Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum friend with possible munchausens by proxy

189 replies

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 10:37

What would you do?

I can't go into all the details RN but it's been going on for years.

Constant doctorsce trips in different cities, requesting different hospital when one hospital won't believe here, unexplanable illnesses, lack of diagnosis, mystified specialists, sitting in GP surgery waiting room for hours, hospital waiting room A+E, lots of messages about it all sending people photos.

Teachers suspicious and saying “don't think it's constapation”, doctors refusing to write up letters she's requesting.

Blaming allergies that are unproven and reactions for bad behaviour and constapation for when he's naughty.

Says he can't join in sports or plays because of bib or costume and his “allergies”.

There is always a drama and she seems to get pleasure from telling people about it all. Longer it goes on it looks more and more like her own “accounts” of these things happening.

The doctors stopped listening at a point she then became addicted to the homeopath. Who kept giving “pills” she then kept paying for calls even when on holiday to shamanic therapist cause his behaviour was so bad.

I don't even know when she will stop.

OP posts:
Famzonhol · 29/05/2023 12:48

I’d agree with a pp who says that MbP is where the child is being deliberately harmed by the parent which doesn’t sound like the case here.

But if the child is missing a lot of school for no real reason, that is harmful. Like I say - lots of children being brought up by parents with mental health issues and it doesn’t matter whether it’s the parent’s “fault” or not - harm is still being done.

Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 12:47

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 12:41

When you say "in these cases", do you mean in genuine MbP/FII/FDIA cases, or in cases of mistaken accusations like yours? I'm assuming you mean the latter, but just asking for clarification because I don't think you mean that actual parents with MbP are commonly neurodiverse!

In cases where families are wrongly accused

JosephFrancis · 29/05/2023 12:47

Difficult.

I constantly worry that I'm going to be seen as one of those mothers because my daughter has a relatively unknown condition and I did have to take her to a few different doctors before I found the right one for her. I can say it is very frustrating to have doctors acknowledge something is wrong but be baffled by the cause. Because of the way people have reacted (with disbelief that there is yet another thing wrong, that doctors can genuinely be clueless and I must be lying) I deal with everything alone as much as I can and I do not share in real life.

I'd say if you have real fears, report to social services. As much as I would be horrified to have someone make such a report, I know that no social worker could find any evidence to support that claim and it would soothe whoever reported to know it was unsubstantiated. Hopefully the same is true for your friend. Children with complicated conditions and medics with no answers are more common than mothers with munschausens by proxy after all.

SnickersWasAHorse · 29/05/2023 12:47

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 12:44

So far on this thread, the parents of allergic children totally understand how this can be a fellow allergic mother feeling desperate and not listened to.

Everyone else screams FII.

Speaks volumes.

But both situations exist. Parents who can get doctors to listen exist. It’s very much a real problem, but parents with FIL exist also.

It’s not as simple as there only being one or the other.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 12:47

@ADHDDDDDDDBOOM I have anaphylaxis, and diagnosed MCAS, and three other severe non ige allergic conditions. My mother has watched me struggle with these for my entire life. Do tell me more about how little I understand allergies. Hmm

(Sorry I can't talk about having biological children and what their allergies are like: I am too medically unstable to bear a child. My bad, I guess. My own will have to do.)

IntoDeepBlueSea · 29/05/2023 12:45

@Greenleafgirl - your absolutely right, and your observation is exactly my experience too, every time.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 12:44

So far on this thread, the parents of allergic children totally understand how this can be a fellow allergic mother feeling desperate and not listened to.

Everyone else screams FII.

Speaks volumes.

IntoDeepBlueSea · 29/05/2023 12:44

@ContinuousProcrastination - but that's not what she's describing is it? If your child was constantly destructive, I'd say there is a reason for that...

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 12:41

Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 12:38

Very often too in these cases the mother is autistic so does such an exemplary job of noticing symptoms and pushing relentlessly for support or second opinions and this is misinterpreted as attention seeking , even in meetings reiterating things and seeking clarification is then seen as questioning professionals.

Complaining is seen as a red flag. Seeking a second opinion is seen as a red flag. Safeguarding is weaponised against a lot of wrongfully accused families

When you say "in these cases", do you mean in genuine MbP/FII/FDIA cases, or in cases of mistaken accusations like yours? I'm assuming you mean the latter, but just asking for clarification because I don't think you mean that actual parents with MbP are commonly neurodiverse!

Highdaysandholidays1 · 29/05/2023 12:41

@Greenleafgirl that sounds awful, it sounds like once you were caught in the system, the scrutiny was intense. Of course had you not come to their attention, and just turned up via social services, most of this would not warrant any intervention at all. Social services can't keep pace with the existing deluge of extreme child abuse cases, so going around searching for emotional abuse isn't something they can usually do- unless, as I say, you become caught in the system (which I have myself) and then have a whole lot more scrutiny than someone else. There are kids living with parents who are addicts, parents who have profound MH issues, physical neglect all over the UK that aren't attended to, it's often quite arbitrary what rises to the top and gets inspected.

