Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum friend with possible munchausens by proxy

189 replies

Schooldinners1 · 29/05/2023 10:37

What would you do?

I can't go into all the details RN but it's been going on for years.

Constant doctorsce trips in different cities, requesting different hospital when one hospital won't believe here, unexplanable illnesses, lack of diagnosis, mystified specialists, sitting in GP surgery waiting room for hours, hospital waiting room A+E, lots of messages about it all sending people photos.

Teachers suspicious and saying “don't think it's constapation”, doctors refusing to write up letters she's requesting.

Blaming allergies that are unproven and reactions for bad behaviour and constapation for when he's naughty.

Says he can't join in sports or plays because of bib or costume and his “allergies”.

There is always a drama and she seems to get pleasure from telling people about it all. Longer it goes on it looks more and more like her own “accounts” of these things happening.

The doctors stopped listening at a point she then became addicted to the homeopath. Who kept giving “pills” she then kept paying for calls even when on holiday to shamanic therapist cause his behaviour was so bad.

I don't even know when she will stop.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AlexandriasWindmill · 30/05/2023 19:09

Not all allergies are easy to diagnose and DCs' positions change especially at the age of the DC in the OP. Our consultant wouldn't entertain any allergy testing at that age because it wouldn't necessarily be conclusive and hitting puberty can impact too.
Dh is allergic to dairy. He has been for years. He can still end up accidentally eating something with dairy. Sometimes because the ingredient isn't flagged in a sweet or sometimes because a trusted foodstuff changes its recipe and there's no publicity around it.
So it's perfectly plausible that a DC with suspected allergies could go through cycles of eating and being ill. It doesn't mean their DM is making it up. It doesn't mean their DM is deliberately feeding them stuff that makes them ill.
And the reason why people feel passionate is every nonsense thread blaming a mum reinforces the idea that a woman with an ill child must be attention seeking rather than an engaged primary carer constantly interacting with a sexist and seriously understaffed NHS. Despite the numerous papers, research and statistics that prove both of those facts.

Suddenlysummer · 29/05/2023 20:44

SnickersWasAHorse · 29/05/2023 10:52

I’ve NC for this and I’m being sparse with details on purpose.

In my job I came across a child who I believed was a victim of this. The mother would claim all sorts of things about them and a sibling, including claims of cancer. I called SS and they weren’t interested.
Eventually a HCP came in to see the child related to another issue, I and other staff cornered them with all the evidence we had: contradictory statements from the mother, video evidence that contradicted what she claimed the child could do. No one was interested.

Report but be prepared for no one to follow it up.

this is an interesting but upsetting listen.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/p0fhzh45?partner=uk.co.bbc&origin=share-mobile

Thank you for this link. I've just listened to the whole thing. It's definitely worth listening to.

Hairbrushhandle · 29/05/2023 18:22

itsgettingweird · 29/05/2023 17:10

The biggest thing here that is a red flag for me (but read my previous post about why I'm on the fence) is that this mum excuses behaviour as a reaction to foods a week after he's had them.

If you know your child has intolerances and what to - and that it's that that causes behaviour - you don't give them to the child.

But it may be the reverse iyswim? She actually knows he has behavioural problems and doesn't know how to support him so is seeking an answer.

Either way a report to social services should get her the support she needs.

It can easily take 72 hours for a non-ige reaction. And my DC are frequently given foods by school that they're not supposed to have. We have a constant guessing game or whether it's a reaction to something we don't know they had or if they've got a bug. School deny giving my DC the wrong foods but I've asked my DC and their friends and they call confirm theyve had the e.g. chocolate cookie

itsgettingweird · 29/05/2023 17:10

The biggest thing here that is a red flag for me (but read my previous post about why I'm on the fence) is that this mum excuses behaviour as a reaction to foods a week after he's had them.

If you know your child has intolerances and what to - and that it's that that causes behaviour - you don't give them to the child.

But it may be the reverse iyswim? She actually knows he has behavioural problems and doesn't know how to support him so is seeking an answer.

Either way a report to social services should get her the support she needs.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:30

@ADHDDDDDDDBOOM Again with the having no actual argument.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:28

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:21

I mean something that actually demonstrates why you take issue with FII, beyond some children having non ige allergic conditions (which I have not seen anyone in the thread disputing, least of all me).

