Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum friend with possible munchausens by proxy

189 replies

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 10:37

What would you do?

I can't go into all the details RN but it's been going on for years.

Constant doctorsce trips in different cities, requesting different hospital when one hospital won't believe here, unexplanable illnesses, lack of diagnosis, mystified specialists, sitting in GP surgery waiting room for hours, hospital waiting room A+E, lots of messages about it all sending people photos.

Teachers suspicious and saying “don't think it's constapation”, doctors refusing to write up letters she's requesting.

Blaming allergies that are unproven and reactions for bad behaviour and constapation for when he's naughty.

Says he can't join in sports or plays because of bib or costume and his “allergies”.

There is always a drama and she seems to get pleasure from telling people about it all. Longer it goes on it looks more and more like her own “accounts” of these things happening.

The doctors stopped listening at a point she then became addicted to the homeopath. Who kept giving “pills” she then kept paying for calls even when on holiday to shamanic therapist cause his behaviour was so bad.

I don't even know when she will stop.

OP posts:
Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 14:32

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:30

@Greenleafgirl As previously covered in the thread, we actually don't have a good sense of how rare it is, partly because it's such a rapidly developing field. It certainly doesn't reflect the view of all experts to claim it's extremely rare. The intersection of MbP/FII with the probably much more common factitious or induced illness (not imposed on someone else, "just" on oneself) is really complicated, and the way that the latter has completely exploded (with MBI) online over the last twenty, but particularly the last ten, years means that the implications for MbP are something of an uncharted territory.

I found this - it’s extremely rare

Mum friend with possible munchausens by proxy
Mum friend with possible munchausens by proxy
verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:30

@Feefee10 They are not fully integrated, unfortunately.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:30

@Greenleafgirl As previously covered in the thread, we actually don't have a good sense of how rare it is, partly because it's such a rapidly developing field. It certainly doesn't reflect the view of all experts to claim it's extremely rare. The intersection of MbP/FII with the probably much more common factitious or induced illness (not imposed on someone else, "just" on oneself) is really complicated, and the way that the latter has completely exploded (with MBI) online over the last twenty, but particularly the last ten, years means that the implications for MbP are something of an uncharted territory.

Feefee10 · 29/05/2023 14:27

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 11:20

If she doesn't get the response she wants she will transfer to a new hospital and to new doctors who makes noises she likes for however long that lasts.

She stopped going to one hospital as she saw a doctor wrote in notes she was either anxious or neurotic.

It doesn't matter the NHS systems are integrated so the dcs care record will go across different hospitals. It's all on there so doctors will see she's been flagged as anxious.

Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 14:26

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:23

@Greenleafgirl I'm sorry you were mistakenly accused but that doesn't mean anyone with suspicions of MbP/FII shouldn't report it. It is a very serious situation and does need to be investigated.

Genuine cases of MSBP are extremely rare but can be fatal. Understandably SS cast the net wide to catch those cases but in doing so they end up punishing parents who are doing nothing wrong.

The guidance needs updating. Im aware that recently Cathie Long and BASW put out something updated which was helpful but sadly many LA are using outdated guidance. Once is alleged it spirals so quick and nobody is prepared to then take the risk that it’s not actually FII/MSBP and families are ripped apart and genuinely ill children removed which is hugely traumatising and wrong

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:23

@Greenleafgirl I'm sorry you were mistakenly accused but that doesn't mean anyone with suspicions of MbP/FII shouldn't report it. It is a very serious situation and does need to be investigated.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:22

@NeverDropYourMooncup I am well aware that people with EDS can play sports, and I am no fan of the zebra shite myself either. But in this case the OP is describing a child who needs a wheelchair (which as your post hints at, most EDS patients actually shouldn't be using) according to the parent, and yet also plays rugby, when contact sports for a patient with severe EDS would be contra indicated.

Greenleafgirl · 29/05/2023 14:20

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:15

There have been multiple child deaths where concerns were not acted on. It's never wise to assume someone else is taking action. Safety and welfare of the child must come first.

More deaths due to SS being busy investigating those who aren’t doing anything except trying to get their dc the support/diagnosis /EHCP etc they need meanwhile all the poor children we see beaten to death and neglected in the news weren’t even properly checked.

We had a full child protection investigation and on one occasion the SW said ‘hang on I just need to get my phone out and put it on loud as I’m the duty worker and I’m case there’s an emergency’ and in that moment I thought ‘she’s here - nothing is wrong , the dc aren’t being harmed in any way and there will be be other children who are being harmed and not investigated while they are wasting their time on us’ they were clearly stretched as it was , I almost felt guilty and it wasn’t my fault

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/05/2023 14:19

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 12:24

@NeverDropYourMooncup I have severe EDS, thanks, there's literally nothing you can tell me about it. Hence why I know it isn't treated by a shaman and EDS patients don't play rugby.

