Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end a friendship over not being made a bridesmaid?

359 replies

SillyBilly1993 · 30/05/2023 00:24

I had a lovely wedding a couple of years ago. My best friend of many years was my chief bridesmaid, she was my witness and made a speech too. I paid for her bridesmaids dress, jewellery, for her hair and make up. She did a bit of a pants job of organising my hen party which was stressful as I had to pick up the slack, but over the years she’s been a great friend to me and I’ve always felt really lucky and proud to have her in my life as such a close friend.

My friend got engaged last year and I assumed that she would ask me to be her maid of honour too. But time went by and eventually I got an invitation to her hen party from another friend of hers, which confirmed my fears that I wasn’t going to be asked to be a bridesmaid.

I was incredibly hurt that my friend hadn’t spoken to me to let me down gently, but I didn’t want to confront her because I knew that she had other difficult things going on in her life and because I couldn’t see what good could come of making a fuss.

But it was her hen party over the weekend, and I found it incredibly difficult. It felt humiliating that everyone knew that she had been my chief bridesmaid but I hadn’t been given any role in hers. It was upsetting to see her talking excitedly about plans for the wedding weekend with the bridesmaids. It was jarring to see how amazing and well planned her hen party was - it brought it home how little effort she had put into mine. I’d recently tried to organise a holiday with her but she’d said she didn’t have enough annual leave to spare, but in front of me at the weekend she was organising a holiday with other friends.

I can’t see us moving past this. The friendship wasn’t what I thought it was, and I feel like a fool. It’s made me feel worthless - that someone that I valued so highly would so completely not feel the same way.

I don’t think that anything that she could say would save the friendship now, so I’m intending to reduce contact with her, attend her wedding, and then quietly stop seeing her. AIBU for cutting her off in this way without saying anything because I wasn’t made a bridesmaid, am I taking it too seriously or should I confront her with how I feel first?

OP posts:
1offnamechange · 30/05/2023 13:27

I wouldn't cut her off completely if she's otherwise a good friend because it sounds like an example of cutting your nose off to spite your face.

But if you see this as a watershed moment of realisation that she sees your friendship in a different way to you then it's absolutely fine to reassess on that basis and almost recategorise her in a lower friendship level.

e.g if you would have bought an am expensive wedding present for a best friend but spent less on just a normal friend, if you'd do a favour for a really close friend but wouldn't for just an acquaintance, how often you'd make time to see her and prioritise her over other friends, etc.

ilovesushi · 30/05/2023 13:23

My understanding is that bridesmaids are the unmarried female friends/ family. I wouldn't expect to be a bridesmaid as a married woman. Even with a very close friend I wouldn't necessarily expect to be maid of honour as there might be a sister or cousin that is considered closer.

Nanny0gg · 30/05/2023 12:58

NatureNurture85 · 30/05/2023 00:32

I wonder if she felt she should have been your MOH? And the crap hen do organisation was well because she doesn’t see the friendship in the same way?

Your post comes across as very needy of her and perhaps that turns her off?

She was MOH (chief bridesmaid)

I'd be very hurt too, OP.

changedforanswer · 30/05/2023 12:54

Knock over the pedestal you have put her on. She's not your greatest friend. She considers you a friend of sorts but not the same value you gave her.

Move on.

oakleaffy · 30/05/2023 12:54

NatureNurture85 · 30/05/2023 00:27

Do you think you put her and the friendship on a bit of a pedestal? In that she just didn’t see you in the same way?

using words like ‘proud’ of your friendship is a bit odd, I’m not proud of my friendships they kind of are what they are. They ebb and flow.

''Proud'' is an odd thing to say of a friendship..
I have said I'm ''Lucky'' to have certain friends- eg, that that one feels completely at ease with them, but 'Proud' does seem that a friend is looked up to- rather than being 'equals' or complimentary.

But I can understand @SillyBilly1993 feeling hurt.

@SillyBilly1993 I was part of a group of three which is never a good number...I found out that two of them were going to a specific event- It absolutely upset me, which was so out of the blue- It took me right back to being a child again, the feeling of 'rejection'

One of them 'phoned as I was feeling 'Lump in throat~ish' and I'm afraid to say I broke down in sobs.

To my surprise, the person was very understanding- and it was talked about and the three of us still go out together.

But the feeling of emotional pain was very real. It hit completely out of the blue.

continentallentil · 30/05/2023 12:44

Might there be other reasons she’s picked the other ones - sisters, SIL etc?

