealthy and it shows.

Ime it's the poorer people who share their food and will give money to beggers. Wealthy people tend to be less generous usually because they have no idea what it's actually like to be poor, and they probably stay wealthy for this reason too!

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 01/06/2023 03:28

You need to make it clear to your DC AND to the other DC that they are not to help themselves to food under any circumstances.

Send them home at regular intervals, particularly when you're having your meals. They are being fed, but it sounds like the mum is taking the easier and cheaper of option of letting them eat elsewhere.

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 01/06/2023 03:27

Despite the PR put about by some activists, it is extremely rare in this country for children to genuinely not have enough to eat

Extremely rare? Get your head out your arse

Catsmere · 01/06/2023 03:19

It was CF territory the minute they came in uninvited imo. As for taking food - what are you, a food bank?

Nicecow · 01/06/2023 03:13

It's a hard one OP. They're definitely hungry, but that might be due to the mum not being able to afford enough food rather than being a CF. I like PP comment re the loaf of bread. I'd try and get an understanding of the situation, and normally I'm a hard bitch but if they're genuinely hungry I'd probably work out how to give them a few meals a week if you can afford to do so.

Wanderingfree32 · 01/06/2023 01:49

I'd ask them what school they go to and report this to the school. Just say that they seem to be hungry all of the time.

I personally would buy a 75p loaf and value jam and give them a few slices of toast and jam whenever they're round. They sound like they're very hungry.

Biscuitmonster2318 · 01/06/2023 01:30

Where our local area is there is a charity that helps out. You can be working or no income but struggling to feed or clothe your children. It’s a self referral process and private. It’s called Gianna’s baby bank and as long as there is a child in the family they will help or let you know who else could. As it’s self referral lots more families are asking for help as no need to ask GP or schools or social services
obviously if they arrive at the house and they think a referral to social services might get more help for the family then they will discuss this with them.

itdoesnt · 01/06/2023 00:14

You know nothing about me i.have one severely disabled child and another who.has just been diagnosed with diabetes,so no I can't afford to feed random.neighbours kids and with COL,crisis neither can many other families.

And some people can. There's no need to refuse hungry kids if you can afford to give them some food because some people can't. Safeguarding is everyone's business.

Why the people who can't afford to feed an extra sandwich on this thread are so angry is beyond me. We're talking about small kids who are hungry and looking for food. Yes report to ss if there are concerns but you won't solve the worlds problems by reporting to ss.

SqueakyDinosaur · 31/05/2023 22:10

@potniatheron Oh well, that's fine then! We're not as bad as Sudan or Somalia, so everything's just fine and dandy! In the 7th biggest economy in the world, I can't help thinking we should be aiming a bit higher than that. The effects of malnutrition kick in well before we get the telegenic pictures of skeletal babies. FFS.

pinkyredrose · 31/05/2023 18:04

x2boys · 31/05/2023 17:38

Good for you but I m not going to feed a random child ,at the expense of my own kids 🙄

It's almost as though the parents don't have responsibility for feeding thier own children.

x2boys · 31/05/2023 17:38

Sandylanes69 · 31/05/2023 17:30

Safeguarding is everyone's business - except when it comes to hungry children who aren't your own, eh? I'm not wealthy; I've also never denied food to a hungry child. The UK is full of selfish people.

Good for you but I m not going to feed a random child ,at the expense of my own kids 🙄

potniatheron · 31/05/2023 17:34

I look after my own first and foremost. I learned the importance of that the hard way.

If you can afford to feed four extra children other than your own, then be grateful for your privilege and don’t preach to others.

Sandylanes69 · 31/05/2023 17:30

potniatheron · 31/05/2023 10:04

This is exactly it. When my kids were younger I would absolutely give their friends a bag of crisps or an apple if they asked. I could not afford to casually give them dinner unless I had planned for them to come to dinner as I was budgeting and measuring food amounts very carefully at the time for financial reasons. And i certainly would not have tolerated my kids' friends stealing my food without permission - on moral as well as financial grounds.

Some folks on this thread are virtue signalling because they are wealthy and it shows.

Safeguarding is everyone's business - except when it comes to hungry children who aren't your own, eh? I'm not wealthy; I've also never denied food to a hungry child. The UK is full of selfish people.

Sheruns · 31/05/2023 16:55

pinkyredrose · 31/05/2023 16:20

What did you say when they took the pizza? I'd have lost it over that!

To be fair I didn't say anything as I was just a bit too shocked. I know I should have but I'm crap at telling people no. Especially kids. They've been round this afternoon but only for the past hour as we were out until then. I'll see what happens when I cook dinner. They will of course be told to go home before I plate up tonight

OP posts:
potniatheron · 31/05/2023 16:42

SqueakyDinosaur · 31/05/2023 15:40

No, I don't know you, but I can still say that when you say "Despite the PR put about by some activists, it is extremely rare in this country for children to genuinely not have enough to eat - and genuine charities and activists acknowledge this", you are talking absolute bollocks.

To clarify: when I say 'don't have enough to eat', I'm talking about clinical malnutrition. Not just 'being peckish because Mum hasn't got my dinner on yet so I'll nick my mate's mum's leftover pizza.'

