Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it true that the best time to buy a house was always yesterday?

34 replies

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 18:14

Rates are so extortionate at the moment I can’t help but hope they’ll fall a bit

Would we be crazy to continue renting for now in the hope we’ll get a better deal later this year. We’ve been viewing houses and the one we fell in love with would be £500 more a month than what we are renting. I know you have security but we could use that money now, really. What does everyone think, will rates fall? How are people coping who are due to remortgage this year?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GasPanic · 31/05/2023 11:57

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 23:01

They have, surely it’s got to come to a head at some point but I suppose that might not be for another many years as you say. It’s tricky

IMO there is no point in the past 15 years when there has been more negativity around house prices and more clearly negative indicators for the market.

2007/2008 was the last time. People in my area buying new builds in 2007 did not recover their purchase cost in sales value until 2017.

Will there be a drop in prices in the next few years as big as there was in 2007 ? Hard to tell and no one can say for sure. But everything seems to be lining up towards that, and this time QE is not an option. Inflation appears to be defying (goverment) expectations and the talk appears to be of rates going higher than previous expectations not lower.

I would be wary of purchasing highly priced new builds at the limit of my affordability, even more so flats and even more so luxury flats. These are the types of properties that can get the most negative equity in a falling market.

I would also be very wary of buying a "starter" property - ie a property I expected to move from in a couple of years time. Reason being is if there is negative equity in a falling market, I wouldn't be able to sit tight for years in order to climb out of it, and therefore I would be stuck in a house probably too small for my needs and unable to upgrade.

On the plus side for buying, inflation is eroding money all the time it is left in the bank (in fact because house prices aren't rising strongly atm they are actually falling in real terms) and I think it will be at least 6 months to a year before any significant movement starts to happen, so that is a fair bit of rent.

There are no certainties as to what is going to happen in the future, only probabilities.

sunnydayhereandnow · 31/05/2023 07:56

I think there's a big difference between speculating on the property market and buying a place that you love, to live in.

In my experience/opinion, it's nearly always a good idea to get on the property ladder and buy your own place, as long as (a) you can afford a repayment mortgage and have a little bit of cushion in case the rates go up again, (b) you are planning to stay there for a few years at least, and (c) you are buying a property that is likely to be reasonably appealing to similar people when you sell.

Negative equity is only actually an issue when you come to sell. In the meantime, every month you are effectively enlarging your deposit by paying your mortgage back so your 5% will quickly become more.

You're right that rates are high now but over the course of any mortgage rates will go up and down, no matter where you started. But in the end you generally come out better:

With both my 1st and 2nd properties, I bought when prices were fairly high and during the 7 years or so that I owned each the value of the property didn't increase massively (say 10%) - but my equity went up hugely because of the repayments, so each time I sold I had a much bigger deposit for the next place.

Do your due diligence and check that there hasn't been a massive unjustified rise in prices where you are buying, or that you're not buying a very unusual property that might be harder to resell - but I think that in most popular areas with decent schools/commuting etc, prices are unlikely to go down much as homes will continue to be in demand.

3BSHKATS · 31/05/2023 06:48

MidnightMeltdown · 30/05/2023 21:49

People have been saying every year since the 2016 referendum that it's a bad time to buy. Anyone taking note of this would have paid 7 years of rent and be in a significantly worse position. Buy as soon as you are able to.

Theyve been saying it every year since 2001 …. Still waiting

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 23:01

MidnightMeltdown · 30/05/2023 21:49

People have been saying every year since the 2016 referendum that it's a bad time to buy. Anyone taking note of this would have paid 7 years of rent and be in a significantly worse position. Buy as soon as you are able to.

They have, surely it’s got to come to a head at some point but I suppose that might not be for another many years as you say. It’s tricky

OP posts:
CloudlessSunnyDays · 30/05/2023 22:16

I'm sure we could all use our mortgage payments 'right now' 😂

Theyre always saying there's going to be a crash.

no one knows what's going to happen. But personally I don't think there's a better time to buy a house than yesterday or any time previous to tomorrow.

if you can afford it, stress tested to at least 7%.

yes, it's more than your rent, but it's going into your asset, building equity.

you say it's suitable for the next 5-10 years. What would be the driving force to move then? If it's something you'd Prefer/like but you could stay 15/20 years then I'd buy now.