ContinuousProcrastination · 29/05/2023 12:41

No child is "just naughty", or always comes from somewhere.

Oh ffs what a load of balls! 7 year olds are perfectly capable of being naughty occasionally. My child is nearly 7 and took something from his little sister earlier. He knew full well he shouldn't have, he just took it because he wanted it and didnt realise an adult was watching so he'd get caught. That is being "naughty", having an impulse to do something you know full well you shouldn't do, and choosing to do it anyway.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 12:40

@IntoDeepBlueSea I think our takes are probably not poles apart. It's definitely not you I disagree with the most, haha. For what it's worth, when I lean towards thinking someone has MbP, that isn't necessarily me saying that I think they are poisoning their child - it can mean a whole lot of different things, poisoning is just one extreme manifestation. And even in this case I'm not saying I think the mother in question necessarily is hurting her child. Just that I think it meets the threshold to report. It could be that they are struggling and everything is going wrong, and they need help, but the exact profile of what's wrong is not factitious illness.

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 12:39

mommatoone · 29/05/2023 12:15

Out of interest OP, how does the child react? Like, one minute he's running around a rugby field, next minute he is being carried or being put in a wheelchair. What does he say about it?

He seems normal most times when you meet him but she has described him as becoming more and more controlling of her and what she does.

So he wants all of her attention and that's when he's happiest.

Things like her doting on him, spoon feeding him and him only sleeping in her bed with the bright light on. She's a single mum.

OP posts:
Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 12:38

Very often too in these cases the mother is autistic so does such an exemplary job of noticing symptoms and pushing relentlessly for support or second opinions and this is misinterpreted as attention seeking , even in meetings reiterating things and seeking clarification is then seen as questioning professionals.

Complaining is seen as a red flag. Seeking a second opinion is seen as a red flag. Safeguarding is weaponised against a lot of wrongfully accused families

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 12:37

He is now well behind his peers at school, can't write or read very well at all and attendance is poor due to all the days off and hospital trips.

Trips she sets up and organises to fill her time with.

I most people are suspicious but are scared to stand up and be the one who raises it. All concerned for their own jobs presumably.

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 29/05/2023 12:36

IntoDeepBlueSea · 29/05/2023 12:00

Ok, well spoon feeding etc does sound extreme, but you STILL don't get it. She may be wrong about what is making him behave so badly, but something IS, so that needs looking at.

Clearly anyone who could flag/ help, is so busy blaming her, no one is actually doing anything to help the child.

He could be behaving badly because of her behaviour, it really doesn't sound normal at all!

IntoDeepBlueSea · 29/05/2023 12:35

@verysmellyjelly - I actually thought you were agreeing with me with your last line - "There is a related point, which is that linking conditions to MbP accusations by implication and in a generalised and clumsy way is actually harmful to real sufferers of those conditions".

This could equally be talking about those who are dealing with conditions, and being accused of making it up.

If you go back, I agreed that there may well be something wrong, but the insistence (by a lay person) that all those things add up to Mbps is a bit dramatic. I think asking someone to take a look is one thing. The point of this condition, surely, is that the parent is making the child ill, to garner sympathy, money, support etc.

This mother may be behaving bizarrely, but nothing she says implies that the child is being poisoned.

I think a lot of it comes down to the carer's personality. If she was a rich hippie saying her child was banned from eating sugar, could only do yoga, not PE, and how she has this wonderful naturopath, no one would be throwing around this life ruining accusation. She would be seen as having more money than sense, and urge worst that could be said is how sad for the child that they're not allowed birthday cake.

If this mum we're talking about is struggling, agitated, has no one to support her, or make her feel heard for whatever reason, she is supposed to be stoic, demure, a martyr.

She is obviously loud, shares too much, and it's clear that, Mbps notwithstanding, OP doesn't like her and finds her annoying.

God forbid it turns out she and the son are both too some degree ND. Issues with impulse control, not reading the room, not understanding that no one else is interested... ?

Post for advice, say you're worried, but don't start assuming that you know the underlying issues, and at least irl, don't start using labels that can be hard to come back from.

Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 12:35

Highdaysandholidays1 · 29/05/2023 12:31

The thing is, both things can be true. This mother may be attention-seeking over his illness and her illness, and the child and she might also be ill. I know someone who fits into this category myself, but ultimately they were proved right that there were problems with the children even if they dealt with them in an attention-seeking way reflecting their own mental health issues.

One doesn't preclude the other necessarily.

