Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I was 18, he was 31

217 replies

UptownFuckYouUp · 29/05/2023 09:02

Married with children now. We initially met at work, although he wasn't in a position of power over me. I pursued the relationship and he turned me down multiple times due to my age before we started dating. I'm nearly 30 now and I'm wondering just how wrong our relationship is/was? Or does it not matter now all these years down the line? Does the fact that I pursued him make it ok?

OP posts:
IanFromAccounting · 29/05/2023 11:48

My grandparents married as soon as my grandmother was 18. My grandfather was 32. They met through my grandmother’s aunt and GM would have been in her early teens when they first met. They have been very happily married for over 60 years.

Yes by current standards it’s morally questionable but my GF is a wonderful man, and certainly not a creep. Things are what they are. If you don’t feel it was problematic and you are happy together, I really wouldn’t waste time examining the past.

missmollygreen · 29/05/2023 11:46

You were 18, old enough to vote, die for your country, get a mortgage so im pretty sure you were also old enough to know if you liked someone or not.
And you are now married with children, so it obviously worked out well.

Obviously context is everything, if he had been your teacher and groomed you from a young age then it would be bad.
But two consenting adults.... come on.

readbooksdrinktea · 29/05/2023 11:44

Elior · 29/05/2023 11:35

Imagine if it became an unwritten law that you could only date people of your age - not younger, not older? It would be so, so dull.

Yes!

DontGoThereYet · 29/05/2023 11:39

My 18y is in the middle of her A Levels. If a 23 plus bloke expressed an interest in her, I would think he was odd and why couldn’t he find someone at his own life stage. Over 30 and I would definitely think he was a creep.

SerafinasGoose · 29/05/2023 11:38

Eighteen is of adult age. You're not just over the age of consent at that age; you're of an age of legal autonomy and responsibility.

But context is everything. If this had been your schoolteacher who'd known you since the age of 11, your neighbour who had watched you grow up, your school mate's dad, your older babysitter from when you were a young child - you get the picture - there's something insidiously creepy and predatory about a man of that age striking up a relationship with an 18-year-old.

It's about the balance of power, and the propensity on the part of some males to abuse it.

Elfidela1980 · 29/05/2023 11:37

Same sort of thing, but with a sixteen year age gap. He was my graduate employer. It was shit-show, but entirely consensual, initiated by him asking me out. Our relationship ended after he impregnated another woman, and he told me to find another job! Basically a walking cautionary cliché 🤪

I’m now in the same age group he was and I do wonder. From my POV I guess I was flattered and naive (21) and came from an abusive household. I didn’t have the life experience or support to know it wasn’t very likely to be everlasting love. It’s clearly not a crime but in retrospect it was an epic mess waiting to happen. I know if the same thing happened now our professional body would want a stern word with him about his conduct. Happily, I doubt it would happen much now, perception of these sort of relationships has changed a lot.

I suspect had we stayed together like you OP, I’d have thought it was a wonderful love story between two people who were meant to be, after all, nobody got lied to or professionally disadvantaged and it worked out great in the end.

IMO an age gap isn’t automatically proof of future incompatibility or the younger partner being taken advantage of; I have a colleague who is twenty years happily married to her former driving instructor (he’s 25 years older!) If my late thirties pal came home with a a 21 y.o employee I wouldn’t necessarily assume they were a power-wielding creep but I’d wonder about the appeal. If they’d known the young person as a child I’d have much more grave concerns.

Elior · 29/05/2023 11:35

Imagine if it became an unwritten law that you could only date people of your age - not younger, not older? It would be so, so dull.

Hellno45 · 29/05/2023 11:33

I wouldn't apply today's norms and values to your relationship. However, if you feel like you were exploited or groomed them maybe you could dicuss that in counselling so you can express those thoughts.

I was 21 when I dated a man older than my mum. He was in his mid 40s. We met in the pub. We were friends and then lovers. I genuinely lived him and moved in with him. I would have married him if he was prepared to have more children. He had a 10 and 12 year old. I still think fondly of him. He in no way exploited me. It was a very mutual relationship.

DontGoThereYet · 29/05/2023 11:33

It’s gross. I judge the 24y going out with my friend’s 18y old. No way.

PiperHarris · 29/05/2023 11:29

I met a 30 year-old man at work when I was 18 and temping before university. Everyone - not least my parents - was horrified until they met him and then they loved him too. We were together for 8 years and he was and is a lovely man. We are both happily married to other people now. I did not miss out anything by being with him - on the contrary, I gained a lot from the relationship.

StopStartStop · 29/05/2023 11:21

Oh, this is getting me down now.

Stop it. Just stop.

It's not weird to have an older partner. Some cultures are set up like that. You don't marry your age-mates, you marry the next generation up, because they are in a better position to support a family.

When I was 22 I had a lovely affair with a man of 46. At 65 I remember him, fondly. He wasn't a pervert, he was a nice man who couldn't believe his luck. My most recent love-interest (just ended) is nineteen years younger than me which makes him... very neatly...46.

At fifteen or sixteen I'd have been happy to marry an older man and get on with my life but I was stuck in school because that's how we do it here, keeping young adults as children until their mid-twenties.

You people are the weird ones. Not every age-gap relationship is perverted.

And, what @Elior said.

barmycatmum · 29/05/2023 11:21

I was absolutely head over heels for a 32 year old man when I was 18. Nothing happened except a close mentorship/friendship, but if it had, at age 50 now, I still wouldn’t feel weird about it.
he was a gentle soul, and the power differential wasn’t huge, as he was very shy / late bloomer.