I'm looking to move, porting my rate for the Amount left on my mortgage and getting extra at the current rate.

it'll be a chunk more to pay each month, but if I can find what I want, at a price I can afford, I'll be there & sit tight.

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 22:14

Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 30/05/2023 21:50

We thought the same but ending finding a house we both like so went ahead. Mortgage is double our previous rent but we did not think it would fall anytime soon so..

That’s fair enough. Hope you love your home! It’s so tricky isn’t it

OP posts:
Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 30/05/2023 21:50

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 18:14

Rates are so extortionate at the moment I can’t help but hope they’ll fall a bit

Would we be crazy to continue renting for now in the hope we’ll get a better deal later this year. We’ve been viewing houses and the one we fell in love with would be £500 more a month than what we are renting. I know you have security but we could use that money now, really. What does everyone think, will rates fall? How are people coping who are due to remortgage this year?

We thought the same but ending finding a house we both like so went ahead. Mortgage is double our previous rent but we did not think it would fall anytime soon so..

MidnightMeltdown · 30/05/2023 21:49

People have been saying every year since the 2016 referendum that it's a bad time to buy. Anyone taking note of this would have paid 7 years of rent and be in a significantly worse position. Buy as soon as you are able to.

Letsallthinkofaname · 30/05/2023 21:24

Buy as soon as you can afford to and are able to comfortably overpay. If you can over pay you're in a good position for if the rates go up (as you have flex in your budget) plus you'll be chipping away at what you owe quicker.

I could have borrowed more than I have to get a bigger place but I didn't want to. Where I've got meets my needs in a good area and I'm able to over pay comfortably and still save.

Freetodowhatiwant · 30/05/2023 21:23

If you have the money to buy now I would always go for it. I recently bought a new residential, after renting for almost 3 years due to separation, and although it’s a painfully high mortgage compared to previous ones I have fixed for two years in the hope that by then it will have come down to at least 3.xx rather than 4.xx. But I would rather get back into the market than risk renting. Yes my mortgage payments are now higher than my rent was, previously I have always found mortgage payments lower than what rent would be, but time IN the market is what counts in the very long run. Even if house prices dip (I don’t think there will be an outright crash) it doesn’t really matter if you intend to hold onto your property long term and can afford the repayments.

VestaTilley · 30/05/2023 21:17

Rates won’t fall much; if you can afford £500 extra a month I would buy.

lionsleepstonight · 30/05/2023 21:15

20 years ago, my mortgage underwriting bosses told us for many years, a 25 year mortgage interest averaged out at 6%. Very interesting to see that still stands. Op, we've had years at v low rates and now we're in a cycle of more mid range rates. 18 years ago fixing at 5% was a great rate (i know as I did it).

Buy a reasonable home you can live in for at least 5 years and you'll ride out the bumps and be owning for 5 years (rather than still renting).

Take your current rent, x 12 x 5 = can you afford not to buy?

Also, where in the country are you. Not all of the UK has the highs and lows as you read in the media (which assumes everyone lives in London / South East).

Truestorypeeps · 30/05/2023 21:10

As you already allude, no one has a crystal ball. I don't think there will be a major adjustment/crash for the foreseeable... covid, the Ukraine war, inflation, higher interest rates, and still there is demand for housing with prices up everywhere. Ultimately there is only so much land and many, many people on it.

Of course, there will be a crash at some point, it's cyclical but who knows when, 15/20 years, you could be a good way through a mortgage by then. Then just as before, the prices will rise again and be back to what you paid at some point.

Short-term, perhaps the market will adjust slightly, maybe -5/-10% IF the COL crisis affects people's ability to get a mortgage, cooling demand. But historically, property prices, like the stock market, are on an upward trajectory with a few dips along the way. Of course, we could be on a peak or a trough, literally no one can say with any degree of certainty.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 30/05/2023 21:09

Well... we bought in August 2008 with a 5% deposit at a 7% rate, and yes, we did go into negative equity, but were able to sell in 2013 for what we paid. Having had 5 years of building equity instead of paying rent.

10 years on we're 9 years off being mortgage free in the next house we bought.

