Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or should DH’s ex back off ?

187 replies

Cocolocobaby · 28/05/2023 21:58

I Married my husband 4 years ago. He has 3 children with his ex. He was with ex partner 15 years. His ex has few family members in the UK.

The issue for me is that My husbands ex hosts events which me and DH aren’t invited to but all my in laws are invited too.
E.g - BBQs, Christmas parties, Birthday Parties, Summer parties, Platinum Jubilee, Easter lunch .
These parties are basically just her, her new husband and my in-laws.

I find it sad that she invites my husbands family but not us . I understand she has known my husbands family for many years and they are her children’s grandparents and aunts and uncles but I find it so frustrating that my husband and I are not invited .

For example , It is Christmas Eve and we can’t see in-laws as they are going to a
Meal at husbands ex house which we aren’t invited to.
I know DH would absolutely love to attend as he wants to see his children as much as possible. We are just around the corner but on our own as we haven’t been asked along.

My husband has no problem with this and is just happy his children have a great relationship with his family. He is happy his ex has his family to support her.

I have a great relationship with my husbands family and we do all meet up together. His parents are extremely welcoming to me and I adore them . They are really lovely people .

So here is my issue .
I feel that his ex won’t let go of DH’s family and I wish she would move on . It seems (to me) slightly competitive that she will host a party so that DH and I will be excluded . E.g - she will have an Easter Feast - meaning DH and I can’t see his family or his children as we won’t be invited to the party.

She is remarried . So why does she keep inviting DHs family over ? I wonder if her new partner always wants her exs family over?

I can’t work out if i ABU or if husbands ex is just being manipulative or if she is doing nothing wrong !? On occasions when I did meet her she was very rude to me . I ignored this but I immediately felt she had an agenda.

Next week BIL is over from France for 3
nights in UK. The one night he is in town - We have been told that husbands Ex is hosting a dinner party for everyone but of course me and DH aren’t invited ! It’s DHs bloody brother !!!

I don’t want to become obsessed and bitter . I have a lovely Husband and children ( 3 myself with DH) and my in-laws are lovely to me .

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 31/05/2023 03:38

ineedtrinnyandsusannah · 30/05/2023 22:15

DC may be young now but they’ll soon be older and the precedent has been set.

Even if OP starts inviting all the family around, it’s going to be a huge adjustment for them to start saying no to the ex all the time. That will likely cause ructions.

So, how do you think DC will feel when all of their dad’s side of the family (and their sibling) are quite often celebrating things that they’re not invited to.

To be honest, a lack of boundaries isn’t always helpful to children of divorce either. It can be confusing, that’s worth considering too.

Why do they have to say no all the time?

they can do as they did the one time the OP and her DH organised something and do both?

It’s also worth considering that the Op’s DH hasn’t bothered his arse over the years to organise anything for occasions. He’s left it all to the mother. Why would people stop doing something they’ve done for years to just do nothing? He’s had years to make the effort. This is his doing. Not the exes.

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/05/2023 02:01

Thatboymum · 28/05/2023 22:37

i find it weird that you view this as controlling. And if I’m being honest I think this is really a you problem as it’s coming across as quite insecure , they were her and her children’s family for many many years just because the relationship broke up doesn’t mean everybody in the family should walk away from her. I think it’s lovely for the kids , it’s also really odd that you think you should be invited, you weren’t part of her family and she doesn’t know you so why would she invite you ? Why can’t dh go to the odd event without you or suggest to his ex it would be nice for him to be included so he can see his children. I don’t think you have a place in this situation in my opinion but you should encourage your dh to be more forward about going

This.

They are still her family. If anything I think its controlling of you to want to intefere in her relationship with them.

ineedtrinnyandsusannah · 30/05/2023 22:15

DC may be young now but they’ll soon be older and the precedent has been set.

Even if OP starts inviting all the family around, it’s going to be a huge adjustment for them to start saying no to the ex all the time. That will likely cause ructions.

So, how do you think DC will feel when all of their dad’s side of the family (and their sibling) are quite often celebrating things that they’re not invited to.

To be honest, a lack of boundaries isn’t always helpful to children of divorce either. It can be confusing, that’s worth considering too.

3luckystars · 30/05/2023 22:11

I think it’s really bad form.

candlesflamesandbrooms · 30/05/2023 22:07

OhmygodDont · 30/05/2023 21:28

I mean all this woe is the second family. Yet they expect the first family to be dropped like a hot potato the second they come along by the dads family.

