Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants to see her son without her grandson & me

341 replies

Grxcegrxxn · 29/05/2023 23:34

For a bit of context, myself & my partner have been together 4 years, we had our son 18 months ago. Partners mother has only seen our son twice. We have encouraged her to schedule a day to come & see us or we can travel to her, but she either cancels plans or just doesn’t show up. She missed our sons first birthday, didn’t see him over the Christmas break, even though she lives a few streets away. FIL sees our son regularly but always comes to ours alone without MIL. We’ve been in no contact with MIL for 10 months now but recently she has started getting FIL to communicate for her instead of just reaching out herself. FIL invited us to a bbq at their house, we agreed we’d go, then the day of FIL messages & says ‘mom recons it’s best to leave it, I think you and her need to chat face to face privately’. When my partner asked what about (assuming she was upset about something & wanted to talk it out) he responded ‘it’s nothing bad your mom just wants mom and son time with you away from everyone els’. Insinuating she wants to be alone with him away from myself & our son. Usually I wouldn’t be bothered if it was directed at me, BUT I don’t understand why she wants to be away from her grandson as well? Am I taking this too personal? :/

OP posts:
FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 11:43

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 11:40

"There is nothing in OP's posts that suggest MIL went NC and OP knew it" Really?

OP tells us numerous times that MIL won't contact them/her son. That she hasn't spoken to them for 10 months/over a year, won't reply to the many messages her DS has left her, she leaves the house when she hears DS is coming round - I think most people would know that this person isn't speaking to them, commonly referred to as NC.

For possibly the fifth time, OP and her partner were TOLD that MIL wanted to see him, so they trusted what they were told and believed she wanted to see him.

Is there some reason you can't comprehend this? Am I writing it in sanskrit? What the actual?.......

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 11:40

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 11:17

Again, OP was told this. So she, and her partner, believed it. There is nothing in OP's posts that suggest MIL went NC and OP knew it. Nothing at all. I repeat, OP and her partner was told that MIL wanted to see son on his own. So they believed it. Because that is what they were TOLD.

"There is nothing in OP's posts that suggest MIL went NC and OP knew it" Really?

OP tells us numerous times that MIL won't contact them/her son. That she hasn't spoken to them for 10 months/over a year, won't reply to the many messages her DS has left her, she leaves the house when she hears DS is coming round - I think most people would know that this person isn't speaking to them, commonly referred to as NC.

Grxcegrxxn · 04/06/2023 11:37

UCknowitall · 04/06/2023 06:27

Going round there to get a reason for this odd and hurtful behaviour is 'chasing her ? ' ... wtf ?? No it isn't ! You have been stressing over this for months. ! How about he takes his head out of his arse and stops making excuses as to why he won't confront whatever is going on.

I still maintain that your DP is only too well aware EXACTLY what it is. There is some dislike of you as he is very young to have a child. She feels like you have trapped him. He knows it, she knows it, even FIL knows it.. yet know one is speaking .

They live round the corner . He could sort this all out right here and now.. it's Sunday morning. He can turn up on the doorstep at 9am and have THAT conversation. He won't though - because he already knows .

trapped him by having a child? Where on this thread have I said DP feels Iv ‘trapped him’? & yes it is chasing her, we’d be dancing to her tune, doing exactly what she wants when she can’t be arsed to drop her son a text, it’s mind games. Why should we have to keep going to her to just be turned away, it’s a waste of time.

OP posts:
RailwayCutting · 04/06/2023 11:35

UCknowitall · 03/06/2023 19:36

I have read the updates and the entire thread but I still don't get something .

If this were MY mother or MIL behaving in this way .. FOR TEN MONTHS !! I wouldn't

a. Ring to say I am on my way !!!
b. Give ANY kind of notice as to when I would be turning up.

She may well have a busy social life/be an alcoholic/ not like you because you are pink/green/black/Muslim/Christian etc ... but I would want to know what the hell it was and would be making it my mission to do so !

