Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants to see her son without her grandson & me

341 replies

Grxcegrxxn · 29/05/2023 23:34

For a bit of context, myself & my partner have been together 4 years, we had our son 18 months ago. Partners mother has only seen our son twice. We have encouraged her to schedule a day to come & see us or we can travel to her, but she either cancels plans or just doesn’t show up. She missed our sons first birthday, didn’t see him over the Christmas break, even though she lives a few streets away. FIL sees our son regularly but always comes to ours alone without MIL. We’ve been in no contact with MIL for 10 months now but recently she has started getting FIL to communicate for her instead of just reaching out herself. FIL invited us to a bbq at their house, we agreed we’d go, then the day of FIL messages & says ‘mom recons it’s best to leave it, I think you and her need to chat face to face privately’. When my partner asked what about (assuming she was upset about something & wanted to talk it out) he responded ‘it’s nothing bad your mom just wants mom and son time with you away from everyone els’. Insinuating she wants to be alone with him away from myself & our son. Usually I wouldn’t be bothered if it was directed at me, BUT I don’t understand why she wants to be away from her grandson as well? Am I taking this too personal? :/

OP posts:
Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:05

sandyhappypeople · 30/05/2023 15:59

I don't think that's a reflection on your DH though, you normally find that they are more loyal to the people they live with.. they hide behind the 'anything for a quiet life' syndrome, my dad was like it (with regards to my step mum).

He should be refusing to pass message back and forth though, he can surely see how counterproductive that is to getting the relationship back on track (assuming that's what everyone wants of course).

If your DH keeps trying and trying, maybe he should just stop all together.. and don't accept any incoming messages from FIL.. put the ball firmly in her court, and tell your FIL to stop trying to make it happen, as it's not in his or your control, it's up to her to make the effort now, she's got your DH number to arrange a mother son meeting if that's what she wants.

Agree, she needs to contact DP directly, not hiding behind FIL & getting him to pass messages for her.

OP posts:
Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:02

jannier · 30/05/2023 15:54

Do you like spending 1 to 1 with your child? That doesn't change when they are 20, 30 or 40 just like spending time with a friend. Have you stopped it in the past? Something's happened and your not saying.

What planet are you on? She hasn’t got the decency to even drop her son a message or pick up the phone when he calls. If she was so eager to see him for 1 on 1 time she can stop hiding behind FIL & reach out to her son herself. Phone works both ways. It’s not her sons job to chase after her when she ignores him. & never stopped her seeing DP or DS, we’ve had to BEG her to make an effort to see them cause she cant be arsed.

OP posts:
sandyhappypeople · 30/05/2023 15:59

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 15:06

I agree, FIL seems scared of her, she can be very stubborn so I think FIL is nervous to get on her bad side in case he looses her. But surely your son comes first, even before your wife. He’s leaving his son in the dark about whatever has happened that’s rubbed her the wrong way, it’s all mind games.

I don't think that's a reflection on your DH though, you normally find that they are more loyal to the people they live with.. they hide behind the 'anything for a quiet life' syndrome, my dad was like it (with regards to my step mum).

He should be refusing to pass message back and forth though, he can surely see how counterproductive that is to getting the relationship back on track (assuming that's what everyone wants of course).

If your DH keeps trying and trying, maybe he should just stop all together.. and don't accept any incoming messages from FIL.. put the ball firmly in her court, and tell your FIL to stop trying to make it happen, as it's not in his or your control, it's up to her to make the effort now, she's got your DH number to arrange a mother son meeting if that's what she wants.

jannier · 30/05/2023 15:54

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:10

finally someone with sense

MIL clearly has an issue with me for whatever reason & is trying to push myself & my son out by manipulating her son into ‘mom & son time’. After ignoring him for a year. Mom & son time is a sugarcoated way of saying ‘I want to see you but I don’t want the extra baggage like your partner and child’. I’m glad someone can see it from my perspective.