Again with the reading stuff that is not there.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 29/05/2023 16:22

None of this needs further discussion though really, at least from the OP's point of view. The OP does not know if this is just 'naughtiness' and whether the child feels iller on some days than others or what's going on with going for different tests. So- report it, although I'm not sure what you are actually going to say, as from what I can see there's not that much here, the child once used a wheelchair in an airport, not every day at school (so how is that incompatible with doing rugby weekly at a different time period altogether), they use alternative practitioners (like millions of people), they've been to more than one hospital (again, standard stuff, hard to get referred to different places through GPs so not sure how she's managing that unless privately), speaks as if her child is fragile and vulnerable (not great, but not social services worthy). The woman in question is very likely to be already on the radar of the school and health-care professionals in fact, she seek them out all the time!

The tale the OP has told is one that makes it sound like MbP might be a possibility and people are salivating (why?) at the prospect, but it's not a very rounded tale and when you get to the bottom of the actual accusations, they are not compelling if alternative explanations can easily be found. The child is not wheel-chair bound and all these health-care appointments are reported to the school, there are plenty of eyes on the child. Is it emotionally abusive, perhaps. Is it going to be something intervention-worthy, report to SS and allow them to make the call.

Plus if the person can get the council out (? is that even a thing) to do an assessment, and ask for 1 to 1 support, good on them. This is not given out to naughty children. It's incredibly hard to get SN provision at the moment, which makes this tale even less convincing to me.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:21

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:19

Have you read the thread? I have added throughout.

I mean something that actually demonstrates why you take issue with FII, beyond some children having non ige allergic conditions (which I have not seen anyone in the thread disputing, least of all me).

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:19

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:19

You cannot back your statements up- no matter how confidently and arrogantly you assert them.

Fine.

I'm genuinely just waiting to hear anything you might say that is actually an argument. I've already given a wealth of arguments throughout the thread.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:19

Have you read the thread? I have added throughout.

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:19

You cannot back your statements up- no matter how confidently and arrogantly you assert them.

Fine.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:17

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:17

It's like arguing with an arrogant wall. 🙄

If you have anything beyond ad hominem, do share.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:17

It's like arguing with an arrogant wall. 🙄

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:15

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:13

So educate us then

Still waiting.

You have claimed to already be well informed. You have claimed an expert level knowledge. If that's true, you don't need any education from me.

I'm... interested by the role in this thread of some very angry posters who are saying they work in positions where they deal with FII, but whose posts don't demonstrate much knowledge of it. I am genuinely open to hearing FII-critical views, but so far haven't really heard any.

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:13

So educate us then

Still waiting.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:13

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:11

@ADHDDDDDDDBOOM I said "good for you" because you were gloating about being able to have children and how that gave you a better, deeper, superior insight into allergy, when I had just specifically explained that I have extensive experience with it but cannot have kids due to being severely unwell and chronically medically unstable.

If you really think gloating at childless women is appropriate, you have some thinking to do.

please quote the "gloating part".

Im experienced. Not a cunt.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:13

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:11

tell me how often it is that parents reporting of their child's illnesses are disregarded.

Go on. Then compare with it with actual diagnosed munchausens by proxy.

I am waiting.

Again, neither of these things has been accurately quantified. Are you actually aware of the issues surrounding not just MbP but FII in general? Your phrasing suggests you aren't. It's a really difficult condition to discern, let alone to diagnose or treat. It's almost certainly hugely under diagnosed. MBI then complicates that further.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:12

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:07

Fine so maybe I should hvae read the threa.d I am glad that issues hae been dealt with to your saitisfaction on the thread. What I am saying and have said is that mothers concerns are more often disregarded than munchausens by proxy is actually properly the case. I am an educated woman. I am a solicitor who specialises in child protection. I have seen in ny own example and in my work that it is usual that parents (usually mothers) are disprespected and ignored and ridiculed and laughed at. By HCPs who ought to know better.

If I sound angry then this is because I am.

I'm a professional who also deals with families on a daily basis who are not believed or listened to by other HCP's.

I always make sure I'm the health care professional who does listen.

I also work with families on child protection plans/Child in need plans and have worked with families where FII is suspected.

But we're wrong and shouting others down. Supposedly.

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:11

tell me how often it is that parents reporting of their child's illnesses are disregarded.

