Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What's the one single thing a government could do to make your life better?

309 replies

verdantverdure · 29/05/2023 15:14

Mine?

Rejoin the EU.

It the single most powerful lever any government could employ.

It makes the country significantly better off at a stroke and improves all kinds of situations, growth, investment, labour shortages, farming, fishing...

What's yours?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
verdantverdure · 13/06/2023 11:59

I keep meaning to look into it @mellongoose.

OP posts:
mellongoose · 02/06/2023 07:11

verdantverdure · 29/05/2023 21:48

*They are all being passed as separate bills. So not cancelled.

If it had been kept as one bill opposition parties were going to turn it into a political protest over hunting.*

How @mellongoose?

Multiple private members bills for each single issue. All accepted by government.

I think something to do with how hunting hounds are kept was going to spark amendments on the entire hunting row. But I might be wrong about this bit.

Robyn847 · 01/06/2023 22:19

Ahh. I've realised you said what's the one single thing. Pizzas in spoons it is then.

Robyn847 · 01/06/2023 22:18

Stop this MPs "expenses" shenanigans. They have their own home where they live in their constituency. If they need to go to London for government matters they stay in a purpose built halls-of-residence type place, with office space for working, and a simple bedroom and lounge. They get paid one salary they have to live off and petrol money for driving to and from their constituency.

NHS, Teachers, Police, Carer home staff, etc paid enough to attract and retain workforce at capacity.

Tenner paid upfront for each NHS appointment. If you turn up for your appointment you get your tenner back. If you turn up but you're rude to other Patients or Staff you forfeit your tenner. If you don't follow medical advice given you forfeit your tenner. If you don't turn up you forfeit your tenner.

Shop assistants and DJs banned from using "tannoy voice" when talking over the speakers and must speak in their normal voice.

All public spaces/kids soft play/shops/pubs etc etc have a Goverment employed sniper. If there's anyone too loud/obnoxious/not controlling their kids/being a general arse then you can text a certain phone number with a code for your location (like Pay and display parking by text) and is there's enough complaints about any one person the Sniper gets the nod to take them out.

This weather we're having now but all year round.

Free pizzas in Wetherspoons on a Friday.

Room102 · 01/06/2023 20:06

Yes, that's true, that was what was asked. I guess I just think it makes no sense really out of context of the bigger picture and how it will all be funded or any type of long-term plan.

Ahhahaaa yes, like when the "Minister for Brexit" couldn't come up with a single benefit about it. But again, not remotely a surprise, it was completely obvious it was an absurd idea from the very start.

verdantverdure · 01/06/2023 14:17

It is disappointing to see a thread like this - and so many others so not an attack on you OP! I mean the responses more tbh - with so many demands but nobody thinking about any type of coherent plan in terms of "how would you actually achieve this? How will it be paid for?"

To be fair @Room102 I asked people what a government could do to improve their lives, not how to pay for it.

I agree with you on the long term planning front. There needs to be little jam today though otherwise it's just nonsensical to current voters.

(Like when Tory politicians say we'll see the benefit from Brexit in 50 years, when most of us will be dead.)

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 01/06/2023 14:11

kangaroopelicanartic · 31/05/2023 20:18

Why Leeds or Manchester? Why not Newcastle or Sunderland?

Or Sheffield?

OP posts:
Room102 · 31/05/2023 22:35

I totally agree @Room102 The UK has some phenomenally capable, if not world class people in these fields, and yet our brand of doing politics is so toxic, they don’t want to stand for election or even join a political party. I have felt so desperate about all of these issues - energy security, food security, disabled rights, business strategy, I considered it, but as an ethnic minority female heading towards retirement, I’m not sure I have the energy to deal with the truth twisters. There are some good politicians in the mix, but how they keep themselves going is anyone’s guess.

Depressing, isn't it @CheeseTouch ?

Everybody with integrity who would be capable wouldn't touch it with a bargepole. Why would those successful in their careers already give up their privacy and subject themselves and their families to abuse and danger, and give up permanent well-paid careers for the potential for a lower paid, short-term contract? And deal with that toxic work environment. It's not going to happen, so only the dregs go into politics. Either they are independently wealthy but rather dim people on a power trip or trying to use it as a stepping stone to other work, or they are people with none of the real skills and expertise we need because we won't pay enough to get them (I'd cut the number of MPs to 1/3 and triple their salaries, most are pointless windbags anyway).

