Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that “waiting until they ask” isn’t always the best approach to sex education.

57 replies

MyTruthIsOut · 29/05/2023 21:01

I have a son who is in Year 4 (9 years old) and we had a letter come home from the school last week to say that after the half term the curriculum will include puberty, menstruation and sex education.

My son has never asked me where babies come from, or how they are made, or how they get into mother’s tummy etc….he’s shown zero interest. I have on occasions over the last year or so tried to encourage gentle conversation to try and spark his imagination but he’s not been remotely interested.

He knows about periods as he sees me manage mine and he knows about breasts being for breastfeeding, but that’s the end of his knowledge. He’s simply never asked me about anything.

I know there is a general sense of not having “the talk” with children until they initiate it and start asking questions rather than force the discussion upon them, but I really don’t want my son to go back to school after half term and have this taught to him by his teacher when I would much rather teach him about it myself.

My sister thinks I will just embarrass him if I start talking to him about puberty, sex and pregnancy etc, but I don’t see how it will be any less embarrassing than having to talk about it at school with his teacher and in front of all his friends. I really don’t want him being the clueless one in the class when it comes to something so important.

My husband is on the fence as to how much I say I.e how much detail to go in to. I think he’d rather the teacher deal with it.

I’m really close to my son and we talk lots about many things and he’s always asking me questions about meaningful topics (except babies obviously) so I want to have these talks with him too.

I don’t want to just give him a book and send him off on his way and let the teacher have the ‘awkward’ discussions (as my sister described it).

How has everyone else dealt with this?

OP posts:
TellKingTutIWantMyMummy · 30/05/2023 08:10

There is no issue with correct terminology and whilst I agree with you educating your child as you see fit, children can’t comprehend what you’re saying the same way adults do and they mix up what they’re saying.

so your clear and scientific explanation of sex will become something different.

for example, my dd came home one day and said she knows what sex is and proudly proclaimed it was when a man and a woman put their privates together to make a baby.

another child in the same convo said it was when a man puts his penis in a vagina and moves it about a bit.

your son at that young age absolutely will cause all sorts of dramas. I don’t believe it’s age appropriate, you’ll gross him out and quite frankly, does he care for the nitty gritty?

there is a reason the educators in our world wait to teach this until later on, let’s assume they’re the experts here.

MyTruthIsOut · 30/05/2023 06:13

Thanks everyone for your tips and the sharing of your own experiences.

I’ve got to go into work this morning and then I’m going to do some work with him this afternoon once I’m back.

My aim is so start off slow and take his lead to see how the conversation unravels.

I’m a nurse so talking about bodies and their functions are quite normal to me so hopefully I will talk to him openly and matter-of-factly to make sure he doesn’t feel uncomfortable.

A previous poster said that parents need to be careful talking about this topic as other parents might not like it if adult information (as some may perceive it to be) spreads like wildfire throughout the classroom, but surely the fear of other people’s reactions can’t dictate how we educate our children at home?

We have always used correct terminology in our house so my son has always referred to his penis as a penis. However, at the start of his current academic year (Year 4) he came home from school one day and told me that he’d “hurt his wily” which surprised me as he’d never used that term before. I asked him why he’d used the word willy and he said that when he’d told his teacher, he had used the word penis and she’d told him that penis was a “grown up word” and it’s not okay to use it and said he should refer to it as a willy instead.

I was honestly gobsmacked!

I spoke to the teacher and explained that in our house we have always used correct terminology as I see no point in pretending otherwise….an arm is an arm, a leg is a leg and a penis is a penis etc and therefore I would appreciate it if she didn’t tell my son he can’t use the correct words for his body parts. It was a nice enough conversation as I really like his teacher but ultimately the outcome was that although she understood my point, she said that if other children started saying the word “penis” then there was a chance that other parents who felt it wasn’t age-appropriate would make complaints about the school, be it her specifically or the teaching environment.

It’s sad but I could definitely imagine it happening.

OP posts:
FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 29/05/2023 23:02

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 29/05/2023 22:40

The first question dd asked on the subject was "Lucy's mummy has a baby in her tummy but they don't want another baby so they're not going to keep it, how did it get in there if they didn't want it and what will they do with it?". In the car on the way home from Brownies. So that was fun.

Opted for "casually telling them little things every so often from an early age" with my younger two!

It's always the car, I use that if I have something important I need to talk about with DD now. I think because we're in close confines but can't actually look at each other it makes the car a 'safe place' to have discussions she would otherwise avoid.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 29/05/2023 22:59

DS did ask the questions, which I've always answered in what I felt was age appropriate for him.

