Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or should DH’s ex back off ?

187 replies

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 21:58

I Married my husband 4 years ago. He has 3 children with his ex. He was with ex partner 15 years. His ex has few family members in the UK.

The issue for me is that My husbands ex hosts events which me and DH aren’t invited to but all my in laws are invited too.
E.g - BBQs, Christmas parties, Birthday Parties, Summer parties, Platinum Jubilee, Easter lunch .
These parties are basically just her, her new husband and my in-laws.

I find it sad that she invites my husbands family but not us . I understand she has known my husbands family for many years and they are her children’s grandparents and aunts and uncles but I find it so frustrating that my husband and I are not invited .

For example , It is Christmas Eve and we can’t see in-laws as they are going to a
Meal at husbands ex house which we aren’t invited to.
I know DH would absolutely love to attend as he wants to see his children as much as possible. We are just around the corner but on our own as we haven’t been asked along.

My husband has no problem with this and is just happy his children have a great relationship with his family. He is happy his ex has his family to support her.

I have a great relationship with my husbands family and we do all meet up together. His parents are extremely welcoming to me and I adore them . They are really lovely people .

So here is my issue .
I feel that his ex won’t let go of DH’s family and I wish she would move on . It seems (to me) slightly competitive that she will host a party so that DH and I will be excluded . E.g - she will have an Easter Feast - meaning DH and I can’t see his family or his children as we won’t be invited to the party.

She is remarried . So why does she keep inviting DHs family over ? I wonder if her new partner always wants her exs family over?

I can’t work out if i ABU or if husbands ex is just being manipulative or if she is doing nothing wrong !? On occasions when I did meet her she was very rude to me . I ignored this but I immediately felt she had an agenda.

Next week BIL is over from France for 3
nights in UK. The one night he is in town - We have been told that husbands Ex is hosting a dinner party for everyone but of course me and DH aren’t invited ! It’s DHs bloody brother !!!

I don’t want to become obsessed and bitter . I have a lovely Husband and children ( 3 myself with DH) and my in-laws are lovely to me .

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 29/05/2023 13:13

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 22:06

I am really trying to change my mindset ! Hence the post. I suppose it just seems abit controlling to me . So that’s why i have posted to try and be open minded and see different perspectives .

What living arrangements are in place?

Don't you ever have the children on special occasions?

OhmygodDont · 29/05/2023 13:09

How often does dh throw events or even invite his family around when his older children are at yours?

Honestly this sounds lovely for the children and quite mature of the adults involved. None of this one it’s a ex we must act like she never existed even though it’s the grandchildren/niece/nephews mothers which isn’t nice for the children.

Ex sounds like a person who loves to throw a get together, she invites her children’s family, that’s understandable it makes the children happy, the family is happy.

If your dh never has the children for special occasions his not missing out because his family is there, as he wouldn’t see them anyway. His family and children however are gaining by spending time together.

What would be weirder would be inviting her ex and his wife and their children to all her gatherings. I’m sure at that point all the posts would be saying she was trying to upstage op and show she was the better host or trying to show off to her ex etc.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 29/05/2023 12:55

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 22:21

I see it as her preventing DH spending special events with his children .

But presumably your husband has them on birthdays as well (just not perhaps all day every year). What's stopping your husband organising a family get together for the kids' birthdays/Xmas (which are entirely predictable dates)?

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 29/05/2023 12:54

nevynevster · 29/05/2023 12:44

What I don't understand is why the step kids weren't invited to the lunch bbq and then there'd be no need for another evening party for the grandparents to see the grandkids

I don't get it either.

Op doesn't seem to want to organise anything, but also doesn't want the ex to either.

nevynevster · 29/05/2023 12:44

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 28/05/2023 22:33

It's not cruel, she's doing what she always does.

It sounds like she arranged her event around yours as well.

It would be very odd to invite your ex, his wife and their kids over to your home with your new husband, it's pretty normal to invite people you've known and loved for over a decade and who are related to your dc.

Your in laws sound like they are doing their best to balance everyone's needs and see all the kids regularly.

If you're not going to make the effort to arrange things then you can't really be pissed off when she does it.

What I don't understand is why the step kids weren't invited to the lunch bbq and then there'd be no need for another evening party for the grandparents to see the grandkids

beachcitygirl · 29/05/2023 11:13

Yep she's playing games.
His family should be making sure that your DH is able to see his brother. That is a ridiculous state of affairs.
You have a DH problem
You have an in-laws problem
No wonder you're annoyed, I would be too.
But
bear in mind, she's not inviting her ex's family. She's inviting her kids family.

You & DH should be arranging gatherings.
And including all the kids.
Your DH should be explaining situation to his family
Your DH should be having contact every other easter/xmas etc & you two should
Host then.

