Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people with an average mortgage are still far better off than their renting counterparts

242 replies

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:06

I met with a friend today who was moaning about having sorted their remortgage this week and how their payments have increased by £250 a month due to interest rises. She's now paying £1000 for their 3 bed semi and I do fully appreciate how stressful knowing this remortgage was due has been for them this past year and how painful suddenly paying so much more is. I'm not in any way trying to minimise that for my friend or others with a mortgage in this position.

However, I rent and we live in a very similar property in a similar area to her which I had been paying over £1100 for for the past 2 years and a few months ago this increased to £1250. When we were told about the increase we looked to see if there was anything we could possibly find for cheaper and everything comparable was actually closer to the £1400 mark.

I feel like the news has covered the impact interest rises are having on home owners virtually every day since the mini budget last September but renter's have only had a cursory 'and rents will increase due to landlords passing on their increases' at the end of the odd story. And with zero acknowledgement that rents were already so much higher than mortgages anyway and still are. It's not like renting has suddenly become the better option; it's still utterly impossible!

Am I being unreasonable to think there needs to be more outrage and support for renters and not just those needing to remortgage.

OP posts:
FrownedUpon · 28/05/2023 21:49

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:43

Well actually in my situation I will sell the house at the end of that to fund my retirement while renters get housing benefit alongside their pension to cover their rent. The grass really isn’t greener on either side!

Not all renters get housing benefit. My sibling is using their state & small work pension to pay their rent & is left with very little over for anything else.

Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 28/05/2023 21:49

SweetSakura · 28/05/2023 21:45

Wouldn't insurance pay out for this?

When we had a big leak all the work was covered by the insurance (plastering, carpets, plumbing etc).

Probably for not all of that, and again, it depends on your insurance level so you can add this as a monthly cost.
i was a renter up until few months ago and honestly we were better off renting!
now we have to worry about fences, trees in the garden etc. I am not arguing but in our case, we decided to buy but we had more money spare when renting.

SaturdayGiraffe · 28/05/2023 21:48

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:46

My father in law has just had to pay £11000 for a new boiler after it broke down.

Unless he has zero maintenance costs for the next 4 years, that alone is more than the ‘extra’ you pay in rent.

Blimey, what’s he boiling, Loch Lomond?

Larner · 28/05/2023 21:48

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:43

Well actually in my situation I will sell the house at the end of that to fund my retirement while renters get housing benefit alongside their pension to cover their rent. The grass really isn’t greener on either side!

Where are you going to live if you have no house?

Badbudgeter · 28/05/2023 21:48

In a way I agree with you (average mortgage holder) but also there are additional costs with being a homeowner. Buildings insurance, maintenance it feels like something goes wrong every other month. I know people with housing association tenancies. Secure, cheap rent,complaining about the inconvenience of them fitting new kitchens and insulation.

I think my point is people moan when their lives are worse than before. Things are shitter than they were for many of us. There's always going to be someone worse and better off than you. I think it can be acknowledged that life is hard for people renting in the private sector, rent is going up, lack of supply. Its also hard for those who have a mortgage as incomes are largely stagnant but everything costs more. No one group has a monopoly on misery there's plenty to go around.

openstop · 28/05/2023 21:48

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:46

My father in law has just had to pay £11000 for a new boiler after it broke down.

Unless he has zero maintenance costs for the next 4 years, that alone is more than the ‘extra’ you pay in rent.

That's really really expensive. Did he go through British gas or something?

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:48

My insurance wouldn’t pay for my leak as it was classed as maintenance not an accident. The hot water cylinder failed. If a pipe were to burst yes they would cover it. But not all things are covered.

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:48

@Haveallthesongsbeenwritten surely that kind of event would be covered by your home insurance which costs a few hundred pounds a year, not thousands. A new boiler costs a 2-5k and should last a decade at least so I'm not buying that boiler maintenance costs that much on its own. In fact the man our landlord sent out to service our boiler had a quote of £100 for a service on his van and the boiler's not been looked at other than an annual service since we moved here 3 years ago so again, it's not adding up.

