Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to weekend leave from hospice

284 replies

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 19:25

DM is in a hospice with stage four terminal lung cancer. I try to get up to see her every few weeks and as she hasn't seen my DD since Feb, I decided I would take her up next weekend as it's the end of half term. We could stay at Mums, and go visit her Friday, Saturday and Sunday for a few hours at a time but in between go to visit parks, museums etc... DM is currently not mobile, relies on a wheelchair and uses a commode. She's also very frail, weak and at a high risk of infection. She wants to ask the hospice for weekend release next weekend and I just don't think I can do it. It would mean moving a bed into the living room, helping her in and out of the wheelchair (alone) at several locations, bringing home a commode. Manoeuvring her on and off it (in front of five year old). It would also mean me and DD can't go out for the day after visiting her as she can't be left alone due to not being able to walk. I feel like an awful awful daughter but would I be unreasonable to say we maybe need to do it when she's a bit stronger and it's just me without DD??

OP posts:
JMSA · 28/05/2023 21:19

OP, I am genuinely sorry for my hurtful reply. I should have waited before responding to your opening post.
My grandmother, to whom I'm very close, is going through the same thing. I can't imagine not moving heaven and earth to grant her request, but I understand that everyone's circumstances are different.
I did find your tone in the OP very flippant, but that's no excuse to express myself in the way that I did.
Apologies once again and all the best.

TattiePants · 28/05/2023 21:18

We managed to keep my DGM at home when she had terminal cancer but the only reason that was possible was there were 3 of us who all lived close by doing round the clock care plus paid carers and nurses that took time and money to arrange. The final time my DGM used the commode, her legs went completely and fortunately my DH was visiting as he had to lift her as there was no way either me or my DM could do it safely. If the op was on her own that situation could be very dangerous for both her and her DM. My DCs visited a lot but were shielded from all aspects of her care, not something a 5 year old should witness.

Toddlerteaplease · 28/05/2023 21:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

But you also have to be able to do it safely, and it sounds like the OP can't do it safely. I would not do this for my mum
If it wasn't safe or practical.

dawngreen · 28/05/2023 21:17

Why not say a picnic type meal in the hospice grounds. You could have a chat knowing that the staff are close if needed.

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:14

Doodar · 28/05/2023 21:11

Could your partner come with you for a day With Dd, then take her home and you have some time with your mum alone? I say this gently but I would pull out all the stops to make this happen. Your Dd shouldn’t come first in all this.

DH is away. That's part of the reason we're going. Mum really wants to see her, which is why I thought daily visits for a few hours at a time (any longer is too much as she gets tired easily) with some walks round the ground would be ideal.

OP posts:
Bobbybobbins · 28/05/2023 21:13

I think your mum will absolutely love seeing both of you and this is the main thing. Maybe just a short walk or something from the hospice if she is in a wheelchair.

My mum died at home last summer and the last two weeks were incredibly difficult with no care provided at all. All the best.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 28/05/2023 21:12

Yanbu - your lovely DM clearly needs a team of carers and looking after a 5 year old is a full time job solo - you cannot possibly keep your DD ok at the same time as doing everything for your mum. You would need to hire a nurse, or possibly two, to be with you around the clock.

Your original idea is much better. DD will form some genuinely long-treasured happy memories if the visit can be of several short (45 min max) visits that are fun, morning and afternoon with other stuff in between. With the other plan DDs memories of the weekend will be mostly miserable and possibly traumatic.

Spellcheck · 28/05/2023 21:12

I can see it from both sides - on the one hand, your DM just wants to be home for a bit. The hospice must feel so final for her, so medical. On the other hand, the hard work involved looking after an almost immobile patient single-handed without all the conveniences of the hospice cannot be underestimated. Plus your little girl too… It would be impossible. Oh it’s so sad.
I can only echo what PP have said, and that is, can you arrange for a nurse to come and stay and help in her home?
Otherwise could one of the staff try and explain to your Mum that home would be impossible owing to lack of a proper bed (hospital style bed is the only option for people in this position in my experience), and the facilities that are lacking at home? It might sound more palatable coming from them and won’t affect your relationship.
I’m so sorry you’re in this situation, and your poor Mum too 🩷

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:12

realityhack · 28/05/2023 21:06

OP I am so sorry about your mum.

Ignore the bitchy and unkind responses, they are talking out of their arses and have no idea what such care really involves.

If your mum requires two to transfer then please do not do this- she would need OT equipment to enable this safely and worst case scenario, if you try to do it yourself alone, she could end up falling during a transfer and breaking a hip or you end up with a chronic back injury. There are health and safety reasons why mobility/transfers need to be carefully assessed in palliative care and this does not sound safe at all with you trying to juggle this all alone with a 5 year old. Who is going to watch your 5 year old whilst you are helping her with all this?

I would say no to her going home, BUT, I would see if I could bring in some of her favourite board games, music, movies and lovely food and try to have a nice get together in the hospice instead. Hospice staff are absolutely lovely so I am sure they could help you do this and arrange something really nice.