It would be nice if all 4 of the adults ie you & DH and her and DH would include the other in your events for sake of kids but that wouldn't work for everyone - I get that.

It sucks OP but be proactive

ORGANISE events yourself

TUCKINGFYP0 · 29/05/2023 10:45

So when she arranges events he says- well it’s great they will see all of my family and have fun with their mum. I accept I’ll have to wait and do a fake - Christmas / Easter celebration the next day . Which we do

and the kids are not seeing HIS family . They are seeing THEIR OWN family. They have a link with their aunts / uncles / cousins / GP that exists entirely independently of him.

TUCKINGFYP0 · 29/05/2023 10:44

Cocolocobaby · 29/05/2023 10:34

You are so wrong. He doesn’t complain as he doesn’t want the children to feel guilty or worried or sad.
He has always said - so long as the childrens mum is happy - this means the children will be happy . If the children are happy then that’s what comes first.
So when she arranges events he says- well it’s great they will see all of my family and have fun with their mum. I accept I’ll have to wait and do a fake - Christmas / Easter celebration the next day . Which we do.

its not he doesn’t want to see the children. He just doesn’t want them feeling guilty about leaving their mum to come to our house as she would make it clear she wasn’t happy with them. She can be quite controlling with the children .

Having Christmas celebrations “ the next day “ is not fake. That’s what every single separated and divorced parent in the Uk does ( except for the tiny percentage who still do these things together ).

It’s what many families up and down the country so when they can’t see their loved one on the exact day of their birthdays.

It’s what most kids do when they have their birthday party at the weekend when these birthday was midweek.

It’s what most adults do when they go out at the weekend to celebrate a birthday or anniversary.

You do sound a bit bonkers.

Are you staying that when you organise a party for your husbands birthday ( and invite all his family ) , you do this on a Monday if that’s his actual birthday rather than the weekend before or after ? Because otherwise that would be fake ?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 29/05/2023 10:36

Cocolocobaby · 29/05/2023 10:29

He is bothered about seeing his children. He adores them. Hence why we live around the corner and always see them whenever they want to come which is 2 nights bug often they pop in for dinner on other nights . They are lovely kids.
the kids and DH know that there is hell to pay’ if mum is upset . So my DH says - spend Xmas with mum - we will see you before or after. He doesn’t want kids to stress. The children come first .

@Creamyoda - you are so so wrong here. .The point is that even though DH is desperate to see the kids he waits for the day after the special events as he doesn’t want children to be put in the middle and stressed. We would not be selfish and say - if you don’t come to my house every other Christmas Day im taking your mum to court etc !

He could still do celebrations and invite his family the day before or day after, or week before or week after.

he and you could have celebrations with your kids, his kids and invite the in laws regardless.

That he has chosen not to is his choice and it’s ridiculous to expect everyone else to stop doing things just because you don’t like it.

Cocolocobaby · 29/05/2023 10:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You are so wrong. He doesn’t complain as he doesn’t want the children to feel guilty or worried or sad.
He has always said - so long as the childrens mum is happy - this means the children will be happy . If the children are happy then that’s what comes first.
So when she arranges events he says- well it’s great they will see all of my family and have fun with their mum. I accept I’ll have to wait and do a fake - Christmas / Easter celebration the next day . Which we do.

its not he doesn’t want to see the children. He just doesn’t want them feeling guilty about leaving their mum to come to our house as she would make it clear she wasn’t happy with them. She can be quite controlling with the children .

OP posts:
Cocolocobaby · 29/05/2023 10:29

Creamyoda · 29/05/2023 08:27

No she isn't, he isn't bothered about seeing his children on special occassions, this is the only chance the grandparents get to share these events with them. It's not up to OP to do anything, especially not to discuss the fact holidays are monopolised- her DH should have done that long ago.

He is bothered about seeing his children. He adores them. Hence why we live around the corner and always see them whenever they want to come which is 2 nights bug often they pop in for dinner on other nights . They are lovely kids.
the kids and DH know that there is hell to pay’ if mum is upset . So my DH says - spend Xmas with mum - we will see you before or after. He doesn’t want kids to stress. The children come first .

@Creamyoda - you are so so wrong here. .The point is that even though DH is desperate to see the kids he waits for the day after the special events as he doesn’t want children to be put in the middle and stressed. We would not be selfish and say - if you don’t come to my house every other Christmas Day im taking your mum to court etc !

OP posts:
Rudicoolcat · 29/05/2023 10:06

I think this is a 'you' thing. Your husband's family have built a very close bond with the mother of their grandchildren over the years. Why should they feel obligated to decline her offers to host family get togethers. She is still 'part of the family' by definition as mother of the grandchildren she shares with your husband.

