Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people with an average mortgage are still far better off than their renting counterparts

242 replies

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:06

I met with a friend today who was moaning about having sorted their remortgage this week and how their payments have increased by £250 a month due to interest rises. She's now paying £1000 for their 3 bed semi and I do fully appreciate how stressful knowing this remortgage was due has been for them this past year and how painful suddenly paying so much more is. I'm not in any way trying to minimise that for my friend or others with a mortgage in this position.

However, I rent and we live in a very similar property in a similar area to her which I had been paying over £1100 for for the past 2 years and a few months ago this increased to £1250. When we were told about the increase we looked to see if there was anything we could possibly find for cheaper and everything comparable was actually closer to the £1400 mark.

I feel like the news has covered the impact interest rises are having on home owners virtually every day since the mini budget last September but renter's have only had a cursory 'and rents will increase due to landlords passing on their increases' at the end of the odd story. And with zero acknowledgement that rents were already so much higher than mortgages anyway and still are. It's not like renting has suddenly become the better option; it's still utterly impossible!

Am I being unreasonable to think there needs to be more outrage and support for renters and not just those needing to remortgage.

OP posts:
TUCKINGFYP0 · 28/05/2023 22:35

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:40

Okay, so the argument for home maintenance (not improving to your personal taste because we all know that landlords absolutely don't do this.. Genuine, essential maintenance), you're telling me that the average homeowner spends £3000 a year, every year on this? Because that's the difference between my rent and my friend's new mortgage rate. And like I said, if I were to move I'd actually be looking at £1400 so that's £4800 a year, just on essential maintenance. I'm sorry, but I find that hard to believe.

Landlords have to pay their letting agent, service fees for the building, common repairs , ground rent, insurances, gas safety checks, boiler repairs as well as servicing, landlord registration, EICR, LRA, PAT. That’s on top of any repairs that are needed, redecoration between tenancies, routine maintenance and new flooring and kitchen and bathroom as required.

Your landlords mortgage will have gone up too , it’s just that their rates are higher for rented properties than for home owners. Oh and even higher if they are a limited company or have more than 6 properties.

So yes these are “ genuine essential costs “ Hmm.

It’s very easy to underestimate the costs of owning a property.

BungleandGeorge · 28/05/2023 22:33

GneissGuysFinishLast · 28/05/2023 22:20

No it isn’t, and I’m not sure exactly how you could come up with any sort of figure without knowing the term? - it’s a 185k repayment mortgage. Remortgaged last month with Halifax. Rate is 4.29%.

Given that’s below the base rate yes that a low rate, and only available as you have a large deposit of 25% ! And I’d guess it’s a long fixed rate so a bit of a gamble. 35 year terms aren’t available to many people due to their age either

Larner · 28/05/2023 22:32

I don’t know the full ins and outs of what had to be done

No shit.

Colourmylifewith · 28/05/2023 22:32

TedMullins · 28/05/2023 21:56

No of course YANBU. I’m a homeowner but I have very little sympathy with a lot of the things homeowners tend to moan about. Boo hoo, we have to pay to fix our own stuff. I have a flat with a service charge which is not a particularly pleasant cost, particularly when it increases, but when I entered into home ownership I accepted that was part of the deal. (Mortgage protection insurance is optional too, I’m totally uninsurable due to health issues but you can get a mortgage without it.)

Wow!! Someone who is actually in the real world, speaking sense!!! Thank god, sadly so many don’t have your attitude

BananaBlue · 28/05/2023 22:32

Plottingspringescape · 28/05/2023 22:21

Well let's face it most people with a mortgage have the option to sell up and rent if they want. Most renters do not have the same level of choice.

Yes.

and as a home owner I’m unlikely to come home to a ‘you need to leave in 8 weeks’ letter just like that and totally out of my control.

Issues with finding a home, changing sch/work if needing to relocate.

so many ppl in hotels moving every few days.

I’m a home owner, things are a bit tight but I’m a bit disappointed by some of the tone deaf responses here.

https://www.romfordrecorder.co.uk/news/23484609.havering-council-keeps-homeless-family-hotels-months/

'Disgusting': Single mum says being homeless is costing her more than renting a house

A homeless single mum from Romford has been housed in budget hotels for months by Havering Council - but says it is costing her more than her old…

https://www.romfordrecorder.co.uk/news/23484609.havering-council-keeps-homeless-family-hotels-months/

Colourmylifewith · 28/05/2023 22:30

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:41

Are you kidding?

I spend more far more than that in a year on home maintenance, safety checks (annual boiler service etc.) and insurances that are required for home ownership!

Yet if the house stood empty you would still need to pay council tax, standing charges for utilities and also insurance at a minimum. That’s part of being a home owner. Too many attitudes that landlords are going Tennent’s a ‘favour’ by up keeping their OWN property, the majority of which would need to be paid wether there were tenants in or not!