OP posts:
cadburyegg · 28/05/2023 21:47

YANBU. I am in the process of remortgaging and will be paying £660 a month, which is more than I was paying before but still affordable. Renters pay £1400+ for similar properties, although it's correct that they qualify for more help through UC

Sillysosij · 28/05/2023 21:47

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:43

Well actually in my situation I will sell the house at the end of that to fund my retirement while renters get housing benefit alongside their pension to cover their rent. The grass really isn’t greener on either side!

in my area, housing benefit is capped at £850 for me and my daughter. The cheapest 2 bed flat is £1300! Housing benefit is not an answer. And I don’t really want to be worrying about being evicted when I’m 80. But that’s life for a tenant. The grass is absolutely greener when you own something rather than nothing.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:46

Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 28/05/2023 21:41

A massive leak which means redecorating or plastering, roof issues etc. Plumbing issues or boiler. That would cost a lot!

My father in law has just had to pay £11000 for a new boiler after it broke down.

Unless he has zero maintenance costs for the next 4 years, that alone is more than the ‘extra’ you pay in rent.

SweetSakura · 28/05/2023 21:45

Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 28/05/2023 21:41

A massive leak which means redecorating or plastering, roof issues etc. Plumbing issues or boiler. That would cost a lot!

Wouldn't insurance pay out for this?

When we had a big leak all the work was covered by the insurance (plastering, carpets, plumbing etc).

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:43

Sillysosij · 28/05/2023 21:41

And at the end of that, in 30 years, you’ll own a house.

In 30 years, tenants will have nothing. It should cost a little more to own something in the end. Instead all those costs you have, they don’t vanish for tenants. They get passed on in the rent. Renting will always make you worse off because it covers mortgage, agent fees, landlord expenses (including all those you just listed), and profit. And at the end. Despite whining about the cost of it. The landlord will have a house. They will be mortgage free. Because someone else paid it off for them.

Well actually in my situation I will sell the house at the end of that to fund my retirement while renters get housing benefit alongside their pension to cover their rent. The grass really isn’t greener on either side!

PeanutCat1 · 28/05/2023 21:42

YANBU! our mortgage has recently increased by almost £200 per month but our mortgage payment is still around £400 less per month than rental on similar properties. We bought our home in 2019 so have always just benefited from really low interest rates, so although it feels like a big jump really we've just been spoilt with very low rates in the past. I also imagine that tenants are experiencing rental increases to reflect the interest rates rising on buy to let mortgages as well. Ultimately there will be plenty of homeowners struggling with the increases but that's absolutely not to say that things are any easier for renters at all.

Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 28/05/2023 21:41

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:40

Okay, so the argument for home maintenance (not improving to your personal taste because we all know that landlords absolutely don't do this.. Genuine, essential maintenance), you're telling me that the average homeowner spends £3000 a year, every year on this? Because that's the difference between my rent and my friend's new mortgage rate. And like I said, if I were to move I'd actually be looking at £1400 so that's £4800 a year, just on essential maintenance. I'm sorry, but I find that hard to believe.

A massive leak which means redecorating or plastering, roof issues etc. Plumbing issues or boiler. That would cost a lot!

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:41

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:40

Okay, so the argument for home maintenance (not improving to your personal taste because we all know that landlords absolutely don't do this.. Genuine, essential maintenance), you're telling me that the average homeowner spends £3000 a year, every year on this? Because that's the difference between my rent and my friend's new mortgage rate. And like I said, if I were to move I'd actually be looking at £1400 so that's £4800 a year, just on essential maintenance. I'm sorry, but I find that hard to believe.

Are you kidding?

I spend more far more than that in a year on home maintenance, safety checks (annual boiler service etc.) and insurances that are required for home ownership!

Sillysosij · 28/05/2023 21:41

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:21

Are you forgetting that home ownership comes with other costs?

Our mortgage has increased by £300 a month. Our help to buy loan has increased by 50 a month. Building insurance by £7 a month.

So just over £350 increase in a very short time and then the hot water cylinder springs a leak.

£150 emergency plumber to stop the leak
£320 heating engineer to repair the cylinder
£160 replaster the ceiling that the water leaked through
£80 repaint the water damaged areas

Still hoping that the carpet will dry out and not need replacing as that will be another £600 on top.

Over £1100 we have had to pay out EXTRA this month on top of our usual mortgage cost.

And at the end of that, in 30 years, you’ll own a house.