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 21:02

MimiSunshine · 30/05/2023 20:58

because We’ve had such low interest rates for so long they’ve become considered normal.

the rates we have now are the historical normal. You might find this Article useful
and interesting.

ultimately no one can truly predict things but no I don’t think there is a property crash coming.
i would be looking to buy as big as you can afford so you don’t have think about moving again now in 5 years but without over stretching yourself financially.
don’t worry too much about the idea of negative equity as it’s only a problem if your forced to sell.

Thanks!

OP posts:
MimiSunshine · 30/05/2023 20:58

because We’ve had such low interest rates for so long they’ve become considered normal.

the rates we have now are the historical normal. You might find this Article useful
and interesting.

ultimately no one can truly predict things but no I don’t think there is a property crash coming.
i would be looking to buy as big as you can afford so you don’t have think about moving again now in 5 years but without over stretching yourself financially.
don’t worry too much about the idea of negative equity as it’s only a problem if your forced to sell.

Projected UK Interest Rates in 5 Years

With inflation showing signs of easing yet labour market still tight, when will BoE start easing its monetary policy? Read on for more on projected UK interest rates in 5 years…

https://capital.com/projected-interest-rates-in-5-years-in-the-uk

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 20:34

3BSHKATS · 30/05/2023 19:49

I don’t think they were ever superlow even in 2008 2009. There was never this big 30% off crash that people were hoping for. But you’ve got to remember even a 10% crash in your position might be a year salary, then, when you add into the fact that there’s compounded interest on that years salary, shaving 10% of could be the difference between you, retiring two or three years early. And then if you take my very very strong advice an over, pay your mortgage, even if you are literally rounding up 854 to 860, for a few years, it adds up you would be amazed. And then when you’re in a better position in your 40s, you will be able to smash through that mortgage in five years as long as you don’t just keep borrowing all the time to do it up.

That’s a point

OP posts:
treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 20:24

Lcb123 · 30/05/2023 20:19

We’re buying now, got a good price in a popular area. But - we do have a 20% deposit, and we’re buying a house we know we should happily live in for 5-10 years. I wouldn’t be buying with a low deposit at the moment

Having 20% is excellent! Congratulations on buying. We only have 5% so think negative equity risk is quite bjg

OP posts:
Lcb123 · 30/05/2023 20:19

We’re buying now, got a good price in a popular area. But - we do have a 20% deposit, and we’re buying a house we know we should happily live in for 5-10 years. I wouldn’t be buying with a low deposit at the moment

3BSHKATS · 30/05/2023 20:09

The celtic tiger thing didnt really happen in the UK.

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 20:02

magicstar1 · 30/05/2023 19:50

I wouldn’t buy now, as I think there’s going to be something major happening over the next while. I’m in Ireland but I’m talking globally like 2008.
I was looking at houses back then but decided to wait for a while. We bought for €265k and the price for the same house was €399k two years before.

Hope you’re right

OP posts:
magicstar1 · 30/05/2023 19:50

I wouldn’t buy now, as I think there’s going to be something major happening over the next while. I’m in Ireland but I’m talking globally like 2008.
I was looking at houses back then but decided to wait for a while. We bought for €265k and the price for the same house was €399k two years before.

3BSHKATS · 30/05/2023 19:49

I don’t think they were ever superlow even in 2008 2009. There was never this big 30% off crash that people were hoping for. But you’ve got to remember even a 10% crash in your position might be a year salary, then, when you add into the fact that there’s compounded interest on that years salary, shaving 10% of could be the difference between you, retiring two or three years early. And then if you take my very very strong advice an over, pay your mortgage, even if you are literally rounding up 854 to 860, for a few years, it adds up you would be amazed. And then when you’re in a better position in your 40s, you will be able to smash through that mortgage in five years as long as you don’t just keep borrowing all the time to do it up.

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 19:30

3BSHKATS · 30/05/2023 19:22

No I disagree. The writing is absolutely on the wall and staring everybody in the face at the moment. It’s like the calm before the storm in 2008. Everybody could see it coming.

Do you think things will be super low again soon then

OP posts:
3BSHKATS · 30/05/2023 19:22

mondaytosunday · 30/05/2023 19:13

Trying to forecast the property market/ mortgage rates is a fools game. You MAY get a better deal, property prices MAY also go up. Unless you can save considerably more for a larger deposit in the meantime I'd just take the plunge.

No I disagree. The writing is absolutely on the wall and staring everybody in the face at the moment. It’s like the calm before the storm in 2008. Everybody could see it coming.