Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants to see her son without her grandson & me

341 replies

Grxcegrxxn · 29/05/2023 23:34

For a bit of context, myself & my partner have been together 4 years, we had our son 18 months ago. Partners mother has only seen our son twice. We have encouraged her to schedule a day to come & see us or we can travel to her, but she either cancels plans or just doesn’t show up. She missed our sons first birthday, didn’t see him over the Christmas break, even though she lives a few streets away. FIL sees our son regularly but always comes to ours alone without MIL. We’ve been in no contact with MIL for 10 months now but recently she has started getting FIL to communicate for her instead of just reaching out herself. FIL invited us to a bbq at their house, we agreed we’d go, then the day of FIL messages & says ‘mom recons it’s best to leave it, I think you and her need to chat face to face privately’. When my partner asked what about (assuming she was upset about something & wanted to talk it out) he responded ‘it’s nothing bad your mom just wants mom and son time with you away from everyone els’. Insinuating she wants to be alone with him away from myself & our son. Usually I wouldn’t be bothered if it was directed at me, BUT I don’t understand why she wants to be away from her grandson as well? Am I taking this too personal? :/

OP posts:
Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 16:56

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:49

Your missing the part where she’s asking FIL to make DP go & see her. If she doesn’t want to know then she needs to leave us be & stop giving hold & cold treatment to her son getting his hopes up that she may want to see him just to change her mind last minute. Like I said, we were in no contact 10 months, DP had gotten over it, soon as we stopped forcing it she reaches out asking dp to see her.

Your father in law doesn't have to pass anything on though, he should stand up to her and say if she wants to make contact she knows where you are and how to get hold of you all. He doesn't have to be a passive player in this.

Coralsunset · 30/05/2023 16:55

It would also explain why she's never there when DH goes round as arranged...

Terzani · 30/05/2023 16:54

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:37

My speculation? It’s not a speculation, it’s that FIL has told us, he said him & MIL split for a few weeks & he stayed at his dads for a while. They sorted things out & got back together (when fil stopped talking to us for a bit).

And what did FIL say about the reasons of such an irrational behaviour from MIL? How did he explain such a deep conflict? ”Dear son and DIL, we didn’t only have a casual disagreement, but we split up for some weeks, just because she doesn’t want me to visit you.” ”And why is that?” .... She must have given him a reason, no matter how absurd. If he refuses to say or gives a vague answer or claims she didn’t explain at all (which is very hard to believe), it's your DP's right to find out why she is behaving like this. She can’t hide forever from her son and can’t ghost him and you like this.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:53

Coralsunset · 30/05/2023 16:52

I wonder if FIL is making that up (that MIL wants contact with DH)? And is trying to manipulate the situation so there is contact again.

this is a possibility, considering she hasn’t made any contact herself.

OP posts:
Coralsunset · 30/05/2023 16:52

I wonder if FIL is making that up (that MIL wants contact with DH)? And is trying to manipulate the situation so there is contact again.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:49

Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 16:44

I mean he's a grown man, if she's decided she no longer wants a relationship with him then of course that's sad, but if he's old enough to have a child himself not sure abandoning is the right word. Unfortunately you cant force people to be in your life if they dont want to, that sadly includes parents. He needs to start to deal with the reality if hes tried and she wont respond. If she gets shitty with her husband seeing you then surely that's something he has to sort out with her- what on earth are either of you supposed to do about it?

Your missing the part where she’s asking FIL to make DP go & see her. If she doesn’t want to know then she needs to leave us be & stop giving hold & cold treatment to her son getting his hopes up that she may want to see him just to change her mind last minute. Like I said, we were in no contact 10 months, DP had gotten over it, soon as we stopped forcing it she reaches out asking dp to see her.

OP posts:
Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:46

saraclara · 30/05/2023 16:37

The only thing I can think of them is to basically pin FIL down, all the questions of him and simply don't accept any more useless replies. Your DP has to be frank, strong, and simply tell him that he's really worried about his mum and needs to know the truth. Ask questions about every element of this, that can't be side stepped. So "why does she not answer the phone to me?". "Why did she cancel (arranged visit)?"

this is ideally what needs to happen but FIL always insists there’s no issue, no hard feelings etc, he plays dumb like he doesn’t wanna spit it out so we can resolve whatever it is. I think maybe MIL doesn’t like me & doesn’t want to see me for whatever reason but they don’t wanna be outright with it to DP incase it upsets him or pushes him away, cause if she did say ‘I just don’t like your partner’ DP would probs cut contact with her for good. So shes tiptoeing round it. I’d rather her just rip the bandaid off & say it how it is so we can all move on.