Do you like spending 1 to 1 with your child? That doesn't change when they are 20, 30 or 40 just like spending time with a friend. Have you stopped it in the past? Something's happened and your not saying.

suburbophobe · 30/05/2023 15:44

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe

Please read all of OP's comments.... (go to the first one then click on "see all").

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/05/2023 15:32

Or maybe he should arrange to visit his father, on his own, and explain how awkward this all is?

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/05/2023 15:30

I don't think you're being unreasonable but it's up to your partner if he wants to go and see his mother on his own. Yes, you have a child now but that doesn't mean that he can't go and visit his parents on his own.

Given what you've said in your post, it's probably a good idea if he goes to speak to his mother to find out what the issue is; perhaps he can sort it out with her and the 'blockage' will clear.

It's still a mother and child bond, however old they get and that doesn't change even with the addition of other people.

I hope it gets resolved so that you feel able/welcome to visit or have your partner's parents to your home. It does sound difficult but I would definitely not stand in the way of your partner going to his parents without you or the baby.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 15:25

TooBigForMyBoots · 30/05/2023 15:24

Does she usually go to the pub of a morning?

Not in the morning, evenings, but she will stay drinking till late then go to work hungover. My Nan was like this, like a ‘functioning alcoholic’.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 30/05/2023 15:24

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:20

UPDATE - dp did drop in after she asked for mom and son time, he got there & she wasn’t home anyway, his brother who was home said she’d gone to the pub with a friend. Dp called her, no answer, left a message to see when she’s free for him to go and see her, still no response days later. Surely if she was eager to see him she wouldn’t of responded? Even FIL hasn’t responded. It’s giving dp mixed signals, one minute she wants the see him the next she ignores him.

Does she usually go to the pub of a morning?

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 15:24

saraclara · 30/05/2023 15:19

So your DP has a brother? Has he asked him what's going on? Have either of you asked his dad?

It's bizarre that in ten months no-one has communicated with each other about this at all. Your DP hasn't popped round in that time until now, he hasn't talked to his brother about it, and there's been a huge elephant in the room when fil has visited.

For goodness sake, TALK!

Please read the other updates Iv added before commenting. Iv stated several times now, DP has been down to talk this out numerous times but MIL never seems to be home when Dp shows up. She doesn’t answer her phone when dp calls or texts. She is outright IGNORING us. & whenever we do bring it up to FIL he claims there is nothing wrong & MIL doesn’t have an issue. Brother doesn’t seem to notice anything strange, he’s still a teen & teens can be ignorant or blindsided to things like this.

OP posts:
Zarataralara · 30/05/2023 15:22

If she does have a drink problem that would fit in with manipulative behaviour. Ime alcoholics are incredibly manipulative.

saraclara · 30/05/2023 15:19

So your DP has a brother? Has he asked him what's going on? Have either of you asked his dad?

It's bizarre that in ten months no-one has communicated with each other about this at all. Your DP hasn't popped round in that time until now, he hasn't talked to his brother about it, and there's been a huge elephant in the room when fil has visited.

For goodness sake, TALK!

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 15:13

sandyhappypeople · 30/05/2023 14:58

One thing you could do is cut off FIL as soon as he tries to pass messages from her.. just say, 'no, with respect, if she's got something to say she can say it herself to us' make it clear you will not participate in this sort of bullshit behaviour.

I feel for FIL but he's got a backbone.. he should use it.

He obviously knows what's up with her so should give his son the heads up, isn't his brother any the wiser?

& brother is much younger so he’s not really clued up I don’t think, he’s at that age where he just sits on his gaming console all day without a care in the world. Iv noticed that the brother seems to get his way more than DP ever has. For instance, when dp lived with them before he started driving, if he ever needed a lift to work etc all he ever got from his mom was ‘you’ve got legs you can walk it’, which I somewhat understand, at his age he didn’t need his parents driving him everywhere, BUT now his brother is working & going to college, MIL will give him lifts, not even just to work, to his gf’s, to meet his friends etc. Like his brother get’s all the special treatment. Or if brother needs money, they’ll lend it him, but if DP needs money she’ll refuse to lend him any. Times where we’ve been struggling she hasn’t lent us a dime but will give brother money to buy games on PlayStation when he still lives at home & doesn’t have bills to pay.