This is why I don't think the hospice will even let her. She was moved from a wheelchair to her bed the other day when I saw her. One nurse left the room and Mum wanted to be shuffled up the bed a bit. I went to take her under the arm with the nurse on the other side but she wouldn't let me. Said it was a safety risk as I wasn't trained and it was better for the nurses to do it.

OP posts:
Bluebells1970 · 28/05/2023 21:12

I can't imagine for one second a hospice agreeing to this. She's not only going to need physical care, but equipment in place as well as trained carers. Then add in a hospice or community nurse for medication.

It's not going to happen, OP, but I'd let your DM imagine it if it brings her some comfort. My Dad died in a hospice and we were unable to arrange taking him home due to lack of care support.

Doodar · 28/05/2023 21:11

Could your partner come with you for a day With Dd, then take her home and you have some time with your mum alone? I say this gently but I would pull out all the stops to make this happen. Your Dd shouldn’t come first in all this.

realityhack · 28/05/2023 21:10

WiddlinDiddlin · 28/05/2023 21:06

Do those of you having a pop at the OP have personal experience of being 'cared for' by people who mean well but in fact cannot meet your care needs?

I have.

Until you have, I'd suggest you shut the fuck up.

Its fucking horrible, realising their out of their depth, being bastarding uncomfortable, having to have your loved ones struggle to do the personal care you require, and them realising they are doing it badly... or not realising but you can't fucking ask them to sort out your knickers AGAIN because they're rubbing your fanny raw, you can't tell them sorry, you didn't actually wipe my arse properly and now shit is making the skin burn. Having to ask them to readjust your position again, trying not to go on and on about how the mattress is hurting your arse or you just can't get in a position that doesn't hurt.

It is awful.

OP's mum THINKS she wants a weekend at home but in reality, she really doesn't and would not enjoy it and I very much suspect the hospice would not agree to it anyway.

Far far better that OP does exactly as she plans, several hours there each day doing nice things within her Mums capabilities, where shes safe and as comfy as possible.

So well said.

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:09

mainsfed · 28/05/2023 21:06

Can you leave dd home with her dad and you take mum home for the weekend, with help from carers?

I think it’s more important your mum gets a path visit home than you dd making memories.

I do understand if it’s not feasible though, it sounds like a lot of work. I just don’t think the reason to say no is due to a 5yo if there is alternative childcare available.

This is what I'd rather do. I can concentrate on her and not feel like my daughter is scared or unhappy or nervous of Nanny. To have to sort Mums toileting in front of DD would be too much for both of them. If it were just me, I'd do it, I'd manage. But I can't look after both of them at the same time.

OP posts:
bloodywhitecat · 28/05/2023 21:07

I nursed DH through terminal cancer and a stroke with two under twos in the house, we had carers three times a day (we could've had four visits). Support was minimal as care companies are struggling and the hospice we came under was an hour away. I had an inkling of what I was letting myself in for as I had worked in a hospice but it was a dark, lonely, scary place to be in. I don't regret what i did but it was the hardest thing I have ever done.

Sending you much love OP.

WiddlinDiddlin · 28/05/2023 21:06

Do those of you having a pop at the OP have personal experience of being 'cared for' by people who mean well but in fact cannot meet your care needs?

I have.

Until you have, I'd suggest you shut the fuck up.

Its fucking horrible, realising their out of their depth, being bastarding uncomfortable, having to have your loved ones struggle to do the personal care you require, and them realising they are doing it badly... or not realising but you can't fucking ask them to sort out your knickers AGAIN because they're rubbing your fanny raw, you can't tell them sorry, you didn't actually wipe my arse properly and now shit is making the skin burn. Having to ask them to readjust your position again, trying not to go on and on about how the mattress is hurting your arse or you just can't get in a position that doesn't hurt.

It is awful.

OP's mum THINKS she wants a weekend at home but in reality, she really doesn't and would not enjoy it and I very much suspect the hospice would not agree to it anyway.

Far far better that OP does exactly as she plans, several hours there each day doing nice things within her Mums capabilities, where shes safe and as comfy as possible.

realityhack · 28/05/2023 21:06

OP I am so sorry about your mum.

Ignore the bitchy and unkind responses, they are talking out of their arses and have no idea what such care really involves.

If your mum requires two to transfer then please do not do this- she would need OT equipment to enable this safely and worst case scenario, if you try to do it yourself alone, she could end up falling during a transfer and breaking a hip or you end up with a chronic back injury. There are health and safety reasons why mobility/transfers need to be carefully assessed in palliative care and this does not sound safe at all with you trying to juggle this all alone with a 5 year old. Who is going to watch your 5 year old whilst you are helping her with all this?

