Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people with an average mortgage are still far better off than their renting counterparts

242 replies

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:06

I met with a friend today who was moaning about having sorted their remortgage this week and how their payments have increased by £250 a month due to interest rises. She's now paying £1000 for their 3 bed semi and I do fully appreciate how stressful knowing this remortgage was due has been for them this past year and how painful suddenly paying so much more is. I'm not in any way trying to minimise that for my friend or others with a mortgage in this position.

However, I rent and we live in a very similar property in a similar area to her which I had been paying over £1100 for for the past 2 years and a few months ago this increased to £1250. When we were told about the increase we looked to see if there was anything we could possibly find for cheaper and everything comparable was actually closer to the £1400 mark.

I feel like the news has covered the impact interest rises are having on home owners virtually every day since the mini budget last September but renter's have only had a cursory 'and rents will increase due to landlords passing on their increases' at the end of the odd story. And with zero acknowledgement that rents were already so much higher than mortgages anyway and still are. It's not like renting has suddenly become the better option; it's still utterly impossible!

Am I being unreasonable to think there needs to be more outrage and support for renters and not just those needing to remortgage.

OP posts:
stayathomer · 29/05/2023 14:28

Everyone we know who privately rents has moved in the last twelve months. Not usually from their own choice, but because the LL is selling or gas out the rent up too far.
We had moved nearly every 2 years when renting- my 15yo has lived in nine houses, if you look at our list of addresses it looks like we were under witness protection scheme😅

Riverlee · 29/05/2023 14:25

SquashPenguin · 28/05/2023 21:14

It’s shit for everyone.

Fourth post on thread sums it up…

LakieLady · 29/05/2023 14:15

Madwife123 · 28/05/2023 21:46

My father in law has just had to pay £11000 for a new boiler after it broke down.

Unless he has zero maintenance costs for the next 4 years, that alone is more than the ‘extra’ you pay in rent.

😮How much? Does he live in a castle or something?

I had a new boiler just over 2 years ago, cost £1,300. I had the 30 year old bathroom suite replaced at the same time, cost, £5k all in, but I concede that wasn't an actual repair, it was functional.

In 2020, I had to have the windows and doors replaced ( £13k). The year before that, new soffits, facias, guttering and downpipes, plus re-felting the roof on the bay window - £2.6k (and that was cheap - next cheapest quote was nearly £4k).

I had a leak under the sink at the start of this year, emergency work to stop it was £200+. Then a proper fix was another £150. Then I needed a new kitchen tap, £140, and the annual boiler service was £110.

I now need a fencepost replacing, and I can't find anyone who'll come out and just do one post - too small a job, apparently.

Three rooms, plus hall/stairs/landing, desperately need redecorating. It seems bloody endless, there's always something that needs doing and it's always expensive. And I'm too old and decrepit to go getting up ladders and shite myself.

MidnightMeltdown · 29/05/2023 14:14

Comedycook · 29/05/2023 12:54

@MidnightMeltdown house was bought ten years ago so not that long ago really.

It's a long time in terms of house price growth though. London house prices have doubled in the past 10 years

Comedycook · 29/05/2023 12:54

@MidnightMeltdown house was bought ten years ago so not that long ago really.

verdantverdure · 29/05/2023 12:50

It's the constant moving that worries me with renting.

Everyone we know who privately rents has moved in the last twelve months. Not usually from their own choice, but because the LL is selling or gas out the rent up too far.

It really worries me that so many children are growing up without a garden, and without pets and having to move all the time. It's not my idea of stability.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 29/05/2023 12:45

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 12:18

We bought the house 5 years ago. HTB is interest free for the first 5 years and then starts being paid. Ours starts in July. We’ve worked out it will be around £60 a month. We were paying nothing before so that’s the ‘increase’ I mean.

Property was bought for £267k, 75% mortgage, 20% HTB and 5% deposit yes. Zoopla tells me the house is now valued at £230k. Neighbours recently sold there’s for £215 however so think it might be a little overestimated. Zoopla doesn’t take into account an ongoing legal battle with a large piece of land behind the houses that means there is a waste ground being used by travellers and rough sleepers while this is ongoing and so it’s now a less attractive area to buy.

Ours won’t achieve full value as we had a major leak recently and haven’t been able to fully repair the damage due to costs. Plus we haven’t been able to afford to decorate so new build white with 3 children after 5 years looks very grubby. I think we would be lucky if we got £200k for it right now.