What’s best the for the children is best for the children.

Ex invites her children’s family bar her own ex to their stuff.

The father and his new wife and children are welcome to host parties and invite all
but the ex / children’s mother.

Er no Tbf op would get slaughtered if she didn't invite the DSC to Christmas dinner with the family (as they are part of the family), it's just the ex isn't so that potato got dropped in the divorce 😂

I don't think considering the all children of the family is unreasonable. Isn't that what's always spouted on here ? But it's interesting that's your read on it.

But let's not pretend this is done in the name of what's best for the kids ? 😅

it's really odd behaviour by a ex wife and a bit of a power play. The in laws probably feel sorry for mum and are trying to be polite and not rock the boat, hoping she would petter off with the invites not ramp up.

But I think push comes to shove I imagine they will slowly start declining and have gathering just in-laws, DSC, DC op and her DP as a family gathering.

This type of nuttery can't last long before someone goes - this is weird.

Things like this remind me how not to be a nutty ex wife.

.

OhmygodDont · 30/05/2023 21:28

I mean all this woe is the second family. Yet they expect the first family to be dropped like a hot potato the second they come along by the dads family.

What’s best the for the children is best for the children.

Ex invites her children’s family bar her own ex to their stuff.

The father and his new wife and children are welcome to host parties and invite all
but the ex / children’s mother.

AlienatedChildGrown · 30/05/2023 21:26

In-laws exist in their own right, as humans, with feelings etc. They aren’t just bit players to decorate other people’s love story and/or union. And they aren’t a package deal that has to follow the path of one family member’s love life.

DSIS and I met our SIL from when we were all pretty young. We developed a relationship. We like each other. Even if my nephews didn’t exist all that would still be true. And just because she is no longer with our brother doesn’t mean we’ve fallen out of “like a lot and care about” with her. We all went through so many ages & stages together. She’s great.

Neither DSIS or I can or will change who we want to spend time with based on how our brother, or anybody in his life romantically, feels about it. We don’t exist only as our brother’s sisters. We’re our own people, we’re attached to who we’re attached to, and we’re free to spend festivals and free time with who we choose.

Perhaps that is how your in-laws feel ? They’ve known her for a long time and like, or love her. The ex and your DH may have moved on from their feelings for each other. But that doesn’t mean his entire family have to follow suit and move their emotional attachments where he moves his.

In time, you’ll be able to develop your own close relationship with them, if you all click. We humans are prone to noticing what we don’t have and spend energy on why we don’t think is fair, normal, or expected. Whereas when we focus on sowing the seeds of what we could have, rather than what somebody else is harvesting, we are a lot more likely to driving a combine harvester of our own in time.

I’m really not being mean. I know what it’s like to feel like the not so wanted in-law. Twice ( might be a me problem at this point 😅). And it’s crap. But crap doesn’t get better until we work how much we want what we don’t have. And follow through by working out how to get what we want. Doing the grind and drudge work needed to make that happen.

And life is way too short to waste it peeking in through the window like a cat left out in the rain, thinking the dog is the bastard problem, cos he’s in there being patted and getting all the fishy titbits.

Cos that is worst outcome. Both unable to see the freedom of life on the window ledge, as well as wildly overestimating how much fun it is to be petted the whole time.

OhmygodDont · 30/05/2023 20:57

candlesflamesandbrooms · 30/05/2023 20:44

Op doesn't state that they are babies/toddlers though...

But yes of course so silly for people to consider the younger members of the family 🙄 they are born without emotions so don't need to be considered

When people say oh won't someone think of the children, they mean kids from the first marriage. Children from second family have zero emotions and totally will understand why their older siblings are talking about a Christmas party with their joint grandpa and grandma and they aren't invited.

It’s their half siblings mother having parties.

what normal parent expects their children to be invited to their half siblings parents thrown parties smh. There’s some digging deep here to make the ex the bad guy.

Im
not the only
one to presume young children and the op hasn’t corrected any of us since they only married four years ago.

candlesflamesandbrooms · 30/05/2023 20:49

I mean what's really weird is mum asking her ex in laws for every special occasion.

So that they are booked with her - so literally excluding OPs DH and the second children.

It's a really weird thing to do and I say this as a ex wife.

candlesflamesandbrooms · 30/05/2023 20:44

OhmygodDont · 30/05/2023 20:34

How the toddlers/babies feel about not being invited to their half siblings parents parties? You serious.

Op doesn't state that they are babies/toddlers though...