OP posts:
Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 15:06

sandyhappypeople · 30/05/2023 14:58

One thing you could do is cut off FIL as soon as he tries to pass messages from her.. just say, 'no, with respect, if she's got something to say she can say it herself to us' make it clear you will not participate in this sort of bullshit behaviour.

I feel for FIL but he's got a backbone.. he should use it.

He obviously knows what's up with her so should give his son the heads up, isn't his brother any the wiser?

I agree, FIL seems scared of her, she can be very stubborn so I think FIL is nervous to get on her bad side in case he looses her. But surely your son comes first, even before your wife. He’s leaving his son in the dark about whatever has happened that’s rubbed her the wrong way, it’s all mind games.

OP posts:
Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 15:02

BeverlyHa · 30/05/2023 14:51

Is she your actual mother in law or the mother of the man you live with? did she meet you when the dating period was going into full time commitment?

Mother to dp, grandmother to our son. & met her early in the dating period, she was always polite but would still do very sly things to make me feel left out like taking pictures at family gatherings but making sure I wasn’t in any, making me sit away from the immediate family table & id have to sit the family friends or distant relatives whilst dp would be asked to sit with them, luckily he used to stay with me regardless so I wasn’t alone at a function they invited me too. Little things that some people may not think twice about but it’s those little things that make you aware of how your not welcome or accepted. She only became ignorant when finding out I was pregnant, she wasn’t happy about it & only reached out once DS was born, met him a day after he was born & saw him once when he was 3 months old & then nothing since. There’s been a sudden shift since DS was born.

OP posts:
sandyhappypeople · 30/05/2023 14:58

One thing you could do is cut off FIL as soon as he tries to pass messages from her.. just say, 'no, with respect, if she's got something to say she can say it herself to us' make it clear you will not participate in this sort of bullshit behaviour.

I feel for FIL but he's got a backbone.. he should use it.

He obviously knows what's up with her so should give his son the heads up, isn't his brother any the wiser?

MeridianB · 30/05/2023 14:56

Just ignore them. They can either be grown up and have a conversation or they can run the drama on their time.

I feel sorry for your DP but he can stop doing all the running now, safe in the knowledge that he tried his best to sort it out.

mrsdarthlord · 30/05/2023 14:53

“I do think on Mumsnet people bend over backwards to excuse mothers/Mil's.

Some are just manipulative narcissists.

I wouldn't put up with this shit for a second.”

100% agreed to its the above

She’s manipulating you and your DP. Is it normal to want to see your adult child without his partner/grandchild? Absolutely, nothing wrong with it. But I really don’t think that’s the main point here. For 10 (!) months she’s been avoiding your partner, he’s been trying to contact her on multiple occasions. It’s controlling, narcissistic behaviour, it’s her way or the high way. I also think that OP has every right to feel sad that MIL doesn’t want to see her grandchild. I definitely would.

To be honest, if the roles were reversed (you not liking your MIL) I feel like more people would be saying that you should try to make some effort to see her from time to time, at the end of the day she’s your DP’s mom. Not often but occasionally, during some larger family gatherings. I think it should work both ways, even if she doesn’t like you she should be making some minimal effort and not behaving like a child.

Probably not a popular opinion but I’d stop justifying her behaviour. “But as a mother she has every right to see her adult son on his own” someone said in one of the earlier posts. No, there is no right nor law guaranteeing this, it’s a privilege you don’t deserve if you’re a shitty, manipulative person.

Your post resonates with me because of a similar family situation. After almost 10 years of bending backwards I decided to stop trying with my MIL (very similar manipulation style and passive aggressive behaviour). She also specifically tried to exclude me from some family events, which my DH didn’t agree for; I know how much it hurts). My life has been much better since I just stopped trying to please her. I think if someone hasn’t experienced something similar, they try to give you advice which would apply to ‘normal’ people. But in this instance it simply won’t work. She won’t change. You/your partner will give in once, she’ll keep doing the same thing over and over again. Try your best to move on and be happy. Don’t let her live rent free in your head. All the best.

