Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is H dealing with this in the right way?

137 replies

userhank · 28/05/2023 21:46

We have DS together he's 5. Also have dss who is 9. They have not been getting along well at all now for the last couple of months. It's always the same thing.

DS misses dss. Dss comes to stay (eow and school holidays) and DS wants to play with him. Dss doesn't want to play.

DS then gets angry at this and lashes out at everyone, dss included. Dss then refuses to play with DS for the rest of the weekend because his brother is mean. However he never wants to play with DS to begin with. It's a viscous circle.

I had a word with dss last weekend and explained that while I know his brothers lashing out is unacceptable, DS just misses him and wants to play with his brother. DS is generally a really good boy. Never in trouble at school, very polite and well mannered. I don't have any issues with him really until dss arrives and it all kicks off.

This weekend, dss arrived and said he was going to make a real effort with DS this weekend. He promised us he was going to play with his brother and spend spend some time with him. Until 5 minutes later, DS asked him to play, dss said no and the whole thing kicked off again.

I try deal with this amicably. I can see it from both sides. My son misses his brother when he's not here and hers excited for him to come. My step son thinks his little brother is mean and all he does is hit and kick him.

H has had enough and took dss to his mums for the rest of the weekend and has sent me a text to say the boys will no longer see each other. He has also fallen out with me too it seems.

So I have 3 children to deal with here.

I've been apart of my step sons life since he was a baby and I love him very much. He's a good kid. However there is a side to him which I've seen on going which H is completely oblivious too. Dss is jealous of DS. He will get DS into trouble and blame DS for everything even when he is not at fault. H immediately takes the side of dss and my son gets into trouble. This doesn't happen all the time but there is a lot more too this than just dss doesn't want to play. I think dss has figured out that if he says 'no' to DS, then DS will start kicking and hitting and then that gets DS into trouble.

So sad but I think that's what's happening here. H cannot see any of this at all. I've tried to explain it to him but he just shuts me down.

I also think there is too much of a big deal being made if it. They are brothers. They will fight. Sometimes my so can say the smallest thing to dss without even meaning too and dss will go in the hugest sulk and it just doesn't get forgotten about. I have 2 kids fr a previous relationship and they fight like cat and dog every day but they don't hold grudges. It's forgotten about minutes later. Dss gets on well with my kids, just not his brother.

I think I'm done with this step mum malarkey. I'm not being horrible about my step son here. I'm not an evil step mum. I've done so much for him and done everything I can to make sure he's as included in our family as can be. There is issues but I feel I'm the only one that can see them and H is just not listening to me. And now he's buggered off sulking, taken dss with him and left my little boy wondering where the hell his brother and dad have gone.

OP posts:
Haywirecity · 28/05/2023 22:57

I should of said in the post that I don't expect dss to play.

I'm sorry but I don't think that's true because in you're opening post you said...

I had a word with dss last weekend and explained that while I know his brothers lashing out is unacceptable, DS just misses him and wants to play with his brother. DS is generally a really good boy. Never in trouble at school, very polite and well mannered. I don't have any issues with him really until dss arrives and it all kicks off. This weekend, dss arrived and said he was going to make a real effort with DS this weekend. He promised us he was going to play with his brother and spend spend some time with him.

So it's pretty clear you are pressurising your step son to play with your son. I don't think that's fair. It's git to be your stepson's decision. My sister and I have 4 years between us and we really didn't hang around together until we were in our late 20s!!

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:57

@InceyWinceySpidy no we were playing as a family! We were all playing football together. What am I supposed to do? Tell my 5 year old he can't play while me, his dad and brother play together?

OP posts:
Tigofigo · 28/05/2023 22:57

parietal · 28/05/2023 22:44

If you want the boys to play, you have to structure the play and supervise v closely. So all 3 of you play a board game or do geocaching or similar. You can't expect Dss to play with DS without an adult.

This.

Gaming can bring out the worst in kids as well.

A great thing to do to get them to bond a bit more might be to do a fun and silly you (or even better your H) vs them game... For example piggy in the middle where you stay the piggy the whole time, a you Vs them nerf battle, floor is lava... nothing too competitive or rules-based that needs keeping score. Let them win.

whumpthereitis · 28/05/2023 22:56

He’s got to dread going to your home tbh. He gets there and his younger brother attempts to commandeer his attention, and when that fails he lashes out at him. No wonder he doesn’t want to play with or be around him. It probably is best, for both your husbands relationship with his son and for the sake of the brothers having any chance of developing a decent sibling relationship, that they are separated. At least for the time being.

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:55

@Theunamedcat no but I wouldn't trust him too.

The other week, dss whacked DS so hard on the arm it left a mark. Ds was screaming. Me and H came in to see what happened and dss said my son hit him first. So obviously H shouted at my son saying that dss has every right to hit if my son hits him first.

My daughter witnessed it all and told me afterwards that DS never hit dss at all and I know she's telling the truth. I haven't said anything to H as it's pointless. He will stick up for dss entirely.