You say he 'went round when invited but told she would be back late' - 'so came homel' ... I would not be doing that for starters. I would wait.

In current circumstances. They are at a family party. Unless you and your DP have fallen out with THE ENTIRE family I would turn up and deal with it. If you haven't fallen out with the entire family why have you been singled out for exclusion. ???

OP - do you have some protected characteristics that your DP family are discriminating about - but too canny to mention ? Race ? Religion ?

Or perhaps you are from a very different socioeconomic class from MIL ?

Baby in early 20s is not something that happens in my social circle. They are either v consciousness about birth control or have no qualms about abortion - because planning a baby at that age would just be regarded as weird and self sabotaging... could this be the reason ? Does she regard her son as 'trapped' into parenthood far too young but doesn't have the guts to say it ??

The MIL is early 40s and her son is early 20s

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 11:32

GnomeDePlume · 04/06/2023 11:23

If my FIL told DH that MIL wanted to see him we would assume that MIL wanted to see him. Normal people assume that those types of messages are genuine.

Exactly.

GnomeDePlume · 04/06/2023 11:23

If my FIL told DH that MIL wanted to see him we would assume that MIL wanted to see him. Normal people assume that those types of messages are genuine.

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 11:17

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 10:54

Ah come on now. Anyone reading that title will assume MIL has said this. If they don't then they will when they read...

Dp went over soon as she said she wanted to talk to him

How can she go 10 months without seeing her grandson then ask her son to NOT bring him with when visiting?

she’s asked for mum & son time

He accepted her offer for mom & son time

stay to see her son for the time SHE requested.

soon as we stopped forcing it she reaches out asking dp to see her.

MIL is allowed to call the shots & tell DS not to bring his partner

But the reality is OP knows MIL has gone no contact and did not ask FIL to pass on msgs, as she also said - "Just cause MIL doesn’t want a relationship with her son"

OP is upset and angry that her MIL has gone NC with them, maybe with good reason, who knows, but she needs to deal with what is actually happening and stop mincing FIL's words. Facts matter!

Again, OP was told this. So she, and her partner, believed it. There is nothing in OP's posts that suggest MIL went NC and OP knew it. Nothing at all. I repeat, OP and her partner was told that MIL wanted to see son on his own. So they believed it. Because that is what they were TOLD.

GnomeDePlume · 04/06/2023 11:14

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 10:06

OP didn't twist it. She (and her partner) was TOLD she wanted to see her son only. That is what she was told!!!!

And then when DP has attempted to see his DM she has disappeared off out despite the time/day having been arranged.

The suggested meet ups may have been FIL's attempts to bring the family back together. As soon as MIL hears about them the attempts are quashed.

I havent seen anything to suggest OP/her DP have any idea what the issue is.

I still think this is something to do with DM's self image as a 'young mum'. I have known people cling onto this image long after time has made it a lie. It becomes key to their identity. Being a 'young GM' is not an identity she feels able to step into.

Before OP had their DS MIL was able to pass off the relationship between OP & DP as a teenage bf/gf thing. Now they have a family that doesnt work anymore.

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 10:54

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 10:06

OP didn't twist it. She (and her partner) was TOLD she wanted to see her son only. That is what she was told!!!!

Ah come on now. Anyone reading that title will assume MIL has said this. If they don't then they will when they read...

Dp went over soon as she said she wanted to talk to him

How can she go 10 months without seeing her grandson then ask her son to NOT bring him with when visiting?

she’s asked for mum & son time

He accepted her offer for mom & son time

stay to see her son for the time SHE requested.

soon as we stopped forcing it she reaches out asking dp to see her.

MIL is allowed to call the shots & tell DS not to bring his partner

But the reality is OP knows MIL has gone no contact and did not ask FIL to pass on msgs, as she also said - "Just cause MIL doesn’t want a relationship with her son"

OP is upset and angry that her MIL has gone NC with them, maybe with good reason, who knows, but she needs to deal with what is actually happening and stop mincing FIL's words. Facts matter!