Go on. Then compare with it with actual diagnosed munchausens by proxy.

I am waiting.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:11

@ADHDDDDDDDBOOM I said "good for you" because you were gloating about being able to have children and how that gave you a better, deeper, superior insight into allergy, when I had just specifically explained that I have extensive experience with it but cannot have kids due to being severely unwell and chronically medically unstable.

If you really think gloating at childless women is appropriate, you have some thinking to do.

Minihippyme89 · 29/05/2023 16:10

OP I have read through the whole thread and know there’s a massive difference of opinions but I just wanted to say that your opening post could be a description of my childhood. My mother was exactly like that woman you are describing, there was absolutely nothing wrong with me at all and it’s left me with deep emotional scars. I wish someone had reported my mother back then because maybe I wouldn’t have had to go through so much.

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:09

@TiredOfCleaning How do you know how frequent MbP/FII/FDIA is when it's something that many of the experts acknowledge is a moving target and very difficult to pin down with any accuracy?

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 16:08

@NeverDropYourMooncup I'm literally referring to standard medical advice for EDS. If you think anyone with EDS who is so severely affected they need to use a wheelchair would also be playing contact sports, I have a bridge to sell you.

Like many disabled women, I have also been sexually assaulted. Does that adequately fill up the square on my bingo card, since that is apparently what you've decided we are playing?

I mean, for heaven's sake. This conversation did not have to go like this, but your hostility is just off the charts. All because I asked you not to keep linking EDS to factitious illness. If you seriously think that improves the rep of the condition with HCPs, then sure, go on, keep doing it! I can't stop you. But I can assure you, you are wrong.

TiredOfCleaning · 29/05/2023 16:07

verysmellyjelly · 29/05/2023 15:57

@TiredOfCleaning Maybe you should have read the thread because we have discussed pretty much all of this. Nobody is saying that false accusations don't occur.

So does MbP/FII/FDIA. There are red flags of this in what OP has shared.

It's simply incorrect to assume that anyone who acknowledges that doesn't understand complex illness. Speaking as someone who actually has cold urticaria myself along with a host of other things (some very rare), genuine serious illness has actually made me more frustrated with the "illness industry" and with fakers and factitious disorder in general. Not to say it isn't a mental illness: I'm very aware that it is. But in practice there is also a grey area in terms of where the "gains" come in, and where FII crosses over with malingering. We just don't know the situation with OP's acquaintance, and she may be struggling with other issues and no factitious component at all. But OP isn't wrong to have these concerns.

It's really troubling that several people are trying to shout down even the suggestion of reporting concerns about factitious disorder.

Fine so maybe I should hvae read the threa.d I am glad that issues hae been dealt with to your saitisfaction on the thread. What I am saying and have said is that mothers concerns are more often disregarded than munchausens by proxy is actually properly the case. I am an educated woman. I am a solicitor who specialises in child protection. I have seen in ny own example and in my work that it is usual that parents (usually mothers) are disprespected and ignored and ridiculed and laughed at. By HCPs who ought to know better.

If I sound angry then this is because I am.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 29/05/2023 16:06

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/05/2023 16:01

I'm not. I'm pointing out that disease presentations vary. You pointed out that rugby probably isn't a good idea for somebody with EDS and therefore, they can't have EDS, I pointed out that there are reasons in my own experience that where people can have EDS and still want to do those things, even with some rather predictable outcomes. Others have more severe forms.

Regarding children, it's Mumsnet. Clue's in the name for the vast majority of posters. I've had children who also have diagnoses with different presentations that don't correlate with your experience of them. I'm allowed to acknowledge their existence and that, on the basis of my diagnoses, I was advised similarly. However, if it comforts you a little, they were both products of domestic abuse and one is unable to have children herself. So thanks for the congratulations upon being beaten and raped on multiple occasions, maybe that will make your winning on the internet all the sweeter. But I'll still disagree with you that your assertion that a child who has periods of doing stuff they might enjoy automatically means the mother is lying about the inability to do everyday things at other times.

Well said.

That same poster said "good for you" when I described my kids and other kids suffering. Then accused me of making her feel awful for not being able to have kids.

I stopped responding to her and she immediately moved on to you with the same things she was saying to you.

As I said upthread. Unhinged.

Swipe left for the next trending thread