With the greatest respect, I think it would have been something you ought to have realised when you got together with your husband. He has other children with another woman; just because his relationship broke down with her, the other family relationships don't necessarily have to. I think this is a 'what's best for the grandchildren' type situation rather than what suits the second wife.

Don't be too insecure about this. You say his family are lovely and you clearly like them very much too. He finished his romantic relationship with her and has built another with you. Trust in that.

Make your own offers to host. You can always invite her if you are feeling so inclined. But blended families always have and always will, throw up feelings like this.

Be happy that everyone is loving, kind and respectful, it could be so difficult in different circumstances.

TUCKINGFYP0 · 29/05/2023 09:58

I have a question @Cocolocobaby . You and your partner have three kids together - is that right ? So you have 5 birthdays a year, on dates that are nothing to do with his ex.

Do you arrange parties on all of these 5 dates and invite your families (including all his 6 children of course )? Do his family attend all these events that you invite them to?

Do you invite his ex ( and her husband ) as well as her children? Because you say in your OP that you want her to invite you both to her parties, so surely you should set that precedent by inviting them to these parties at your own home.

You say you find it frustrating that she doesn’t invite you and your partner . Yet you have said nothing about events that you host and invite them to.

If you want things to change , why haven’t you been inviting her?

Gothambutnotahamster · 29/05/2023 09:43

Rewis · 29/05/2023 09:17

If your husband, in laws, kids and ex are atotally fine with it then there is nothing you can do nor should do. I agree it is weird. It's one thing to be in good terms but it's another to spend Christmas together and not see other grand kids or their own child. It is also weird that BIL comes to town to see his family and has a quick coffee with his brother so he can make it to a dinner to his brothers ex partners house. But since all the main players involved think it's totally normal then just let it all play out. Just concentrate on making holiday memories with your husband and your children.

I agree with this.

CarpetSlipper · 29/05/2023 09:41

Has the ex wife always done this? Did she plan and host all parties/get togethers for the time her and your DH were together? If so, it may just be that nobody else can be arsed to put the effort in and they’re quite happy for her to carry on organising everything.

It does seem strange and your feelings are perfectly understandable but I think the solution here would be for you/your DHs family to host sometimes and invite everyone.

Privatemedical246 · 29/05/2023 09:41

I think it depends if she was the one who facilitated contact with their grandkids and the father was never that fussed then I don't blame them. It sounds like he wasn't fussed about trying to be in kids lives more by fighting for 50/50 and walking away leaving the home whilst you think was lovely of him, more sounds like he cba with having the kids 50/50 and preferred to have 5 nights to himself. It sounds the family get to see their grandkids more this way whereas if your DH only has them 2 nights a week and then this doesn't fall over occasions you would host them I can see why they want to keep a strong relationship going with the mother of their grandchildren. Why didn't he go to.court for 50/50 access? That's what I'd be expecting in place then maybe the family wouldn't feel the need to stay in contact with the ex.

thecatsthecats · 29/05/2023 09:37

TheShellBeach · 28/05/2023 22:37

Because they're her children's family.

So are the three kids OP has with her husband.

It's great that she has maintained family relationships, but ffs, she's pushing her ex and her children's half siblings out of their own family.

She should either include them (if she's so into maintaining family relationships) or back the fuck off just once or twice a year so that perhaps all SIX of her ex's children have some shared memories of family get togethers when young.

Phoenix9 · 29/05/2023 09:33

In your situation I'd be fine, their choices are on them and at least you and DH are excluded together.

It could be a lot worse. DPs family could be inviting the ex everywhere with DP in attendance and you been excluded and sat at home on your own because the ex is there.. but that's my current situation, but it does lend a different but similar experience to what your currently going through.

Honestly if DH is happy and you get on well with the in-laws have a conversation about splitting holidays so DH is included in some etc...

Thequeenofwishfulthinking · 29/05/2023 09:22

Cocolocobaby I’ve been thinking and my opinion would change if there’s any chance your DH’s family have a toxic dynamic. Is your DH the black sheep or scapegoat of the family?
if so then the relatives are doing this deliberately.
I have a friend whose family is dysfunctional and this sort of situation would be because of the fucked up boundaries and attitudes of the people involved,

Rewis · 29/05/2023 09:17

If your husband, in laws, kids and ex are atotally fine with it then there is nothing you can do nor should do. I agree it is weird. It's one thing to be in good terms but it's another to spend Christmas together and not see other grand kids or their own child. It is also weird that BIL comes to town to see his family and has a quick coffee with his brother so he can make it to a dinner to his brothers ex partners house. But since all the main players involved think it's totally normal then just let it all play out. Just concentrate on making holiday memories with your husband and your children.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 29/05/2023 09:14

guineacup · 29/05/2023 09:11

This. What are the custody arrangements? It sounds like she has the lion's share and your DH has them EOW or something.