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 10:06

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 09:45

" those two lazy to read past the title" - but even the post title has been twisted. FIL said this not MIL, she doesn't want to see any of them.

OP didn't twist it. She (and her partner) was TOLD she wanted to see her son only. That is what she was told!!!!

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 10:04

MRex · 04/06/2023 09:38

rejected her own son while he was growing up and spent no time with him, not even Christmases
Admitted by OP that she was working. Turning that into abandonment looks like OP's work, or at least something she willingly concocted alongside her DP.

Let's be honest, if you were MIL raising children by working all the hours from a young age, and then had your ungrateful DS parroting that you abandoned him because you had to work Christmases, do you not think you might get upset? And if the girlfriend was the one feeding this narrative, you wouldn't put in a bit of distance?

As said, she was not a mother to her son and spent no time with him. Please read the comments. The son is not being 'ungrateful' for being upset at being neglected. Choosing to work every single Christmas day is a form of neglect if she didn't have to. Even apart from Christmas, she spent no time with her son. The mother should be grateful her neglected children give her the time of day, when she won't see her children and wished she didn't have them.

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 09:45

" those two lazy to read past the title" - but even the post title has been twisted. FIL said this not MIL, she doesn't want to see any of them.

MRex · 04/06/2023 09:38

rejected her own son while he was growing up and spent no time with him, not even Christmases
Admitted by OP that she was working. Turning that into abandonment looks like OP's work, or at least something she willingly concocted alongside her DP.

Let's be honest, if you were MIL raising children by working all the hours from a young age, and then had your ungrateful DS parroting that you abandoned him because you had to work Christmases, do you not think you might get upset? And if the girlfriend was the one feeding this narrative, you wouldn't put in a bit of distance?

FelisCatus0 · 04/06/2023 09:20

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 09:11

Thank god someone else realises MIL has gone NC with them and at no point has asked her DS to pop round his own. I'm amazed at how many people jumped on the band wagon.

I agree with almost everything you have said, except maybe the reason why she went NC. We have no way of knowing the reason but given the way OP has twisted comments out of shape I can imagine she is not easy going irl.

@JadedTeal the way OP has twisted comments out of shape I can imagine she is not easy going irl.

I'm not sure what thread you've been reading, because the OP on this thread has not twisted ANY comments, indeed and in fact, they're the ones who had their comments twisted, and often by those two lazy to read past the title, let alone read past her first OP to read all her responses.

Also the fact that the MIL rejected her own son while he was growing up and spent no time with him, not even Christmases, shows it has absolutely nothing to do with the OP.

JadedTeal · 04/06/2023 09:11

UCknowitall · 04/06/2023 07:09

' no contact' is utterly pointless when the other party has already done the same to you !

NC is the appropriate behaviour when someone's behaviour towards you is detrimental to your wellbeing.

MIL has decided to NC her son and his family . For a reason you don't appear to know - although I suspect you do and 'chasing' MIL to wring it from her own lips is not necessary as you already know the answer.
You both now deciding NC is the best way forward is fine if you accept that she doesn't approve of your decision to have a child very young. (You can't un-birth him) .

However - to say 'we have decided to 'go NC' with someone who has been NC with you for over ten months.. sounds rather immature and petulant.

I say again (a point I have made 5 times on this thread but as yet is unaddressed or acknowledged by OP) I believe your DP and possibly you - are only to well aware what the problem is. If it were a genuine mystery then any sane person with a hitherto normal interaction with their parents .. would of gone round and sorted it out in the first month .

He knows what it is. Pretty sure you do too. There is no mystery . She got on with you fine as a gf. Why not ? Young 20 something gets a gf .. all lovely. Make her welcome etc.. New GF is pregnant. That's a game changer for a young 20 something.. I certainly wouldn't want it for my DDs or DS and would be extremely unimpressed by their lack of care for their own fertility.. the only difference being that I would take the attitude that whilst not ideal - it's done and to crack on with what life has dealt and remember that a baby is a blessing .
Sounds like MIL can't quite see it like that yet .. maybe ever ..