BeverlyHa · 30/05/2023 14:51

Is she your actual mother in law or the mother of the man you live with? did she meet you when the dating period was going into full time commitment?

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 14:40

MiddleParking · 30/05/2023 14:38

The woman we’re talking about is in her early forties. Young enough to be a mother to a child the same age as OP’s. Your mum was just horrible and so is OP’s MIL.

I agree, some people just shouldn’t have kids if they plan on abandoning them.

OP posts:
MiddleParking · 30/05/2023 14:38

MintJulia · 30/05/2023 12:36

@rainingsnoring Sorry you find it bizarre. I suppose it is, a bit. My DM wasn't interested in any of her 9 dgcs. She wanted photos for the mantel piece and boasting rights if any of them achieved anything outstanding but otherwise regarded them as rather tiresome.

We could either rage against it or just accept that was the way she was. Is it so unusual? I can think of a few older women like that. A hang over from the 'seen but not heard' era maybe

The woman we’re talking about is in her early forties. Young enough to be a mother to a child the same age as OP’s. Your mum was just horrible and so is OP’s MIL.

UCknowitall · 30/05/2023 14:31

This is all so bizarre. You live close by and your DP hasn't seen his mother for ten months .. she is avoiding him.. and his dad doesn't mention the problem. Do none of you actually speak to each other ??

If that were my mum. I would go round without warning at random times if the day . You say the brother lives at home... and even he doesn't know what the problem is ? Just send him
round after work and tell him not to come home until he's seen her. !

I have to hypothesis for the avoidance..

  1. You are in some way 'different' . Racially, culturally, socioeconomically, and your DPs mother has a prejudice that is socially unacceptable. So smiles to your face BUT now you have a child that is 50% you - and permanent . She can't cope..
  1. You are early 20s and already have a child. Amongst my social circle that would be pretty unusual (and silently judged) . Middle Class environment where lives are v 'mapped out' .. GCSE, A'levels, Uni.. gap year . Graduate position somewhere... Early 20s already with a baby would be very frowned upon . (Although no one would admit it - a bit like your MIL) !
Amybelle88 · 30/05/2023 14:30

Good on all the people being objective on here and trying to see if there's a reason for MIL behaving like this.

I happen to think she's just a bit of a horrible cow and you have both done plenty to try and rectify this situation. Tell FIL he is always welcome and you want to maintain a relationship with him, but no further effort will be made with MIL unless she reaches out at this point. There's only so much you can do and only so many times you can be ignored without it being plain rude and hurtful.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 14:27

Fraaahnces · 30/05/2023 14:04

I wonder if the marriage between FIL & MIL is breaking down, and if she isn’t actually an alcoholic or has some kind of MH issue that the FIL feels he can’t discuss due to his own pride/hope/feelings, etc. I would totally give up on trying to get the truth out of her. She doesn’t give a shit. Work on nurturing the relationship with DFIL. He might need that atm.

MIL & FIL allegedly split up shortly after he visited us & during the visit he said he was going to have a chat with MIL to try and bring her to get more involved in DS & DP lives, days later FIL suddenly went quiet & we didn’t hear from him for a few weeks. I wonder if maybe her lack of interest is bothering FIL & causing friction between them at home cause he’s getting an earful from MIL whenever he visits us. Maybe that’s why they split for a bit cause her trying to control him into not seeing us isn’t working as well as she thought.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 30/05/2023 14:21

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 14:02

We do & I did suggest it to DP because same as you I wanted to make sure she was actually there, but he felt like he was having to ‘chase’ after her when realistically he shouldn’t have to

I'd have marched down to the pub and confronted the awful woman. The brother who I assume lives at home might know what the hell is going on. Your FIL needs to find some cojones.

She's a jealous narcissist. I'd block her on everything you and partner when she discovers that she'll be knocking on her son's door

Swipe left for the next trending thread