Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not pay this back

57 replies

moneyquestion22 · 30/05/2023 16:46

very outing but whatever. i am really quite upset by this.
family member bought tickets to a big event a few hours away as a gift. i am broke - 2 under 2 and currently on mat leave (smp) i have a 0 hour contract and have been told there’s probably no hours to go back to so god knows what my life looks like in july onward. family member knows this. regardless the event is something i absolutely love and know she spent a lot on tickets for so i said ok screw it i’ll find a way to slot it into the budget since the main ticket was a gift.

booked coach for a fiver, and found a cheap hotel. family member then last minute got all funny about the coach and how we’d be late etc etc (we wouldn’t) and how it made it less fun. i didn’t want to argue so agreed we’d change journey there to a train. 30 quid extra out of pocket.

got there and had a great time but then the public transport was insane and blocked off for ages on the way back to the hotel. checked uber and it said it would be a tenner so i said ok let’s just split it i can work with that. by the time we’d walked to somewhere the uber could access we checked again and it said £30. family member started arguing with me saying we should have stayed at the train stop and just waited. we had a huge falling out last year so i didn’t want to risk arguing and just said ok split the taxi whatever. by the time she booked it it went to £40. i said actually no i can’t afford/justify that let’s leave it so we went to nearby bar to warm up before planning to walk back to the train stop. family member booked the taxi anyway and basically just said it’s here get in.

said to me on the way home remember to transfer the taxi money. then texted me earlier saying send me £20. i haven’t replied because i am actually quite upset. this is a close family member who is well aware that her one wage (not including her husbands) is almost double my entire household income and she has no kids or nursery fees etc to worry about. i panic when the formula tub starts to get low. i literally don’t have £20 to my name i genuinely have £1.04 in my bank right now and my mat pay stops next month.

i just don’t even know what to say i just feel hurt that she has no idea how big a deal £20 is in my position. i went to the event with intentions to budget and now i’m £30 down from the train and she wants £20 for a taxi i agreed to cancel. wibu to just ignore her.

OP posts:
LaMaG · 30/05/2023 19:01

There are 2 types of "broke" people, those who actually do not have money and those that no longer have it cos they spent it all on themselves already. My sis claims she is 'broke" at the end of the month but she eats out 4 times a week.

I think be honest about your current situation and how desperate things are. Maybe remind her that you had said you couldn't afford the taxi and could she wait a few weeks for it. Then when you have 3 or 4 to spare pay her back over the months, if she has any decency she will write it off.

I think she is BVU and I feel really bad for the tight spot you are in. And ignore the nasty comments upthread, you are doing your best and it won't always be so hard xx

Hollyppp · 30/05/2023 18:57

Dacadactyl · 30/05/2023 18:08

@moneyquestion22 I thought as much about it being your older sister.

Look, if you think she might get angry with you over it, just ring her up, say "I don't want to fall out with you over the money, but things are really tight for us at the minute with me being on SMP. I'm embarrassed to have to tell you this but I didn't want you to know the ins and outs of our situation. Id really appreciate it if you could cover the cab for me because I really had carefully budgeted for the night out and told you at the time i coudlnt afford it."

Don't let her bully you or make you feel bad. And if she still comes back asking for the money, she's a bullshitter and not on half as much as she makes out. What sort of well off sister (after finding out her sibling is struggling for money) badgers her for 20 quid?!

This

LaMaG · 30/05/2023 18:56

TellKingTutIWantMyMummy · 30/05/2023 18:53

Send her a screenshot of your bank account and say you physically can’t right now.

I was literally going to say the same thing!

TellKingTutIWantMyMummy · 30/05/2023 18:53

Send her a screenshot of your bank account and say you physically can’t right now.

moneyquestion22 · 30/05/2023 18:50

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 30/05/2023 18:41

Your sister is being an idiot. If it were me I’d write this off. The only time I wouldn’t (and I don’t lend my DB money) is if happened again and again and I was expected not to be paid back.

