Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or should DH’s ex back off ?

187 replies

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 21:58

I Married my husband 4 years ago. He has 3 children with his ex. He was with ex partner 15 years. His ex has few family members in the UK.

The issue for me is that My husbands ex hosts events which me and DH aren’t invited to but all my in laws are invited too.
E.g - BBQs, Christmas parties, Birthday Parties, Summer parties, Platinum Jubilee, Easter lunch .
These parties are basically just her, her new husband and my in-laws.

I find it sad that she invites my husbands family but not us . I understand she has known my husbands family for many years and they are her children’s grandparents and aunts and uncles but I find it so frustrating that my husband and I are not invited .

For example , It is Christmas Eve and we can’t see in-laws as they are going to a
Meal at husbands ex house which we aren’t invited to.
I know DH would absolutely love to attend as he wants to see his children as much as possible. We are just around the corner but on our own as we haven’t been asked along.

My husband has no problem with this and is just happy his children have a great relationship with his family. He is happy his ex has his family to support her.

I have a great relationship with my husbands family and we do all meet up together. His parents are extremely welcoming to me and I adore them . They are really lovely people .

So here is my issue .
I feel that his ex won’t let go of DH’s family and I wish she would move on . It seems (to me) slightly competitive that she will host a party so that DH and I will be excluded . E.g - she will have an Easter Feast - meaning DH and I can’t see his family or his children as we won’t be invited to the party.

She is remarried . So why does she keep inviting DHs family over ? I wonder if her new partner always wants her exs family over?

I can’t work out if i ABU or if husbands ex is just being manipulative or if she is doing nothing wrong !? On occasions when I did meet her she was very rude to me . I ignored this but I immediately felt she had an agenda.

Next week BIL is over from France for 3
nights in UK. The one night he is in town - We have been told that husbands Ex is hosting a dinner party for everyone but of course me and DH aren’t invited ! It’s DHs bloody brother !!!

I don’t want to become obsessed and bitter . I have a lovely Husband and children ( 3 myself with DH) and my in-laws are lovely to me .

OP posts:
Fedupofdiets · 29/05/2023 07:23

Yanbu it is a weird situation indeed. Lovely that she is still friendly with the ex in laws but dominating the social situations is out of order. Your DH needs to step in.

P1ckledonionz · 29/05/2023 07:22

It sounds as if 20 years and three children had already happened and you have married into a preexisting dynamic that involves a lot of already established relationships. I can understand your frustration but I think people often underestimate the primal connections that are forged between family members when a couple share children, and these connections cannot be undone easily.

MaPaSpa · 29/05/2023 07:13

Op how old are your kids and how old are hers? Because you say you’ve been together for 4 years and have 3 kids ? So I imagine they’re all baby to toddler is that why they’re not going to parties with their siblings?

I can see that Ex could very possible have an angle in trying to take all the occasions but it also seems like she’s one of those people who like to host if she does so many?

do you want to go? Or do you just want in-laws not to? I think that’s the issue.

May the end of the day no one is a mind reader and if your DH thinks it’s normal and doesn’t see an issue it may be hard to change the dynamic. But it’s not weird for you and him not to be invited tbh or that IN-laws are.

I think she should be sharing the kids special occasions though.

twigy100 · 29/05/2023 07:12

Have you thought about saying that you want to host the party as you want to spend time with BIL and family but invite ex and children also so no one misses out. Instead of being you vs ex try and build a relationship. It might not work but don't know until you try.

JulieHoney · 29/05/2023 07:11

YABU - they clearly love her and she loves them. That she and their son broke up doesn’t mean the family and the ex can’t remain close; they’ve been her family for 20 years.

She’s the type of person who likes to host parties. That’s not going to change.

You’ve been with your DH for only 4 years and you have 3 children together? I’m not surprised you aren’t at the hosting parties stage yourselves, you must be run ragged.

WeAreTheHeroes · 29/05/2023 07:06

SchoolShenanigans · 28/05/2023 22:19

I find it stranger that they accept all of the invitations without asking you guys what you're up to.

And why are the kids with her for every special occasion?