Skethylita · 28/05/2023 22:29

I know that a lot of people on here are very keen to give costs which may or may not arise annually when owning a house (I certainly hope that I won't have to deal with leaks every year), but there are some considerable advantages to owning that no amount of money saving by renting can make up for:

  • the security: I can own and never have to worry about being kicked out at 2 months' notice again for whatever reason someone else decides. Each house move has cost me the best part of £1000, and there were times where this happened every year.
  • being allowed to maintain the house. Yes, that is a priviledge. I no longer have to ask whether that fuse box from the 1960s can be updated, I can decide it will be.
  • being allowed to choose my own timeline for maintenance. I no longer have to worry about having to be in the house at 11am on days I'm working (I can't take days off outside of my scheduled ones). If I decide that the gutter can wait another month before clearing is needed I can make it so. If I cannot be arsed to cut the grass for 3 weeks then that's my priviledge, because I don't have to follow a stupid contract where everything has to be perfect for inspection.
  • being allowed to decorate. I fucking hate magnolia with a passion. One of my walls has about 30 nails stuck in it because I like the pictures and decorations I have hung there and I didn't need to get a knock by knock permission to do so.

Nothing can convince me that the extra money I am spending on the mortgage and maintenance (yes, I pay more than I did for a less desirable house, all in) is not worth the freedom and security that comes with owning a house. And, ultimately, the money in this piggy bank made of bricks and concrete.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:25

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 22:24

So did ours. It’s not even in the house any more, it was moved to the garage.

His was moved to the loft which involved reinforcing the floor. I don’t know the full ins and outs of what had to be done but I know he was horrified at the price and couldn’t understand why it couldn’t go back in the bedroom it had been in for 15 years.

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 22:24

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:20

You missed my other post explaining the cost. It had to be relocated to meet current building regs also.

So did ours. It’s not even in the house any more, it was moved to the garage.

Divorcedalongtime · 28/05/2023 22:23

OnSusansFloor · 28/05/2023 21:36

YANBU. I'm mortgaged and dreading my upcoming increase, but I have a friend who had her second baby a week ago and their landlord (in a property they've only been in for 6 months) has just given them 8 weeks notice to leave as he wants to sell. The absolute maximum they can afford is about £300 below what they'll need for a 2-bed around here. The stress she and her DH are under, whilst also trying to navigate all the adjustments that come with having a new baby in the family, is enough to sink a ship. I really worry that it will break them.

I’m in this position too but without the baby and instead 3 tweens teens. The rent I pay £1200 is cheap (yeah right) compared to what everything else is now here , £1800 for 3 bedroom and £1500 for 2 bedroom.
sucks

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:22

Plottingspringescape · 28/05/2023 22:21

Well let's face it most people with a mortgage have the option to sell up and rent if they want. Most renters do not have the same level of choice.

Not when you’re in negative equity!

Plottingspringescape · 28/05/2023 22:21

Well let's face it most people with a mortgage have the option to sell up and rent if they want. Most renters do not have the same level of choice.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:20

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 22:19

Is the new boiler gold plated? We had a top of the range boiler fitted last year, along with replacement of 14 radiators and it cost us a touch over £8k. The boiler’s guaranteed for 10 years with free servicing for the first five. We’ve never spent £5k a year on maintenance.

You missed my other post explaining the cost. It had to be relocated to meet current building regs also.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 28/05/2023 22:20

BungleandGeorge · 28/05/2023 22:15

That’s only the interest on a 190k mortgage? And not a bad interest rate

No it isn’t, and I’m not sure exactly how you could come up with any sort of figure without knowing the term? - it’s a 185k repayment mortgage. Remortgaged last month with Halifax. Rate is 4.29%.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:19

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 22:14

@Madwife123
Yes, I appreciate that. But most people do have some equity these days. I'm sorry that you don't. I genuinely never said (and don't mean) that every homeowner is living the life of Riley and absolutely many will be struggling far more than many renters are. But nevertheless, most homeowners have some equity (deposits and constantly rising house prices have made sure of this in most situations). Where as very few renter's have any say or control over how much they pay and if they are struggling, landlords are not incentivised to help because there's always someone else who can take their place and can pay.

The only way we could afford to buy our first home was using the government help to buy scheme. Which they should have called “help to get yourself in crippling debt that you actually can’t afford”. So our deposit was by much at all. And as the help to buy scheme had to be a new build that’s what we bought so we paid over the odds and like all new builds the house lost value initially.

Curtains70 · 28/05/2023 22:19

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:43

Well actually in my situation I will sell the house at the end of that to fund my retirement while renters get housing benefit alongside their pension to cover their rent. The grass really isn’t greener on either side!

