Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end a friendship over not being made a bridesmaid?

359 replies

SillyBilly1993 · 30/05/2023 00:24

I had a lovely wedding a couple of years ago. My best friend of many years was my chief bridesmaid, she was my witness and made a speech too. I paid for her bridesmaids dress, jewellery, for her hair and make up. She did a bit of a pants job of organising my hen party which was stressful as I had to pick up the slack, but over the years she’s been a great friend to me and I’ve always felt really lucky and proud to have her in my life as such a close friend.

My friend got engaged last year and I assumed that she would ask me to be her maid of honour too. But time went by and eventually I got an invitation to her hen party from another friend of hers, which confirmed my fears that I wasn’t going to be asked to be a bridesmaid.

I was incredibly hurt that my friend hadn’t spoken to me to let me down gently, but I didn’t want to confront her because I knew that she had other difficult things going on in her life and because I couldn’t see what good could come of making a fuss.

But it was her hen party over the weekend, and I found it incredibly difficult. It felt humiliating that everyone knew that she had been my chief bridesmaid but I hadn’t been given any role in hers. It was upsetting to see her talking excitedly about plans for the wedding weekend with the bridesmaids. It was jarring to see how amazing and well planned her hen party was - it brought it home how little effort she had put into mine. I’d recently tried to organise a holiday with her but she’d said she didn’t have enough annual leave to spare, but in front of me at the weekend she was organising a holiday with other friends.

I can’t see us moving past this. The friendship wasn’t what I thought it was, and I feel like a fool. It’s made me feel worthless - that someone that I valued so highly would so completely not feel the same way.

I don’t think that anything that she could say would save the friendship now, so I’m intending to reduce contact with her, attend her wedding, and then quietly stop seeing her. AIBU for cutting her off in this way without saying anything because I wasn’t made a bridesmaid, am I taking it too seriously or should I confront her with how I feel first?

OP posts:
Grapewrath · 30/05/2023 09:50

Op your friend does not have the same investment into this friendship as you- I’m sorry about that. I would make an excuse regarding the wedding as it will just trigger you more then I would slowly disengage

NessieMcNessface · 30/05/2023 09:48

Fully understand your upset OP, I’d feel the same; your feelings are natural and I can see exactly why you felt awful at your friend’s hen do. it must have been a slightly surreal experience.

i would hold my head up and attend the wedding cheerfully as if nothing was bothering me, but I would then pull back from the friendship and focus on others that are more dependable.

I wouldn’t discuss it with her or with anyone tbh but then that’s just me. I would just try to behave with dignity and move on.

Ecosl · 30/05/2023 09:48

@SillyBilly1993 I think you could probably agree that you can't accept a BM role to be reciprocal and different people view friendship differently.

I think you are hurt because after the discussion on the hen weekend it demonstrates that she really cares alot less about your friendship. It's not even about the fact they are going on holiday it's the fact they speak of it, delibertaley leaving people out of the conversation. That rude IMO. The effort of the hen vs yours makes u feel a but sad. Fair enough. Not going on holiday with you because no holidays is no problem but making plans infront of you just emphasised that she prioritised other friends holidays. Which logically we can see if fine but if you are the one impacted it's hurtful.

I think you distance yourself. Go to the wedding, give your well wishes and then see what happens. put the ball in her court. Don't end it just move on with other friends and see what happens. If it's more organic than dramatic it will be easier. And you know you did the best thing for you without making a fuss.

Sorry you feel so shit and let down. It is sad and your feelings are very valid.

X

Jellycats4life · 30/05/2023 09:47

I’m not surprised you’ve abandoned this thread OP because you’ve had so many scathing responses. MN at its finest 🙄

But YANBU. Absolutely everyone in your shoes would feel crushed to be treated the way you have. Anyone who claims otherwise is lying.

Katiesaidthat · 30/05/2023 09:45

I think if you look back with calmness you will see other symptoms of her phasing you out. She is moving on to pastures new. It happened to me with a male friend actually, years ago. He had done the same to his prior best friend, so I recognised the symptoms a decade later. I would scale back this friendship to the appropriate level she has YOU at. Once you do that, you will feel so much better. It will fizzle out naturally, I think.

user1492757084 · 30/05/2023 09:45

Concentrate on your marriage and being friends with all of your friends.
This particular friend has chosen others to be her bridesmaids.
That is her choice.
Nothing more; nothing less.