Absolutely this. Your DH needs to discuss with her who is doing what well in advance and divvying up the family occasions.

When do your kids see what is their family too?

It's quite possible his parents disapprove of what your DH did when he left his previous partner and that's why they keep going to hers instead of asking what you are doing. They don't blame you btw they just aren't realising the impact.

SidekickSylvia · 29/05/2023 07:00

Pteryl · 28/05/2023 22:57

But the dad isn’t there either? I wouldn’t expect my husband’s ex-wife to invite my children to a party if their father wasn’t even invited. That would be more odd. I would have my own party, invite my children and family, my step children and family, and some friends.

But that's the thing. If his family spent special occasions with op and her husband, they would be spending it with all six of his children and their son/brother/uncle, instead of just the 3 older children and his ex wife. Because his 3 older children can come to his house, but his 3 younger children can't go to his ex wife's.

It's not right, op.

Goneblank38 · 29/05/2023 06:59

I don't hink you're ebony unreasonable either - it seems excessive to me. But..your husband sounds really passive. Like he's happy for her to arrange all of these lovely events for the kids and extended family rather than pushing for shared time over holidays, arranging parties and having a word to his parents about his wishes. If it bothers him too, he really needs to talk to his family about it and make alternate plans to bring everyone together.

Feelinadequate23 · 29/05/2023 06:56

YANBU this is seriously weird from both ex and your DH’s family! No way would my parents go to a party my ex was throwing instead of seeing me!

Flopsythebunny · 29/05/2023 06:56

Alainlechat · 29/05/2023 06:51

A lot of posters are saying you are the one who is unreasonable but in real life I don't know anyone who is in a situation like this.

It would be down to the DH to ensure his family had a continued relationship with his children.

What about the ex's relationship with the in-laws? Are they supposed to abandon her after having a close relationship with her for so long?
It was their son who decided to move on, not them

Tadah2 · 29/05/2023 06:55

I don’t think you are being unreasonable, they are equally his children too. His family is getting all these memories and your husband is missing out. If this was the other way around, and a husband invited his ex-wives family to loads of events and excluded his ex-wife (in days that weren’t always days he had the children), I think lots of people would have something to say about it. I do think it’s more of a husband and family issue though (than the ex).

I would host events on the days you have the children and say it’s an all day thing, early afternoon- kids bedtime. Although, unlike others, I wouldn’t invite the ex - she clearly doesn’t want to socialise with you guys.

MintJulia · 29/05/2023 06:54

Ontheperiphery79 · 28/05/2023 22:02

Why on earth would she want her ex and you at any event she is hosting?!
I think it's great that she's maintained good relationships with her children's family.
If your husband has an issue with it, he can talk to his family about it.

This. You aren't part of her friendship group and I'm sure your dh has no desire to spend his leisure time with his ex-wife. Or she,him.

She's inviting her children's family to family gatherings. That's a good thing. Polite, positive, optimistic.

There's nothing to stop you hosting similar parties. Do you issue the same sort of invitations?

Flopsythebunny · 29/05/2023 06:53

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 22:20

We will see BIL for a coffee before he heads off to the party.
I can’t work out if everyone feels obligated to go as they don’t want to offend her or they will really enjoy it and just don’t worry that their brother / son isn’t invited .

DHs parents are extremely well educated and I just can’t understand how they don’t feel sympathy for their son who is not invited to events ( Christmas Eve / Easter / childrens birthday ) yet they are . They are spending these days with their sons children but their son isn’t Invited .

It sounds like they like her and her husband's company.
The children are old enough to choose for themselves where they spend special occasions.

Alainlechat · 29/05/2023 06:51

A lot of posters are saying you are the one who is unreasonable but in real life I don't know anyone who is in a situation like this.

It would be down to the DH to ensure his family had a continued relationship with his children.

electriclight · 29/05/2023 06:45

I do not find ex's actions odd at all.

She has a relationship with your DP's family that is independent of him. The relationship grew over 20 years, was made more special by the fact that she doesn't have family nearby, and I imagine is more like friendship now.

Of course she doesn't invite you and your DP. It would be quite unusual to invite your xh and his wife to your party.