Thank god someone else realises MIL has gone NC with them and at no point has asked her DS to pop round his own. I'm amazed at how many people jumped on the band wagon.

I agree with almost everything you have said, except maybe the reason why she went NC. We have no way of knowing the reason but given the way OP has twisted comments out of shape I can imagine she is not easy going irl.

UCknowitall · 04/06/2023 07:09

' no contact' is utterly pointless when the other party has already done the same to you !

NC is the appropriate behaviour when someone's behaviour towards you is detrimental to your wellbeing.

MIL has decided to NC her son and his family . For a reason you don't appear to know - although I suspect you do and 'chasing' MIL to wring it from her own lips is not necessary as you already know the answer.
You both now deciding NC is the best way forward is fine if you accept that she doesn't approve of your decision to have a child very young. (You can't un-birth him) .

However - to say 'we have decided to 'go NC' with someone who has been NC with you for over ten months.. sounds rather immature and petulant.

I say again (a point I have made 5 times on this thread but as yet is unaddressed or acknowledged by OP) I believe your DP and possibly you - are only to well aware what the problem is. If it were a genuine mystery then any sane person with a hitherto normal interaction with their parents .. would of gone round and sorted it out in the first month .

He knows what it is. Pretty sure you do too. There is no mystery . She got on with you fine as a gf. Why not ? Young 20 something gets a gf .. all lovely. Make her welcome etc.. New GF is pregnant. That's a game changer for a young 20 something.. I certainly wouldn't want it for my DDs or DS and would be extremely unimpressed by their lack of care for their own fertility.. the only difference being that I would take the attitude that whilst not ideal - it's done and to crack on with what life has dealt and remember that a baby is a blessing .
Sounds like MIL can't quite see it like that yet .. maybe ever ..

standardduck · 04/06/2023 06:45

Grxcegrxxn · 04/06/2023 00:50

Thank you for your comments, we have chosen to go no contact till MIL contacts us herself or comes to us to talk. We are keeping contact with FIL but aren’t going to entertain any conversation that involves MIL till she coughs up what the problem is.

Good decision, OP.

It's her loss!

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/06/2023 06:44

UCknowitall · 04/06/2023 06:27

Going round there to get a reason for this odd and hurtful behaviour is 'chasing her ? ' ... wtf ?? No it isn't ! You have been stressing over this for months. ! How about he takes his head out of his arse and stops making excuses as to why he won't confront whatever is going on.

I still maintain that your DP is only too well aware EXACTLY what it is. There is some dislike of you as he is very young to have a child. She feels like you have trapped him. He knows it, she knows it, even FIL knows it.. yet know one is speaking .

They live round the corner . He could sort this all out right here and now.. it's Sunday morning. He can turn up on the doorstep at 9am and have THAT conversation. He won't though - because he already knows .

I think he’s chased his mother enough. What she’s doing is vile and manipulative so trying to have it out with her won’t work. She obviously sees herself as some kind of victim in this to be ignoring him.

UCknowitall · 04/06/2023 06:27

Going round there to get a reason for this odd and hurtful behaviour is 'chasing her ? ' ... wtf ?? No it isn't ! You have been stressing over this for months. ! How about he takes his head out of his arse and stops making excuses as to why he won't confront whatever is going on.

I still maintain that your DP is only too well aware EXACTLY what it is. There is some dislike of you as he is very young to have a child. She feels like you have trapped him. He knows it, she knows it, even FIL knows it.. yet know one is speaking .

They live round the corner . He could sort this all out right here and now.. it's Sunday morning. He can turn up on the doorstep at 9am and have THAT conversation. He won't though - because he already knows .

Grxcegrxxn · 04/06/2023 00:50

Thank you for your comments, we have chosen to go no contact till MIL contacts us herself or comes to us to talk. We are keeping contact with FIL but aren’t going to entertain any conversation that involves MIL till she coughs up what the problem is.

