Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In tears all day, flashbacks to fucking up awful final hours of Mum's cancer, starting to drink

137 replies

PleaseMakeItGoAway · 28/05/2023 22:23

I need to make it stop. I'm tearful all day over loads of stuff around her death really but at the back of it is the awful thing that happened when Mum was dying.

She choked and made a noise like drowning, like she was afraid. I didn't try to roll her on her side in case I made it all worse. I didn't try to roll her because when she was conscious, she was uncomfortable even gingerly lying on her side.

This was because she had huge tumours all through her abdomen and I was fucking afraid that the vascularised tumours would rupture and haemorrhage, or that there would be a massive variceal bleed.

So she choked and I didn't do anything but call for the hospice nurse, and now how do I live with that for the rest of my life? How am I supposed to do that?

I have poured myself a drink to make it stop but I can't obviously do this very often. I'm in counselling but a therapist can't make what I have done (or failed to do) not be the reality.

OP posts:
SayItStraight · 29/05/2023 00:45

I'm really sorry your Mum's passing has been so traumatic.

I’ve been with more people professionally at end of life than I can count, and I am surprised that you have not experienced this in death before. It's ready normal.

You did the right thing not to move your Mum. It could have furthered her distress and you spared her that. It also could have made the noises worse and you would have blamed yourself (even though that too, would not have been your fault).

I'm sure you are aware that anger is part of the grief cycle and you sound very angry and upset with yourself. But I would gently suggest you are kind to yourself over this. You were really brave to be there for your Mum in her last moments like that. She would not want you to carry this self-blame. Get as much rest as you can, for now. And just know death is sometimes awful, you did nothing wrong and everything right.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 29/05/2023 00:40

Just chiming in to agree that you did nothing wrong, you have nothing to blame yourself for. My mum died of cancer, those last 48 hours were rough.

You hear about the death rattle, but you're not prepared for it. With my mum, it sometimes sounded like she was trying to talk, she got agitated sometimes. She wasn't aware of anything, the drugs she was on saw to that.

You thought your Mum was in distress, so you called for the hospice nurse, the person who has been through this process a million times, the person with the most experience. Your mum needed help, so you shouted for the person most able to help her. That was the correct thing to do.

Your Mum probably wasn't aware of anything that happened to her in that last day, but if she was, it would have been that you were there, and that you loved her. She won't have known that you were scared, that you were worried about doing the wrong thing, just that you were there for her.

BetiYeti · 29/05/2023 00:37

My mum made awful sounds at the end. No one prepares you for it. I was wracked with guilt and fear over mum’s last days. Kept thinking about what I could have done differently. Time is making the memories less vivid and less painful. Take care OP. Have a drink and try and push some of the difficult memories to one side to give yourself a break x

BlueFlint · 29/05/2023 00:27

Oh OP. It's absolutely NOT your fault. Death can be utterly awful to watch but I think what you described is not necessarily uncommon. I had a similar experience when my Mum died and it was traumatising, despite being prepared for it (not by hospital staff, I just did a lot of morbid reading up). Please please don't blame yourself, I'd imagine your dear Mum was much less aware of it than you were and I'm sure you did the right thing in calling for help rather than trying to move her by yourself. I spent weeks and months going over things in my mind after losing my Mum. Eventually the awfulness does start to fade, I promise - you do learn to live alongside it. I'm so sorry for your loss. Please take care of yourself, and if you don't mind me saying - do try to be careful with self medicating with booze, it may feel it helps in the moment but isn't ideal longer term (speaking from experience here).

CJat10 · 28/05/2023 23:55

I struggled with PTSD after a family member's death. It was horrific. She was drowning from secretions and gurgling for hours and hours. I called the hospice (who had previously been unhelpful and unwilling to be involved until she was closer to death...yes really) They rolled her which made things 100 times worse. She woke and panicked grasping me and trying to plead for help. I wish I'd never let the nurses move her. Point of my tale is no matter what you did you'd be struggling. So dismiss the guilt and deal with grief and trauma.