Siblings get very strange about money and what’s owed to them and paid ourt (my SIL and her DB but that’s to do with a flat they both own yet he’s hardly paid anything towards).

exactly. dh’s sister owes him hundreds from before i met him so literally like 5 years ago and he’s wrote it off because he knows she can’t afford it. i just find her so unforgiving and zero empathy considering she is the first person to spout up about mental health and works in that field but doesn’t somehow link the massive connection between mental health issues and financial issues. like she can’t see how a £20 taxi can be a huge emotional drain on someone all i can think right now is that’s 2 tubs of formula for my child

OP posts:
Itsanotherhreatday · 30/05/2023 18:49

Nobody should buy gifts that then require extra funds to use - it’s hardly a gift?

if you were my sister I wouldn’t have mentioned it.

I also have savings I don’t see as real money - helps separate the finds - bit I’m not a dick.

moneyquestion22 · 30/05/2023 18:47

thanks everyone. i actually feel so nervous to talk to her about it for some reason. thing is she mentioned multiple times about how ‘broke’ she is and in the same breath said she can afford a 9k car in cash and has savings for a mortgage. she’s one of those who doesn’t count savings as real money and i really just don’t actually think she gets it which i find so frustrating.

OP posts:
GonnaGetGoingReturns · 30/05/2023 18:41

Your sister is being an idiot. If it were me I’d write this off. The only time I wouldn’t (and I don’t lend my DB money) is if happened again and again and I was expected not to be paid back.

Siblings get very strange about money and what’s owed to them and paid ourt (my SIL and her DB but that’s to do with a flat they both own yet he’s hardly paid anything towards).

Susuwatariandkodama · 30/05/2023 18:38

Some people are shockingly weird when it comes to money! I can’t image demanding my sister pay £20 especially if I was in a good financial situation, it doesn’t make any sense to me.

If I was in your situation I’d tell her I can’t repay it in full but I will send whatever I can afford when I can afford it.

canfor · 30/05/2023 18:34

Yep, just let her know that things are really tough right now, can she wait until you return to work and you will repay in full or treat her to the same amount in another way. Spell out how much SMP is. Better to be pretty blunt about why you can't afford it right now.

caringcarer · 30/05/2023 18:30

She's your sister. Ring her and tell her you enjoyed the night out but you are so broke you don't know how you can buy nappies this week. Tell her you have £1.04 left this week but you will pay her back for taxi at £2 each month. Any loving sister would apologise to you and tell you to forget the taxi money. Don't just not communicate with your sister because your relationship is worth a hell of a lot more than £40.

Gastromancy · 30/05/2023 18:27

Bargellobitch · 30/05/2023 17:09

I'd just say you will pay half back but things a very tight right now so you'll have to wait for some cash to come in.

Obviously nothing you can do about it now but having a second child while other one is under 2 and on a 0 hour contract seems like it wasn't a sensible decision. So maybe your family member feels it's also not fair for her to take on paying for stuff because you left yourself short.

Oh, very nice. I bet you feel very satisfied with yourself for that dreadful comment.

Lovelynames123 · 30/05/2023 18:24

As an older sister with a higher income than my younger sister, I think your sister is being a dick. In our family it would never be asked for but at some point in the future, when times are easier, it would be reciprocated automatically

KarmaStar · 30/05/2023 18:18

You have not got the money so stop worrying about giving her something you haven't got.
She sounds very self centred to not have some empathy with your situation.
She is not better than you,she has no grounds to think she has accomplished more than you and vice versa,you have two beautiful children whom you've invested your life in,that's a huge accomplishment.
Tell her bluntly you are broke .end of.

Meeting · 30/05/2023 18:17

You shouldn't have got into the taxi, or at the least when it turned up you should have said "I told you I can't afford it so I won't be paying you" and let her make that decision.

That being said she's totally out of order.

My reply would probably be that you can't pay it right now and you'll have to give it her back if and when you can (maybe add that it won't be for a long time) if she insists.

treesareyellow · 30/05/2023 18:15

She’s being unreasonable, not you!

