Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that “waiting until they ask” isn’t always the best approach to sex education.

57 replies

MyTruthIsOut · 29/05/2023 21:01

I have a son who is in Year 4 (9 years old) and we had a letter come home from the school last week to say that after the half term the curriculum will include puberty, menstruation and sex education.

My son has never asked me where babies come from, or how they are made, or how they get into mother’s tummy etc….he’s shown zero interest. I have on occasions over the last year or so tried to encourage gentle conversation to try and spark his imagination but he’s not been remotely interested.

He knows about periods as he sees me manage mine and he knows about breasts being for breastfeeding, but that’s the end of his knowledge. He’s simply never asked me about anything.

I know there is a general sense of not having “the talk” with children until they initiate it and start asking questions rather than force the discussion upon them, but I really don’t want my son to go back to school after half term and have this taught to him by his teacher when I would much rather teach him about it myself.

My sister thinks I will just embarrass him if I start talking to him about puberty, sex and pregnancy etc, but I don’t see how it will be any less embarrassing than having to talk about it at school with his teacher and in front of all his friends. I really don’t want him being the clueless one in the class when it comes to something so important.

My husband is on the fence as to how much I say I.e how much detail to go in to. I think he’d rather the teacher deal with it.

I’m really close to my son and we talk lots about many things and he’s always asking me questions about meaningful topics (except babies obviously) so I want to have these talks with him too.

I don’t want to just give him a book and send him off on his way and let the teacher have the ‘awkward’ discussions (as my sister described it).

How has everyone else dealt with this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pointythings · 31/05/2023 11:52

I think @MyTruthIsOut has put it very well, and using the scientific terminology takes the ick factor out of it. I agree matters of sexual pleasure are for an older age group.

MyTruthIsOut · 31/05/2023 11:25

Harringtonperle · 31/05/2023 11:16

Boys need to know about periods as it affects daily life and periods will be happening at school. Wet dreams will not (I hope!) be happening at school. Periods are key to human biology. Erections are as well, I agree, but wet dreams definitely are not. There is no relevance to my daughter if a boy in her class has had an orgasm in his sleep

Take the word orgasm out the equation and just refer to it as ejaculation.

Ejaculating is science based and so is easier to talk about.

The word “Orgasm” is associated with sexual pleasure which children do not need to know about at this age. Yes they need to know that sex feels nice and it’s normal for two adults to do have sex, but they do not need to understand about orgasms and climaxing at 9 years of age.

OP posts:
MyTruthIsOut · 31/05/2023 11:21

Harringtonperle · 31/05/2023 11:04

Thank you everyone, and apologies to the OP for hijacking the thread. Respectfully, @pointythings I get what you are saying but maybe they should just teach about wet dreams to boys, my child is a girl and and teaching her about wet dreams is 100% unnecessary and will probably be quite confusing

You haven’t hijacked the thread 👍

I suppose it gets difficult though if you only teach the girls about what happens to them and only teach the boys what happens to them because I think it’s important both sexes are aware of what happens to the other. Plus, just as things spread around the classroom, it might confuse a boy if they hear girls talking about periods and ovaries etc and have absolutely no clue what they’re talking about.

And when things aren’t taught equally that’s when mis-information is spread from one sex group to another.

At least if they are all being taught the same topics they are all receiving the same education and information.

For example, my son’s school will be discussing menstruation in the school and they will also be discussing sanitary products. I will teach my son about this before he goes back to school, but I do think boys should be taught about this as part of widening their knowledge and hopefully having more empathy towards girls who start their periods and the stress that comes along with managing it.

I hate the term “wet dream” and I think that’s what make the idea of discussing it seem really inappropriate, but ultimately it’s just the penis ejaculating sperm. It’s no different to when the penis ejaculates sperm during sex.

I will explain to my son that there is one type of ejaculation that happens consciously as a man (when he is awake and having sex) and another type of ejaculation that happens to boys when they are asleep.

I will liken it to bed-wetting in the sense that it is something natural that just occurs during sleep. For example, as the child grows up their bladder is learning how to contain wee during the night, just as the penis is learning how to contain the sperm. And just like how children grow out of weeing during their sleep once the bladder has learned how to function, boys will also grow out of ejaculating whilst they’re asleep once their penis has learned how to function as a man’s penis instead of a boy’s penis.

Okay, it’s not factually correct but I think it will make it easy to explain and easier for my son to understand the concept.