I started anti depressants and tbh its been the only thing to help me cope

adrem · 28/05/2023 23:52

I’ve had 2 relatives do this.
The first time was a real shock but the nurses told me it’s very normal, like a final burst of breathe.

My mums death was really traumatic as she was scared of dying and seemed to be fight it.

I and a nurse moved the bed to face out through the French doors ( traditional thing to do, for the soul to be free ) and she freaked out and made that weird noise. I blamed myself too but the nurses really did reassure me it was normal.

My grandad also made the noise when we put his left hand in the arm of his robe ( an Opus Dei tradition we had to follow ) and again turned the bed.

Being there when your loved ones pass is horrible and I hope you have someone to support you now but nothing you did was your fault. You were there for them.

Beseen22 · 28/05/2023 23:51

I'm a palliative care nurse. It's difficult to say but it sounds to me similar to a loss of ability to control oral secretions and it can be an incredibly distressing uncomfortable noise. Sadly not every death is peaceful and sometimes there are symptoms that have to be controlled even right at the very last stage. In all honesty once that noise is there we can give medicine to dry up secretions and we can as a last resort suction but it's going to continue. It's not distressing to the patient but so so distressing to family. Repositioning would have helped drain the fluid away but it wouldn't have made a massive difference. I think it is commendable that you were with your mum right to the end and from the sound of it at home and gave her her final wishes although it was very worrying for you. I do believe that even while unconscious that people are aware of who is there.

Have you reached out to GP? I'm not sure how long ago you lost your mum but if this flashbacks are going I would definitely recommend speaking to your GP.

I have a video to share by an amazing palliative care Dr on the process of dying, I found it incredibly comforting. I find it so sad that we have birth doulas and birth debriefs but no similar service for death.

What happens as we die? | Kathryn Mannix | TEDxNewcastle

Most of us have never seen anyone die. Few have any idea what to expect as death approaches, and most have unrealistic fears about it. Kathryn wants to chang...

https://youtu.be/CZDDByT0Vr0

mellicauli · 28/05/2023 23:51

I guess we like to see ourselves as agents but in this circumstance you were just a witness. A witness to a terrible, sad event. You didn't cause the cancer and no one could cure the cancer. You are not medically qualified, so you called someone who was better qualified to tend to your Mother. This was the right thing to do and all you could reasonably be expected to do in the circumstance. Because you didn't know the right thing to do and you didn't want to hurt your Mother. And you have no medical expertise.

pbdr · 28/05/2023 23:43

I'm a doctor, and I've looked after countless patients at the end of life. Choking/gurgling/vocalisations are very common in a person's final hours. They can be an indication that the person is becoming less conscious and are no longer protecting their airway. It's highly likely that your mum was unaware of what was happening, but it can still be very distressing for you to witness. If your mum had previously had pain/discomfort being on her side you absolutely made the right call in not moving her. I don't know if she would still have been able to feel any pain by that stage but it's not worth taking the risk, and moving her would not ultimately have made any difference. You were right to call the hospice nurse.
For what it is worth, if I found myself in the same situation with my own mum I would do exactly what you did. You have not let her down at all, you've just endured the horrible experience of having to see your mum die, and while it is natural to feel you should have protected her from everything that happened, the sad reality is that that is not in your power. I have little doubt that if your mum could read this post she would be the first to reassure you that you did everything that could be done for her at the end. You were there for her, and while you couldn't fix it (because it couldn't be fixed) you stuck by her so that she didn't have to go through it alone.
You should be feeling proud of yourself, not guilty. I hope you find some peace.

SoShallINever · 28/05/2023 23:41

God I feel for you.
Lost my mum 6 months ago. Also in a hospice.
The end was horrific, and I also feel I let her down badly. One thing I'm sure of though lovely, is that they wouldn't want us turning to alcohol.
And God knows I've downed a lot more winecthan is good for me recently.

Zarataralara · 28/05/2023 23:40

PleaseMakeItGoAway · 28/05/2023 23:03

Seek comfort from friends, family, your community, your doctor or counsellor, whoever can give you comfort

I can't because I feel I don't deserve it because I let her down.