I would not sever the friendship by being spiteful and entitled.
Attend the wedding and have fun.
The realationship might change yet again once you both are married and further again if you have kids at similar times.

You don't need to judge your friend.
You chose your attendants and she is choosing hers.
You are both celebrating each others' weddings.

Miriam101 · 30/05/2023 09:43

God what a lot of unfeeling responses. The OP isn't saying she feels entitled to be her bridesmaid! She's saying she feels hurt and a bit humiliated, and I can totally see why.

OP, I would definitely cool it a bit with this woman, though not to the point of not going to her wedding: that's going low! You're right that she obviously doesn't seem to see things in the same light. Is there any chance she chose her bridesmaids because they had already asked her to be theirs? (This is what a friend of mine did.) Whatever, either she will reach out to you at some point and you can continue the friendship, albeit in a slightly less intense way. Or she'll really show you how little space she has for you in her life, in which case, it will leave you with much more time in your life and heart for other, more thoughtful people. As PPs say, friendships ebb and flow.

In general though I hate hate hate the concept of "best friends"! From the bloody Reception playground it creates nothing but hassle and heartache. I have a six-year-old daughter and honestly sometimes the world of adult female friendships doesn't seem that much more mature...

Lidale · 30/05/2023 09:41

She's just not that into you. Sorry.

WhatNoRaisins · 30/05/2023 09:39

BeverlyHa · 30/05/2023 09:36

I hear unfortunately stories about English women doing this to their best or other friends all the time. The stupidity, ignorance and coldness of what means to be a true friend in this country is baffling

Agree, we normalise a lot of very poor behaviour.

TeaParty4Me · 30/05/2023 09:37

but over the years she’s been a great friend to me and I’ve always felt really lucky and proud to have her in my life as such a close friend.

YABVU

You say she’s been a great friend for years but you want to fall out with her over this 1 thing?!

Be upset that you weren’t chosen but accept that she chose someone else instead.
Don’t throw your toys out of the pram and bring up her doing a bad job at your wedding etc as that’s really childish.

Be happy for your friend and enjoy the wedding without the stress.

BeverlyHa · 30/05/2023 09:36

I hear unfortunately stories about English women doing this to their best or other friends all the time. The stupidity, ignorance and coldness of what means to be a true friend in this country is baffling

Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 09:34

EllandRd · 30/05/2023 00:32

Oh get over it being so entitled. This is her wedding not yours, stop making it all about you.

I don't think OP is making her friends wedding all about her, is she? She's posting on an anon message board though about how she feels upset by this. A lot of people would to be fair, doesn't sound like OP has said anything to the friend to make her feed bad or whatever.

OP I agree with others that sadly it sounds like perhaps she doesn't view the friendship to the same extent that you do.

willWillSmithsmith · 30/05/2023 09:33

brunettemic · 30/05/2023 09:15

Stop being so melodramatic and get over yourself. She can have a cat as a bridesmaid if she wants, it’s her wedding. You’re honestly acting like a child, if she was really your “best friend” you’d just talk to her about it like a grown up.

Do you have close friends? You sound very intolerant. Having a cat would have been a lot less hurtful or maybe you don’t believe in people having feelings, all water off a ducks back to you I guess.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/05/2023 09:33

I think she should have spoken to you, as she was your BM, and she must have known how you felt about the friendship.

I didn’t have any adult bridesmaids (just children of the family) and I’m very happy with that decision! Was just too complicated, as I have friends from different friendship groups who I value equally, and the idea of “dressing” them also seemed a bit overwhelming to me.

My oldest friend from school came round before the wedding when I was getting ready and signed the register along with the best man. I organised my own hen do!

BagLadyHere · 30/05/2023 09:30

If going to the wedding is too upsetting I'd just decline now. She's had her head turned by another friendship group re holiday etc so I'd back off without an argument and focus on other friends. She's been thoughtless so look after your own feelings. Flowers

anotherside · 30/05/2023 09:23

@brunettemic
Stop being so melodramatic and get over yourself. She can have a cat as a bridesmaid if she wants, it’s her wedding. You’re honestly acting like a child, if she was really your “best friend” you’d just talk to her about it like a grown up

You don’t sound much like a grown up.

phoenixrosehere · 30/05/2023 09:21

I think yabu only because you haven’t actually talked to her about it. If you are as close as you say shouldn’t you be able to talk to her about your feelings and ask?