OP posts:
Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 16:44

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 14:40

I agree, some people just shouldn’t have kids if they plan on abandoning them.

I mean he's a grown man, if she's decided she no longer wants a relationship with him then of course that's sad, but if he's old enough to have a child himself not sure abandoning is the right word. Unfortunately you cant force people to be in your life if they dont want to, that sadly includes parents. He needs to start to deal with the reality if hes tried and she wont respond. If she gets shitty with her husband seeing you then surely that's something he has to sort out with her- what on earth are either of you supposed to do about it?

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:41

jannier · 30/05/2023 16:33

I don't get a see all option there is nothing to click under her name

I still think something has happened or she is ill
And saying I want to see my child on their own isn't odd which was my point .....as she hadn't spoken to him for 10 months I don't get how she said it anyway.....perhaps that's dad trying to patch things up.

Right but the issue is PATCH WHAT THINGS UP? the only reason I’m annoyed is because we are being told ‘everything is fine, mom is fine with DP’ BUT then FIL is also saying things that are insinuating there is an ‘issue’ or a elephant in the room that needs addressing. We weren’t aware there was a problem, we can’t recall anything bad happening that would make mil act like this. Nothing has happened ON OUR end.

OP posts:
NotMyMill · 30/05/2023 16:39

Lobelia123 · 30/05/2023 08:04

I think all the kind and accommodating advice is quite frankly ridiuclous. Theres a lot more going on than someone not wanting to host a BBQ. She is deliberately excluding the OP and her child and setting up an adversarial situation where her husband is being pushed to choose between seeing his DIL and grandchild, and being on her side. I think its time this passive aggressiveness was confronted head on. i would absolutely make my husband bring it out into the open and sto[p pandering to his horrible, manipulative mother. If shes not interested in you or the little one, thats her loss, but she has no right to prevent the granddad from having a relationship with you.

This!

saraclara · 30/05/2023 16:37

The only thing I can think of them is to basically pin FIL down, all the questions of him and simply don't accept any more useless replies. Your DP has to be frank, strong, and simply tell him that he's really worried about his mum and needs to know the truth. Ask questions about every element of this, that can't be side stepped. So "why does she not answer the phone to me?". "Why did she cancel (arranged visit)?"

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:37

Terzani · 30/05/2023 16:31

Yes, they are, because their only focus is not to lose access to booze. But in this case it all feels quite weird. A manipulative MIL, ok, but to what effect? What exactly she wants? Because so far she has achieved nothing, and nobody seems to be able to reach her and ask her anything.

Does she really want to spend time with her son, as FIL claims? Doubtful, since she keeps rejecting his calls and leaving the house instead of waiting for him. And indeed, all this spending time with the son could be just an excuse invented by FIL, who maybe wanted to sweeten the blow when OP&DP&grandson visit was cancelled. Or does she want her son to leave OP and his new family? But how, since she keeps her son at a distance and doesn't even talk to him?

Even the most passive-aggressive people open their mouth sometimes to express their minds. But in 10 months she didn't seem to say anything. OP says that MIL and FIL ”allegedly split up” shortly after he visited them, and then: ”I wonder if maybe her lack of interest is bothering FIL & causing friction between them at home cause he’s getting an earful from MIL whenever he visits us.” But is it any of this true or is just OP’s speculation? In any case, MIL gained nothing - all that she seems to do is to annoy and alienate others.

My speculation? It’s not a speculation, it’s that FIL has told us, he said him & MIL split for a few weeks & he stayed at his dads for a while. They sorted things out & got back together (when fil stopped talking to us for a bit).

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 30/05/2023 16:33

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 01:46

currently trying to arrange a day for him to see her when she’s free & yes I definitely think there’s something going on behind closed doors that she may not want me knowing, but I don’t see how she plans on resolving whatever the issue is without me knowing what’s gone wrong. & the main thing that bothers me is her lack of interest in her grandson, she wants mom & son time but not mom, son & grandson time. It’s just bizarre.

So did she call this morning to meet him this morning, then she went to the pub?Confused

jannier · 30/05/2023 16:33

FelisCatus0 · 30/05/2023 16:22

@jannier At least have the basic common decency to read ALL the OP's post/replies (by clicking on See all under the OP) before writing a load of nonsense. OP's partner has gone above and beyond to speak to his mother, visiting her, calling etc, SHE WON'T ANSWER HIM!

I don't get a see all option there is nothing to click under her name

I still think something has happened or she is ill
And saying I want to see my child on their own isn't odd which was my point .....as she hadn't spoken to him for 10 months I don't get how she said it anyway.....perhaps that's dad trying to patch things up.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 30/05/2023 16:33

JadedTeal · 30/05/2023 16:14

I am absolutely not suggesting that your MIL is right here by any stretch of the imagination but it seems to me that things are not quite as they may seem.