Well, my counsellor yes I can weep openly with her. But I don't want to worry my partner or my best friend, and I don't deserve comfort anyway.

But you do. Would your mum want you to feel like this and not have anyone comfort you?
Grief does horrible, weird things to you. I had “ flashbacks” to my dh’s accident — I wasn’t there yet in my head I saw it all clearly. I went over and over it for months. I was told this was my brain trying to make sense of an event that didn’t really have any sense.
Can you talk to someone at McMillan or at the hospice? Or keep talking to your counsellor.
I really hope you find peace, you really do deserve it. I’m so sorry for your loss.

silverlentils · 28/05/2023 23:39

silverlentils · 28/05/2023 23:38

I am so very sorry for your loss and how traumatic it has been for you. You did EXACTLY the right thing, which was to call a nurse, you could not have done anything else.

I think this type of trauma response is your brains way of going in a loop trying to find a way to make the person live, it's known as the bargaining stage of grief...if I could go back and do x or y they could still live, I would have some power to make them be alive.

It was totally out of your hands though, as it is for all of us when that time comes. There are very few things in life we have no control over which is hard for us, as humans, to comprehend, but death is one of them.

Please know that this is a stage of grieving and have a drink and if there is one thing I'm sure of, your mum wants you to have a good life and a happy one. The suggestions to speak to Macmillan or a grief counselling service are good ones.
And I am sorry for what a phone nurse told you before, but she was wrong - calling a nurse in that situation was the only thing you could have done and the exact right thing.

Sorry that should have read 'have one drink tonight and then stop, because if there is one thing I'm sure of...."

SootysCaravan · 28/05/2023 23:39

So sorry for your loss OP. It sounds like you did exactly what your dear Mum would’ve wanted by staying by her side. Please be kind to yourself and don’t allow those final moments to override a lifetime of happy memories

Babyroobs · 28/05/2023 23:38

It sounds like your mum was just too weak to clear the secretions and even with drugs to dry up the secretions, they don't always work so even if you had requested drugs to help there is no guarantee they would work. End of life secretions don't generally distress the dying person, it is more distressing for the person having to watch and listen. Sometimes turning makes things worse, sometimes helps a little but again there's no guarantee and can distress someone further to turn them at this stage. Please don't beat yourself up about this. I've witnessed a lot of deaths that sounds similar to your mums and it sounds as though nothing would have altered things. She is at peace now and would not want you to be distressed over this. I hope you have people for support.

silverlentils · 28/05/2023 23:38

I am so very sorry for your loss and how traumatic it has been for you. You did EXACTLY the right thing, which was to call a nurse, you could not have done anything else.

I think this type of trauma response is your brains way of going in a loop trying to find a way to make the person live, it's known as the bargaining stage of grief...if I could go back and do x or y they could still live, I would have some power to make them be alive.

It was totally out of your hands though, as it is for all of us when that time comes. There are very few things in life we have no control over which is hard for us, as humans, to comprehend, but death is one of them.

Please know that this is a stage of grieving and have a drink and if there is one thing I'm sure of, your mum wants you to have a good life and a happy one. The suggestions to speak to Macmillan or a grief counselling service are good ones.
And I am sorry for what a phone nurse told you before, but she was wrong - calling a nurse in that situation was the only thing you could have done and the exact right thing.

ThreeLocusts · 28/05/2023 23:36

O just to say you do deserve solace. You were there with her, you subjected yourself to witnessing this. You acted on the information yu had. Be kind to yourself, you deserve it.

Mirabai · 28/05/2023 23:34

Oh OP, it was just the death rattle, it’s different in different people. You did exactly the right thing.

Your mum would be so sad to see you torturing yourself like this. Try to get some peace. x

Xrays · 28/05/2023 23:31

PleaseMakeItGoAway · 28/05/2023 23:15

I have heard terminal secretions before though and they didn't have the sound and tone of the person's own distinctive voice throughout the gurgling and rasping. That's happened twice before that I have experienced.

This sounded different.