Then last weekend, me and DS were out playing football in the garden. Dss came out, took the ball from DS and refused to give it back. Then my son starts crying, H comes out and dss shouts 'he never lets me play with him' and sulked. DS then got shouted at again by H. I tried explaining that DS had done nothing wrong but it didn't matter.

H doesn't see any of what goes on when he's here so I don't trust him to watch them alone. He just turns a blind eye to absolutely everything.

OP posts:
Beezknees · 28/05/2023 22:55

Your H needs to be more involved in this. It's not fair that you're left to deal with it. It's his son.

It does sound like you are babying your DS though. At 5 years old he is presumably at school, does he hit and kick the other kids there if he doesn't get his own way? That's not acceptable.

Older kids don't often want to play with younger kids, it's normal. When my DS was a similar age my neighbour's younger kids kept wanting him to go over to play but DS found it boring.

InceyWinceySpidy · 28/05/2023 22:54

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:41

It depends what it is really. We went to the park a couple of weeks ago and they were playing football but dss ended up sulking because DS doesn't underhand the rules of football so I told DS home so dss could play with his dad.

It's got to the point where dss doesn't want to do anything at all.

H is constantly telling dss before he leaves for work that he doesn't have to do anything he doesn't want to do when he's here so I end up feeling I just have to do whatever dss wants.

This is more of the same.

You see "we took both boys to play football, and DSS and his sulking at my poor DS put a stop to that so I had to take DS home"

What happened, is yet again, DSS was expected to play with a child half his age, when all he does is let you know that he doesn't want too.

It's got to the point where dss doesn't want to do anything at all.

It's got to the point where DSS can't take any more being paired up with a 5yr old. A 5yr old who lashes out when DSS doesn't want to play how the 5yr old wants too. You said yourself, DSS happily gets on with your older DC.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 28/05/2023 22:53

Your 5 yo isn't too young to understand that hitting and kicking to get your own way will not make people want to spend time with you. It's understandable that dss doesn't really want to play with ds. You need to take the pressure off this situation and try to support them in redeveloping a relationship at their own pace. Is there an outing you could all go on that both would enjoy and bond over? I think you will see your little boy upset and maybe not fully understand from dss point of view.

It's hard to tell whether your dh is BU or just fed up of his son feeling forced in to spending his weekends pandering to a younger sibling. You need to teach ds to accept no as an answer if he asks to play and then you can distract him with something else.

WimpoleHat · 28/05/2023 22:50

He's 9 and I'm tip toeing around my own home trying my hardest to not let anyone upset him because the minute his dad gets home, he runs straight to him and tells him the smallest little thing that has annoyed him which then leads to ME being shouted at for allowing it to happen.

Your DH needs to be there to look after DSS whenever he is at your house in which case…..

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:48

InceyWinceySpidy · 28/05/2023 22:42

OP you can't see it, but it's DS who is the problem here. And it's not because you're deliberately defending him, I can see that you genuinely feel that DS is sad, and wondering where daddy and big brother are.

What is screaming out to the rest of us, is that DSS does not want to play with a 5yr old. He wants to play with his peers, ie your older children.

The 5yr old keeps pestering him when he's trying to play his Xbox, wanting different games, then essentially attacking DSS when he says "no."

The only person who thinks it's endearing that DS misses his big brother, is you. This is no fun for DSS at all. He can't relax in his own father's home because DS is wanting to play continually. So yes, DH has done the right thing by taking DSS out for the day, so the boy can breathe! And he's annoyed with you for not seeing why this was imperative. You only see poor DS, abandoned by his own father and the brother he loves so much.

My kids aren't here.

Yes I do see your point entirely! I don't force my step son to play with my son. I constantly tell DS that dss doesn't have to play if he doesn't want too. However I walk on egg shells around my step son! He's 9 and I'm tip toeing around my own home trying my hardest to not let anyone upset him because the minute his dad gets home, he runs straight to him and tells him the smallest little thing that has annoyed him which then leads to ME being shouted at for allowing it to happen.

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 28/05/2023 22:48

I'm a similar amount older than my sister, and the expectation that I play with her combined with my parents blissfully ignoring the fact that she would hit and kick me utterly poisoned any chance we had at a decent relationship when older. 30 years on and I still keep very very strict boundaries. And that's without the complications of a blended family, little brother getting to see dad all the time, dad being absent due to work on contact weekends etc.

I have a five year old and if she was hitting and kicking anyone I would be furious with her. She is absolutely old enough to know better than that.

Theunamedcat · 28/05/2023 22:45

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:41

It depends what it is really. We went to the park a couple of weeks ago and they were playing football but dss ended up sulking because DS doesn't underhand the rules of football so I told DS home so dss could play with his dad.

It's got to the point where dss doesn't want to do anything at all.

H is constantly telling dss before he leaves for work that he doesn't have to do anything he doesn't want to do when he's here so I end up feeling I just have to do whatever dss wants.

You do not have to do whatever he wants he is nine let him crack on and occupy himself do things with ds your DH is being underhand with those comments he is effectively preventing you from parenting in your own home perhaps he should stick around and parent his own child/children instead of leaving it to you

Does he ever watch the two of them together by himself?

parietal · 28/05/2023 22:44

If you want the boys to play, you have to structure the play and supervise v closely. So all 3 of you play a board game or do geocaching or similar. You can't expect Dss to play with DS without an adult.