Paid less of the mortgage than planned as my partner was furloughed during covid and we took a 6 month mortgage break during this time. So by the time HTB take their 20% back and the mortgage is cleared we walk away in debt.

Pretty unrelated but zoopla is so much less accurate than it was 10ish years ago. Our house sold for 50% more than the zoopla estimate. We were shocked.

Apparently smaller properties are in demand just now because many people are downsizing due to financial issues.

Twinpeaches · 29/05/2023 12:28

Threads like this are so frustrating. Life has on the whole got worse for everyone other than the super rich as a result of 13 years of this government. They love it when we look to each other to ‘blame’ rather than shouting about the actual issues.

ThankmelaterOkay · 29/05/2023 12:25

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 12:18

We bought the house 5 years ago. HTB is interest free for the first 5 years and then starts being paid. Ours starts in July. We’ve worked out it will be around £60 a month. We were paying nothing before so that’s the ‘increase’ I mean.

Property was bought for £267k, 75% mortgage, 20% HTB and 5% deposit yes. Zoopla tells me the house is now valued at £230k. Neighbours recently sold there’s for £215 however so think it might be a little overestimated. Zoopla doesn’t take into account an ongoing legal battle with a large piece of land behind the houses that means there is a waste ground being used by travellers and rough sleepers while this is ongoing and so it’s now a less attractive area to buy.

Ours won’t achieve full value as we had a major leak recently and haven’t been able to fully repair the damage due to costs. Plus we haven’t been able to afford to decorate so new build white with 3 children after 5 years looks very grubby. I think we would be lucky if we got £200k for it right now.

Paid less of the mortgage than planned as my partner was furloughed during covid and we took a 6 month mortgage break during this time. So by the time HTB take their 20% back and the mortgage is cleared we walk away in debt.

Ah that makes sense.

So the equity loan has been adjusted to reflect the price fall?
ie if you think it’s dropped 25%, then the equity loan is adjusted accordingly? Right?

So if it started at £53,400, it’s now £40,050?

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 12:22

GasPanic · 29/05/2023 12:19

I suppose it is a question of whether houses are viewed as an investment or place to live.

As an investment they will probably will be pretty poor at first, but time will probably deal with that, provided the swingeing interest rate increases that are coming are serviceable to allow people get to that point.

The issue with IR rises is always the delta. Someone who is entering year 6 is not only having to cope with the large base rate rises, but also the phasing in of the interest rate on the government equity loan simultaneously (you probably don't need me to tell you this).

The real issue is for people who bought these as starter homes with the intention of moving onto bigger places - because my guess is that they are stuck for 10-20 years to ride out the NE.

In about 2-3 years time I think HTB will be held up as a prime example of why the government should not involve itself in markets like this, and indeed why it doesn't usually.

Agreed!

We had a full vision in place of enter year 6, remortgage at a similar rate. Our earnings should have been higher at this point (but covid put a stop to that) so we could add the help to buy loan into the mortgage and pay it off that way.

GasPanic · 29/05/2023 12:19

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 11:47

It’s not paying the help to buy interest that’s the issue for us.

It’s the fact that help to buy meant we had to buy a new build so now we’re in negative equity, as is common with new builds in the first few years. So we can’t remortgage and we are stuck on the SVR rate.

Combined with interest rates going through the roof. The house that looked affordable thanks to help to buy, in fact isn’t.

I suppose it is a question of whether houses are viewed as an investment or place to live.

As an investment they will probably will be pretty poor at first, but time will probably deal with that, provided the swingeing interest rate increases that are coming are serviceable to allow people get to that point.

The issue with IR rises is always the delta. Someone who is entering year 6 is not only having to cope with the large base rate rises, but also the phasing in of the interest rate on the government equity loan simultaneously (you probably don't need me to tell you this).

The real issue is for people who bought these as starter homes with the intention of moving onto bigger places - because my guess is that they are stuck for 10-20 years to ride out the NE.

In about 2-3 years time I think HTB will be held up as a prime example of why the government should not involve itself in markets like this, and indeed why it doesn't usually.

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 12:18

We bought the house 5 years ago. HTB is interest free for the first 5 years and then starts being paid. Ours starts in July. We’ve worked out it will be around £60 a month. We were paying nothing before so that’s the ‘increase’ I mean.

