Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants to see her son without her grandson & me

341 replies

Grxcegrxxn · 29/05/2023 23:34

For a bit of context, myself & my partner have been together 4 years, we had our son 18 months ago. Partners mother has only seen our son twice. We have encouraged her to schedule a day to come & see us or we can travel to her, but she either cancels plans or just doesn’t show up. She missed our sons first birthday, didn’t see him over the Christmas break, even though she lives a few streets away. FIL sees our son regularly but always comes to ours alone without MIL. We’ve been in no contact with MIL for 10 months now but recently she has started getting FIL to communicate for her instead of just reaching out herself. FIL invited us to a bbq at their house, we agreed we’d go, then the day of FIL messages & says ‘mom recons it’s best to leave it, I think you and her need to chat face to face privately’. When my partner asked what about (assuming she was upset about something & wanted to talk it out) he responded ‘it’s nothing bad your mom just wants mom and son time with you away from everyone els’. Insinuating she wants to be alone with him away from myself & our son. Usually I wouldn’t be bothered if it was directed at me, BUT I don’t understand why she wants to be away from her grandson as well? Am I taking this too personal? :/

OP posts:
rainingsnoring · 30/05/2023 12:24

MintJulia · 30/05/2023 02:51

It could simply be she isn't a baby-lover and wants to spend an hour or two with her son. She doesn't have to be interested in her DGC, it isn't compulsory.

My dm was like that.

These sort of odd posts often crop up on this type of thread.

Would it be acceptable to say 'Sorry parents, I don't do old people. It isn't compulsory, you know' and just cut contact because your parents are old and frail/ repetitive/ slow/ demented?

Utterly bizarre. A grandparent might not be 'a natural' around toddlers but there is a balance between totally ignoring your GC and DS and offering full time childcare and overnight stays.

It's sounds as if the 'MIL' is a tricky woman and FIL is just trying to keep the peace and is enabling her poor behaviour. There is an outside chance that there is something serious going on in the background but it doesn't sound likely if she is going to the pub with friends.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 12:19

AlfietheSchnauzer · 30/05/2023 12:16

Sorry but I'm thinking differently here. This woman gives her husband grief if he sees his grandson ffs... No health diagnosis justifies such appalling behaviour!!

Op - you come as a team. She either accepts that or she can bugger off and stay NC

Thank you, someone with sense. Just because she may not feel like seeing her grandson, doesn’t mean she has to ban her husband from seeing him too. It’s controlling behaviour. It’s giving ‘well if I’m not seeing them then your not seeing them either’.

OP posts:
AlfietheSchnauzer · 30/05/2023 12:17

@JudgeRudy How exactly does her anxiety, agoraphobia or any other health diagnosis justify her giving her husband grief when he sees his own grandson????

Utter nonsense

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 12:17

Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 12:06

She's human and can't necessarily help how she feels though. If she's early 40s she was presumably young when she had your partner, is he quite young still too? Perhaps she's disappointed he's had a child young as she knows what it's like, perhaps she still has a lot going on in her own life- not like she's retired and has all of the time in the world, maybe she's struggling with the menopause and this on top is hard to deal with. These aren't excuses, but he should talk to her if he wants to know, I know you said she's evasive but I'm sure he can find a way. I'm not sure how working Christmas day when he was young is overly relevant though.

My partners are the same age & are incredibly involved in our sons life & don’t use their age as an excuse to abandon their grandchild because they don’t ‘feel like it right now’ & I responded to someone who asked ‘what was MIL like with DP growing up? I said she put work before anything els, she would work Christmas Day, meaning she chose work over spending a traditional holiday with her kids, that’s what dp has told me used to bother him, dp & his brother used to get upset MIL wouldn’t spend Christmas with them.

OP posts:
AlfietheSchnauzer · 30/05/2023 12:16

Sorry but I'm thinking differently here. This woman gives her husband grief if he sees his grandson ffs... No health diagnosis justifies such appalling behaviour!!

Op - you come as a team. She either accepts that or she can bugger off and stay NC

TonTonMacoute · 30/05/2023 12:13

Well, it sounds a very weird situation but only she knows what's behind it. It certainly doesn't make sense to anyone else.