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:43

Pixiedust1234 · 28/05/2023 22:41

I've tried to speak to my 5 year old about this but he's too young to understand.

He is old enough NOT to kick and hit others. My god, stop being ridiculous. Discipline your child properly. Even an adult wouldn't want to be around if he acts like this. You really think schools would say he's too young?

Your poor dss is being bullied and you are allowing it.

My ds is punished believe me. By us both but more by his dad.

OP posts:
crazeekat · 28/05/2023 22:42

i think they are all being unreasonable. husband by leaving with dss and basically showing dss how to get all his attention. dd is learning to kick off to get what he wants. the next time it starts i would take myself off out and have dh deal with it all. it's not ur job to keep everyone happy.
there is defo some jealously at play dss and ds so they need to share more eg 20 mins of one game, then they switch. they play well together then they get rewarded. small steps. i don't think it is unreasonable to expect dss to at least give a little bit of time to ur dd, they are brothers and need to learn to tolerate each other.

InceyWinceySpidy · 28/05/2023 22:42

OP you can't see it, but it's DS who is the problem here. And it's not because you're deliberately defending him, I can see that you genuinely feel that DS is sad, and wondering where daddy and big brother are.

What is screaming out to the rest of us, is that DSS does not want to play with a 5yr old. He wants to play with his peers, ie your older children.

The 5yr old keeps pestering him when he's trying to play his Xbox, wanting different games, then essentially attacking DSS when he says "no."

The only person who thinks it's endearing that DS misses his big brother, is you. This is no fun for DSS at all. He can't relax in his own father's home because DS is wanting to play continually. So yes, DH has done the right thing by taking DSS out for the day, so the boy can breathe! And he's annoyed with you for not seeing why this was imperative. You only see poor DS, abandoned by his own father and the brother he loves so much.

Theunamedcat · 28/05/2023 22:42

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:37

I haven't said I expect him to play. I spend my weekends keeping DS away from him. I don't expect dss to play. All DS wants to do is game with his brother but on separate games.

I then end up spending my entire weekend playing with my son so dss has his son space.

Then I have H who is zero help to me at all and falls out with me even though I'm trying to keep it all going along as best as I can.

I'm getting the feeling no-one is really reading what your saying

You have a DH problem

Pixiedust1234 · 28/05/2023 22:41

I've tried to speak to my 5 year old about this but he's too young to understand.

He is old enough NOT to kick and hit others. My god, stop being ridiculous. Discipline your child properly. Even an adult wouldn't want to be around if he acts like this. You really think schools would say he's too young?

Your poor dss is being bullied and you are allowing it.

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:41

Whatyoutalkingabouteh · 28/05/2023 22:35

Would they get on if you did an activity together out of the house?

It depends what it is really. We went to the park a couple of weeks ago and they were playing football but dss ended up sulking because DS doesn't underhand the rules of football so I told DS home so dss could play with his dad.

It's got to the point where dss doesn't want to do anything at all.

H is constantly telling dss before he leaves for work that he doesn't have to do anything he doesn't want to do when he's here so I end up feeling I just have to do whatever dss wants.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 28/05/2023 22:40

My two are same age difference they usually play together for a bit then seperate and do their own thing eldest has always been cautioned not to promise to play unless he means it, its not always successful because they are children but it works for the most part and now they have switches and an xbox they can cross platform on its much easier

userhank · 28/05/2023 22:37

SavBlancTonight · 28/05/2023 22:30

My dc have that age gap. They play v little together. You are being ridiculous expecting a 9 year old.to.play with a 5 year old for any extended.length of time

It's not just about how much your ds wants to play. Younger siblings ALWAYS want to play with their older siblings. Doesn't mean they get to.

I haven't said I expect him to play. I spend my weekends keeping DS away from him. I don't expect dss to play. All DS wants to do is game with his brother but on separate games.

I then end up spending my entire weekend playing with my son so dss has his son space.

Then I have H who is zero help to me at all and falls out with me even though I'm trying to keep it all going along as best as I can.

OP posts:
Polik · 28/05/2023 22:35

It is no child's responsibility to have to play with another. Your 5yo needs to learn that. Allow your 9yo to be a child too and do his own thing.

Whatyoutalkingabouteh · 28/05/2023 22:35

Would they get on if you did an activity together out of the house?

Soubriquet · 28/05/2023 22:34

5 years old is NOT too young to understand. He is plenty old enough to realise that the games he wants to play, and the ones his brother plays are completely different.

Stompythedinosaur · 28/05/2023 22:34

It sounds like you are landing the blame on your dss for your ds' poor behaviour, when your dss is actually the one being hurt.

It's pretty understandable that he doesn't want to play with much younger kid who hits him. It isn't your dss' responsibility to manage your ds' behaviour or to entertain him.

It's your responsibility to closely supervise at flash points such as when your dss arrives, and to correct any violent behaviour. 5yo is plenty old enough to know you aren't allow to hurt people if they don't want to play with you.