I think they probably really love her don't you, and enjoy her company. If they didn't, they'd make an excuse and say no. Maybe they'd think twice if their son or gc were unhappy about it but they're not.

If it makes you jealous and cross that they spend special occasions with her, get your invitations out first.

Flopsythebunny · 29/05/2023 06:44

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 22:05

Why would she and her new husband want Her exs family at all events ??

im not trying to argue just can’t understand it !

Because they are her children's family and were her family for over 15 years and it sounds like they all love her. That's not something you just throw away.
However much you want to, you cannot just whitewash her out of your in-laws life.
Host your own parties when it's your husband's weekends with the children and keep your neb out of her relationship with the in-laws.

HelloThereChatGBT · 29/05/2023 06:09

YANBU. His family are being very weird not advocating for his inclusion, but that’s on him to say.

I do like @McKenzieFriend001 ’s idea to host something and invite her.

Haywirecity · 29/05/2023 06:07

Why didn't you or your husbands family organise a meal for your brother in law? Then your husband's ex would be too late?

EllandRd · 29/05/2023 06:05

YABU, why on Earth do you think she should invite you? How strange.

Mintyt · 29/05/2023 05:59

I wouldn't like it and to me it seems unkind, her excluded you (no threat to her) the children's father and her children's siblings. It's either very innocent or very callous. Can your husband speak to her along the lines of can you invite us, then you will be able to tell if this behaviour is unkind or without thinking

McKenzieFriend001 · 28/05/2023 23:18

@Cocolocobaby would you and your husband consider hosting a party and inviting the children's mum? Maybe if you offer the olive branch first she might get the idea you are as approachable as the rest of the tribe.

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 23:15

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 28/05/2023 23:09

If they are bagsying all the special occasions then DH should speak to his parents about splitting their time between all their grandchildren. I think coming to yours for a bbq and not eating much then heading off to hers later is quite rude. I can understand why this is hurtful. I think it is fine for her to invite them to things but i find it weird your inlaws aren't considering your family too since you say you have a good relationship with them. And i still think his brother accepting her throwing a party that your dh won't be at is very strange.

I find it strange too
. I wonder if people feel
obliged to go to every event . Does
DH feel he can’t say no .

but I’ll never know!!

OP posts:
Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 23:12

McKenzieFriend001 · 28/05/2023 23:04

How old are his children?

Bloody ridiculous I say that his ex has been handed the monopoly on the children's time and on all special occasions: he's obviously quite happy with this set up, because there doesn't seem to be a court order in place, and 2/14 is the bare minimum a non-resident parent can actually, well, parent.

No wonder his family get invited to all the parties and special occasions: and go. If he's never stepped up as a father and created his own traditions with the children on special occasions, there's nothing to host...

They stay here 2 nights out of 7. Come
over whenever they fancy for dinner . Kids adore their dad.
Kids teenagers so like being at home in their rooms . They live in a beautiful home as DH happily walked away from it so his children Could stay in it. He is a lovely bloke . I am the one who finds this all odd.
when I asked DH why this doesn’t bother him /
he just said that his parents don’t want to rock the boat so go along and who is he to stop it all ! He is happy. The kids are happy. It’s me who is questioning it.

OP posts:
Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 28/05/2023 23:09

If they are bagsying all the special occasions then DH should speak to his parents about splitting their time between all their grandchildren. I think coming to yours for a bbq and not eating much then heading off to hers later is quite rude. I can understand why this is hurtful. I think it is fine for her to invite them to things but i find it weird your inlaws aren't considering your family too since you say you have a good relationship with them. And i still think his brother accepting her throwing a party that your dh won't be at is very strange.

McKenzieFriend001 · 28/05/2023 23:04

How old are his children?

Bloody ridiculous I say that his ex has been handed the monopoly on the children's time and on all special occasions: he's obviously quite happy with this set up, because there doesn't seem to be a court order in place, and 2/14 is the bare minimum a non-resident parent can actually, well, parent.

No wonder his family get invited to all the parties and special occasions: and go. If he's never stepped up as a father and created his own traditions with the children on special occasions, there's nothing to host...

Swipe left for the next trending thread