Nothing you’ve said indicates to me she doesn’t think of you as a friend, although probably less close than a few years ago.

You feel how you feel, and I probably would be a bit put out in your shoes, but I would suggest being more grown up about this. If this hasn’t happened would you think anything was wrong with your relationship? If not, you can assume she’s still a friend. The next time you are out for coffee or whatever you can raise if you want - without making it a big deal.

Blueskies13 · 30/05/2023 12:42

Maybe you need to talk to her. Maybe she feels the friendship has changed over the last few years. You can still be friends but maybe not best friends. She should have explained to you. Maybe that’s why you are hurting.

Rosscameasdoody · 30/05/2023 12:42

Whilst I agree that it’s hurtful to realise that perhaps your friend doesn’t value your friendship as highly as you clearly do, I don’t think it’s a reason to end the friendship. Accept that she may be in the same situation as you described yourself in one of your earlier posts - having several close friends, any one of which she could ask, and let it go. Not worth losing a friendship over.

willWillSmithsmith · 30/05/2023 12:38

mainsfed · 30/05/2023 11:18

I think it's fine to go to the wedding, it's a free meal and good people watching.

Just don't invest in it, no new dress or expensive gift.

This is a good idea. Don’t ‘invest’ in the day but don’t burn your bridges with the friendship (just yet at least). Observe how the friendship is going after the wedding and you can probably make a better judgement call on it then.

Eleganz · 30/05/2023 12:36

OMG12 · 30/05/2023 12:19

Do adults have “best friends”?? I just have friends

Of course they do, well at least some people do. It isn't inherently childish to have a best friend.

For OP though this seems to be a classic example of one person valuing a friendship much more than the other.

My advice to OP is to do a slow fade and step back from the relationship until either you get to a place where you feel it is balanced (top tip would be that point is where your contact is being equally sought between both parties rather than one doing most of the running) or, if you can't do that, you can just let the friendship wind up of its own accord and move on completely.

willWillSmithsmith · 30/05/2023 12:34

OMG12 · 30/05/2023 12:19

Do adults have “best friends”?? I just have friends

I tend to say my closest friend now rather than best friend as friendships change as you get older and my friendships are not as intense as in my younger years. My best friend growing up, although still a friend, has not been my closest friend for many years. My closest friend is the one I feel the most connection with now at my age and lifestyle.

TeaParty4Me · 30/05/2023 12:31

mainsfed · 30/05/2023 11:43

Again, you are ignoring the 'friend's' other behaviour (lying about not be able to go on holiday, half arsing OP's hen do', etc).

That's not heinous behaviour, but it has made OP realise that the friendship is uneven, and that's a good thing, because she can now concentrate on other close friends.

YABU TeaParty to think OP should continue to be the one that gives the most in this friendship.

But these weren’t an issue until the bridesmaids thing and now suddenly they are.

OPs AIBU is asking if she should cut her off because she wasn’t made a bridesmaid.
And I think she is BU.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 30/05/2023 12:29

OMG12 · 30/05/2023 12:19

Do adults have “best friends”?? I just have friends

No reason why they shouldn't have 'best friends', @OMG12 - as long as you have friends you can trust and who are there for you, and vice versa, does it matter what you call them?

OMG12 · 30/05/2023 12:19

Do adults have “best friends”?? I just have friends

Feelinadequate23 · 30/05/2023 12:06

OP I think the hurtful thing here was that she didn’t have the conversation with you beforehand - she would have known that you would be hurt by not being asked but instead of being an adult and breaking it to you gently, she chose the coward’s way out and let you find out from others. A humiliating kick in the teeth.

I didn’t ask one of my best friends to be my bridesmaid for various reasons and I knew if I didn’t explain/tell her beforehand then she would assume the reason was that I didn’t consider her a close friend, which wasn’t the case at all! So I just explained to her privately before I asked my bridesmaids, offered her an alternative role which I thought she would really enjoy and she was totally fine about it and pleased to have a role. Plus she then wasn’t blindsided when she got a message about the hen from the bridesmaids.

it’s just basic decency to consider your friends’ feelings when planning these things.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 30/05/2023 12:06

Arranging a holiday with other friends would have been it for me. Sounds like she has new shiny friends to play with and doesn’t value you enough to even make arrangements behind your back it’s all in public.

shelbabab · 30/05/2023 12:03

I don't think I'd even want to attend the wedding. If you plan to back away what the point of going. Make an excuse and bow out x

Catspyjamas17 · 30/05/2023 11:49

A couple of friends that were my bridesmaids didn't ask me to be their bridesmaids when they got married a year or two later, simply because I had young children by then and they thought I had enough on my plate.

brunettemic · 30/05/2023 11:44

Yes I have close friends, thank you for asking. I also talk to my friends and if they upset me I tell them, I certainly don’t consider ending a friendship over something like this. OP is being ridiculous, if this person is such a great friend having a conversation like that shouldn’t be a problem and ending the friendship shouldn’t even be a conversation. Of course she can upset, I would be too but I wouldn’t end the friendship.

mainsfed · 30/05/2023 11:43

TeaParty4Me · 30/05/2023 11:39

But why does being a bridesmaid = being a good friend.