But yes of course so silly for people to consider the younger members of the family 🙄 they are born without emotions so don't need to be considered

When people say oh won't someone think of the children, they mean kids from the first marriage. Children from second family have zero emotions and totally will understand why their older siblings are talking about a Christmas party with their joint grandpa and grandma and they aren't invited.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 30/05/2023 20:43

ineedtrinnyandsusannah · 30/05/2023 20:33

Quite sad (and typical) that no one is thinking of how this could make the ‘new’ children feel…

When they’re old enough they probably will feel a bit miffed that their half siblings Mum made effort to do special events at Christmas/Easter/etc and their parents didn’t bother…

Surely you’re not suggesting that the ex should make her children miss out because the OP’s DH, and the OP, have chosen not to do anything for theirs? That’s ludicrous

OhmygodDont · 30/05/2023 20:34

How the toddlers/babies feel about not being invited to their half siblings parents parties? You serious.

ineedtrinnyandsusannah · 30/05/2023 20:33

Quite sad (and typical) that no one is thinking of how this could make the ‘new’ children feel…

drpet49 · 30/05/2023 17:40

Sux2buthen · 28/05/2023 22:13

No, it's weird as shit.

I agree. It is like a power play by the ex wife. Very weird.

SquaresandStarlings · 30/05/2023 17:30

OP YANBU!!

This is a sad situation for you but at the moment you can't really control it. She sounds very controlling and quite nasty.

As PPs have said, start to host your own things and hopefully there will eventually be more of a balance or things may even turn in your favour.

Was it an amicable or acrimonious split?

NotABridesmaid3 · 30/05/2023 16:37

OP why don’t you throw some parties and invite the in laws first? You will have to give them lots of notice to beat DH’s exes invitations. I’m sure that would piss the ex right off 🤣

Achwheesht · 30/05/2023 16:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 11:12

Gothambutnotahamster · 30/05/2023 08:49

I agree @Creamyoda the only thing is that the DH isn't complaining- according to the Op, he's happy with the situation, it's only the Op who isn't.

Yea that's very true!

yoga4meinthemorning · 30/05/2023 11:08

Maybe she doesn't want 3 under 4s screaming through a party?

I'd assume a couple with 3 very young children wouldnt want to come to parties.

Are you a lot younger than her? If he was with her 15 years, has 3 teens with her they must have been quite young?

For him to then get with you and have 3 more DCs?

He chose to have 6 DC! That's going to cause some stress!

And no he shouldnt have made his dc homeless so he could make a new family with someone else. The fact that you consider it a possibility that he could have kept the house speaks volumes.

TUCKINGFYP0 · 30/05/2023 09:08

Here’s an easy solution OP ( if you want one and I suspect you don’t - I think you just wanted everyone to say how terrible your partners family are for not doing what you want ).

When is the next birthday in your family - your partners or one of your kids? Choose a date on or near that date when you will have your step children. Organise a party for that now and send out invitations to your partners family, his children, their mother and their step father.

Do exactly what you want his ex wife to do - organise parties and invite you and him. That’s what you said you wanted her to do in your first post. Because if you don’t invite her, you are excluding her - which is what you are accusing her of doing.

If you organise lots of these events and always invite her, she will feel obliged to invite you to her events.

You need to chose one of your birthdays so you are not seen to be competing with her.

Simple .

Gothambutnotahamster · 30/05/2023 08:49

I agree @Creamyoda the only thing is that the DH isn't complaining- according to the Op, he's happy with the situation, it's only the Op who isn't.

Creamyoda · 30/05/2023 07:56

We would not be selfish and say - if you don’t come to my house every other Christmas Day im taking your mum to court etc !

He sounds like an absolute melt, full of excuses to make his life easier under the guise of not wanting to stress the children- who live around the corner and would no doubt enjoy time with him if he could be bothered to arrange fun stuff like their mum does. Honestly plenty of children spend time on these occasions quite happily, he has never bothered and so he doesn't see them; he honestly can't then complain about his parents wanting to see their grandchildren, they shouldn't suffer for his lack of backbone and/or laziness.

WeAreTheHeroes · 30/05/2023 07:40

@Achwheesht what does that have to do with anything and why is it any of your business?

Achwheesht · 29/05/2023 22:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Nanny0gg · 29/05/2023 13:15

Sorry, I think it's perfectly fair and reasonable that special days, birthdays, Christmas etc are shared

Your DH should have got that sorted.