I don't blame you though for not wanting to do it. Nobody who would do a decent job of it wants to do it. It is one of the sadnesses of democracy that pretty much anybody who puts themselves forward will be exactly the wrong people, and should be automatically disqualified simply for doing so. 😆

kangaroopelicanartic · 31/05/2023 20:18

Why Leeds or Manchester? Why not Newcastle or Sunderland?

TheWernethWife · 31/05/2023 18:31

Use the River Trent as a natural border and give us northeners our own parliament, either base it in Leeds or Manchester.

breadwidow · 31/05/2023 17:58

LlynTegid · 31/05/2023 13:56

Keep British Summer Time all year round. We could make much more use of afternoon daylight than in the morning.

Ah forgot this one too, though I'd go one louder and move us to Central European Time, so we are one hr ahead of current time. Still have daylight saving so even lighter evenings in summer, but also more light winter afternoons. Does mean Darker mornings but proven to benefit most (will likely reduce traffic collisions plus encourages more people to exercise. There was a pretty big campaign for the change about 10 years ago (www.wearepossible.org/lighter-later) but since bigger problems like Brexit and COVID have eclipsed it. I hope one day we can pay attention to it again

CheeseTouch · 31/05/2023 15:58

Room102 · 31/05/2023 13:57

Let alone the second industrial revolution that is coming our way and will make many jobs obsolete. Is the education and social system being reformed to manage this? Of course not.

I'm afraid that there is nobody in the HOC remotely capable of doing the job properly. None of the key issues that should be their top priorities feature much in any of their interviews, it's all slogans and nonsense. Infantilising and facile.

I totally agree @Room102 The UK has some phenomenally capable, if not world class people in these fields, and yet our brand of doing politics is so toxic, they don’t want to stand for election or even join a political party. I have felt so desperate about all of these issues - energy security, food security, disabled rights, business strategy, I considered it, but as an ethnic minority female heading towards retirement, I’m not sure I have the energy to deal with the truth twisters. There are some good politicians in the mix, but how they keep themselves going is anyone’s guess.

Room102 · 31/05/2023 14:59

The same as salaries increased far above inflation sustainably in previous times of technological development, they can again. Nobody should underestimate the technological changes that are coming very fast in the next two decades, on a scale not seen before. I've been telling people this would come in 2030-2050 since the 1990s but people don't seem to understand the scale. And we can capitalise on that and reimagine our social structures and systems but ONLY if resources are directed to the right areas now to increase productivity with infrastructure and research support, get water/ food/ energy security in place and make HUGE investments now in reforming education. A tripling of funding per head for primary/ secondary schools and far more focus on technology. Otherwise we will just get poorer and poorer. The balance of payments deficit has quadrupled since Brexit (it was bad enough beforehand). GBP continues to collapse, we rely on imports for essentials and have a falling currency value. None of this will change without action on what I've said. Why would foreign investors continue to fund our deficit annually when there is no prospect of growth here and no plan and no productivity rise? We have been falling into a self-perpetuating downwards spiral hence the rising interest rates and the time remaining to climb back out before it becomes a black hole and we cross the event horizon is now limited.

It is disappointing to see a thread like this - and so many others so not an attack on you OP! I mean the responses more tbh - with so many demands but nobody thinking about any type of coherent plan in terms of "how would you actually achieve this? How will it be paid for?"

I don't know if it's that people don't understand economics and only think about what affects their own circumstances, and just think someone else should/ will/ can sort it out, or what. But unless the British electorate actually engages in some realism and a holistic view of not just what needs to change but how this can be done, then there will be no pressure on politicians to actually have any long-term and achievable coherent plans to improve things and actually implement them, and therefore nothing will change and it's black hole bye bye time. Ultimately if the electorate refused to informed themselves and demand their politicians stop talking rubbish and do what needs to be done they will of course just continue with three word slogans and promising the moon on a stick and doing nothing and people should not then be surprised when they continue to get poorer year on year, because without these changes it is inevitable.