I think if you do not feel an imbalance in the power between you, it’s fine

BigglyBee · 29/05/2023 11:20

When I was 18, I had a relationship with a man who was 31. I had a great time, he was a cracking shag, and he remained a supportive friend until we lost touch many years later and I don't regret a thing about it. We got engaged at one point, but had to keep it a secret because my dad was his boss and would have made his life miserable,

Recently, I googled his name and the only thing that came up was an award for gallantry in Afghanistan. He doesn't seem to have any SM (which fits exactly with what I know about him), but I wish he did because I would love to see him again.

OP, your relative ages don't make your relationship wrong or abusive. If you feel good about the relationship, then the likelihood is that it's fine. My husband is 22 years older than me, and when I got to the age I was when we married, I did wonder about what he saw in someone so much younger than him (because I couldn't imagine being attracted to a 20 year old man). Maybe some aspects of the situation weren't healthy, I don't know. But we made the best decisions for ourselves at that time. Since we've been married for 30 years now, and are likely to remain married until one of us dies, it doesn't seem like we did such a bad job of choosing each other.

gogohmm · 29/05/2023 11:17

A 13 year age gap is not that common but hardly that unusual either - you were 18, not a child and from your op you knew what you wanted rather than the other way around. Yes we need to protect young people from predatory adults but at some point we also need to allow consenting adults to make their own choices. In the past 13 years between spouses wasn't uncommon as men went to war/built careers before settling down, but the emphasis on virginity meant young brides were preferable in upper class/middle classes, Dp's parents were 15 years apart, his grandparents 20, men older of course

DeliciouslyDecadent · 29/05/2023 11:13

When I read the title, that song came into my mind 'She was 31 I was 17'...who was it? 'When the sun rose I was a man...'

Elior · 29/05/2023 11:09

The legal cut off is eighteen and you were eighteen. Imagine if everyone in an age gap relationship which started after they turned into an adult was influenced by media coverage of Schofield and started revising their feelings about their long term relationships?

Cailin66 · 29/05/2023 11:04

Hongkongsuey · 29/05/2023 11:01

My daughter and Ihave different opinions on things like this. Mine is that if an 18 year old likes a 30 year old so what? Hers is that it’s verging on being a nonce! I think it’s because 18 year olds are viewed differently now-many are still treated like children. Whereas when I was young, you were expected to be a responsible adult.

My kids are the same, they think it's gross. They spout a lot of nonsense for young adults. I've one back living with me for the summer and it's amazing how they revert into being babies around me. The rest of the time it's about how wrong I am on everything because they know better as they are adults. One thing for certain, I'm always wrong.

Twanky · 29/05/2023 11:03

SoupDragon · 29/05/2023 09:15

no it doesn't. There's nothing odd about the phrasing whatsoever.

It's only odd to the many on this site who like to twist everything to suit their purposes.

Cailin66 · 29/05/2023 11:02

UptownFuckYouUp · 29/05/2023 10:59

For those asking - I have no idea what I want from this thread. Just thinking out loud, sorry.

So you were bored. Well you certainly got this place going. My parents in law had a 20 year gap. Never met them but she died way before him.

Hongkongsuey · 29/05/2023 11:01

My daughter and Ihave different opinions on things like this. Mine is that if an 18 year old likes a 30 year old so what? Hers is that it’s verging on being a nonce! I think it’s because 18 year olds are viewed differently now-many are still treated like children. Whereas when I was young, you were expected to be a responsible adult.

90schickk · 29/05/2023 11:01

My husband is 17yrs older than me, I was 22 when we met and we got together a couple of years later.

I don’t feel wrong at all…two legal adults.

PrincessScarlett · 29/05/2023 10:59

It's not the age gap that is the issue, it's whether the older party knew the younger party as a child and/or whether the older party was/is in a position of authority. This doesn't seem to be the case here OP.

I went to uni with someone aged 18 who was in a relationship with her teacher who was nearing 40. Relationship didn't start until she left school (apparently) but he had been teaching her throughout her teenage years. We all questioned them both at the time it didn't sit right. He was very odd, visiting every weekend and hanging out with 18 year olds.

UptownFuckYouUp · 29/05/2023 10:59

For those asking - I have no idea what I want from this thread. Just thinking out loud, sorry.

OP posts:
ShandaLear · 29/05/2023 10:55

Meh, you were both adults and there was no power disparity. Generally speaking, if large age gaps (e.g. 10+ years) were problematic we would be pointing fingers at most Hollywood marriages - but we don’t. Nobody bats an eye at Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively, or Jay-z and Beyoncé, or George and Amal Clooney. If you’re happy you’re happy. If not, is it possible you’re looking at the age gap as a reason to exit from the relationship?

LumpySpaceGoddess · 29/05/2023 10:54

I have mixed feelings, my grandparents had a 20 year age gap, they loved one another and had a long life together and my nan never seemed 20 years younger so it wasn’t until I was older that I learnt she had married my grandad when she was just a teenager and he was in his 30’s.

I don’t think I’d ever be comfortable with such a large age gap personally, mainly due to the different stages each person will be in, an 18 year old should be trying to find themselves, travelling, studying, having fun not settling down with a fully grown adult who has had so much more life experience, it just doesn’t sit right with me BUT other people’s life choices don’t affect me and surely if you are happy and there’s no abuse and you feel equal to your partner then surely it shouldn’t matter?