Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to buy mil a birthday present?

39 replies

HadEnough2023 · 30/05/2023 10:27

AIBU not to buy mil a birthday present?

She moaned on Mother's Day that she didn't get a gift off us and said it was cruel, she didn't get a gift because I was in hospital over the week of Mother's Day with ds who nearly died.
When we did get round to getting her a box of chocolates she moaned and said that nobody ever buys her a good present.

I brought her a few presents for Christmas and she came round wearing one a while later saying SIL brought it for her which I found quite rude she couldn't even be bothered to remember who brought it for her.

It's her birthday today AIBU not to buy her anything and just let DH deal with it who will no doubt end up buying her another box of chocolates? Grin

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Runnerduck34 · 30/05/2023 12:43

HadEnough2023 · 30/05/2023 12:26

She's had lots of nice gifts before that.
Bottles of spirits that are pricey she likes, money for a horse (yeah you read that right), horsey type presents that weren't cheap, nice clothes, nice perfumes, canvases. Etc.

The problem is SIL gets her a generic gift like flowers and she doesn't dare moan at her but will at us. That's another reason why I've had enough.

So maybe her comments were more about your SIL ( her daughter??) and she was venting? Eitherway let DH deal with it! Your gifts to her sound thoughtful and nice.

wildlifeobserver1 · 30/05/2023 12:32

I don’t know why you’ve taken on the job of getting her gifts. If your DH forgets to get anything, that’s on him. It’s his mother.

escapingthecity · 30/05/2023 12:31

Not your mother, not your problem. Tell your DH his mother's presents are his responsibility from now on. If she complains at you, stick with "take it up with DH". Repeat until she gets the message

HadEnough2023 · 30/05/2023 12:27

@ferneytorro that's true, infact I'll say that if she says anything. Thank you.

OP posts:
HadEnough2023 · 30/05/2023 12:26

Runnerduck34 · 30/05/2023 12:23

She was unreasonable and very insensitive to moan about a lack of mothers day gift when at the time your child was seriuosly ill in hospital.

However IF your DH is crap and thoughtless about buying her a gift at other times then I can see why shes a bit upset. A box of chocolates is a " cant be bothered to give it any thought so will just stop at a petrol station enroute" gift . Clearly if you child is very ill in hospital then thats understandable
But if thats what your DH usually does anyway it probably does feel to her like shes not valued or important to him.
But get him to buy her gifts, hes her son so really he should be doing it not you.

She's had lots of nice gifts before that.
Bottles of spirits that are pricey she likes, money for a horse (yeah you read that right), horsey type presents that weren't cheap, nice clothes, nice perfumes, canvases. Etc.

The problem is SIL gets her a generic gift like flowers and she doesn't dare moan at her but will at us. That's another reason why I've had enough.

OP posts:
Runnerduck34 · 30/05/2023 12:23

She was unreasonable and very insensitive to moan about a lack of mothers day gift when at the time your child was seriuosly ill in hospital.

However IF your DH is crap and thoughtless about buying her a gift at other times then I can see why shes a bit upset. A box of chocolates is a " cant be bothered to give it any thought so will just stop at a petrol station enroute" gift . Clearly if you child is very ill in hospital then thats understandable
But if thats what your DH usually does anyway it probably does feel to her like shes not valued or important to him.
But get him to buy her gifts, hes her son so really he should be doing it not you.

Talipesmum · 30/05/2023 12:21

I don’t know any backstory here but if she wants money then that’s the most low effort thing - your DH can stick a note in a card and job done. Doesn’t sound like she deserves anything after acting like that but I’d just hand over cash in a card to tick the box. Pointless saying “we don’t give money if you’re not a child” - i don’t understand that sentiment at all and seems like you’re holding to pointless principles here.

madnessitellyou · 30/05/2023 12:21

Is your MIL seven? Has she really not twigged that the mass hysteria over Mother's Day has been created by the likes of Hallmark?

I know my dc love me. I don't need anything to confirm that. My own dm can't be bothered. Neither can MIL.

Anyway, she didn't get anything because her grandson was ill in hospital. Most normal people wouldn't even give a lack of acknowledgement a second thought in these circumstances.

Let DH sort a birthday gift for her and let her get on with her sad, hateful life.

Softoprider · 30/05/2023 12:20

So she moans about not getting presents and she moans when she does get presents. You won't give her money so give her store vouchers. She can choose her own present and when she says someone else bought it you won't even care. Job done

ferneytorro · 30/05/2023 12:19

HadEnough2023 · 30/05/2023 10:58

That's what I'm doing now, putting my foot down. He's always wanted to get her presents in the past just didn't have a clue what to get her as she always wants money and not handing over money as a present to someone who isn't a child.
I'm not stressing but I just know there'll be complaints later which my brain can't take today as I've been up 3 nights on the trot with ds being poorly. Might just tell him to drop off whatever he gets her to her house instead save myself the headache today. Grin

But you are still getting involved! Just don't mention it at all, if she says anything look blank and say i think you are speaking to the wrong person.