Property was bought for £267k, 75% mortgage, 20% HTB and 5% deposit yes. Zoopla tells me the house is now valued at £230k. Neighbours recently sold there’s for £215 however so think it might be a little overestimated. Zoopla doesn’t take into account an ongoing legal battle with a large piece of land behind the houses that means there is a waste ground being used by travellers and rough sleepers while this is ongoing and so it’s now a less attractive area to buy.

Ours won’t achieve full value as we had a major leak recently and haven’t been able to fully repair the damage due to costs. Plus we haven’t been able to afford to decorate so new build white with 3 children after 5 years looks very grubby. I think we would be lucky if we got £200k for it right now.

Paid less of the mortgage than planned as my partner was furloughed during covid and we took a 6 month mortgage break during this time. So by the time HTB take their 20% back and the mortgage is cleared we walk away in debt.

ThankmelaterOkay · 29/05/2023 12:13

Sorry, £50/month.

£600 a year? On a loan that started at 1.75%? It can realistically can only increase by 0.2-0.25% per year? So, £50 = 0.25% increase? Ie 2% x 1.12 = 2.25%?

So, if you’d borrowed £100k HTB Equity, the interest would have been £2000 per year at 2%, and it’s now £2250?

i don’t get it

Whammyyammy · 29/05/2023 12:10

SquashPenguin · 28/05/2023 21:14

It’s shit for everyone.

This. Let's stop the comparisons and the race to the bitting

ThankmelaterOkay · 29/05/2023 12:03

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 11:50

Negative equity and forced into a SVR rate of 7.7% isn’t paltry! When your 2.4% deal comes to an end. That’s the issue!

I’m sorry you got caught out in this way.

What did you buy the property for? Presume it was 75% mortgage, 20% HTB Loan, 5% deposit.

What is the property worth now? Assume you bought 7+ years ago? As HTB interest doesn’t start until year 6, and increases annually, you said it had increased by £60?

ThankmelaterOkay · 29/05/2023 11:51

MidnightMeltdown · 29/05/2023 11:46

I assume that you bought a long time ago, which really illustrates the point that it's more about which generation you are, rather than whether you're a homeowner or a renter.

I'm sure that most people who bought in London in the past 10 years will be paying a much higher mortgage, as house prices have risen so much more than wages.

Of course there are always exceptions, but as a whole, baby boomers and gen x are sitting pretty, while millennials and gen z are screwed over. It doesn't matter whether they are renters or homeowners - they are screwed either way because of the time that they were born.

Well, no.

Renters (of any generation) < Z on property Ladder < Y on property ladder < X on property ladder < Boomers on property ladder

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 11:50

ThankmelaterOkay · 29/05/2023 11:48

1.75% x CPI + 2%.

So even with a mega horrific CPI of 10.1%…

1.75 x (10.1% + 2%) = 1.96%.

Paltry.

Negative equity and forced into a SVR rate of 7.7% isn’t paltry! When your 2.4% deal comes to an end. That’s the issue!

OrwellianTimes · 29/05/2023 11:48

Parkandpicnic · 29/05/2023 07:44

As an ex renting homeowner I completely agree with you, I do wonder whether some of these people who have needed to do a lot of work bought listed/old character properties or houses which needed a lot of doing up in the first place?? I doubt most renters are fortunate enough to live in beautiful character properties and if it’s a case of having bought somewhere quite run down then surely the homeowner had factored that in. E.g. saved 30k on the sale price so actually over the course of the mortgage was better off even with paying for those 20k of repairs. You really are completely right, I just don’t think many people who haven’t had to rent (privately) while bringing up a family etc really have a clue. Think they think it must be like renting a nice holiday let on a longer term basis when actually the quality of most rental properties is a world away

My last rental property I lived in was beautifully done up throughout. Everything modern.

Most of us with mortgages aren’t living in pretty character houses. Most of us are living in 1980’s box like semis that weren’t built as well as Victorian era houses, and are now needing a lot of work.

ThankmelaterOkay · 29/05/2023 11:48

1.75% x CPI + 2%.

So even with a mega horrific CPI of 10.1%…

1.75 x (10.1% + 2%) = 1.96%.

Paltry.

Madwife123 · 29/05/2023 11:47

It’s not paying the help to buy interest that’s the issue for us.