If he wants to see them more on special occasions, he needs to increase his involvement and organise his own parties.

Also, why do people think it's your job to organise events on special occasions for your DH's children. He's the one who needs to show some initiative here for HIS children! If he won't then that's on him.

One of the OPs gripes is that her children are missing out - that’s why people are telling her to organise things

She’s the one bothered by it.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 29/05/2023 09:13

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 22:46

Okay so….

My DH has no issue at all and I love his is so bloody okay with this. Speaks volumes .

Lots of perspectives here.

I am happy to
admit maybe I seem insecure . It is hard being married to someone who has had a significant relationship with someone for 15 years and shared 3 children . I can admit that.

I have never been competitive- e.g
am not going to start hosting parties left
, right and center !

Everyone is wired differently. I just can’t imagine that is Christmas Day and my son is at home with his wife whilst I am with my other kids , my sons kids and his wx
wife !

am not going to start hosting parties left
, right and center !

Thats what makes you unreasonable

You don’t want the in laws and children to spend more time and more occasions with you - you just want them not to be there.

My ex in laws often come to me for special occasions. It’s their chance to spend time with my two DDs on those days. My ex doesn’t bother with any of them.

Funnily enough he moans as well that it’s unfair, but apparently not unfair enough for him to organise a birthday get together or christmas gathering…

if you and your DH want to spend occasions with your in laws then invite them. Don’t expect them to not spend (long standing) time with your step children just because you’ve not organised anything for your children,

guineacup · 29/05/2023 09:11

LetItGoHome · 29/05/2023 08:21

Your husband definitely needs to start claiming his children's company on some of the special days. That would balance things up massively. I don't quite understand why he doesn't share these special days? Then party's and gatherings would naturally balance out better.

This. What are the custody arrangements? It sounds like she has the lion's share and your DH has them EOW or something.

If he wants to see them more on special occasions, he needs to increase his involvement and organise his own parties.

Also, why do people think it's your job to organise events on special occasions for your DH's children. He's the one who needs to show some initiative here for HIS children! If he won't then that's on him.

BreatheAndFocus · 29/05/2023 09:03

I changed my mind as I read your posts, OP. At first I thought you were being silly expecting to be invited, but then I read about BIL and the sheer amount of parties/events, and I get where you’re coming from.

I still don’t think you should be invited but I do think you have good reason to suspect this woman is doing something underhand. She’s potentially sabotaging the relationship your children have with your DH’s family and purposely bagging them for each and every event.

However - your in-laws don’t need to accept. If they were ‘busy’ a few times, she might ease off. But more importantly than that, you and your DH need to stand up for your DC. Organise your own events. Think ahead, be strategic, be ever so nice about it, but hold your ground, or, rather, actually take your ground. Do not invite ex. Have your own meals and parties. Invite your DH’s children but not her.

She’s trying to claim her ex in-laws as hers. She’s trying to keep you in the background - and you and your DH are letting her.

TUCKINGFYP0 · 29/05/2023 08:38

electriclight · 29/05/2023 08:08

I disagree with pp saying you or dp need to have a word with the in laws and put a stop to it.

It just seems so mean spirited to look at people who love each other, and enjoy spending time together, and want to make them feel bad about it.

Wouldn't it feel like a more positive move to just start inviting them to things yourself?

I agree. If you have the children for 2 days out of 7 then you MUST have them on some days near their birthdays, Christmas , Easter and summer. So if your husband wanted to ,he could just arrange social events on these days and invite his family. But, as you says he doesn’t want to.

It sounds like she spent their whole marriage doing all the wifework of keeping in touch with his family, organising and hosting all these events for him and his children to see their extended family. Clearly they are all close and love her.

Yet now they are no longer married you seem to think that he should still continue to benefit from this arrangement , that she should do the work of hosting and he ( and his new partner and her kids ) should be invited along. You sound extremely entitled and a bit batshit .

You now have hundred of posts telling that if you want to host social events for your partners family, just do it. Or let him do it.

But you’ve been clear that you don’t want to. You and he CBA with the work involved . You just want his ex to go on doing the work for both or you to benefit from.

When he and his ex wife split up, he stopped benefitting from all her hard work, building relationships and the time and money she spends hosting these events. That’s what happens when you separate / divorce.

She is making all the effort to keep her kids / your step kids in touch with their extended family. But rather than appreciating what she does for them, you resent it .

You are trying to control other people.

You don’t get to control them or her because you have a wedding ring.

You don’t get to tell your partner’s family who they are allowed to socialise with.

You don’t get to tell his ex wife what she does with her time.

You don’t get to decide who she invited to her social events .

You don’t get to control what she does with her kids during the 62% of their lives that she has them.

Just concentrate on what you do with the kids in the 28% of time you have them and let her lead her own life.