Clearly FIL knows what the problem is but doesn't want to say, which is fine but when your DH put him on the spot asking what was going on with DM he said nothing was wrong "your mom just wants mom and son time with you"

From what you have told us... "she hasnt seen him, hasn’t spoke to him over the phone or over messages in over a year" ... so MIL has at no time asked your DH to meet or replied to any of his numerous requests to meet and then not shown up.

"UPDATE - dp did drop in after she asked for mom and son time, he got there & she wasn’t home" - but she didn't ask for mom and son time - FIL suggested she did!

"Mom & son time is a sugarcoated way of saying ‘I want to see you but I don’t want the extra baggage like your partner and child" - but again she didn't say she wanted to see him, FIL did.

"Just because she may not feel like seeing her grandson, doesn’t mean she has to ban her husband from seeing him too" - but did she? Or did FIL ask you not to post about his visit on FB?

"No right to ban her husband from seeing his son & grandson" - You are clearly upset, I would be too if I didn't know why she was doing this but you are twisting the narrative here and that can be hugely damaging if there is something else at play that you don't know about.

"Dp went over soon as she said she wanted to talk to him days ago, they weren’t home" - she didn't say she wanted to talk to him,FIL did.

It seems to me that something has happened that maybe you are not aware of. You and MIL rubbed along ok and (I think you said) this happened suddenly. It looks like MIL has a problem with both you and your DH and FIL is trying, in the worst way possible, to get MIL and your DH to talk.

FIL arranges a BBQ and it looks like she told him she wouldn't be attending, ruining his cunning plan for peace talks so he calls you and cancels.

Was the day she told you she was ill (when you think she was lying and was actually hungover) the last time you heard from her?

As I said, I'm not excusing MIL but maybe you need to be mindful that what FIL is saying is not necessarily what MIL is doing/saying. I really do hope you get to the bottom of it and it all works out for everyone.

Do you know, I read the OP's comments with something niggling at me and this is it.

FiL is encouraging your DP to speak to his mother, but at no point has she expressed that seeing him one to one is her issue, to either of you. Seems like she really is not bothered and it's your FiL trying to make them talk so he's free to come and visit.

Terzani · 30/05/2023 16:31

Zarataralara · 30/05/2023 15:22

If she does have a drink problem that would fit in with manipulative behaviour. Ime alcoholics are incredibly manipulative.

Yes, they are, because their only focus is not to lose access to booze. But in this case it all feels quite weird. A manipulative MIL, ok, but to what effect? What exactly she wants? Because so far she has achieved nothing, and nobody seems to be able to reach her and ask her anything.

Does she really want to spend time with her son, as FIL claims? Doubtful, since she keeps rejecting his calls and leaving the house instead of waiting for him. And indeed, all this spending time with the son could be just an excuse invented by FIL, who maybe wanted to sweeten the blow when OP&DP&grandson visit was cancelled. Or does she want her son to leave OP and his new family? But how, since she keeps her son at a distance and doesn't even talk to him?

Even the most passive-aggressive people open their mouth sometimes to express their minds. But in 10 months she didn't seem to say anything. OP says that MIL and FIL ”allegedly split up” shortly after he visited them, and then: ”I wonder if maybe her lack of interest is bothering FIL & causing friction between them at home cause he’s getting an earful from MIL whenever he visits us.” But is it any of this true or is just OP’s speculation? In any case, MIL gained nothing - all that she seems to do is to annoy and alienate others.

Kerrylass · 30/05/2023 16:29

OP you could tie yourself up in knots trying to figure out whats going on with your MIL, and you might never find out. You wont ever change her, so change how you react to her.

Step away mentally. If your FIL visits, steer the conversation away from her. Discuss with your DP to develop a similar grey stone attitude.

jannier · 30/05/2023 16:27

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:14

Again, you clearly haven’t read any of the other comments Iv added where she wasn’t even home when she asked him to pop down for ‘1 to 1 time’. & the part where she’s asked for mum & son time whilst completely ignoring the fact she’s not seen her grandson in 10 months despite living a few streets away. He accepted her offer for mom & son time & drove to hers to just find out she’d fucked off to the pub with a friend anyway & wouldn’t be back till late. Like I said already, if she was so eager, why did she decide to go out instead of stay to see her son for the time SHE requested. & if you actually read any of the updates Iv posted you’d know she has a history for doing this, making arrangements then letting us down.