Her saying she didn’t have any leave left, could they have already spoken about this trip before yours and it was brought up by someone hence her not having the time for yours?

Her not being great at her duties at your wedding, has she ever organised anything before? Is the one that is chief bridesmaid for her, more organised? Could she have more people assisting her? Your wedding was also a couple of years ago and she could have become better at such things.

You can just pull away but will it sit right with you not knowing her reasons why?

anotherside · 30/05/2023 09:21

You’re not unreasonable to feel sad and hurt because it sounds like the friendship is lopsided in terms of effort and closeness. I’d pull a sickie and not attend the wedding, not out of spite but simply as attending with mixed/negative emotions is a wasted day. You won’t enjoy it and by the sounds of things she won’t particularly feel your absence with other friends/family. If she then contacts you again within a few months of the wedding then you can start again with more realities expectations of the friendship. If she doesn’t contact you for a few months then you have your answer.

readbooksdrinktea · 30/05/2023 09:21

QueenMegan · 30/05/2023 04:59

People only hurt you if you allow it.

Just decide if going is worth it. You're an adult if not decline and do something else.

This. She has phased you out already.

Lampzade · 30/05/2023 09:17

I would just go to the wedding , have a great time and then just slowly retreat from the relationship

gloriawasright · 30/05/2023 09:17

BalloonSlayer · 30/05/2023 06:30

No one has mentioned the most obvious point - traditionally bridesMAIDS are unmarried and once you are married you are never again a bridesmaid.

Traditional families still follow this. Pippa Middeton was famously Kate's bridesmaid but Kate was not hers, nor a "matron of honour," she was just a wedding guest like everyone else.

It could just be that.

I was just about to suggest this .but I wasn't sure if I was right with this.
I think a lot of brides do stick with the traditions .there are probably lots of books and magazines about planning a wedding. And some brides will stick to the "rules"
And if this was the case I Would be even more annoyed by her need to stick by tradition ,
Hurtful for you ? Yes , no doubt there. But a deliberate slight? Maybe not .
Be thankful you are not part of a potential bridezillas wedding party.

brunettemic · 30/05/2023 09:15

Stop being so melodramatic and get over yourself. She can have a cat as a bridesmaid if she wants, it’s her wedding. You’re honestly acting like a child, if she was really your “best friend” you’d just talk to her about it like a grown up.

TUCKINGFYP0 · 30/05/2023 09:13

GuitarsUnderTheStars · 30/05/2023 01:19

I think you just need to adjust. She doesn’t class you as her closest friend but does class you as a friend. If you can think the same, it can all be ok. If you can’t do that, I think distancing yourself a bit is fine.

I agree with this. It’s ok to be hurt about it but I’d just cool things a little, not cut her off. You might regret that in the long term, friendships ebb and flow.

TakeMeDancingNakedInTheRain · 30/05/2023 09:11

I think it sounds like you have a 1 sided friendship to be honest, you thought of her as your best friend, she just considers you a friend, still worthy of a hen invite and wedding invite but you aren't her best mate. I think how you write about her here is very telling, you sound quite needy to be honest, I'd find this hard to deal with. As for paying for the wedding stuff for your wedding, of course you did, it was your wedding, I paid for everything my bridesmaids wore plus hair and makeup, this is standard if you want someone to be in your wedding party.

I'd phase her out, it is hurtful what she's doing, she knows full well what she's doing planning holidays in front of you when she declined to go with you, doing excited bridesmaid talk etc. To be honest if it was me I'd probably just pull out the wedding too, I wouldn't want to waste anymore time or money on her.

MsMarple · 30/05/2023 09:08

BalloonSlayer · 30/05/2023 06:30

No one has mentioned the most obvious point - traditionally bridesMAIDS are unmarried and once you are married you are never again a bridesmaid.

Traditional families still follow this. Pippa Middeton was famously Kate's bridesmaid but Kate was not hers, nor a "matron of honour," she was just a wedding guest like everyone else.

It could just be that.

This is a great point. I was bridesmaid for my two oldest friends, but they weren’t bridesmaids for me. I thought they’d prefer to enjoy the wedding with their husbands and kids, rather than have all the bridesmaid faff.

Mind you, I did speak to them first to check, so I knew my intentions weren’t misunderstood.

Sorry you are feeling upset though OP, but please don’t feel embarrassed - you have done nothing wrong!

Swipe left for the next trending thread