Are these children suffering from malnutrition or starvation? NO. I'm sorry. I don't buy it. They wouldn't be running around and playing for a start.

The rates of children admitted to hospital in England & Wales for malnutrition is thankfully very low when measured on the scale of OECD countries, and is almost always due to an underlying health condition, cystic fibrosis and cancer being the two leading causes. That, thankfully, does not seem to be the case with OP's neighbour's children. She has not said that they appear noticeably underweight.

Childhood malnutrition is a serious issue in the emerging world and pretending that what OP is describing is on a par with what's happening in Sudan or Somalia is just dumb.

x2boys · 31/05/2023 16:32

Ponoka7 · 31/05/2023 16:02

But intervention thresholds are constantly going higher. I'm still in touch with the children, now 26+ year olds who are grateful for me feeding them and occasionally washing their clothes, letting them get baths etc. In the area I grew up in, that was common practice. At my Nan's funeral there were tales of her taking in children and feeding the street because she ran boarding houses and the sailors would bring her catering size tins of corned beef.. Yes, report, research my posts, I always say that. There's nothing virtue signalling about being sick of neighbours/family/friends not reporting abuse/neglect. I take it you're an "me and mine are alright jack" type?

You know nothing about me i.have one severely disabled child and another who.has just been diagnosed with diabetes,so no I can't afford to feed random.neighbours kids and with COL,crisis neither can many other families.

pinkyredrose · 31/05/2023 16:20

What did you say when they took the pizza? I'd have lost it over that!

Ponoka7 · 31/05/2023 16:02

x2boys · 31/05/2023 14:33

Why should any one buy in smart price bread and jam just to feed random kids ,because their mother appears to be neglecting them ?You seem to missing the point here feeding a kid a jam butty,isn't hoping to solve any long term problems ,but as long as it makes you feel.virtuous 🙄

But intervention thresholds are constantly going higher. I'm still in touch with the children, now 26+ year olds who are grateful for me feeding them and occasionally washing their clothes, letting them get baths etc. In the area I grew up in, that was common practice. At my Nan's funeral there were tales of her taking in children and feeding the street because she ran boarding houses and the sailors would bring her catering size tins of corned beef.. Yes, report, research my posts, I always say that. There's nothing virtue signalling about being sick of neighbours/family/friends not reporting abuse/neglect. I take it you're an "me and mine are alright jack" type?

Naunet · 31/05/2023 15:47

AllOfThemWitches · 30/05/2023 21:32

For fuck's sake, it's kind of common knowledge that many people are seriously struggling and some of you think the answer is to just tell hungry kids to bugger off because they're a slight inconvenience. Wow.

Food banks exist, you can’t expect other people to regularly feed your children, don’t be ridiculous, how do you know OP can afford to?

SqueakyDinosaur · 31/05/2023 15:40

potniatheron · 31/05/2023 09:41

You don't know me. I grew up on FMS. My kids were on FMS for a time. I simply do not think it is OP's job to feed someone else's children. Because she, like me, like millions of us, can't afford to. And also the stealing is wrong. Please take a seat and spend some time examining your morals and your own smug prejudices.

No, I don't know you, but I can still say that when you say "Despite the PR put about by some activists, it is extremely rare in this country for children to genuinely not have enough to eat - and genuine charities and activists acknowledge this", you are talking absolute bollocks.

Antiquedisco · 31/05/2023 15:22

Some children are just greedy and don’t know when to stop. It doesn’t make them terrible people, it’s just the way some kids are. You need to say no or send them home. They are taking the piss! I can say this knowing my own daughter is like this. She is asd and doesn’t seem to have that polite gene! I have told friends not to let her eat all their food and to feel free to tell her no.

WaltzingWaters · 31/05/2023 15:09

Some kids do just have crazy appetites and most kids love snacking. Wanting chocolate and pizza is very normal but the fact they’re gobbling down beetroot pasta and mackerel seems like it’s genuine hunger.
I think I’m quite a relaxed parent but there’s no way I’d be letting my 6yo go into a strangers home without at least having a proper conversation and checking that it’s okay with those parents for my kids to be there, and that those parents seem normal! The fact the mum knows they’re there and isn’t bothered about talking to you makes me concerned.

It could of course be that by kid number 3&4 she’s just very (too) relaxed, she could not really know that they’re eating lots at yours, she could be really lazy and just not care, or she could be genuinely struggling.

Try to speak to her and gauge the situation. If you still have concerns, I’d ask to speak to the safeguarding team at the kids school and report it to get long term help.

I’d feed them with cheap, filling foods when you can when you can. Pasta, potatoes, veg, sandwiches. Make sure that them helping themselves to snacks is a no. Keep boundaries in place, whilst showing compassion and making sure they don’t starve.

TheKobayashiMaru · 31/05/2023 15:02

Sheruns · 30/05/2023 19:21

I get that it's weird but in my defence I did ask them to go home and I didn't give them the leftovers, they'd grabbed them before I even turned round to collect the plate

I'd nip this is the bud straight away. They should not be helping themselves to food in another home unless explicitly invited to do so

Yfory · 31/05/2023 14:43

Are they more grabby for food this week than normally? It might be a half term thing (ie no free school meals)

Swipe left for the next trending thread