It’s the fact that help to buy meant we had to buy a new build so now we’re in negative equity, as is common with new builds in the first few years. So we can’t remortgage and we are stuck on the SVR rate.

Combined with interest rates going through the roof. The house that looked affordable thanks to help to buy, in fact isn’t.

MidnightMeltdown · 29/05/2023 11:46

Comedycook · 29/05/2023 10:03

We own and our mortgage is currently fixed and about £500 a month. We live in London. To rent an equivalent home would cost us £2500 a month. Dh has a good salary but we'd be really really struggling if we rented. I don't know how people are managing. I feel so so grateful that we own our house

I assume that you bought a long time ago, which really illustrates the point that it's more about which generation you are, rather than whether you're a homeowner or a renter.

I'm sure that most people who bought in London in the past 10 years will be paying a much higher mortgage, as house prices have risen so much more than wages.

Of course there are always exceptions, but as a whole, baby boomers and gen x are sitting pretty, while millennials and gen z are screwed over. It doesn't matter whether they are renters or homeowners - they are screwed either way because of the time that they were born.

ThankmelaterOkay · 29/05/2023 11:44

GasPanic · 29/05/2023 11:30

Help to buy was just a way of making the unaffordable affordable.

What it has done is propped up prices and made people take on larger amounts of debt than they would have done if the market had been left to properly find its own level.

It doesn't benefit homebuyers at all. It benefits homeowners.

As to whether people with mortgages are better off than renters, that depends on how much negative equity they have - which will be making a comeback as rates go up and prices drop.

Aren’t the HTB equity loans paltry interest though?

So you just pay the interest. You just can’t move etc.

Curtains70 · 29/05/2023 11:42

OrwellianTimes · 29/05/2023 11:36

It’s crap for everybody. But you can’t directly compare rent to mortgage.

Your £1200 rent covers all the upkeep of the property too - replacing boilers, roofs, driveways, safety certificates, fire alarms etc.

Her £1000 doesn’t cover any upkeep. My house currently needs two doors replaced, a new boiler, a new driveway, external wall repairs - all of this together will cost near enough £15,000, and add to that the kitchen is about 35 years old and really needs replacing, easily another £15k.

The big difference is obviously equity at the end, so of course buying wins out on that. But the increase in price is just as rubbish for anyone.

I understand that I really do but at the same time some of those issues can't be compared with renting either.

I'll give you boiler and safety certificates but as somebody who rented for years most landlords won't give a shit about doors, drive way or an old kitchen.

Last time I was looking to rent most landlords are after the absolute highest price with the lowest standards of housing possible.

OrwellianTimes · 29/05/2023 11:36

It’s crap for everybody. But you can’t directly compare rent to mortgage.

Your £1200 rent covers all the upkeep of the property too - replacing boilers, roofs, driveways, safety certificates, fire alarms etc.

Her £1000 doesn’t cover any upkeep. My house currently needs two doors replaced, a new boiler, a new driveway, external wall repairs - all of this together will cost near enough £15,000, and add to that the kitchen is about 35 years old and really needs replacing, easily another £15k.

The big difference is obviously equity at the end, so of course buying wins out on that. But the increase in price is just as rubbish for anyone.

MrsMiagi · 29/05/2023 11:35

Theinventoroftoasterstrudel · 28/05/2023 21:40

Okay, so the argument for home maintenance (not improving to your personal taste because we all know that landlords absolutely don't do this.. Genuine, essential maintenance), you're telling me that the average homeowner spends £3000 a year, every year on this? Because that's the difference between my rent and my friend's new mortgage rate. And like I said, if I were to move I'd actually be looking at £1400 so that's £4800 a year, just on essential maintenance. I'm sorry, but I find that hard to believe.

Rented for years and now have had a mortgage for almost 3. We now pay buildings insurance, mortgage protection, boiler servicing, appliance cover, and whilst it doesn't amount to over 3k it does add up. All it takes is one repair and could easily be thousands extra a year.
That being said rent prices are outrageous. We pay about £100 more for the mortgage than when we were renting. We only managed a mortgage because my SO had a bit in savings following a previous house sale. We used a FTB scheme and I took on loads more responsibility to double my salary.
I have seen family have to move several times due to no fault evictions and the stress is unreal.
I don't know what the solution is