If I was your DP I would have a meeting and see what happens. If she doesn't have a good reason for this strange request he can decide to not bother again.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 30/05/2023 12:09

Clearly there are other issues ? Was she against you 2 being together , Dow she differ from any mental illness ?

Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 12:06

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 12:03

Yes! I thought the same because she would make jokes whilst I was pregnant like ‘I feel too young to be a grandma’ & would say she hates being called ‘nanna, grandma’ etc. I do feel like she’s just pretending she doesn’t have a grandchild to keep her ‘youth’. Sounds incredibly selfish though.

She's human and can't necessarily help how she feels though. If she's early 40s she was presumably young when she had your partner, is he quite young still too? Perhaps she's disappointed he's had a child young as she knows what it's like, perhaps she still has a lot going on in her own life- not like she's retired and has all of the time in the world, maybe she's struggling with the menopause and this on top is hard to deal with. These aren't excuses, but he should talk to her if he wants to know, I know you said she's evasive but I'm sure he can find a way. I'm not sure how working Christmas day when he was young is overly relevant though.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 12:03

GnomeDePlume · 30/05/2023 11:57

I wonder if the issue is that she has become a grandmother and this conflicts with her view of herself as being young.

Rather than being happy that she has the energy to be an active grandparent she is hiding from it and pretending it hasn't happened.

Yes! I thought the same because she would make jokes whilst I was pregnant like ‘I feel too young to be a grandma’ & would say she hates being called ‘nanna, grandma’ etc. I do feel like she’s just pretending she doesn’t have a grandchild to keep her ‘youth’. Sounds incredibly selfish though.

OP posts:
Fifthtimelucky · 30/05/2023 11:59

This does sound very odd.

Given her young age, I wonder whether she is struggling to see herself as a grandmother and doesn't feel old enough (or want to feel old enough) to take on that role. Many women in their early 40s still have primary aged children after all (as I did). She might also be struggling to see her 'baby' in the role of father.

Given that she must have become a mother young herself, that would be very hypocritical, but people's feelings aren't always logical!

GnomeDePlume · 30/05/2023 11:57

I wonder if the issue is that she has become a grandmother and this conflicts with her view of herself as being young.

Rather than being happy that she has the energy to be an active grandparent she is hiding from it and pretending it hasn't happened.

mamabear715 · 30/05/2023 11:49

As I said before, time to stop pandering to her.
She must feel really special with everyone tiptoeing round her. She's a waste of space. FIL is enabling her.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:44

TheCatterall · 30/05/2023 11:34

@Grxcegrxxn this sounds so crap for your poor DP. What was she like with him whilst he was growing up etc?

FiL is just pandering to her now and enabling this behaviour to continue by keeping his visits a secret etc. He must know what’s going on and should really have a chat with DP to enlighten him a bit.

MIL is either a complete narc or has MH issues that folks at home are ignoring/covering for. Or maybe she’s just an arsehole?

Think if I was DP I’d either write her off and stop engaging or camp at hers until she turns up from the pub.

It is, he likes to act like he’s not bothered but surely it must, if your own mother can’t give you the time of day that must be the ultimate rejection. DP said his mom was never the ‘maternal’ type, apparently she always put work first, she would work Christmas Day every year. He claims he barely saw her, he had a better relationship with his dad, his dad was more family oriented & was the one that used to say he couldn’t wait for grandchildren etc. Definitely think FIL knows what the issue is but won’t tell us whenever we ask, dp has asked ‘is mom upset with me? She hasn’t answered any calls or texts’ & FIL just says no everything’s fine when everything clearly isn’t fine.

OP posts:
purplecorkheart · 30/05/2023 11:38

As an one off I wouldn't be too bother about her wanting to meet her son alone. Maybe he can find out what is going on.

TheCatterall · 30/05/2023 11:34

@Grxcegrxxn this sounds so crap for your poor DP. What was she like with him whilst he was growing up etc?

FiL is just pandering to her now and enabling this behaviour to continue by keeping his visits a secret etc. He must know what’s going on and should really have a chat with DP to enlighten him a bit.

MIL is either a complete narc or has MH issues that folks at home are ignoring/covering for. Or maybe she’s just an arsehole?