But, I do respect that people are saying each death is very different so perhaps that's why.

The death rattle is very common. And yes sometimes you do hear what seems to be their voice. It’s not that unusual.

When my Mum was right at the end I do believe she was semi conscious even though the nurses kept telling me she wasn’t. I honestly think they wanted me to believe that because they were trying to make me feel better, and I understand that but I know my Mum and when I walked into her room and saw her, mouth open, rattling sounds, gurgling, I also could feel her anger coming through in the noises- it’s hard to explain but she was a very angry person all her life and I could hear the same sorts of noises and feel the same anger from her in those moments. I think she was angry with the nurses for not sorting her pain relief out properly and she was angry with them for letting me see her like that. I could truly sense that. I was very upset by seeing her like that and sat outside her room on the floor, torn between staying and knowing if I stayed I’d be further traumatised. So I decided to go. And I had no idea if that was the right thing to do or not but she died an hour later. Apparently it’s quite common for people to wait for everyone to leave to then die.

4 years on and I still think about it a lot, all the should I have done xyz etc but it’s not going to change anything.

Until people have been through it they really won’t understand. It is life changing. But not ending. Yours didn’t end when hers did.

Ivyiris · 28/05/2023 23:29

As someone who nurses people at end of life, you absolutely done the right thing. For us it sounds horrible but to them they wouldn't be aware. Hope you get some closure on this in time, may be worth speaking to someone from palliative care. So sorry for your loss

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 28/05/2023 23:17

This reminds me of my FILs death from cancer. It was loud, it was hard to witness. I think what you describe even has a name, the death rattle. It is a normal part of the dying process but my God it was hard to watch. I don't think he had any idea of what was going on and that's not defensive hope speaking, that is genuinely my opinion. DH still gets very upset 3 years on, understandably. And yes i think vocal chords could be activated as you describe.

I'm very sorry for your loss.

PleaseMakeItGoAway · 28/05/2023 23:15

DoughnutDreams · 28/05/2023 23:08

It is likely to have been terminal secretions, which can sound like choking or drowning, but is really just air gargling over fluids in a relaxed throat. The person isn't suffering or distressed. In fact, it comes because the person is so close to death that their brain isn't signalling to swallow and isn't conscious of it.

I have heard terminal secretions before though and they didn't have the sound and tone of the person's own distinctive voice throughout the gurgling and rasping. That's happened twice before that I have experienced.

This sounded different.

But, I do respect that people are saying each death is very different so perhaps that's why.

OP posts:
FiveShelties · 28/05/2023 23:12

I am sure your Mum would not want you to feel like this.

It is tough losing your Mum, my Mum died two weeks ago and even though I knew she was on end of life care it was still a shock. You need to remember the good times and remember your Mum as she would like you to remember her.

Irisheyesareshining · 28/05/2023 23:11

I tried to give my dad a drink the night before he died of terminal prostate cancer. He was so thirsty and has sadly lost his ability to speak. I remember so well saying dad are you thirsty and him choking on the water . It’s taken me a long time to realise it’s nobody’s fault 😢

GulesMeansRed · 28/05/2023 23:11

And for others reading this thread - OP made the decision she wanted to stay until the end and be there and that was the right decision for her. For us, the right decision was for us to take mum home, watch rubbish telly, switch the phone off and call back in the morning.

You don't have to be with a loved one to the end. It's OK to be a bit selfish and protect yourself from what the OP is going through. In many cases the person who is dying will be unconscious and unaware if you're there or not. Make the right decisions for you and your family, take advice from the medical staff and don't be guilted into staying unless you really want to.

I do think you should share how you are feeling OP. You don't need to spill your guts but you owe it to your partner at least to tell him that you are struggling to come to terms with the last minutes of your mother's life.

Cruse helpline :

Helpline - Cruse Bereavement Support

Our Helpline volunteers are here to help you make sense of how you're feeling.

https://www.cruse.org.uk/get-support/helpline

Domino20 · 28/05/2023 23:08

The way people with terminal illnesses are treated in this country is appalling and NONE of that is your fault.