Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Same parents, different surnames: has anyone done this?

84 replies

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:01

My DH has a very English but unusual surname, and I have a non-English surname which I never contemplated changing. When DC were born, we gave them all his surname, but they all have my surname on their birth certificates as a middle name (so, think, "Tomkinson, Anna Paulette Jourdain" - not the real name, but like that).

My DD2 announced today that it's very "old-fashioned" that they should all have DH's surname rather than mine. I said it had never really occurred to me to do it differently! She thinks at least one of them should have my surname "to make it fair" and because "it's not very good for women's equality to just ignore your surname, you know?"

Further to this, she informed me this evening that she has "done research" and apparently Harriet Harman's daughter has her surname, while her two sons have her husband's. This, apparently, proves that it is normal. However, she accepts that daddy might feel a bit upset if she and DD1 both take my surname, so she's happy to be the only one with mine!

I actually knew about Harriet Harman's children, but I've never come across anyone personally who mixed up surnames for their kids. In principal, I think it is totally reasonable! In practicality, would it not be really confusing?

YABU - it's weird and confusing
YANBU - it's a nice idea and who cares if it's confusing?

DD2 is 9. I have no idea how she knows who Harriet Harman is.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/05/2023 20:14

I wonder why somebody would choose for the male children to have their father's surname, but not the female ones?

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:14

She turns 10 in August, right before the start of the school year. I'd be inclined to say she can decide then, just because it'd be so neat and tidy (just in time for Y6!).

DH doesn't have any particular attachment to his surname, which is actually FiL's stepfather's surname anyway. Apparently FiL stepfather was a bigoted, xenophobic, racist git, so I don't think anyone feels strongly about his great-grandchildren carrying his name!

OP posts:
treesareyellow · 29/05/2023 20:12

It makes total sense to do that!

JaninaDuszejko · 29/05/2023 20:12

Friends of ours have a DD with her Mum's surname and DSs with their Dad's surname. Everyone seems to cope with them being one family.

Wish we'd done it with the DC TBH but didn't think of it till they were older.

ValBiro · 29/05/2023 20:09

We have done the same as @SlipperyLizard and yeah... It probably is confusing for people that don't know us well. Their opinion doesn't bother me but if they were to ask out of curiosity it wouldn't make me feel uncomfortable or annoyed either. Like... I wouldn't feel like I needed to defend our decision.

MyUsernameIsBetterThanYours · 29/05/2023 20:08

Well firstly congratulations on raising an awesome, independent minded, feminist 9 year old! She sounds fabulous.

I think if she genuinely wants to do it, why not? 9 is young though so you might want to get her to wait a little so she can be sure about her decision before she goes through with it. Maybe say that you’d support her with it in six months if she’s still keen then.

TakeMe2Insanity · 29/05/2023 20:08

My friend did this as an adult.

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:06

I think that's actually very smart! It just never occurred to us at the time. I have two DDs (11 and 9) and a DS (7).

OP posts:
SlipperyLizard · 29/05/2023 20:03

DH and I agreed that girls would have my name, boys would have his. We have two DDs, both with my surname & DH’s as a second middle name.