In 30 years, tenants will have nothing. It should cost a little more to own something in the end. Instead all those costs you have, they don’t vanish for tenants. They get passed on in the rent. Renting will always make you worse off because it covers mortgage, agent fees, landlord expenses (including all those you just listed), and profit. And at the end. Despite whining about the cost of it. The landlord will have a house. They will be mortgage free. Because someone else paid it off for them.

Larner · 28/05/2023 21:40

Yanbu. Plus, renters pay rent till they die.

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:40

Okay, so the argument for home maintenance (not improving to your personal taste because we all know that landlords absolutely don't do this.. Genuine, essential maintenance), you're telling me that the average homeowner spends £3000 a year, every year on this? Because that's the difference between my rent and my friend's new mortgage rate. And like I said, if I were to move I'd actually be looking at £1400 so that's £4800 a year, just on essential maintenance. I'm sorry, but I find that hard to believe.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 28/05/2023 21:37

You’re not comparing like with like as I’d guess she has a considerable equity in the house for her payment to be only 1k a month?
youve also forgotten the maintenance costs of owning a home which are considerable. Plumbing issues, gutters swept, boiler servicing, general maintenance and repairs are all regular expenses not required when renting

OnSusansFloor · 28/05/2023 21:36

YANBU. I'm mortgaged and dreading my upcoming increase, but I have a friend who had her second baby a week ago and their landlord (in a property they've only been in for 6 months) has just given them 8 weeks notice to leave as he wants to sell. The absolute maximum they can afford is about £300 below what they'll need for a 2-bed around here. The stress she and her DH are under, whilst also trying to navigate all the adjustments that come with having a new baby in the family, is enough to sink a ship. I really worry that it will break them.

Haveallthesongsbeenwritten · 28/05/2023 21:35

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:29

I'm genuinely not trying to say that people with mortgages are not struggling. It's hard to word exactly what mean without it sounding like I'm saying 'people with mortgages have it so easy' but that's not what I'm trying to say.
I just feel that since last September, the discussion has been pretty much exclusively about how it's those with mortgages that are suffering the most due to interest rate rises but it is simply a fact (it seems) that it's still more expensive to rent and renters are taking just as much of a financial hit as a direct result of the interest rate rises but no one's talking about that anymore.
And yes I appreciate that there are other costs involved in home ownership but unless your mortgage is up for remortgage soon, this isn't something that is currently affecting every homeowner where everyone I know who rents seems to have had their rent increased. And you can bet you bottom dollar that not every one of their landlords has actually had to remortgage when they made the decision to increase their rent.

I think if “you” rent you are better off because your landlord will be fixing anything. Also you wont need things like a mortgage protection insurance etc.

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:29

I'm genuinely not trying to say that people with mortgages are not struggling. It's hard to word exactly what mean without it sounding like I'm saying 'people with mortgages have it so easy' but that's not what I'm trying to say.
I just feel that since last September, the discussion has been pretty much exclusively about how it's those with mortgages that are suffering the most due to interest rate rises but it is simply a fact (it seems) that it's still more expensive to rent and renters are taking just as much of a financial hit as a direct result of the interest rate rises but no one's talking about that anymore.
And yes I appreciate that there are other costs involved in home ownership but unless your mortgage is up for remortgage soon, this isn't something that is currently affecting every homeowner where everyone I know who rents seems to have had their rent increased. And you can bet you bottom dollar that not every one of their landlords has actually had to remortgage when they made the decision to increase their rent.

OP posts:
Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:28

Plus there are legal caps in place as to how much landlords can increase rent per year. No caps for how much mortgage interest increases per year.

It isn’t the case that home owners or renters are worse off. EVERYONE (except the very wealthy) is struggling and it’s not a race to the bottom.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:26

Dressydress · 28/05/2023 21:23

@Madwife123 I get that but our rents are high and it covers these things too.

That’s the point I’m making. Rent doesn’t just cover rent. It covers repairs, emergencies, safety checks, updating, insuring the building. All the things that home owners pay on top of their mortgage. So while it may seem cheaper to have a mortgage in actual fact it’s probably around the same by the time the home owner pays all the things the rent also includes.

Of course you own your home at the end of it but on the flip side there is almost no help available if you fall on hard times. A renter can claim housing benefit. A home owner can’t etc.