OP posts:
Harringtonperle · 31/05/2023 11:16

Boys need to know about periods as it affects daily life and periods will be happening at school. Wet dreams will not (I hope!) be happening at school. Periods are key to human biology. Erections are as well, I agree, but wet dreams definitely are not. There is no relevance to my daughter if a boy in her class has had an orgasm in his sleep

pointythings · 31/05/2023 11:11

@Harringtonperle I don't believe in segregating these things. We're never going to understand each other if we can't even talk about the basics of biology. Boys need to learn about periods. Girls need to learn about erections. No taboos are required. The British prudery about sex helps nobody.

And yes, one of mine is a girl.

Harringtonperle · 31/05/2023 11:04

Thank you everyone, and apologies to the OP for hijacking the thread. Respectfully, @pointythings I get what you are saying but maybe they should just teach about wet dreams to boys, my child is a girl and and teaching her about wet dreams is 100% unnecessary and will probably be quite confusing

MyTruthIsOut · 31/05/2023 07:41

pointythings · 31/05/2023 07:33

@Livinginanotherworld sadly it's all too likely that at 10, some boys will already have been exposed to porn. Talking about it when they are still young is going to be the best way to instil realistic ideas around sex, relationships and body image.

A wet dream involves orgasm. Mentioning that it is normal to experience pleasant sensations will take the fear out of it. Also there is nothing wrong with saying that having sex should be pleasant for both people involved.

Sad but true. My son plays football after school on a local court with boys of all ages ranging from 5 up to 12. It’s just an informal kick-about but they all have great fun.

There’s one lad there who is in my sons year (aged 9/10ish) who has a mobile phone and quite frequently he gets it out and shows the screen to some
of the other boys and says, “Come and look at what this woman is doing, she’s well fit!” and the way the other children respond shows it’s something that visually
makes them uncomfortable. They tend to look at the screen and then instantly back away.

I did speak to the teacher who spoke to the parent, but ultimately as I don’t actually see what images/videos the boy is sharing they can’t act on just my assumptions.

So yes, porn absolutely is flying around at this age and I plan to talk to my son about it over the coming weeks as we
continue to build on what I’m already teaching him. It’s horrifying to think we have to talk about this to our pre-teens but sadly it’s a necessity.

OP posts:
pointythings · 31/05/2023 07:33

@Livinginanotherworld sadly it's all too likely that at 10, some boys will already have been exposed to porn. Talking about it when they are still young is going to be the best way to instil realistic ideas around sex, relationships and body image.

A wet dream involves orgasm. Mentioning that it is normal to experience pleasant sensations will take the fear out of it. Also there is nothing wrong with saying that having sex should be pleasant for both people involved.

titchy · 30/05/2023 22:10

I don't think anyone has suggested teaching a 9 year old about orgasms and porn.

Though as, what half, of all year 6 have seen porn a conversation with a 9 year old sadly is probably a sensible course of action.

Livinginanotherworld · 30/05/2023 22:01

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:53

@Livinginanotherworld ah, the 'protect their innocence' argument... 🙄

Knowing these things protects children. It gives them the vocabulary to report it if someone touches them in a way that is sexually predatory. It gives them the vocabulary to talk about what is happening to their bodies - see my comment above about wet dreams in 10 year olds (it happens). It is not at all unusual for girls of 9 to start their periods either - would you rather they were 'innocent' (and terrified) when that happened to them?

There's a reason why countries which start sex education early and in an age appropriate way have lower rates of teenage pregnancy, lower abortion rates and a higher age of first intercourse. Knowledge is power.

The innocence I was talking about was a 9 year child knowing about orgasms and pornography, not about the mechanics of periods and reproduction, imo it’s too much too soon.

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:53

@Livinginanotherworld ah, the 'protect their innocence' argument... 🙄

Knowing these things protects children. It gives them the vocabulary to report it if someone touches them in a way that is sexually predatory. It gives them the vocabulary to talk about what is happening to their bodies - see my comment above about wet dreams in 10 year olds (it happens). It is not at all unusual for girls of 9 to start their periods either - would you rather they were 'innocent' (and terrified) when that happened to them?

There's a reason why countries which start sex education early and in an age appropriate way have lower rates of teenage pregnancy, lower abortion rates and a higher age of first intercourse. Knowledge is power.

Livinginanotherworld · 30/05/2023 21:35

Divorcedalongtime · 29/05/2023 21:05

I would start asap. I started when mine were tiny (nothing explicit of course) and I’ve kept it up relentlessly.
it’s super important to get these messages across.
very important to get boys to understand how much porn and sex in general is aimed at them and how girls do not generally orgasm from penetration.

read the books boys and sex and girls and sex , much more information in those.