OP posts:
Shelby2010 · 03/06/2023 23:03

I don’t think you’ll ever get a rational answer or get MIL to behave in a normal manner. I think you just have to accept that she is a complete nutcase & adjust your behaviour accordingly..

Don’t try going round there, just send a message saying to let you if they want to come round.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 03/06/2023 21:13

Time to bin the lot of them until they learn to behave like normal, decent people. Stop giving them any more of your headspace. They're not worth it.

Ishareyourissue · 03/06/2023 20:30

Grxcegrxxn · 03/06/2023 20:10

I’m so sorry you had to deal with that, wtf?! Some MIL’s are just outright vulgar with no specific reasoning besides the fact that DP can’t be controlled anymore, I’m sick of people excusing MIL’s toxic behaviour. My MIL has had problems with most of DP’s ex girlfriends (expect one which just so happened to be her bestfriends daughter)🙄 I genuinely believe she just doesn’t like me & can’t outright admit it to DP incase he cuts her off so is using terms like ‘mom & son time’ to manipulate him into excluding me & our son without him realising it’s intentional. X

It’s weird isn’t it. My MIL is possessive over him . All the ‘family’ talk whilst excluding me and the dc ????

I hope you can sort it out !

Grxcegrxxn · 03/06/2023 20:10

Ishareyourissue · 03/06/2023 19:59

I have a similar MIL issue which came to light a few years ago.

On DH birthday he was at work, the dc had got him a few bits and a a cake for when he got home……he returned and seemed a bit down. Turns out at lunchtime his mum had turned up with other family to take him out for lunch, and a cake, and a small ‘party’. Except I hadn’t been told or invited or the dc so he didn’t go and MIL was fuming!

More recently his grandmother died. I was talking to MIL about the arrangements and saying we would leave the younger dc as they may be noisy etc and she started saying that dh couldn’t take me , that no other women were going (?) then I said ok well he will be there early (he had a specific role) she said ‘no we are taking him so he can only leave when we want as this is a FAMILY thing’
He wanted to drive himself she said no he HAD to go with her so that she could MAKE SURE he had a drink 🤦‍♀️
Then she started calling me all sorts of things totally out of the blue . On the day he didn’t go which was a shame for him but we couldn’t excuse her behaviour as part of grief because what she said was so nasty

I’m so sorry you had to deal with that, wtf?! Some MIL’s are just outright vulgar with no specific reasoning besides the fact that DP can’t be controlled anymore, I’m sick of people excusing MIL’s toxic behaviour. My MIL has had problems with most of DP’s ex girlfriends (expect one which just so happened to be her bestfriends daughter)🙄 I genuinely believe she just doesn’t like me & can’t outright admit it to DP incase he cuts her off so is using terms like ‘mom & son time’ to manipulate him into excluding me & our son without him realising it’s intentional. X

OP posts:
Ishareyourissue · 03/06/2023 19:59

I have a similar MIL issue which came to light a few years ago.

On DH birthday he was at work, the dc had got him a few bits and a a cake for when he got home……he returned and seemed a bit down. Turns out at lunchtime his mum had turned up with other family to take him out for lunch, and a cake, and a small ‘party’. Except I hadn’t been told or invited or the dc so he didn’t go and MIL was fuming!

More recently his grandmother died. I was talking to MIL about the arrangements and saying we would leave the younger dc as they may be noisy etc and she started saying that dh couldn’t take me , that no other women were going (?) then I said ok well he will be there early (he had a specific role) she said ‘no we are taking him so he can only leave when we want as this is a FAMILY thing’
He wanted to drive himself she said no he HAD to go with her so that she could MAKE SURE he had a drink 🤦‍♀️
Then she started calling me all sorts of things totally out of the blue . On the day he didn’t go which was a shame for him but we couldn’t excuse her behaviour as part of grief because what she said was so nasty