Report if you feel strongly the child is being harmed and let others judge that. My feeling is little will happen, yes, she's being a pain about it all and showing letters, but ultimately if the child is at school, playing games, and goes in a wheelchair once a year as tired on holiday, then no one is going to intervene for that. He's not being actively harmed as in given substances, or something.

They now say it’s ‘emotional abuse’ and can remove on that basis so whether or not illness has actually been induced they say giving a child a ‘sick role’ is abuse . This is what they tried to pin on us it was disgusting they just kept saying ‘possible emotional abuse’ and ‘future harm’ but didn’t elaborate or give any examples they just say it with little to no evidence we had to fight and fight hard as the school were saying I’d never even given medical info (v embarrassing for them when they refused the SAR And I had emails if kept and I wen got the LA to get the schools emails where they clearly did have the care plan etc)

SmartHome · 29/05/2023 12:35

My son has EDS, diagnosed at GOSH when he was 7. He luckily is not severely affected - hyper mobility in hands and legs but also has a cardiac condition which is thought to be related. He also suffers from digestive issues and resulting constipation and is also slightly on the spectrum (undiagnosed) and could be described as 'highly strung' - as suffers with some anxiety which is also thought to go along with EDS. Much of this improved post-puberty.

However, I managed to get him diagnosed, access appropriate treatment (physio to stop tie walking) and relavent follow up appointments. He then went onto do well at school without missing more than a few mornings or afternoons for appointments and is now enjoying secondary school, expected to do well at GCSEs, sports and has a small, but strong friendship group. He also managed to turn his annoying hypermobile hands, which used to cause him a big issue with writing, into a positive as he now plays guitar at a very high level.

The girl I mentioned was in the same class as him and she is a school refuser, very troubled, is under social services and is struggling academically as missed so much schooling. That is the difference. The way her mother responded to her "sore tummies" was very different and has done her a great disservice. Whether or not she actually has a medical condition remains to be seen. The mother talked of EDS but I never saw her bend her hand back to touch her wrist like my son did on command as his playground party trick.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 12:34

Pinkbonbon · 29/05/2023 12:33

Honestly I'd just post publicly to her social media 'Getting help for the MBP yet or do we have to storm the basement and save Gypsy Rose?'
Along with a meme pic. Not just to be mean but to call everyone else's attention to it. The more people around her that know whats what, the harder it'll be for her. And the less sympathy she will get. Which is what she feeds on. So let everyone know what she is doing.

Pinkbonbon takes no prisoners Wink

Pinkbonbon · 29/05/2023 12:33

Honestly I'd just post publicly to her social media 'Getting help for the MBP yet or do we have to storm the basement and save Gypsy Rose?'
Along with a meme pic. Not just to be mean but to call everyone else's attention to it. The more people around her that know whats what, the harder it'll be for her. And the less sympathy she will get. Which is what she feeds on. So let everyone know what she is doing.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 29/05/2023 12:31

The thing is, both things can be true. This mother may be attention-seeking over his illness and her illness, and the child and she might also be ill. I know someone who fits into this category myself, but ultimately they were proved right that there were problems with the children even if they dealt with them in an attention-seeking way reflecting their own mental health issues.

One doesn't preclude the other necessarily.

Report if you feel strongly the child is being harmed and let others judge that. My feeling is little will happen, yes, she's being a pain about it all and showing letters, but ultimately if the child is at school, playing games, and goes in a wheelchair once a year as tired on holiday, then no one is going to intervene for that. He's not being actively harmed as in given substances, or something.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 12:29

Furthermore, for everyone:

Constipation is not diagnostic of Ehlers Danlos syndrome. It is not in the diagnostic criteria. It is a very common complaint of childhood. The pp who suggested that constipation in a child should lead to a consideration of EDS is being absolutely misleading to the point of irresponsibility.

Further: there is no definitively established link between coeliac and EDS. There is no definitively established link between autoimmune and EDS. There is no definitively established link between neurodiversity and EDS. Research into all these overlaps is merely ongoing.

A pp simply thinking it "maybe, sorta, kinda sounds like" any given condition is not a good enough reason to discount the welfare of a child who may be a victim of factitious illness imposed on them by a parent. Welfare and safeguarding is paramount.

Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 12:29

Ours started after we pushed for an EHCP and extra support ….

Creamyoda · 29/05/2023 12:28

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 11:46

I think reporting it anonymously is an idea however I wonder why no one has connected the dots yet between schools, doctors and healthcare professionals, she's trying to get him an EHCP now and 1:1 in school.

Maybe they have more information about it then you do? If you're concerned then report to social services who might do something to support the child if he is genuinely poorly and isn't getting anywhere with medical staff (not unheard of), or the mum who is evidently poorly if she is making it all up.