It would be easier to read if you didn't drop feed...the app doesn't let me filter your comments
Is she an alcoholic or have other issues?

FelisCatus0 · 30/05/2023 16:22

@jannier At least have the basic common decency to read ALL the OP's post/replies (by clicking on See all under the OP) before writing a load of nonsense. OP's partner has gone above and beyond to speak to his mother, visiting her, calling etc, SHE WON'T ANSWER HIM!

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/05/2023 16:20

surbobophone, I had multiple pages again, but I went back to read OP's posts which is why I suggested that her partner go to speak to his father (just the two of them) to find out what the issue is since partner's mother is flakey.

There's nothing to be gained from OP linking this in to partner's parents not wanting to see their grandson; it looks as if they don't want to see any of them, for whatever reason?

The only people who can answer this would be partner's parents and only one of them is communicative.

OP should disengage, let partner sort this out - or not - whichever he prefers. They've been no contact for 10 months so there's no real incentive from anybody.

BMW6 · 30/05/2023 16:18

Your poor partner. WTF is wrong with her !
If I were him I'd just leave off trying to contact her, he's done more than enough reaching out to her.

Let her approach him for their one to one time - if she really wants it and makes the supreme effort 🙄

JadedTeal · 30/05/2023 16:14

I am absolutely not suggesting that your MIL is right here by any stretch of the imagination but it seems to me that things are not quite as they may seem.

Clearly FIL knows what the problem is but doesn't want to say, which is fine but when your DH put him on the spot asking what was going on with DM he said nothing was wrong "your mom just wants mom and son time with you"

From what you have told us... "she hasnt seen him, hasn’t spoke to him over the phone or over messages in over a year" ... so MIL has at no time asked your DH to meet or replied to any of his numerous requests to meet and then not shown up.

"UPDATE - dp did drop in after she asked for mom and son time, he got there & she wasn’t home" - but she didn't ask for mom and son time - FIL suggested she did!

"Mom & son time is a sugarcoated way of saying ‘I want to see you but I don’t want the extra baggage like your partner and child" - but again she didn't say she wanted to see him, FIL did.

"Just because she may not feel like seeing her grandson, doesn’t mean she has to ban her husband from seeing him too" - but did she? Or did FIL ask you not to post about his visit on FB?

"No right to ban her husband from seeing his son & grandson" - You are clearly upset, I would be too if I didn't know why she was doing this but you are twisting the narrative here and that can be hugely damaging if there is something else at play that you don't know about.

"Dp went over soon as she said she wanted to talk to him days ago, they weren’t home" - she didn't say she wanted to talk to him,FIL did.

It seems to me that something has happened that maybe you are not aware of. You and MIL rubbed along ok and (I think you said) this happened suddenly. It looks like MIL has a problem with both you and your DH and FIL is trying, in the worst way possible, to get MIL and your DH to talk.

FIL arranges a BBQ and it looks like she told him she wouldn't be attending, ruining his cunning plan for peace talks so he calls you and cancels.

Was the day she told you she was ill (when you think she was lying and was actually hungover) the last time you heard from her?

As I said, I'm not excusing MIL but maybe you need to be mindful that what FIL is saying is not necessarily what MIL is doing/saying. I really do hope you get to the bottom of it and it all works out for everyone.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:14

jannier · 30/05/2023 16:08

My planet is that something happened until he goes and finds out nobody knows.....or you do but are not saying
My other comment was about you not seeming to think anyone would want to have some 1 to 1 with an adult child.

Again, you clearly haven’t read any of the other comments Iv added where she wasn’t even home when she asked him to pop down for ‘1 to 1 time’. & the part where she’s asked for mum & son time whilst completely ignoring the fact she’s not seen her grandson in 10 months despite living a few streets away. He accepted her offer for mom & son time & drove to hers to just find out she’d fucked off to the pub with a friend anyway & wouldn’t be back till late. Like I said already, if she was so eager, why did she decide to go out instead of stay to see her son for the time SHE requested. & if you actually read any of the updates Iv posted you’d know she has a history for doing this, making arrangements then letting us down.

OP posts:
jannier · 30/05/2023 16:08

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 16:02

What planet are you on? She hasn’t got the decency to even drop her son a message or pick up the phone when he calls. If she was so eager to see him for 1 on 1 time she can stop hiding behind FIL & reach out to her son herself. Phone works both ways. It’s not her sons job to chase after her when she ignores him. & never stopped her seeing DP or DS, we’ve had to BEG her to make an effort to see them cause she cant be arsed.

My planet is that something happened until he goes and finds out nobody knows.....or you do but are not saying
My other comment was about you not seeming to think anyone would want to have some 1 to 1 with an adult child.