OP has said what a great friend she’s been over the years and that would be more important to me than me not having a big role in her wedding.

Her friend obviously has reasons for choosing the people she did to be her bridesmaids.
If she has been a bridesmaid for numerous other women then she cannot have them all at hers and has to choose.

It is very possible that they are super close but the woman is also super close and probably more super close to other people.

It doesn’t mean you should end a friendship over it.

Again, you are ignoring the 'friend's' other behaviour (lying about not be able to go on holiday, half arsing OP's hen do', etc).

That's not heinous behaviour, but it has made OP realise that the friendship is uneven, and that's a good thing, because she can now concentrate on other close friends.

YABU TeaParty to think OP should continue to be the one that gives the most in this friendship.

Lightsgoingout · 30/05/2023 11:39

Flip side OP, I had a friend who was really rude and not very nice when I didn’t make her my bridesmaid. I was hers and she didn’t take it well. Didn’t come to my hen do and didn’t bother coming to my wedding (I had to chase her to see if she was even coming).

Our friendship never recovered, she messaged a few years ago, I was nice but made it clear I wasn’t bothered about keeping in contact.

I think your doing the right thing, got to the wedding then phase out contact if this isn’t the relationship you thought it was

TeaParty4Me · 30/05/2023 11:39

Miriam101 · 30/05/2023 11:23

Surely you can understand that it's NOT about the role per se- it's about the message it sends: of not being valued anywhere near as much as the OP thought she was, and as much as she values this friend?

I'm fairly sure that if the chose bridesmaids had been sisters or fiance's sisters or daughters the OP would have said and would not be feeling this way. But if she has, as seems pretty clear, chosen other friends over her for no reason other than she values them more, even though until this point OP had thought of the two of them as being super-close, then surely it is understandable she should feel sad and start to re-evaluate the friendship?

But why does being a bridesmaid = being a good friend.

OP has said what a great friend she’s been over the years and that would be more important to me than me not having a big role in her wedding.

Her friend obviously has reasons for choosing the people she did to be her bridesmaids.
If she has been a bridesmaid for numerous other women then she cannot have them all at hers and has to choose.

It is very possible that they are super close but the woman is also super close and probably more super close to other people.

It doesn’t mean you should end a friendship over it.

jenny38 · 30/05/2023 11:37

Some people have a few best friend type friendships. It depends how many bridesmaids she is having? Plus since you married have your lives moved jn different directions, nit quite as close etc.
I would be hurt, but I also recognise I xan be pretty sensitive. Arranging holidays with others and knocking you back etc indicates you are a little lower down the list of priorities. Would I end the friendship? Not sure, I would likely give it some time, reassess when things are not so raw.
Maybe you have friends in your life who were secretly hoping to be your maid of honor? Look at it from different perspectives. But in time, if you still feel this way, then if course its OK to walk away.

SallyWD · 30/05/2023 11:36

Well it seems clear she has closer friends than you. That's it. Entirely up to you whether you want to end a friendship over this. I mean you can still be good mates but just acknowledge the fact you're not her best friend.

mainsfed · 30/05/2023 11:29

Miriam101 · 30/05/2023 11:23

Surely you can understand that it's NOT about the role per se- it's about the message it sends: of not being valued anywhere near as much as the OP thought she was, and as much as she values this friend?

I'm fairly sure that if the chose bridesmaids had been sisters or fiance's sisters or daughters the OP would have said and would not be feeling this way. But if she has, as seems pretty clear, chosen other friends over her for no reason other than she values them more, even though until this point OP had thought of the two of them as being super-close, then surely it is understandable she should feel sad and start to re-evaluate the friendship?

Yep, sounds like bride has a few BMs, so her leaving out OP and not even bothering to tell her says she doesn't value the friendship as much as OP. Not to mention the holiday stuff and half arsing OP's hen do.