Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people with an average mortgage are still far better off than their renting counterparts

242 replies

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:06

I met with a friend today who was moaning about having sorted their remortgage this week and how their payments have increased by £250 a month due to interest rises. She's now paying £1000 for their 3 bed semi and I do fully appreciate how stressful knowing this remortgage was due has been for them this past year and how painful suddenly paying so much more is. I'm not in any way trying to minimise that for my friend or others with a mortgage in this position.

However, I rent and we live in a very similar property in a similar area to her which I had been paying over £1100 for for the past 2 years and a few months ago this increased to £1250. When we were told about the increase we looked to see if there was anything we could possibly find for cheaper and everything comparable was actually closer to the £1400 mark.

I feel like the news has covered the impact interest rises are having on home owners virtually every day since the mini budget last September but renter's have only had a cursory 'and rents will increase due to landlords passing on their increases' at the end of the odd story. And with zero acknowledgement that rents were already so much higher than mortgages anyway and still are. It's not like renting has suddenly become the better option; it's still utterly impossible!

Am I being unreasonable to think there needs to be more outrage and support for renters and not just those needing to remortgage.

OP posts:
Hummusanddipdip · 28/05/2023 22:10

SweetSakura · 28/05/2023 21:45

Wouldn't insurance pay out for this?

When we had a big leak all the work was covered by the insurance (plastering, carpets, plumbing etc).

Nope, bought our house in December, fully redecorated by previous owner, so lots of issues hidden and homebuyers report didn't spot, both bathroom and en suite have had to be ripped out and replaced along with livingroom and hallway ceilings.
Home insurance wouldn't cover because it was "wear and tear" that caused the damage, couldn't go back on the previous owner as although he knew about the leaks, he had proof he had done "everything possible" to repair the issues... completely decimated mine and dh savings to fix all that damage

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:10

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 22:08

@Spectre8 surely home repossession is a last resort and the bank will try to help someone genuinely struggling to prevent this from happening. I don't remember rent holidays being a thing but mortgage holidays are an option. I see on here countless people suggesting how homeowners can temporarily save money by going interest only or increasing the term of ther mortgage to reduce their payments. None of this is an option for renters. And not every renter is entitled to housing benefit. I'm certainly not.

You need equity in the home to be able to do those things and take breaks.

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 22:08

@Spectre8 surely home repossession is a last resort and the bank will try to help someone genuinely struggling to prevent this from happening. I don't remember rent holidays being a thing but mortgage holidays are an option. I see on here countless people suggesting how homeowners can temporarily save money by going interest only or increasing the term of ther mortgage to reduce their payments. None of this is an option for renters. And not every renter is entitled to housing benefit. I'm certainly not.

OP posts:
Sillysosij · 28/05/2023 22:06

Cosyblankets · 28/05/2023 22:00

Landlord here.
I've recently remortgaged. My tenants had just signed for another 6 months just before I remortgaged. I will not be putting their rent up until the end of that 6 months. If they stay I will give them the open market monthly rent figure and discount this for them as they are good payers and look after the property. I will absorb some of the cost because it would cost us both more if they moved out.
In order to buy the house, I had to find a hefty deposit and a large chunk of money to bring the property up to scratch. A new boiler, new electrics etc probably more than I've ever spent on my own home. If something breaks down it is my responsibility to fix it in a timely manner. They are paying good money to live there.
There is way more than the mortgage payment to consider.

In order to buy a house everyone needs to find a chunk of money for the deposit and any work that needs doing, that’s just normal. I presume you expect to make a profit from being a landlord?

CountessBathorysBeautySecrets · 28/05/2023 22:05

Spectre8 · 28/05/2023 22:03

Well a home only gives a little bit more security. If you don't have any savings your only really one paycheck away from losing your mortgaged house if you suddenly lost your job. Thats why repossessions are up.

Er, repossessions don't take place after one missed mortgage payment.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:03

Larner · 28/05/2023 22:01

Apart from Madwife, it would seem.