I used to play hockey and kickboxed for a while. I was good at relocating my shoulder (knee, ankle, collarbone at the AC joint, fingers, wrists, hip was trickier, though). I figured that, seeing as I was going to be in pain either way and a hospital relocation wasn't needed often, due to being so good at doing them myself, sometimes it was just fucking worth it. It was definitely more enjoyable than the dislocations I got when I stood up from sitting watching the other kids have all the fun and my bandaging of assorted joints was a thing of fucking beauty by the time my Brownie pack did the First Aider's Badge.

No, it's not treated by faith healing or any of that shite. No more than Psoriatic Arthritis, Coeliac Disease or POTS are. But people with EDS certainly can and do play all manner of sports. We're not all the wheelchair using zebras of the internet.

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 14:18

Munchyseeds2 · 29/05/2023 13:49

There is nothing you can do....and it will not be investigated even if you do report it

I'm very concerned for the child actually, whenever I've met him he is just not how she portrays but more of a typical boy who has his moments. Never seen all the problems she says he has.. Nor have others just the results of his meltdowns.

She speaks of him and sees him totally differently as if he is totally incapable of doing things himself or thriving.

Like there is always some big issue she has to fix and if a child is constantly told there is something wrong with them and gets attention from it they will probably start believing they're seriously ill after a life being told this.

OP posts:
verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:15

creasedclothes · 29/05/2023 13:10

You know what op, stay out of it. Not every single observation needs "reporting", especially by people who don't know all the details. Presumably the medical professionals that have dealt and are dealing with her will notice if something is up, as she will have told them, I expect, of various tests and treatments. If they think they need to investigate they will, not you.

There have been multiple child deaths where concerns were not acted on. It's never wise to assume someone else is taking action. Safety and welfare of the child must come first.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:13

@GingerScallop Yes, unfortunately it is far from the case the HCPs will always join the necessary dots. Sad

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 14:13

@ADHDDDDDDDBOOM it is exactly like the bruising example, actually. And being an allergy parent doesn't lend you any special ability to judge whether these concerns ought to be reported, despite your apparent belief that you have the right to be endlessly rude and insulting to childless allergy sufferers.

GingerScallop · 29/05/2023 14:12

LakeTiticaca · 29/05/2023 11:59

Surely all of this will be recorded in his medical notes and the doctors would have raised suspicions by now?

one would hope. Yet I have seen incidences in a patient's life not being connected. Even at the same hospital.
Hopefully this child will get the help they deserve no matter whether the issue is induced illness or actual. What a tough situation for all involved

Hairbrushhandle · 29/05/2023 14:10

I'm an allergy mum and it's so so so hard. You get written off as 'crazy mum' by professionals. The only time I've been taken seriously is by a private gastro who finally diagnosed my DC with allergies and an auto immune disease. What I will say is because no one believes you (note that they do believe DH because he's a man) you end up having to do a ton of research yourself and have to be very careful because the allergy info is also bound up with a host of other propaganda like anti vax, homeopathy, mthfr 'practitioners' etc. And when you're in a bad place and you are desperate to get someone to notice your DC's issues then it can be tempting to go down those roads, like homeopathy. Obviously you also look at peer reviewed articles but then you realise that actually there's hardly any research on these areas because most children's allergy issues rely on women to be heard by health professionals and they're not.

Groutyonehereagain · 29/05/2023 14:02

If you honestly believe that the parent is fabricating illness then you have a duty to report it to a child safeguarding social worker.

Munchyseeds2 · 29/05/2023 13:49

There is nothing you can do....and it will not be investigated even if you do report it

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 13:40

georgarina · 29/05/2023 13:36

That doesn't mean OP shouldn't be suspicious. You had your own experience, but that doesn't mean this situation isn't different and this child isn't being abused.

It would be like OP knowing a constantly bruised child and me dismissing it by saying 'My child has X syndrome which causes bruising. Teachers were all suspicious of me until it was diagnosed. Next question?'

It's absolutely not like a child being bruised.

Perhaps have a scroll back on this thread and have a read of the experiences of parents of the non-ige allergic child.

Or maybe read the allergy forum on here.

Or anywhere for that matter, and see how painfully, painfully common it is to not be believe by professionals, or friends (going by the OP!)

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 13:40

I must add most recently she heard of someone elses child being diagnosed with dyspraxia and is now thinking he has that and has taken him to the doctors regarding feet. Again nothing came of it.

She contacted council to send in independent assesors to look at his class environment as she didn't feel he has enough support and school was doing nothing. He now regularly gets taken out of lessons to a self-regulation room which he enjoys for a break and attention.

School always complain of his behaviour so she said well get him a 1:1 so he will be watched and no longer be a danger or problem to anyone.

As he cannot keep up with class work he misbehaves to divert attention from this point.