Do they really need to know this at 9 years old ?? Protect their innocence for heavens sake.

pointythings · 30/05/2023 21:32

@Harringtonperle all the things you mention may be happening to your 10yo at any time. Can you imagine how scary it could be if you wake up having had a wet dream but don't know what it is?

Melroses · 30/05/2023 17:43

If you give them good solid basics like OP, then everything else follows on and nothing is a surprise.

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 30/05/2023 17:29

Harringtonperle · 30/05/2023 17:08

Help! I'm in a similar boat with DD Y5. In the letter, it says they will be hearing the words ejaculation, erection, wet dreams and intercourse. I am a bit horrified, I don't see why a 10 year old needs to know about this? I guess they learn about sex in Y5 rather than 6. Wet dreams are about sexual pleasure, which IMO has no place around 9/10 year olds. Can someone talk me down? I'm gonna have to have a mortifying conversation with her before the end of half term 😨

Wet dreams are totally normal, and will be happening to some kids from around the age of 10.

It's important these kids know what's happening with their bodies, and why.

It's not mortifying to teach your kid about sex, it's one of the basics of parenting.

Op has given some really good, constructive updates on how to go about the conversations. Your dd will take her cues from you, if you're mortified and embarrassed she will be too, and you won't have an open line of communication with you, which is essential as they grow up.

MyTruthIsOut · 30/05/2023 17:20

Harringtonperle · 30/05/2023 17:08

Help! I'm in a similar boat with DD Y5. In the letter, it says they will be hearing the words ejaculation, erection, wet dreams and intercourse. I am a bit horrified, I don't see why a 10 year old needs to know about this? I guess they learn about sex in Y5 rather than 6. Wet dreams are about sexual pleasure, which IMO has no place around 9/10 year olds. Can someone talk me down? I'm gonna have to have a mortifying conversation with her before the end of half term 😨

When I was talking with my son I didn’t use the word pleasure but I did put the message across that as well ad
making babies sex also feels nice.

I explained that as humans, most of us do things because we enjoy doing them, I.e we seek a personal gratification from an act. Also, my son loves having his back stroked and I said that in the same way that sensation feels nice to a child, the sensation of sex feels nice for adults.

I said that evolution makes sex enjoyable otherwise people wouldn’t do it, and if people didn’t do it then there would be no babies and so the human race would end.

In terms of wet dreams, I wouldn’t go down the route of pleasure as technically the child is asleep when it’s happening, it’s not like they’re masturbating and causing it to happen. Just say that it happens subconsciously and is as natural as yawning, or sneezing (things you have no control over), and that it’s just part of the process of the body changing from being a boys body to a man’s body. I would say that the penis is just learning how to behave like a man’s penis (i.e in order to make babies) as opposed to it just being used for weeing out of.

OP posts:
Harringtonperle · 30/05/2023 17:08

Help! I'm in a similar boat with DD Y5. In the letter, it says they will be hearing the words ejaculation, erection, wet dreams and intercourse. I am a bit horrified, I don't see why a 10 year old needs to know about this? I guess they learn about sex in Y5 rather than 6. Wet dreams are about sexual pleasure, which IMO has no place around 9/10 year olds. Can someone talk me down? I'm gonna have to have a mortifying conversation with her before the end of half term 😨

pointythings · 30/05/2023 16:52

Absolutely fantastic work, OP. This world needs more parents like you.

MyTruthIsOut · 30/05/2023 15:20

Well we just finished the first leg of his learning and it went really well.

I gave him a proper teaching session with hand drawn pictures with labels and everything as we are both visual learners. My son can take in and understand information much easier if he’s got something to look at that matches the words he’s hearing.

He was initially a bit reluctant to get onto the topic and seemed a little bit embarrassed but then his mindset completely changed and he absorbed everything I was saying and wouldn’t stop asking me lots of questions. One question lead to another and another and I kept it factual, informative and delivered my answers at a level that matches my son’s maturity and his ability to understand more complex topics.

We covered:

  1. The typical ages that children go through puberty and how long it lasts
  2. Testosterone and Oestrogen. The outward bodily changes that occur as boys/girls change into men/women.
  3. Changes that occur within the body that are part of puberty (production of breast tissue and egg and sperm production).
  4. The womb, vagina, ovaries and cervix.
  5. The cycle of menstruation.
  6. What Sex is (ie the man puts his erect penis into the woman’s vagina to release the sperm).
  7. How the egg is fertilised.
  8. The 9 month process of pregnancy (some gentle talk about miscarriage too as he saw me go through one).
  9. The process of labour (vaginal and c/s).