BarbaraofSeville · 30/05/2023 12:16

shiningstar2 · 30/05/2023 10:44

Give her a gift voucher for a modest sum you can afford for somewhere generic like m and s. If she can't find anything at all she wants in clothes, shoes, household ext she can use it for food or wine.

This is probably the best solution. Tell DH to do this if he brings it up again.

BarbaraofSeville · 30/05/2023 12:14

Why are you even giving this headspace?

She doesn't sound very nice, or grateful and it's not your job to get her a gift anyway.

If she moans at you, just respond with an airy 'oh, did DH not get you anything' and change the subject.

I'm sure DH will be able to find a gift if he puts a bit of thought into it, not that it sounds like she'll be happy with anything, but that's for him to deal with.

Napmum · 30/05/2023 11:57

HadEnough2023 · 30/05/2023 10:36

I do usually, but my son who was in hospital has been extremely unwell again so my focus has been on my child. How terrible of me I guess. Hmm

You're definitely not the terrible one here. DH needs to step up and buy her something nice, at least a Yanki candle or a scarf. Just send him to a local craft/gift shop.

Some people have crap memories, so I wouldn't worry too much about her getting mixed up about who got her what.

I do agree it's bad form for her to complain about the Mothers Day present if your son was in hospital, but this is really DH issue, not yours

Naunet · 30/05/2023 11:55

Well she should have raised her son to be more considerate of other people if it means that much to her. Not your job to compensate for her bad parenting. Stop getting involved and leave them to it.

Sugargliderwombat · 30/05/2023 11:50

This is not your problem. Step back, tell your husband it's his job from now on.

Mydusa · 30/05/2023 11:46

The upside of giving her the money would be zero effort or thought needed. Which might fit the circumstances here quite well.

Anyway it's not your problem. Tell your husband he's on it from now on and genuinely step back from it.

GiveupHQ · 30/05/2023 11:06

Op you haven’t addressed why you even have a relationship with this woman given your other thread

I wouldn’t want her within a five mile radius of my child

Sourdoughhunter · 30/05/2023 10:58

Let DH do it. It will still irritate you as he will no doubt leave it until the last minute and get something rubbish but it will also irritate you to put effort and thought into it for her not to like whatever gift you get so just let him do it.

I would text MIL to say that you and DH have decided that he will be doing the present shopping from now on for his side so if there is anything she would like for her birthday to text him. Try not to think about it after that.

HadEnough2023 · 30/05/2023 10:58

Topseyt123 · 30/05/2023 10:45

OK, so it seems MIL was an abuser to your DH when he was growing up. So is it any wonder that he doesn't get her presents?

Why then, have you been getting her presents? Why not follow DH's lead here regarding his shit mother and get her nothing?

That's what I'm doing now, putting my foot down. He's always wanted to get her presents in the past just didn't have a clue what to get her as she always wants money and not handing over money as a present to someone who isn't a child.
I'm not stressing but I just know there'll be complaints later which my brain can't take today as I've been up 3 nights on the trot with ds being poorly. Might just tell him to drop off whatever he gets her to her house instead save myself the headache today. Grin

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 30/05/2023 10:51

Justhereforthechristmasthreads · 30/05/2023 10:34

You are both unreasonable

You are unreasonable (along with DH) for not thinking about her birthday before the actual day.

She is unreasonable for being ungrateful

Her DH should be perfectly capable of buying a gift for his mother without needing OP’s input and considering MIL’s behaviour, why should OP put any effort in getting the woman anything?

Wishawisha · 30/05/2023 10:47

Of course not. It should always have been your DH’s job.

Why on earth would you get your husband’s mother something for Mother’s Day?

I don’t get involved in birthday or Christmas presents for the ILs because DH is their son and it’s him that should be doing it. I suppose if he died I’d take over doing it from me / the DC, but that’s really the only hypothetical situation I can imagine where it would become my job.

LaDamaDeElche · 30/05/2023 10:45

She moaned on Mother's Day that she didn't get a gift off us She's not your mother, so why is she moaning at both of you about that? Weird. If she gets you/your children birthday/Xmas presents, then that's different. I get my MIL gifts on those days and she gets me gifts too. I get my mother a gift on Mother's Day and that's it. If I didn't get my mother a card and she moaned, it would be at me, not DP, as she's well aware that it's not his responsibility to get her anything.

Topseyt123 · 30/05/2023 10:45

OK, so it seems MIL was an abuser to your DH when he was growing up. So is it any wonder that he doesn't get her presents?

Why then, have you been getting her presents? Why not follow DH's lead here regarding his shit mother and get her nothing?

shiningstar2 · 30/05/2023 10:44

Give her a gift voucher for a modest sum you can afford for somewhere generic like m and s. If she can't find anything at all she wants in clothes, shoes, household ext she can use it for food or wine.

Thesunwillcomeoutverysoon · 30/05/2023 10:44

Get her a voucher..
For bloody Tesco. Ungrateful bag...