OP posts:
georgarina · 29/05/2023 13:38

creasedclothes · 29/05/2023 13:10

You know what op, stay out of it. Not every single observation needs "reporting", especially by people who don't know all the details. Presumably the medical professionals that have dealt and are dealing with her will notice if something is up, as she will have told them, I expect, of various tests and treatments. If they think they need to investigate they will, not you.

You should never 'just stay out of it' if you're worried a child is being abused.

georgarina · 29/05/2023 13:36

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 11:54

And yes, I really thought this thread was about me. Grow up.

It was very clear (but not for you that's ok we can't all be switched on) that I was giving examples to the OP showing that what the person was doing can be entirely normal when a child has allergies.

I hope that makes it much clearer for you. X

That doesn't mean OP shouldn't be suspicious. You had your own experience, but that doesn't mean this situation isn't different and this child isn't being abused.

It would be like OP knowing a constantly bruised child and me dismissing it by saying 'My child has X syndrome which causes bruising. Teachers were all suspicious of me until it was diagnosed. Next question?'

TripleDaisySummer · 29/05/2023 13:35

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 11:46

I think reporting it anonymously is an idea however I wonder why no one has connected the dots yet between schools, doctors and healthcare professionals, she's trying to get him an EHCP now and 1:1 in school.

I'd be very surprised if this was not being reported and flagged up but if you really have concerns then Social services would be place to report.

I don't see how anyone here can help you - because it's impossible to tell if this is just the mother's mental health problem - the child actually having rare condition not yet identified (bizarrely know a few families who had this situation ) or some mix of the two ( seen that once and professionals were aware and working with both mother and child).

I've also found schools vary widely between conditions and children to how they respond to medical conditions and even know family armed with diagnosis and NHS pediatricians letters and support be dismissed by school school staff.

So no-one here can do more than suggest if you have real concerns then report then to the correct place - Social services who are in best place to investigate and will have more access to information than you or anyone here.

DepartureLounge · 29/05/2023 13:34

NowItsSpring · 29/05/2023 11:57

Fabricated illness is rare but can be very serious - life limiting / life threatening at it's most extreme. Much more common is parents not being listened to and seeing lots of different professionals before they are taken seriously, a diagnosis is made and the appropriate treatment/support put in place. Somewhere in between will be people who struggle with health anxiety who seek frequent medical advice and need a lot of reassurance.
Have a good think about what you 'know, what have you seen and heard? If you have genuine concerns, then you need to report to children's services. Personally I would not do this anonymously - they may need to contact you to clarify information or ask for more detail.

I completely agree with this.

One of my DC, who already had a lot of allergic/atopic issues (virus-induced wheeze, eczema, hay fever etc) and whose father has a history autoimmune conditions, developed gastro symptoms and general lethargy at late primary age. He had already had a lot of hospital input, including some scary A&E admissions when he was tiny, so we were on their radar and I didn't hesitate to raise it with our GP as an issue that needed investigating. I suspected food allergies and didn't see why he shouldn't have his asthma clinic appointment brought forward so as to do skin tests promptly, and also asked for a coeliac screen and diabetes bloods while we were at it. Our GP (who with retrospect had some issues of his own) told me my requests for 'over-investigation' were sinister and insinuated that he would report to social services if I didn't back off. Fortunately, I'm medically trained myself and told him where to go, but very few parents would stick up for themselves in that situation.

I think the homeopathy/shamanic healing thing is worrying, whether the DC has anything physically wrong or not, but you can understand how parents get to the stage where they're desperate to be listened to and treated with something the approximates respect. I don't think it necessarily signals an abuse situation but the truth is you can't really tell from the outside and we definitely can't tell from your retelling of things.

However, of course, if you have worries you must raise them, either directly with social services or indirectly with, say, school. But don't do it anonymously. Quite apart from anything else it virtually ensures your concern won't be followed up and may be seen as malicious. In any case, why would you not put your name to it? The reality is that the most likely scenario of all is a complex picture comprising some physical problems, some behavioural problems, some parenting problems, and an utter lack of support with any of them. Be a grown up and stand by your decision to try and get this child the help he needs and deserves.

IntoDeepBlueSea · 29/05/2023 13:22

I'm not going to go back and tag you, because I really wish I hadn't just noticed your posts, but the two mothers who are so pleased with themselves because they got the right diagnosis, and then disparage other people who SAY they're children are sick but clearly aren't... well shame on you.

To the mother who's child was 7 at GOSH - So you got the right referrals, the right hospital, a timely diagnosis. Bully for you. The other child can't bend their thumb back.. so you know how you sound? Ignorant. There are different forms of EDS, did you know that? How can anyone, whose experienced the worries you've had with your child, have such a smug dismissive attitude to another mother and child?

And the other one. Lucky you, your children only deal with the CMPA etc. Try figuring that out with 3 other things going on.

I was accused on mn, many years ago, of being a misanthrope. This is why I wear the badge happily. FFS.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 13:22

*couldn't see any concern or worry expressed