Room102 · 31/05/2023 14:31

I also think it is shambolic how disabled people are treated in the UK. There needs to be huge investment here for proper services, proper educational provision, proper inclusion in the workplace, and disability benefits like PIP and DLA need to be at least doubled to actually cover the costs of disability on top of normal living costs, as they are meant to.

State pensions should be based on a % of the amount contributed not just the number of years, like in most other European countries. As should unemployment pay, with far more focus on a contributory system.

Part of the problem the UK has is that there are a great many people who contribute little or nothing then wail that public services are terrible. Well of course they are when so many people can choose to work part time and have their living costs subsidised. There are posts on here about it all the time, how people can have the same income choosing to have a SAHP or one parent working minimal hours and the taxpayer pay a large chunk of their rent and living costs for example. Some moves are being made to change this which is good as it is not sustainable or reasonable and that money should instead be used for decent quality education, healthcare and support for the disabled.

Oh and obviously - it goes without saying as it's so obvious - any Government that actually cared about the standard of living in the UK would rejoin the single market and customs union immediately.

Ultimately the services people want can't be funded unless everyone pays much more tax. Often people say they are happy to but they are people paying a few hundred pounds per month and are thinking what, an extra £50-£100 will do it? It won't. Mostly the expectation seems to be that they say this but what they mean is that other people should pay more.

The wealthy in the UK who earn their money in dividends/ from investments need to pay far more for sure: raise capital gains and dividend tax to the level of income tax. But due to the maths, even if that happened, it won't be enough. The only way to do it is to widen the tax base again, reduce the personal allowance and raise the basic rate of income tax substantially. People need to put their money where their mouth is and realise that it's not other people who need to fund it all for them: the systems they wish for are paid for in those countries because everyone pays more tax. People earning under £50k in the UK pay next to nothing, not even enough to fund their current services so how can they be improved?

Then you also get social cohesion and any support for services collapsing because they are funded by only a small proportion of people, and increasingly those people are even prevented from accessing them as well as paying for them for themselves and others. Not a good idea: that is the fastest way ever to erode support for public services which - cynically perhaps - I think is one reason this has been done. And like Brexit, sadly a proportion of the British population is economically illiterate enough to have fallen for it.

But obviously people in those earning brackets can't pay more at the moment because we've all been impoverished by bad economic management and Brexit. The only way to fix it all therefore is for productivity to rise because that is the only way for living standards and salaries to rise in proportion to the cost of living. Which brings me back to my original list: long-term plans for the economy and industrial strategy (infrastructure, SM and CU, fixing the tax system per above, support for start-ups to grow new businesses), huge investment in education and technology and linking that to businesses and technical apprenticeships and retraining mid-life, water/ energy/ food security, long-term plans...

Oh dear. I do not hold out much hope because ALL of our politicians are too incompetent to do this. It doesn't even appear to be on their radars.

Room102 · 31/05/2023 14:08

It is ridiculous. If you use childcare then to get back to the same net pay you would have from £99k you need a payrise to over £150k in on go - just to bring home the same money. If you earn £1 over £100k you lose tens of thousands of pounds in net pay overnight. Obviously people work less when tax rates are extortionate but when the deductions are well over 100%... do they think people will work more not just for free but at a loss? Confused

TheFTrain · 31/05/2023 14:06

Sort out the NHS. My DC had a massive injury well before Christmas and we've literally had our first appointment to see a consultant today. DC needs a big operation, will be given priority, but we have absolutely no idea if this will happen next month (v unlikely) or next year.

AlltheFs · 31/05/2023 14:03

Room102 · 30/05/2023 23:28

They need to get rid of those cliff edges altogether. Hunt actually commissioned research into why UK productivity was so low and one key factor was people cutting hours/ not bothering to seek promotions once they hit either £50k or £100k earnings because of the completely illogical tax system and skyrocketing marginal rates of tax from removing child benefit/ the personal allowance, respectively. Both have been shown by multiple pieces of research to cost more than they save by withdrawing them. So he knows this. Did he do anything about it? No. Then Rachel Reeves was asked about it in her interview with Mumsnet not long ago and she scoffed and said it's "not a priority". Addressing something discouraging your most productive workers from working more is not a priority in a productivity and fiscal crisis? They are all utterly clueless.