I don’t “aspire” to be a renter but if I knew 5 years ago what I know now I wouldn’t have bought this house to be trapped in negative equity with a mortgage I can’t afford.

Spectre8 · 28/05/2023 22:03

Well a home only gives a little bit more security. If you don't have any savings your only really one paycheck away from losing your mortgaged house if you suddenly lost your job. Thats why repossessions are up.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 28/05/2023 22:02

BungleandGeorge · 28/05/2023 21:37

You’re not comparing like with like as I’d guess she has a considerable equity in the house for her payment to be only 1k a month?
youve also forgotten the maintenance costs of owning a home which are considerable. Plumbing issues, gutters swept, boiler servicing, general maintenance and repairs are all regular expenses not required when renting

Re the equity: not necessarily.

We only have 60k equity, home valued at £250k, and are paying £870/month. Newly agreed mortgage.

Larner · 28/05/2023 22:01

CountessBathorysBeautySecrets · 28/05/2023 21:59

Of course.

Most renters aspire to being homeowners. Far fewer homeowners dream of renting again.

Apart from Madwife, it would seem.

Cosyblankets · 28/05/2023 22:00

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:29

I'm genuinely not trying to say that people with mortgages are not struggling. It's hard to word exactly what mean without it sounding like I'm saying 'people with mortgages have it so easy' but that's not what I'm trying to say.
I just feel that since last September, the discussion has been pretty much exclusively about how it's those with mortgages that are suffering the most due to interest rate rises but it is simply a fact (it seems) that it's still more expensive to rent and renters are taking just as much of a financial hit as a direct result of the interest rate rises but no one's talking about that anymore.
And yes I appreciate that there are other costs involved in home ownership but unless your mortgage is up for remortgage soon, this isn't something that is currently affecting every homeowner where everyone I know who rents seems to have had their rent increased. And you can bet you bottom dollar that not every one of their landlords has actually had to remortgage when they made the decision to increase their rent.

Landlord here.
I've recently remortgaged. My tenants had just signed for another 6 months just before I remortgaged. I will not be putting their rent up until the end of that 6 months. If they stay I will give them the open market monthly rent figure and discount this for them as they are good payers and look after the property. I will absorb some of the cost because it would cost us both more if they moved out.
In order to buy the house, I had to find a hefty deposit and a large chunk of money to bring the property up to scratch. A new boiler, new electrics etc probably more than I've ever spent on my own home. If something breaks down it is my responsibility to fix it in a timely manner. They are paying good money to live there.
There is way more than the mortgage payment to consider.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:00

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:57

@Madwife123 I didn't say they had it 'far easier'. I said they were better off, there's a difference. I'm taking purely financially and I'm genuinely not seeing that I'm wrong. Other than the odd exceptionally unfortunate homeowner who's house flooded in a way their insurance wouldn't cover it, I'm not buying maintenance is what makes up the difference and it is purely a fact that, where I live certainly, the rent is more expensive than a mortgage for similar properties.

And I’m saying that’s not the case for everyone!

If I were to rent right now I would actually be entitled to a small amount of universal credit to help with rent payments. But alas we are in negative equity.

I will be better off in 30 years when the house is paid for yes. That doesn’t help me manage the bills now.

And you can budget far better for a fixed expense then an emergency expense that crops up when you can least afford it.

CountessBathorysBeautySecrets · 28/05/2023 21:59

SweetSakura · 28/05/2023 21:51

Well quite. I think they are being disingenuous and they know full well they are in a more privileged position.

Of course.

Most renters aspire to being homeowners. Far fewer homeowners dream of renting again.

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:57

@Madwife123 I didn't say they had it 'far easier'. I said they were better off, there's a difference. I'm taking purely financially and I'm genuinely not seeing that I'm wrong. Other than the odd exceptionally unfortunate homeowner who's house flooded in a way their insurance wouldn't cover it, I'm not buying maintenance is what makes up the difference and it is purely a fact that, where I live certainly, the rent is more expensive than a mortgage for similar properties.

OP posts:
TedMullins · 28/05/2023 21:56

No of course YANBU. I’m a homeowner but I have very little sympathy with a lot of the things homeowners tend to moan about. Boo hoo, we have to pay to fix our own stuff. I have a flat with a service charge which is not a particularly pleasant cost, particularly when it increases, but when I entered into home ownership I accepted that was part of the deal. (Mortgage protection insurance is optional too, I’m totally uninsurable due to health issues but you can get a mortgage without it.)

CrackedSkull · 28/05/2023 21:55

I remember 15% interest rates, they briefly touched 18% . Our mortgage trebled . The anxiety was overwhelming. I was being bullied in my job and could not retaliate because I was terrified of losing my job ( long story) My DC has a mortgage and I pray he never has to go through what we went through . I think rents will go up again to pay for this mortgage rise .

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 28/05/2023 21:54

SweetSakura · 28/05/2023 21:51

Well quite. I think they are being disingenuous and they know full well they are in a more privileged position.

I think you are quite right. I have a mortgage, and don’t envy anybody who rents. Yes, it can be really tough when something goes wrong, or the mortgage goes up, but as others have said, at least I know in 25 years or so, we will own our home outright. I would much prefer that than to rent and claim housing benefit (and likely still need to work to top it up!)

TheHateIsNotGood · 28/05/2023 21:54

Totally agree OP - I'm a poor, single, 60 year old female who cares for a young adult autistic son which has curtailed my earning ability for over 20 years.

But even though I have to find £300pcm (mort+mort ins) out of thin air, even I know I couldn't rent a garage for that. But I have a secure roof over our heads and that is priceless.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:53

I could say the same for renters.

But I’m not saying it’s more difficult. I’m saying it’s equally as difficult right now when the OP said home owners have it “far easier”.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:51

Larner · 28/05/2023 21:48

Where are you going to live if you have no house?

Either buy a smaller property as kids will have left home or rent.

SweetSakura · 28/05/2023 21:51

Sillysosij · 28/05/2023 21:50

I also wonder why any of the ‘owning is more difficult’ people continue to own rather than selling and renting, as it’s so much cheaper and more convenient.

Well quite. I think they are being disingenuous and they know full well they are in a more privileged position.

openstop · 28/05/2023 21:50

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:49

He is in the south and it was complicated by the fact the old boiler was in a bedroom which no longer meets legal standards so he also had to pay for the loft floor to be reinforced so it could be moved up there and new pipework etc.

Ah right! Makes sense. Sounds messy.

blibblibs · 28/05/2023 21:50

We managed to buy our first house last year and had our deal before Liz got hold of the economy.
Our 4 bed rental was £825 ( no increase in the 5 years we lived there) and the mortgage on our 3 bed house is £300 more but I'm still very very thankful we finally managed to become home owners.
There was a point where we ended up in 3 rentals in 14 months, that's no way for anyone to live.

Sillysosij · 28/05/2023 21:50

I also wonder why any of the ‘owning is more difficult’ people continue to own rather than selling and renting, as it’s so much cheaper and more convenient.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:49

openstop · 28/05/2023 21:48

That's really really expensive. Did he go through British gas or something?

He is in the south and it was complicated by the fact the old boiler was in a bedroom which no longer meets legal standards so he also had to pay for the loft floor to be reinforced so it could be moved up there and new pipework etc.

SweetSakura · 28/05/2023 21:49

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:40

Okay, so the argument for home maintenance (not improving to your personal taste because we all know that landlords absolutely don't do this.. Genuine, essential maintenance), you're telling me that the average homeowner spends £3000 a year, every year on this? Because that's the difference between my rent and my friend's new mortgage rate. And like I said, if I were to move I'd actually be looking at £1400 so that's £4800 a year, just on essential maintenance. I'm sorry, but I find that hard to believe.

Actually I think you are being overly fair to home owners here.

A better comparison is between just the interest they pay and the rent payments. Because the amount they are paying down the capital by is gradually building up their equity/paying down their debt so can't really be compared to rent