He's 10 now, year 5. I'm thinking we need to stay talking to him about puberty. He's not having any of it. Will not talk about it, gets annoyed if I bring it up because it's boring (ie not Minecraft), won't have anything to do with books so getting a book would be pointless.

Not attending school atm and we're waiting for an assessment for ASD.

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 29/05/2023 22:40

The first question dd asked on the subject was "Lucy's mummy has a baby in her tummy but they don't want another baby so they're not going to keep it, how did it get in there if they didn't want it and what will they do with it?". In the car on the way home from Brownies. So that was fun.

Opted for "casually telling them little things every so often from an early age" with my younger two!

gogohmm · 29/05/2023 22:18

Mine were taught what they needed to know age appropriately in school then could ask questions at home. First sessions were science really, the emotional stuff came later when they were more mature. None of their friends knew anything either, teachers know his to teach this better than I.

TellKingTutIWantMyMummy · 29/05/2023 22:14

I feel it’s too soon. The other parents won’t thank you when little Timmy tells everyone all about sex. The actual sex part isn’t taught until year 6.

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 29/05/2023 22:13

SugarAndSpike · 29/05/2023 21:59

@CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt how does one make cushions into a vagina??!!

Well I tried glue dots, and then elastic bands, neither of which worked.

2 couch cushions squeezed into a pillow case and a bit of imagination did though 🤣

I'm sure there are easier ways to demonstrate the workings of a tampon, but it did the job and let them practise as much as they wanted.

SugarAndSpike · 29/05/2023 21:59

@CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt how does one make cushions into a vagina??!!

ContinuousProcrastination · 29/05/2023 21:57

Also as a pp said at y4 it will be really basic & focussed on reproduction & menstruation. When I was a girl only the girls were taken off separately to talk about periods, I hope boys are better informed about this now.

SugarAndSpike · 29/05/2023 21:54

Thank you for starting this thread op.

My dd is 4 and I haven't discussed much with her yet apart from 'A tiny seed goes into a tiny egg then it grows and grows in mummy's tummy to make a baby'. My own sex ed when I was a kid was very much left to the school... I don't think I ever talked about it with my parents, which may have led to some of my issues later on.

Excellent advice coming in on this thread. I think simple terms is good. I can't imagine that your ds's school is going to jump into the deep end having not mentioned anything much to the children yet. Surely it'll be simple terms at first too?

ContinuousProcrastination · 29/05/2023 21:54

It doesn't have to be all the details at once.

You can start with younger children talking about the seed coming from the man & the egg coming from the woman, then gradually bring in that the seed comes out of the penis/testes etc. If you talk about the different body parts first (eg that vagina leads to uterus where babies grow) its not a big leap to the mechanics if sexual intercourse in reproduction.

Sexual pleasure/orgasm is different & to me thats something you discuss a little later than the reproduction part, as imho you need more emotional maturity to consider it. It goes along a bit with puberty, self discovery, starting to feel some attraction to others yourself etc.

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 29/05/2023 21:52

I've never waited until asked.

I've just been giving age appropriate information since they have been about 4.

They have always known I'll answer anything they do ask, just because I've been so open about it, and they are very open about asking things, even if it takes me a second to get over the shock first I answer truthfully.

Over the years we have made cushions into vaginas to put tampons in, put condoms on cucumbers, had many discussions about various words they have heard. Discussed birth control, abortions, consent, pornography.... everything you can think of probably, we even did the freedom programme.

My sons and daughters have both had the same education so understand both sexes well too.

Imo it's really better to be proactive, what they don't hear from you they will hear misinformation about in the playground.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 29/05/2023 21:49

Whilst I totally understand yours and your husband’s concerns you are honestly overthinking this. I teach this module to this age group and we’ve had so much training on it. We teach the absolute basics of periods and how babies are created. We don’t discuss sex- just that males have sperm and women have eggs which together create a baby. Don’t worry about your child looking clueless or getting embarrassed; there’s such a range of prior knowledge and it should be a safe space where being embarrassed is fine, they soon get over it and learn what they need to. My kids knew the very basics before they were taught but my son still found it hilarious and awkward learning about it at school.

Weallgottachangesometime · 29/05/2023 21:47

When my daughter was little we watch a video of a baby being born on YouTube. Of course I checked first that it wasn’t horrific . It was nice for her to watch and actually see. I did choose a particularly nice calm water birth though.