Oh absolutely, I completely agree. I’m definitely trapped in my current circumstances. Now at the moment it is fine as I have a young DD and there’s a benefit to me being slightly part time. But once she is in school next year I’d like the option to move back to full time but if nothing changes we can’t actually afford for me to do it.

Room102 · 31/05/2023 13:57

Let alone the second industrial revolution that is coming our way and will make many jobs obsolete. Is the education and social system being reformed to manage this? Of course not.

I'm afraid that there is nobody in the HOC remotely capable of doing the job properly. None of the key issues that should be their top priorities feature much in any of their interviews, it's all slogans and nonsense. Infantilising and facile.

LlynTegid · 31/05/2023 13:56

Keep British Summer Time all year round. We could make much more use of afternoon daylight than in the morning.

Zippedydoo123 · 31/05/2023 13:55

Lower the state pension age to 64 or 65. That way I only got 4 or 5 years before my money improves. I do intend to continue working though until either my health gives way or age 75.

Room102 · 31/05/2023 13:53

@CheeseTouch it is expensive because we have designed our pricing model to peg the price to gas even for the renewables generated. That could - and should - be changed. Also because we stopped investing in nuclear decades ago. And unbelievably we are surrounded by coastline yet import hydro power from Norway!

As with all things in the UK it is because our politicians are incapable of understanding economics and have no long term plans whatsoever for energy security, food security, healthcare, industrial strategy, water security, flood defence, international trade, demographic shifts, etc. Immigration is another hilarious area. There is likely to be population collapse everywhere outside subsaharan Africa in the next 2-3 decades and they are trying to reduce immigration?! Unfortunately it is a case of pay peanuts, get monkeys.

verdantverdure · 31/05/2023 12:21

I stand corrected

The U.K. having the third highest electricity prices in the world is a major driver of U.K. inflation

OP posts:
CheeseTouch · 31/05/2023 11:50

Room102 · 30/05/2023 23:21

That's also a myth. It was debunked on More Or Less on BBC4 as utter nonsense.

The UK has the third highest electricity prices in the world. Hardly something to celebrate! Only Denmark and Germany’s are higher and they have a renewables strategy to get prices down and create jobs for their economies. Shame the UK is so focused on ‘investing’ in oil and gas, when it hasn’t and wont deliver cheaper bills for homes and our businesses, or environmental benefits.

https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy-environment/news/berlin-lays-out-plan-to-bring-back-solar-wind-industry-on-german-soil/

Berlin lays out plan to bring back solar, wind industry on German soil

The German government is looking to acquire shares in renewable energy firms and provide support to wind turbine and solar panel manufacturers in order to encourage their production in Germany.

https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy-environment/news/berlin-lays-out-plan-to-bring-back-solar-wind-industry-on-german-soil/

Wishitsnows · 30/05/2023 23:58

Sort the housing issue so it gets back to people in regular jobs can actually buy a house not just a flat. Also investigate the water companies and find out how much their shareholders have been fleecing everyone. Why do we have Victorian sewerage systems. Why have they not invested in over 100 years. Clearly people have been profiting and not reinvesting the money paid to them.

ecuse · 30/05/2023 23:47

Make going to the GP feel like it did when I was a kid in the 80s and 90s. Being on the list of a doctor that knew you and having the safe expectation that most of the time you'd see them, so they had an idea of your medical history.

In fact - just being able to call and book an appointment for something non-urgent a day or two in advance...or to be able to choose to book further in the future if for example your GP was away and you wanted to wait to see them when you came back. Or if the doctor said to come back in a month, being able to schedule that in as you leave.

The GP system just feels utterly broken. It seems to exist only to give same-day urgent appointments (and only then even if you're lucky to snaffle the handful of gold dust appointments they release at 10am) or to redirect to you 111 if its so urgent you can't wait. Isn't the main point of primary care to pick minor things up early to avoid them becoming major things?

Swipe left for the next trending thread