I would say no to her going home, BUT, I would see if I could bring in some of her favourite board games, music, movies and lovely food and try to have a nice get together in the hospice instead. Hospice staff are absolutely lovely so I am sure they could help you do this and arrange something really nice.

mainsfed · 28/05/2023 21:06

Can you leave dd home with her dad and you take mum home for the weekend, with help from carers?

I think it’s more important your mum gets a path visit home than you dd making memories.

I do understand if it’s not feasible though, it sounds like a lot of work. I just don’t think the reason to say no is due to a 5yo if there is alternative childcare available.

StormShadow · 28/05/2023 21:05

Morechocmorechoc · 28/05/2023 20:59

Look, you don't like any answers that go against the grain. However you asked. So I'm going to answer honestly. You're 5 year old will cope, so why don't you try and bring her home for one day. No nights or long weekend. She is dying and would like to go home. Imagine you asked your kid for something when you were dying. Do you have someone who can come with you just once, or carers support for a day. Maybe rather than deciding its impossible see if you can find a way to compromise. How will you feel if you don't try?

I know it's extremely hard, these situations are, but at least she will know you did what you could. I'm not taking away from what you're already doing, I've done distance for cancer and it's hard. But I have guilt, you don't want it trust me.

What exactly do you mean by your 5 year old will cope?

Because yeah sure, it won't kill her and there won't necessarily be any lasting ill effects. She's still however going to be a 5 year old, behaving the way that 5 year olds do with a 5 year old's level of understanding, around a frail dying woman who OP has told us will be exhausted by only one day with her.

The practicalities here are a problem, because OP is one adult who would need to be in sole charge of a child and a terminally ill person currently reliant on substantial specialist equipment to be able to manage basic functions. Exactly what compromise do you think there can be in this situation?

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:03

Morechocmorechoc · 28/05/2023 20:59

Look, you don't like any answers that go against the grain. However you asked. So I'm going to answer honestly. You're 5 year old will cope, so why don't you try and bring her home for one day. No nights or long weekend. She is dying and would like to go home. Imagine you asked your kid for something when you were dying. Do you have someone who can come with you just once, or carers support for a day. Maybe rather than deciding its impossible see if you can find a way to compromise. How will you feel if you don't try?

I know it's extremely hard, these situations are, but at least she will know you did what you could. I'm not taking away from what you're already doing, I've done distance for cancer and it's hard. But I have guilt, you don't want it trust me.

Thank you for your kind and considered response. I was reacting to the suggestion of three days without looking at alternatives like one day or afternoon at home which might be a more realistic possibility.

OP posts:
exexpat · 28/05/2023 21:03

You are definitely not being unreasonable. Ignore the guilt-trippers who have clearly never had to deal with an immobile elderly parent nearing the end of their life. I have, twice, and I know that there is no way that you could do this without a huge amount of equipment, extra carers to help, and detailed advance planning. If you just try and do it alone, you are likely to end up with your mother on the floor waiting 12 hours for an ambulance, or worse.

If it is really your mother's dying wish to spend one more day or night at home, then maybe you could manage it with a lot of planning and help from the hospice, but definitely not single-handed, and not while also trying to look after a five-year-old. Talk to the hospice and ask what might realistically be possible. A daytime-only visit might be slightly easier than anything involving an overnight stay, but a lot depends on the accessibility of her home and availability of carers.

PennyWeisse · 28/05/2023 21:03

Morechocmorechoc · 28/05/2023 20:59

Look, you don't like any answers that go against the grain. However you asked. So I'm going to answer honestly. You're 5 year old will cope, so why don't you try and bring her home for one day. No nights or long weekend. She is dying and would like to go home. Imagine you asked your kid for something when you were dying. Do you have someone who can come with you just once, or carers support for a day. Maybe rather than deciding its impossible see if you can find a way to compromise. How will you feel if you don't try?

I know it's extremely hard, these situations are, but at least she will know you did what you could. I'm not taking away from what you're already doing, I've done distance for cancer and it's hard. But I have guilt, you don't want it trust me.

I'm a fully grown adult and I have PTSD over the realities of assisting an immobile dying parent with toileting in their final days. It can be horrific.

I absolutely would not inflict this on a 5yo.

7eleven · 28/05/2023 21:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Eh? I didn’t say anything about sponging. Are you drunk?

I hope things go well when you visit your mum but your responses are ridiculous, so I’ll leave you to it.

PennyWeisse · 28/05/2023 21:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Morechocmorechoc · 28/05/2023 20:59

Look, you don't like any answers that go against the grain. However you asked. So I'm going to answer honestly. You're 5 year old will cope, so why don't you try and bring her home for one day. No nights or long weekend. She is dying and would like to go home. Imagine you asked your kid for something when you were dying. Do you have someone who can come with you just once, or carers support for a day. Maybe rather than deciding its impossible see if you can find a way to compromise. How will you feel if you don't try?

I know it's extremely hard, these situations are, but at least she will know you did what you could. I'm not taking away from what you're already doing, I've done distance for cancer and it's hard. But I have guilt, you don't want it trust me.

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 20:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.