Napmum · 30/05/2023 18:09

Well, how much do you want to fall out over £5? You agreed at £30 (so £15 each), and then it was £5 more.

If money is that tight, say so and pay £10 now and £10 later.

Dacadactyl · 30/05/2023 18:08

@moneyquestion22 I thought as much about it being your older sister.

Look, if you think she might get angry with you over it, just ring her up, say "I don't want to fall out with you over the money, but things are really tight for us at the minute with me being on SMP. I'm embarrassed to have to tell you this but I didn't want you to know the ins and outs of our situation. Id really appreciate it if you could cover the cab for me because I really had carefully budgeted for the night out and told you at the time i coudlnt afford it."

Don't let her bully you or make you feel bad. And if she still comes back asking for the money, she's a bullshitter and not on half as much as she makes out. What sort of well off sister (after finding out her sibling is struggling for money) badgers her for 20 quid?!

towriteyoumustlive · 30/05/2023 18:06

moneyquestion22 · 30/05/2023 18:01

yes older sister. i feel like this is so outing i don’t think she uses mumsnet but still i really don’t want beef with her i just feel honestly quite panicked about the whole thing. like it’s either go into my overdraft which is already just about maxed out and i really need for other things like food and formula and nappies or have an argument with her and i’m not sure what’s worse.

also those saying pay her in instalments of £1 at a time i just feel like it’s so humiliating for me i feel like such a failure as it is career/financially wise and to pay back my sister £1 a month is kind of humiliating

I wouldn't see it as humiliating. It's just life, and some people are clueless about how little others survive on.

My baby number 2 turned out to be twins, so when I went back to work I earned £20 a week after childcare and petrol, so had to be quite blunt to friends who wanted to go out for lunch etc... as I just couldn't afford it!

Just message your sister, say you're happy to pay your half, but when you told her at the time you couldn't afford it, you really meant it, so as you only have £1.04 in your bank account at the moment, is it OK if you pay her back £2 a week?

If she gets pissy about it, then hopefully karma one day will strike and she will eventually realise what it is like to have to budget so carefully!

moneyquestion22 · 30/05/2023 18:01

Dacadactyl · 30/05/2023 17:45

Is it your older sister by any chance?

Just tell her "no I can't afford it and i tokd you that at the time. End of story."

yes older sister. i feel like this is so outing i don’t think she uses mumsnet but still i really don’t want beef with her i just feel honestly quite panicked about the whole thing. like it’s either go into my overdraft which is already just about maxed out and i really need for other things like food and formula and nappies or have an argument with her and i’m not sure what’s worse.

also those saying pay her in instalments of £1 at a time i just feel like it’s so humiliating for me i feel like such a failure as it is career/financially wise and to pay back my sister £1 a month is kind of humiliating

OP posts:
moneyquestion22 · 30/05/2023 17:59

powerrangers · 30/05/2023 17:42

She could afford to go. She just couldn't afford the taxi home which she said. But the CF booked one anyway and then just expected OP to pay.

exactly. i budgeted for it. i could afford it the way i’d budgeted but she doesn’t seem to understand the concept that not everyone has money to blow spontaneously at the last minute.

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 30/05/2023 17:45

Is it your older sister by any chance?

Just tell her "no I can't afford it and i tokd you that at the time. End of story."

powerrangers · 30/05/2023 17:42

Imred · 30/05/2023 16:49

If you couldn't afford to go you shouldn't have gone.

She could afford to go. She just couldn't afford the taxi home which she said. But the CF booked one anyway and then just expected OP to pay.

HermioneWeasley · 30/05/2023 17:09

As someone else has said offer to pay £1 a month

Bargellobitch · 30/05/2023 17:09

I'd just say you will pay half back but things a very tight right now so you'll have to wait for some cash to come in.

Obviously nothing you can do about it now but having a second child while other one is under 2 and on a 0 hour contract seems like it wasn't a sensible decision. So maybe your family member feels it's also not fair for her to take on paying for stuff because you left yourself short.

Swipe left for the next trending thread