Think if I was DP I’d either write her off and stop engaging or camp at hers until she turns up from the pub.

jannier · 30/05/2023 11:31

Sounds like they do need a one to one so the air can be cleared.
I love having time to sit and chat with my son we talk about health, emotions, have a laugh, see he's okay etc....I love chatting to my DIL one to one too. Love group family time and having just me and grandkids every interaction is different and builds bonds ....
But her not seeing anyone suggests there is something wrong

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:30

Scarydinosaurs · 30/05/2023 04:12

What was the set up before the baby came? Did he see his mum alone then? Now the baby is here are the only arrangements to see her as a family?

something has clearly happened with her and she wants to tell your DP on her own away from you.

Early 40s is very young so I assume you are also young? I’d think that if your MIL has something difficult going on for herself, although seeing your son is important, it just isn’t a priority right now for her.

Nope MIL used ask us both to visit & on the occasions I would stay home & just dp would go she would get upset that I hadn’t come along. Back then she used to like seeing us together as a group. & yes myself & dp are in early 20s.

OP posts:
Maddy70 · 30/05/2023 11:27

It's fine she wants to see her son alone

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:20

UPDATE - dp did drop in after she asked for mom and son time, he got there & she wasn’t home anyway, his brother who was home said she’d gone to the pub with a friend. Dp called her, no answer, left a message to see when she’s free for him to go and see her, still no response days later. Surely if she was eager to see him she wouldn’t of responded? Even FIL hasn’t responded. It’s giving dp mixed signals, one minute she wants the see him the next she ignores him.

OP posts:
Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 11:10

Can't say I find it overly weird for a mother to want to see their son really. If I were him I'd be keen to see her and find out what was going on.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:10

Lobelia123 · 30/05/2023 08:04

I think all the kind and accommodating advice is quite frankly ridiuclous. Theres a lot more going on than someone not wanting to host a BBQ. She is deliberately excluding the OP and her child and setting up an adversarial situation where her husband is being pushed to choose between seeing his DIL and grandchild, and being on her side. I think its time this passive aggressiveness was confronted head on. i would absolutely make my husband bring it out into the open and sto[p pandering to his horrible, manipulative mother. If shes not interested in you or the little one, thats her loss, but she has no right to prevent the granddad from having a relationship with you.

finally someone with sense

MIL clearly has an issue with me for whatever reason & is trying to push myself & my son out by manipulating her son into ‘mom & son time’. After ignoring him for a year. Mom & son time is a sugarcoated way of saying ‘I want to see you but I don’t want the extra baggage like your partner and child’. I’m glad someone can see it from my perspective.

OP posts:
TheSnowyOwl · 30/05/2023 11:07

You don’t sound as if you like her, so I would be pleased to not have to see her or spend time with her. Your views are either correct, so why would you want your son spending time with someone like that? Or they aren’t and she maybe she needs some support seeing her son and having time with just him. Either way, you and your son don’t need to worry about it and can leave her and your OH to meet up.

bluebeck · 30/05/2023 11:04

The fact MIL works away and is hardly ever there could have been mentioned upthread. Alongside the fact that she lived a few streets away maybe?

I would like to hear the other side of this. Clearly something has gone very wrong indeed.

Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:03

Coralsunset · 30/05/2023 06:42

There’s obviously more to this than meets the eye. As PP have said, why hasn’t DH called his mum?

Once you were together, have all meetings been with both of you? I adore my DIL but I still see DS on his own regularly and would hate it if I never got to see him alone.

Wait until DH has seen his mum and the back story should reveal itself.

again, he HAS called his mom, she doesn’t answer.

OP posts:
Grxcegrxxn · 30/05/2023 11:01

knittingaddict · 30/05/2023 09:09

You seem to be talking about all of you seeing your mil. I think what other people are saying is why doesn't he call or pop in to see his mum? That would be a normal thing to do. At least then you would have some contact, even if indirect, and some idea of what might be going on.

We live 2 hours away from my parents and I would see them on my own most of the time. They weren't the sort to issue invites to their house and certainly not to have bbqs or meals at theirs. If I waited till my husband was available we would have been waiting a very long time. Why isn't your partner being more proactive with HIS mum?

Again, dp has been contacting his mom on a regular basis BUT she never responds, she hasnt seen him, hasn’t spoke to him over the phone or over messages in over a year. & MIL is hardly ever home, she works away. So we can’t just ‘drop in’ whenever we feel like it, we have tried but she’s usually not in.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread