Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to weekend leave from hospice

284 replies

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 19:25

DM is in a hospice with stage four terminal lung cancer. I try to get up to see her every few weeks and as she hasn't seen my DD since Feb, I decided I would take her up next weekend as it's the end of half term. We could stay at Mums, and go visit her Friday, Saturday and Sunday for a few hours at a time but in between go to visit parks, museums etc... DM is currently not mobile, relies on a wheelchair and uses a commode. She's also very frail, weak and at a high risk of infection. She wants to ask the hospice for weekend release next weekend and I just don't think I can do it. It would mean moving a bed into the living room, helping her in and out of the wheelchair (alone) at several locations, bringing home a commode. Manoeuvring her on and off it (in front of five year old). It would also mean me and DD can't go out for the day after visiting her as she can't be left alone due to not being able to walk. I feel like an awful awful daughter but would I be unreasonable to say we maybe need to do it when she's a bit stronger and it's just me without DD??

OP posts:
GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:40

Can I also thank everyone who has taken the time to respond. It's heartbreaking to hear your experiences and I'm sorry you all had to endure this.

OP posts:
Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 28/05/2023 21:38

Have a quiet word with the hospice staff telling them your concerns and ask them to speak to her and suggest that it is not a viable option just at the moment. Could she come home for say two hours one of the afternoons? It may just be that she wants to see her own home again?

TattiePants · 28/05/2023 21:37

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/05/2023 21:35

Is there any way you could bring a little piece of home to your mum? Maybe take in her favourite teapot, plate and cup and have a picnic. Dig out her old photo albums or things to reminisce with. Things, which smell of home.

Please do not feel guilted for being unable to take her home. Your energy and hers would be better spent on having some quality time with your dd, the 3 of you.

Your dd may very well remember your mum and visiting her as she grows up. As a reminder, you could slip your mum a big bag of sweets or an oversized toblerone that she can give to your dd. My meaning is to give something a little out of the ordinary, which your dd won’t easily forget, this she is more likely to remember visiting your mum.

They are some lovely, thoughtful suggestions.

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:37

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/05/2023 21:35

Is there any way you could bring a little piece of home to your mum? Maybe take in her favourite teapot, plate and cup and have a picnic. Dig out her old photo albums or things to reminisce with. Things, which smell of home.

Please do not feel guilted for being unable to take her home. Your energy and hers would be better spent on having some quality time with your dd, the 3 of you.

Your dd may very well remember your mum and visiting her as she grows up. As a reminder, you could slip your mum a big bag of sweets or an oversized toblerone that she can give to your dd. My meaning is to give something a little out of the ordinary, which your dd won’t easily forget, this she is more likely to remember visiting your mum.

Yes, I've actually done this already! DD desperately wanted a purse so I ordered one and Mum has put it in her drawer with £10 inside it for when we visit.

OP posts:
StormShadow · 28/05/2023 21:37

If you'd asked me on day 1 and day 60, my experience taught me that love cannot overcome reality

This is a good way of phrasing it.

StripyHorse · 28/05/2023 21:37

OttoGraph · 28/05/2023 20:17

Can you get in touch with Marie Cure to see whether they can help? They do help care for the terminally ill I their own homes.

Its extremely hard to look after a parent at this stage. Could you perhaps take things from him into the hospice instead? Old photographs to look through and a few things from him instead? Spend time looking together at photographs with your dd for a bit, taking in food and eating together

It might not be full time though. DF had night nurses through Marie Curie, but day nurses (not Marie Curie) popping in at intervals to administer drugs / deal with catheter etc. They weren't there all day though.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/05/2023 21:35

Is there any way you could bring a little piece of home to your mum? Maybe take in her favourite teapot, plate and cup and have a picnic. Dig out her old photo albums or things to reminisce with. Things, which smell of home.

Please do not feel guilted for being unable to take her home. Your energy and hers would be better spent on having some quality time with your dd, the 3 of you.

Your dd may very well remember your mum and visiting her as she grows up. As a reminder, you could slip your mum a big bag of sweets or an oversized toblerone that she can give to your dd. My meaning is to give something a little out of the ordinary, which your dd won’t easily forget, this she is more likely to remember visiting your mum.

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:33

realityhack · 28/05/2023 21:21

The hospice must feel so final for her, so medical

Actually, hospices are nothing like hospitals, they are much more hotel like on purpose. I have been in several during college placements and was really struck by how comfortable and calm they were, it was nothing like being in a hospital.

I can only echo this. Mums hospice is beautiful. She's in a private room with her own bathroom, patio doors leading to a little courtyard. I feel it's far better for DD to see her settled and happy here where we can step out if Nanny needs 'help' rather than her having to watch me manhandle her, likely shouting at her to stay out of the room and her wanting to look.

OP posts:
sadsack78 · 28/05/2023 21:31

YANBU.

I'm so sorry you're having to make this decision, OP. It sounds incredibly upsetting for everyone involved but you especially.

It is a lot of pressure to put on you. It sounds like your mum is unwell enough that her health could take a very rapid and sudden decline, which would put you in a terrible position if you were trying to take care of her alone at home. It could potentially be very traumatising.

It sounds like your mum is at a stage where she is too unwell now for this to be a safe or realistic option. You're doing your absolute best and you are not being a bad daughter by trying to look out for her and not put her in an unsafe situation in her vulnerable state. ❤Flowers

JMSA · 28/05/2023 21:30

@GoGoJasonWaterfalls

I totally get it Flowers Some of the other posters have come up with some great compromises, so hopefully you can find something to keep everyone happy.
Best wishes x

FrostyFifi · 28/05/2023 21:29

OP I had to say no to my terminally ill mum's wish for a last trip. She was nowhere near as frail so we could take her for the weekend but she wanted to go much further away and it wasn't realistic or safe. And there were four adults caring for her and the children were older and more independent.

What she wishes unfortunately does not sound physically possible but I empathise with how upsetting it is to have to say no to someone in this situation, wishing you all the best.

Sugargliderwombat · 28/05/2023 21:29

I think your mum is asking because she would love to, and that is totally understandable, but don't feel bad if you can care for her properly. Saying no might be what she needs to keep her safe and also prevent any awful moments that she might not be anticipating (I'm thinking of the commode and your 5 year old). You know your mum, yourself and her illness ❤️

NotMyDayJob · 28/05/2023 21:28

My MIL (with whom I am extremely close) always tells me she'll never go into a home etc but she never actually did any physical care for her elderly relatives and they did, when push came to shove, go into homes when they were very frail/ had dementia/incontinent etc.

My point being, every one has an opinion about what they would do, and then there's what they do do, when they are faced with the reality.

OP it's a horrible situation but it sounds like going home is really not an option, and the hospice wouldn't allow/facilitate it. Talk to the hospice, let them have the difficult conversations, and prepare for your visit with your DD. Incidentally, I have a five year old and I know exactly what you mean. You're not talking about 'making memories' you just need her to run around the park several 100 times so she's not so endlessly annoying in that way only five year olds can be.

Much love to you

Highdaysandholidays1 · 28/05/2023 21:28

I'd also say wanting to 'go home' is the thing that pretty much every old person in hospital and hospice says endlessly. What they mean is I wish I was well enough to go home, I wish I weren't ill or dying, I wish I could just go home and forget all about it. If you can arrange a trip, great, but your mum must be very ill to be in a hospice (most don't do long stays these days, they will move you back to a care home) and it might not be possible. It not, think about how you could bring home to her- perhaps music, perhaps an ornament, having her own clothes (they can be cut at the back so they can still be worn even if they are in bed), a blanket, anything she associates with home.

Kitkatandcoffee · 28/05/2023 21:27

I would not take your mum home for a weekend it would be to much for all of you. I think some people are underestimating how difficult it is to look after a seriously ill relative.
Is there a park near the hospice you could go to for a picnic with your mum and daughter? Or make a treat afternoon tea or picnic to take in to the hospice and perhaps have it in the grounds of the hospice.
I am sorry you are going through this.

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 21:27

JMSA · 28/05/2023 21:19

OP, I am genuinely sorry for my hurtful reply. I should have waited before responding to your opening post.
My grandmother, to whom I'm very close, is going through the same thing. I can't imagine not moving heaven and earth to grant her request, but I understand that everyone's circumstances are different.
I did find your tone in the OP very flippant, but that's no excuse to express myself in the way that I did.
Apologies once again and all the best.

Thank you. It probably did sound flippant as I didn't really go into the details of the care needed. But let me be clear that I am not against her coming home, but it needs to be when I can fully focus on her and not with half an eye on DD who will get bored and who will be loud and who will get boisterous. And I will feel guilty for DD being unsettled and disturbing Mum and I will feel guilty for neglecting DD to make sure Mum is ok.

OP posts:
NewNovember · 28/05/2023 21:27

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 20:45

It's not that it would 'get in the way' for Christ sake. I'm taking DD up because my DM has not seen her since February and misses her. But if I take DM home then we can't leave the house which is a lot to ask of a five year old child for three days.

3 days? There were young children shielding thst didn't leave their homes for six months or longer. But I agree you would need help to care for her at home

ReachForTheMars · 28/05/2023 21:27

JMSA · 28/05/2023 21:19

OP, I am genuinely sorry for my hurtful reply. I should have waited before responding to your opening post.
My grandmother, to whom I'm very close, is going through the same thing. I can't imagine not moving heaven and earth to grant her request, but I understand that everyone's circumstances are different.
I did find your tone in the OP very flippant, but that's no excuse to express myself in the way that I did.
Apologies once again and all the best.

To be fair to you, I thought I would bend over backwards when we got the shocking diagnosis of stage 4 out of nowhere.

Family pointed out how challenging it would be and within 6 weeks it was abundantly clear how serious end-stage cancer is and the reality of the physical challenges and how quickly things deteriorate.

If you'd asked me on day 1 and day 60, my experience taught me that love cannot overcome reality. So sorry to hear your news X

Sugargliderwombat · 28/05/2023 21:27

If you don't want to, can you speak to the hospice about your concerns so they can convince your mum? So you don't need to carry any guilt?

Polari · 28/05/2023 21:27

@GoGoJasonWaterfalls do what's best for your dd and yourself. Some pp's are just nasty.
Your dm is expressing a wish that unfortunately is unrealistic.
And there's nothing wrong with taking a 5 year old out sightseeing in between visits. No-one could expect a 5 year old to either spend 3 days visiting a hospice or stuck in a house with a very poorly dgm.
2 x 2 hour visits a day will probably exhaust your dm anyway.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 28/05/2023 21:25

I'm so sorry that your mum is dying and some of the responses on this thread, it's actually upset me as I've cared for someone in this situation, two people in fact, and it's just so awful and hard and if I'd got replies like this I would have been very distressed.

In my husband's case, there was no option to come home, he need a team of 2/3 to move him and toilet him, so once he'd moved from home care to the hospice that was that. The hospice won't allow people to go home without the correct equipment, support and trained carers, you can't just take people out and let the fall over which is very likely if you don't have the training to transfer or the equipment at home. The chances of getting carers in at short notice is nil, it takes ages to be accepted by Macmillan/charities for someone sitting with you (plus they don't do actual hands-on care in the one we had) and all the agencies I know are short-staffed.

It must be very traumatic to go and stay in your dying mum's house and to suggest you are going for a holiday, well, it's just such an awful thing to say. What you are thinking about, which is utterly correct IMO is how you can combine this trip with looking after your 5 year old so she's happy, occupied and not traumatized. Many terminally ill people look very scary, and seeing her in a nice hospital and having a cup of tea might be very different from you trying to care for her, wipe her down, change her clothes, the smells etc in her old home if it's not set up well and you don't have other carers. I would ask the hospice about taking your five-year-old in and when's best, they are usually fantastic and used to the whole family visiting. Or even leave your child behind if that's a possibility.

It sounds like she wants to do something, so maybe a short visit, or even sitting in the garden of the hospice or hospital, having a cream tea, take the things she can eat- I would talk honestly about the prognosis of the hospice and ask them for help to help your mum in her final weeks to make her happy, explain what she's said and get their advice.

BungleandGeorge · 28/05/2023 21:23

I think you need to ring and speak to the hospice about her wishes. See what they suggest. You would definitely need carers to be arranged. They'll have had this request from others. I think it would be nice if you were able to try and arrange some time for her in her own home sometime soon, I don’t think you can wait ‘until she’s stronger’ but the hospice can advise on that.

ReachForTheMars · 28/05/2023 21:23

7eleven · 28/05/2023 21:03

Eh? I didn’t say anything about sponging. Are you drunk?

I hope things go well when you visit your mum but your responses are ridiculous, so I’ll leave you to it.

"Dont pick a fight with me"
"I didnt say sponging, are you drunk?"

No, you just said something spiteful and played the victim when your sentiment, but not exact words, were called out.

Waaah waaah. Way to poke the bear and whinge when you get what you deserve.

Back off of poor OP and find someone else to wind up.

Lookong forward to your petty response where you try to act like the bigger person and make yourself look thoughtless, unkind and nasty, such as "Your responses are ridiculous, I'll leave you to it"

No, actually, your responses are ridiculous, not OPs, so take a long hard look at yourself.

realityhack · 28/05/2023 21:21

The hospice must feel so final for her, so medical

Actually, hospices are nothing like hospitals, they are much more hotel like on purpose. I have been in several during college placements and was really struck by how comfortable and calm they were, it was nothing like being in a hospital.

Merryhobnobs · 28/05/2023 21:20

The care of elderly or il parents do get people quite agitated and there are a group of people who say 'I would never use care, I would bend over backwards' BUT that isn't actually always what is best for the patient never mind the rest of the family. You are getting flak when O can see that you are completely torn. Your mu has understandable wants but her needs are met at the hospice. If your daughter is with you then you need to put her needs first because she is little. I would go with the planned visit and then on the next visit you take your mum home for a day. When my Gran was ill we would take her out for lunch or home but after a few hours she did tire and wany back to the safety of the care home.we did take her on one last trip to where she was from but we paid for a strong carer to come with us the entire trip. It wasn't feasible otherwise. Its about safety and health and care and that is about love .

Swipe left for the next trending thread