🙄

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 22:19

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:46

My father in law has just had to pay £11000 for a new boiler after it broke down.

Unless he has zero maintenance costs for the next 4 years, that alone is more than the ‘extra’ you pay in rent.

Is the new boiler gold plated? We had a top of the range boiler fitted last year, along with replacement of 14 radiators and it cost us a touch over £8k. The boiler’s guaranteed for 10 years with free servicing for the first five. We’ve never spent £5k a year on maintenance.

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 22:17

HorseyMel · 28/05/2023 22:12

This is what the advice always was - rent a cheap bedsit with your husband/partner/whatever while saving for a deposit for a house. Get the house, have kids = life's on the right track.

I see so many threads on here where people are saying they can't save for a deposit as they have to rent a 3 bed house as they already have several kids. Yes - exactly - wrong order = high rent costs = can't save a deposit = stuck in a cycle that will see you in retirement paying rent = likely no retirement.

I get that people should do what they want, but I see a decent amount of regret and I wonder if a bit more thought and planning would have led to a better long term decision.

This is where I went wrong.

Bought our first house when we already had 3 children. But couldn’t afford it any earlier.

Bought a house that took us to the very limits of our affordability as we needed it big enough for 5 people which most ‘starter’ homes aren’t. Used help to buy loan to pay a lot of the deposit.

NHS wages froze for years so no pay rise for me. Self employed partner lost thousands in income over covid period and forced to take on a job eventually earning much less so already struggling with the payment we could previously afford.

And then mortgage renewal comes and shoots the payment up. But we’re in negative equity and new builds lose value at first so we’re stuck. And now we need to start making payments on the help to buy loan also.

CountessBathorysBeautySecrets · 28/05/2023 22:16

I doubt that the average homeowner replaces their windows and their kitchen every 20 years. There's a bit of dramatic license on this thread.

BungleandGeorge · 28/05/2023 22:15

GneissGuysFinishLast · 28/05/2023 22:02

Re the equity: not necessarily.

We only have 60k equity, home valued at £250k, and are paying £870/month. Newly agreed mortgage.

That’s only the interest on a 190k mortgage? And not a bad interest rate

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 22:14

@Madwife123
Yes, I appreciate that. But most people do have some equity these days. I'm sorry that you don't. I genuinely never said (and don't mean) that every homeowner is living the life of Riley and absolutely many will be struggling far more than many renters are. But nevertheless, most homeowners have some equity (deposits and constantly rising house prices have made sure of this in most situations). Where as very few renter's have any say or control over how much they pay and if they are struggling, landlords are not incentivised to help because there's always someone else who can take their place and can pay.

OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 28/05/2023 22:13

That was in response to@Sillysosij

HorseyMel · 28/05/2023 22:12

SummerSimmer · 28/05/2023 21:20

YANBU
it is shite for renters and almost impossible to save and rent.
I have tried to explain to my adult DC to prioritise trying to buy before having a family.

This is what the advice always was - rent a cheap bedsit with your husband/partner/whatever while saving for a deposit for a house. Get the house, have kids = life's on the right track.

I see so many threads on here where people are saying they can't save for a deposit as they have to rent a 3 bed house as they already have several kids. Yes - exactly - wrong order = high rent costs = can't save a deposit = stuck in a cycle that will see you in retirement paying rent = likely no retirement.

I get that people should do what they want, but I see a decent amount of regret and I wonder if a bit more thought and planning would have led to a better long term decision.

Cosyblankets · 28/05/2023 22:12

A residential mortgage you can get with 10% deposit. A buy to let needs 25% so yes it's a lot more. For me it is a long term investment. I saved for about ten years to pay for it so it will be a long time before i will be in profit. If I was not going to make a profit what would be the point? I live in an area with a large teaching hospital with a lot of staff of a rotation of a year or two. Not everyone who rents actually wants to buy at that point as they will be moving on.

BungleandGeorge · 28/05/2023 22:11

No insurance doesn’t cover you for whatever has gone wrong, it covers you for the damage (minus the excess)

some costs for you OP:
solicitor fees for house purchase
estate agent fees for house sale
stamp duty
mortgage arrangement fees
boiler every 10-15 years
boiler service every year plus periodic breakdown and parts
new kitchen every 15-20 years
new oven periodically
new windows every 20 years
new fencing every 10-15 years plus maintenance in between
maintenance for gutters and roof (in last 10 years have had 2 new tiles, fixing of gutter twice and yearly clean)
plumbing- various leaks over 10 year period
new flooring wvery 10-15 years
basic decoration
buildings insurance
life/ employment insurance to cover the property

thats not nearly everything and doesn’t include anything major and unpredictable. Yes it’s easily thousands a year. I’ve rented and owned. It’s certainly sometimes much cheaper
and more convenient to rent, for example if you’re moving area every couple of years.