Weallgottachangesometime · 29/05/2023 21:46

Personally I told mine about sex when they were really little, with the help of books so the wording was child appropriate and I had a guide to follow. I think giving the information very young, like before age 6ish is almost easier because they haven’t got the same level of embarrassment about it as when they get older.

Only issue with telling them young befor they’re embarrassed is they then come out with corkers like- “how long does it take for the seed to come out then” when you’re in the middle of shopping or something.

I would just get some books. Have the conversation with him, but also let him know the books are there if he wants to read them himself to find out more. There are some fab books out there. I’d got for some that use accurate language and are direct.

YerAWizardHarry · 29/05/2023 21:43

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 29/05/2023 21:32

My kids have always known where babies come from- I’m a midwife so this is discussed really matter of factly in my house. Don’t be awkward or embarrassed; bodies and sex are normal and natural. I read ‘it’s not the stork’ to mine when they were little, and we have a couple of children’s books on home birth with illustrations of babies being born. My DD2 (year 5) is currently having sex education; her teacher told me that some of the kids were crying in the class because they didn’t want to know about it, which I think is really sad and quite worrying. Kids shouldn’t be afraid to learn how their bodies work.

I had one in my class cry over a cartoon illustration of a vulva… she calmed down a bit though and said at the end she was “just a bit shocked”

YerAWizardHarry · 29/05/2023 21:41

I teach Primary 5 so roughly the same stage but in Scotland. I’d say that generally speaking 3/4 of my class are absolutely clueless (and actually a bit mortified!) by the whole thing. You can generally tell which children have older siblings though!

Wallywobbles · 29/05/2023 21:36

They did ask questions when they were really small. And I'm embarrassingly frank about it all. Teens know oh so much so they don't need to ask. Besides at your age you don't do it anymore.

DaisyWaldron · 29/05/2023 21:36

I think the "wait until they ask" thing is a bit strange, tbh. We don't wait until kids ask to tell them about dinosaurs, or planets or numbers or how digestion or volcanoes or rain or elephants or cooking works. We just wait until the moment they show the vaguest bit of interest in something vaguely related to the subject and then tell them some interesting things about it.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 29/05/2023 21:34

There's a boy version of the book too https://www.amazon.co.uk/Growing-Up-Boys-Everything-Need/dp/0702310972/ref=sr112sspa?crid=2H9Q6VXFM7CUS&keywords=growing+up+for+girls&qid=1685392205&sprefix=Growing%2Caps%2C124&sr=8-2-spons&sppcsd=d2lkZ2V0TmFtZT1zcF9hdGY&psc=1

If it's like the girls one then it will have a small section about the other sex so boys have a brief understanding of what happens to girls and vice versa. I liked this range because it's written by someone who is/was a school nurse so knows how to address things in an age appropriate way. It's simple and it's clear.

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 29/05/2023 21:32

My kids have always known where babies come from- I’m a midwife so this is discussed really matter of factly in my house. Don’t be awkward or embarrassed; bodies and sex are normal and natural. I read ‘it’s not the stork’ to mine when they were little, and we have a couple of children’s books on home birth with illustrations of babies being born. My DD2 (year 5) is currently having sex education; her teacher told me that some of the kids were crying in the class because they didn’t want to know about it, which I think is really sad and quite worrying. Kids shouldn’t be afraid to learn how their bodies work.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 29/05/2023 21:30

DD is in yr 4 and at the same point in PSHE as your son.

At the beginning of this school year I got her the book linked below, which she has read through several times and I've explained how babies are made in simple terms. She thinks the idea of periods and sex are revolting which I think is about right for her age but she has enough of a grasp of the concept to not be shocked in class.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Growing-Up-Girls-Everything-Need/dp/0702310964/ref=sr11_1?crid=2H9Q6VXFM7CUS&keywords=growing+up+for+girls&qid=1685392205&sprefix=Growing%2Caps%2C124&sr=8-1

megletthesecond · 29/05/2023 21:29

Yanbu. If I waited for my dc's to ask about anything they still wouldn't know much. (They're teens now).

I started letting them know how babies were made and born from reception year onwards. The same way they learnt about their bodies, the weather, animals etc.

username98765 · 29/05/2023 21:27

Tbh I'd have a conversation with him about it before returning to school. I only have dd's so it's different but I started these conversations from a very early age. My youngest started her period at 9 so thank goodness I had. I think it's good for them to know it's not embarrassing to talk about it at any age. I had a friend at school that even at the beginning of secondary school had no idea where babies came from as her parents never talked to her about it and they stopped her from going to any sex ed lessons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread