Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Same parents, different surnames: has anyone done this?

84 replies

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:01

My DH has a very English but unusual surname, and I have a non-English surname which I never contemplated changing. When DC were born, we gave them all his surname, but they all have my surname on their birth certificates as a middle name (so, think, "Tomkinson, Anna Paulette Jourdain" - not the real name, but like that).

My DD2 announced today that it's very "old-fashioned" that they should all have DH's surname rather than mine. I said it had never really occurred to me to do it differently! She thinks at least one of them should have my surname "to make it fair" and because "it's not very good for women's equality to just ignore your surname, you know?"

Further to this, she informed me this evening that she has "done research" and apparently Harriet Harman's daughter has her surname, while her two sons have her husband's. This, apparently, proves that it is normal. However, she accepts that daddy might feel a bit upset if she and DD1 both take my surname, so she's happy to be the only one with mine!

I actually knew about Harriet Harman's children, but I've never come across anyone personally who mixed up surnames for their kids. In principal, I think it is totally reasonable! In practicality, would it not be really confusing?

YABU - it's weird and confusing
YANBU - it's a nice idea and who cares if it's confusing?

DD2 is 9. I have no idea how she knows who Harriet Harman is.

OP posts:
WimpoleHat · 29/05/2023 21:00

And yet millions of women change their surnames every year and appear to live peacefully ever after.

I changed my name when I got married. Made an actual appointment at the bank and they changed it on the system for me while I was there. Marvellous. Except the chap who did it somehow didn’t quite do it and I had all sorts of problems and (back in the day) had to carry my passport and my marriage certificate in my bag for 9 months to be able to write a cheque (as yes, that’s how long they took to sort of out). And that was for something run of the mill! I can easily foresee some major administrative cock up with what the OP is suggesting.

Reugny · 29/05/2023 20:56

EggInANest · 29/05/2023 20:50

I can't imagine you'd ever experience one moments peace again if you tried to change your daughter's name on a whim like this.

And yet millions of women change their surnames every year and appear to live peacefully ever after.

There are more people around than lots of people realise who don't use their birth name and have officially changed it.

It really isn't a big deal.

Reugny · 29/05/2023 20:52

We just gave our kids both our names, because we're both the parents. It seemed logical.

I wasn't bothered until I realised my DP's name was as common as muck so then she got given both our names. My DP insisted on the hyphen though even due to my name root it isn't needed, simply because some UK systems still don't recognise a last name can consist of more than one name.

Speaking to a few parents who gave their kids only their father's common as muck name they wished they had done the same.

EggInANest · 29/05/2023 20:50

I can't imagine you'd ever experience one moments peace again if you tried to change your daughter's name on a whim like this.

And yet millions of women change their surnames every year and appear to live peacefully ever after.

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:42

Rumplestrumpet · 29/05/2023 20:39

We just gave our kids both our names, because we're both the parents. It seemed logical.

I will, however, suggest that my daughter passes on my name amd that my son passes on his dad's, to avoid quadrouple-barelled names for the next generation.

My cousin gave her kids only her (and my) name as she didn't like double barrel. I think people no longer just assume a kid will have only the fathers surname

We did consider the double-barrelled approach, but the names just sounded weird put together. Neither of us were particular fans.

OP posts:
mellicauli · 29/05/2023 20:41

I would ask her if Harriet Harman's name was so blimmin' equal then why is she not called Harriet Harwoman?

Honestly, I really don't know why you even entertaining wasting your time doing this. I made a 1 digit mistake in a child's birthday applying for a passport and I was thrown into 3 months of Kafka's Bureaucratic Nightmares. Another time autofill gave my son my surname and I didn't notice. We've never been able to change his Google schools log in. It's just too much for the system to cope with.

I can't imagine you'd ever experience one moments peace again if you tried to change your daughter's name on a whim like this.

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:40

Just realised I mis-spelled "in principle" in my OP. Ugh! I never do that. Apologies... I'm going to blame autocorrect, or my tenuous grasp of homophones as a non-native speaker 😂

OP posts:
FirstFallopians · 29/05/2023 20:39

I love the idea.

One, very depressing, thing to point out is that a lot of people will assume that they don’t have the same parents. Whether that bothers you as a family is very personal, but it’s worth consideration.

Rumplestrumpet · 29/05/2023 20:39

We just gave our kids both our names, because we're both the parents. It seemed logical.

I will, however, suggest that my daughter passes on my name amd that my son passes on his dad's, to avoid quadrouple-barelled names for the next generation.

My cousin gave her kids only her (and my) name as she didn't like double barrel. I think people no longer just assume a kid will have only the fathers surname

Ponderingwindow · 29/05/2023 20:35

This was our intention, but we only ended up having 1 child for assorted reasons. Girls were going to get my surname, and boys his. Though if we had a second, I suspect we might have done it as the first child’s surname is decided by girl or boy and then we alternate.

just giving our children his surname was never on the table. We were married before conception and this was discussed ahead of time. Our names are equally important.

wp65 · 29/05/2023 20:34

Just to add, if we have another, that kid will
probably have my surname too, for ease. But we're unlikely to have a second child.

wp65 · 29/05/2023 20:33

My daughter has my surname, not my husband's. I felt it was so patriarchal and lame that kids are automatically given the father's surname. So I raised it with my husband, he was chill about it, and she has my surname.

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:31

Emeraldrings · 29/05/2023 20:26

My DDs have my surname, mainly because I got pregnant very early on in my relationship with DH and obviously didn't know if it would last. Gave DD2 my surname just as it was easier. DS has husbands surname as we were married by then and he really wanted DS to have his name.
It hasn't really caused a problem but 12 year ago gap between DD2 and DS so not as if they will ever be at school together or anything.
People at work are always intrigued by me having a different name to DS though.

It makes total sense with a big age gap.

I'm always actually a teeny bit surprised by the number of women who take their husband's surname. I can't imagine doing it; I'd feel as though I was pretending to be a different person or something!

OP posts:
Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:29

Interesting that so many have done it!

I do reckon a bit of the motivation is that DD2 thinks my name is more "exotic". With her and DD1, they're only 13 months apart in age and don't look alike at all, so people often assume they're blended family. I can imagine that this might only add to that (but really, who cares?).

OP posts:
Emeraldrings · 29/05/2023 20:26

My DDs have my surname, mainly because I got pregnant very early on in my relationship with DH and obviously didn't know if it would last. Gave DD2 my surname just as it was easier. DS has husbands surname as we were married by then and he really wanted DS to have his name.
It hasn't really caused a problem but 12 year ago gap between DD2 and DS so not as if they will ever be at school together or anything.
People at work are always intrigued by me having a different name to DS though.

ecuse · 29/05/2023 20:21

We made a deal before kids that any daughters would take my surname and any sons would take his. We are married but I haven't changed my name. I believe this to be the perfect solution to the dilemma!

First DC was a girl; she therefore has my surname but my DH's surname as a middle name. So she has both names technically and for passports etc if either of us were to travel alone with them, but day-to-day she just goes by my surname.

Then we had a second DC, also a girl, so per our "deal" should have done the same, but by then I was determined that we would not be having any more than 2 kids! DH wasn't too fussed and happy to stick to the deal but other than him and his brother (who for various reasons is unlikely to have kids) they are only males of his generation - all the other cousins are female and married and changed names. PILs wouldn't have made a fuss but I know it made them sad that their surname would "die out" this generation. So we ended up giving DD2 her dad's surname (with mine as middle name). Which means my two girls have different surnames to one another.

As far as I know it doesn't cause anyone any great confusion at school or wherever. I assume if anyone thinks about it at all they may wonder whether we're a blended family but I don't expect anyone spends much time thinking about it.

The girls so far don't seem too arsed about it! (Tweenaged now).

EggInANest · 29/05/2023 20:21

Maybe she could simply swap the order of the two surnames?

I don’t think it is fair to guilt trip her about ‘upsetting Daddy’ (let alone the ILs as in another PP’s suggestion): the whole point of the patriarchy-by-default option is that woman are never suppose to be upset about children not having their name. Hopefully your DH is open minded and inclined to support your DD’s independent thinking.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 29/05/2023 20:19

Some countries don’t actually allow it. I know the Netherlands require all children with the same parents to have the same surname. No idea how many other countries have such a rule, I know the uk doesn’t.

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:19

JaninaDuszejko · 29/05/2023 20:17

How would you DH's family feel about it? When we spoke to our DCs about our friend's areangement we all agreed it was a great idea but probably too late to change it without upsetting DH's parents. On the other hand it would stop my nephews telling my DC they weren't real 'Duszejko's 🙄

I don't think they'd care - it's a surname which was basically forced on FiL aged 14 or so and I don't think anyone is particularly attached to it.

OP posts:
varsitychic · 29/05/2023 20:17

We have merged our surnames, so DH, DC and I all have the same surname but it's a merger of mine and DH's original surnames.

Jourdain11 · 29/05/2023 20:17

I guess it's just the easiest way to pick the surname for the child!

I wouldn't care about people thinking it was odd, as long as they don't think that DD has changed it because she hates her father or anything.

OP posts:
JaninaDuszejko · 29/05/2023 20:17

How would you DH's family feel about it? When we spoke to our DCs about our friend's areangement we all agreed it was a great idea but probably too late to change it without upsetting DH's parents. On the other hand it would stop my nephews telling my DC they weren't real 'Duszejko's 🙄

PriamFarrl · 29/05/2023 20:17

We got married in the Czech Republic. We were asked at the time if I was going to take DH’s name but also if boys would have his name and girls mine, or both his, or both mine!

holidaylistmania · 29/05/2023 20:16

We did this for ours. Girls have my name boys have his name. It doesn't really come up in real life, some family members were surprised and commented at the time. We just smiled and ignored basically .

Isthisexpected · 29/05/2023 20:15

Our children have my surname because I was the one carrying them. My husband was happy with that argument!