Obviously I didn’t use a lot of those actual terms and kept it quite simplistic but at least now I know he has a good base knowledge that we can continue to build on as he gets older. Some of the words I used he said he’d heard them before at school but that he didn’t know what it meant (vagina was one example he gave) so it shows that the children are talking about this between themselves so I’m now really glad I’ve given him well rounded and factual information as opposed to him just listening to the Chinese whispers that get passed around the classroom.

He was absolutely brilliant and by the end of it he wasn’t embarrassed at all. He was so interested and engaged and I was amazed at how simple it was to talk to him about it. He was so grown up about it all.

I told him that we had other things we would need to talk about over the coming days but that I was very proud of how well he’d listened and I said that he could ask me anything about sex and/or making babies whenever he wanted to.

Thanks for all your previous ideas tips…I especially like the one about letting him watch some videos. When I was trying to get pregnant I watched some really lovey videos about how fertilisation occurs and how the egg turns into a baby and I think he’d really like watching that. I also like the idea of showing him a video of a water birth as they are generally really nice and peaceful to watch.

So I’m glad the initial conversation was had and I’m really happy with how comfortable it was and how interested he became.

Now it’s just a case of waiting for the ongoing inquisitive questions to begin 😂

OP posts:
Allrightmylover · 30/05/2023 09:31

It should be age appropriate obviously but informing children helps protect them from sexual abuse. Many times children who are abused have no idea what is happening to them, just that it hurts and they feel bad. My best mate was a psychologist and she told me this when my child was just a baby. She also said to reinforce it should be because people love and care about each other so no pressure on either side.

lemonaddde · 30/05/2023 09:03

My daughter starting asking questions around age 7/8 and I was honest in an age appropriate way, always using the correct terminology.

I bought her a book when she turned 9 that was focused on periods/hormones/puberty/body changes but did lightly touch on sex and how babies are made. I told her she could read it at her own pace and always feel able to ask me questions.

If she'd got to age 9/year 4 and hadn't mentioned it to me at-all I would definitely be having a conversation about what to expect in PSHE and warn her of the type of content to expect.

Shrouding it in secrecy isn't the answer, especially in this day and age where there is so much available online and we can't control everything they access.

TellKingTutIWantMyMummy · 30/05/2023 08:53

They’re y4. Actual sex act discussions don’t happen until y6.

Divorcedalongtime · 30/05/2023 08:39

TellKingTutIWantMyMummy · 30/05/2023 08:10

There is no issue with correct terminology and whilst I agree with you educating your child as you see fit, children can’t comprehend what you’re saying the same way adults do and they mix up what they’re saying.

so your clear and scientific explanation of sex will become something different.

for example, my dd came home one day and said she knows what sex is and proudly proclaimed it was when a man and a woman put their privates together to make a baby.

another child in the same convo said it was when a man puts his penis in a vagina and moves it about a bit.

your son at that young age absolutely will cause all sorts of dramas. I don’t believe it’s age appropriate, you’ll gross him out and quite frankly, does he care for the nitty gritty?

there is a reason the educators in our world wait to teach this until later on, let’s assume they’re the experts here.

OMG the child is 9, not 3.

33goingon64 · 30/05/2023 08:38

Both my DS asked when they were 3/4 so I told them about eggs from the mum and seeds from the dad joining in the mum's tummy. They were happy with that. Then they asked around 5/6 what their bits were for and what did girls have, so I told them the correct terms and that they'd need theirs for making a baby. That's all DS 7 knows now. DS 12 knew the whole thing at around year 4, same as your son. You don't have to tell DC everything at once.

ZillionDayStreak · 30/05/2023 08:35

I would ignore the whole “what about other parents” thing. That’s something school
has to deal with, and I appreciate it’s tricky. But it shouldn’t stop you making a judgement about what is right for your child, and doing that.

I feel the same way about basic biology as I do about Father Christmas. If other parents want to lie to their child or refrain from telling them things, that’s their decision. It’s not my job to maintain that lie, and avoid bursting their DC’s bubble.

I’m not going to do it deliberately, as that would be rude and unnecessary. And I’ll ask my DC to not share information and explain why. But I won’t let their parenting approach change mine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread