Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to weekend leave from hospice

284 replies

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 28/05/2023 19:25

DM is in a hospice with stage four terminal lung cancer. I try to get up to see her every few weeks and as she hasn't seen my DD since Feb, I decided I would take her up next weekend as it's the end of half term. We could stay at Mums, and go visit her Friday, Saturday and Sunday for a few hours at a time but in between go to visit parks, museums etc... DM is currently not mobile, relies on a wheelchair and uses a commode. She's also very frail, weak and at a high risk of infection. She wants to ask the hospice for weekend release next weekend and I just don't think I can do it. It would mean moving a bed into the living room, helping her in and out of the wheelchair (alone) at several locations, bringing home a commode. Manoeuvring her on and off it (in front of five year old). It would also mean me and DD can't go out for the day after visiting her as she can't be left alone due to not being able to walk. I feel like an awful awful daughter but would I be unreasonable to say we maybe need to do it when she's a bit stronger and it's just me without DD??

OP posts:
BiddyPop · 29/05/2023 09:52

DFIL came out from hospital for his 70th birthday, planned as an afternoon visit. DSIL (married to the middle son, works in related profession but in the community) arranged for a hospital bed at home, "just in case", but things had moved fast and everyone else knew he wouldn't be coming home again by the time it was delivered - he was going to hospice as soon as abed was available.

But on the day of the party, bed had arrived and it was seen as useful to have in case a rest was needed. Which it turned out was a good call.

But then DSIL got DBIL all het up (middle son) about "dad is enjoying being home, he should just stay the night". No thought of the significant care needs for a large man who was no longer mobile, in pain, had significant meds needs, and who did not want any family doing personal care when he was still coming to terms with it having to be done for him. (We had gone from mowing the lawn to never coming home in about 4 days and this was less than 10 days later).

It caused huge upset in the family. Elder son (DH) and daughter could both see DFIL was deeply uncomfortable both with the thought and physically, but couldn't stand up to DDIL. DMIL was beside herself and had let herself get swept along with the hope he could stay but hadn't faced the realities of it, so got terribly upset about it all. The DGDCs were all terribly confused and upset (4, ranging 9 to 3). The 2 who started it all lived next door and bailed out when the going got tough every time and walked out again that time leaving chaos behind.

Instead of DFIL going back to hospital having had a nice day (which he'd had, and he was happy, or maybe resigned and accepting might be a better way to express it, to be going back to hospital - but not upset about it before it all kicked off ), he went back late, terribly upset about it all and about the chaos caused. And late for his meds and in more pain than he should have been.

It caused a lot of upset and certainly changed how DH saw his DB and DSIL.

I say this not to cause upset but to show that there are plans that can be put in place to go out, if physically practical and possible, for the unwell person to enjoy something suitable to their needs at the time but not putting too much pressure on them or the supports available.

So planning for afternoon tea somewhere, maybe even at DM's home, but with sufficient support to manage her needs while there, might be great. Or a car trip to see some places of local beauty she's always loved. But planning a 3 night stay could be way too
Much for her ans you all, especially without the trained support she'll need.

GettingStuffed · 29/05/2023 09:10

You really need to think what's best for your mum. I've cared for a terminally ill relative, but was assisted by 2 live in carers. It's really hard and you need to think care rather than relative and that is a hard thing to do. I think you need to forget taking her home, good carers are booked up for months so just get a couple of carers is not feasible. I agree with pps who say something like a picnic in the hospice grounds or even a short walk around the block would be the best choice, even this is likely to tire her out

Whenisitsummer · 29/05/2023 09:05

Perhaps just explain to your mum that as much as you would love to take her home to spend the full weekend together, you just wouldn’t be able to provide the level of care needed on your own. I wouldn’t say anything about when she’s stronger because that’s not something that’s realistic. Aim for taking her out in the afternoons for a few hours instead, there are taxis designed for wheelchair users although they may well need booked in advance.

EmotionalBlackmail · 29/05/2023 08:56

EasterBreak · 29/05/2023 08:40

If it is something she really wants I would move mountains to make it happen. I'd only regret it for the rest of my life.

So helpful. It's very easy to say something like this but the reality is totally different.

FrostyFifi · 29/05/2023 08:56

If it is something she really wants I would move mountains to make it happen. I'd only regret it for the rest of my life

Ah, you have similar experience then? It might be really useful for the OP if you set out step-by-step exactly what arrangements you put in place and how it all worked, and if it was additionally tricky having a small child to care for. I'm sure she'd find that helpful?

billy1966 · 29/05/2023 08:54

OP,

If you injured yourself lifting your mum, you could be left with long term back issues.

I have known this to happen to a few people.

If it takes two trained nurses to lift your mum, do not even consider it.

Creamyoda · 29/05/2023 08:50

OP you can tell from your posts you want to do the best by your mum, sometimes it's not just saying yes sure it's seeing the bigger picture and applying reality to it. Speaking with hospice staff and having a few hours per day with your DD sounds perfect, it's easy for people who aren't actually living it to say yeah I'd do that- if you weren't bound by the reality and logistics of doing so you would also, there's nothing to suggest you just don't want to see her home for a few days, it's just not practical.

StormShadow · 29/05/2023 08:47

EasterBreak · 29/05/2023 08:40

If it is something she really wants I would move mountains to make it happen. I'd only regret it for the rest of my life.

Ok, you sound pretty sure here. Let's talk practicalities. What exactly would you do to make it possible this weekend?

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 29/05/2023 08:46

EasterBreak · 29/05/2023 08:40

If it is something she really wants I would move mountains to make it happen. I'd only regret it for the rest of my life.

Regret what? If it's important for her to go home for three days, I do it alone. If it's important for her to see DD, she stays in a professional care setting. I'm not denying her request.

OP posts:
EmotionalBlackmail · 29/05/2023 08:46

PurpleFlower1983 · 29/05/2023 07:45

I would try and make it work by hiring carers as a one off. This and petrol money would be going on a credit card if I couldn’t afford it. You will never get this opportunity again.

This is so wrong and irresponsible. Carers aren't available at the drop of a hat and who is going to pay for them? Particularly not for this level of specialist care?!

And suggesting that someone goes into debt to facilitate more visits when she's already juggling a child and a job at a distance to the hospice is crazy. She must be exhausted and under so much pressure. Adding debt to that is a really bad idea.

Having done the terminally ill journey twice with my dad and then a close friend, I'd always advise not taking the 'moving heaven and earth' approach. It's easy enough to say, but you don't know the reality of what you're signing up to or how long for. With both of mine, they lasted three times longer than anyone expected (running into months for one of them) and keeping going at that level of intensity alongside keeping everything else going (you still have to look after your child and go to work. It's not like those are optional!) was pretty awful. I did it, but I'd be very wary of committing to it again.

The OP is doing a huge amount and I thought it was a really sensible plan for the weekend which would allow her Mum to see her daughter whilst providing for the needs of both.

EasterBreak · 29/05/2023 08:40

If it is something she really wants I would move mountains to make it happen. I'd only regret it for the rest of my life.

Beamur · 29/05/2023 08:39

OP. I have been in your situation. My (not elderly) Mum basically came to live with us for the best part of 3 months before she died. She was active and mobile until maybe a fortnight before she died. But she needed personal care and pretty much 24/7 supervision and support.
My MIL lived with us for several weeks after her husband died until we could arrange residential care. She was mobile but unsteady had unreliable toileting and several mornings we found her naked on the floor having tried to use the commode and it going wrong. I really never wanted to have to deal with that. My DH was immensely upset too.
Granny lives in a care home now and often asks when she's leaving. We brought her home once, not even overnight and we agreed never again. Do not underestimate how important the space and equipment homes/hospices have.
I also have a DD, she was 8 during my Mum's decline and early teens the second time.
Caring at home for an elderly relative by yourself with a small child would be relentless and probably horrible. I really really wouldn't recommend it. My DD has been quite traumatised by the stress and upset we felt at the time.
You can't make a normal home easily suitable and safe for someone who is frail and can't use the toilet.
It takes a team of people to do this in residential care. Not one person who is also looking after a very young child.
Your Mum might want this but in your shoes (especially with the wisdom of hindsight) I would refuse. You need probably 3 people minimum to be able to do this safely.

GoGoJasonWaterfalls · 29/05/2023 08:37

@AdvertisementBoard - thank you! I'm not going to go into the intricacies of my Mums current health but I don't believe we are near the end. We will be, it will come, and then we will start making difficult decisions about her end of life care and whether this can be done at home. And at that point I will reduce my hours even more and be up here even more and try to keep every plate spinning. But (oh some posters are going to have a field day with this) I can't start this process without knowing there will be an end. It will physically, emotionally, mentally and financially drain me. I'm trying so fucking hard to be what everyone needs me to be, and I really want to do this for her if it's what she wants, but we can't feasibly do it this weekend.

OP posts:
Ladybug14 · 29/05/2023 08:36

Ladybug14

""There is a massive shortage of carers, you can't magic them up""

I'm not sure where you live but where we are, we paid for care for Dad at home and could get care whenever we wanted it. Literally at an hours notice.

We found 24/7 overnight care (he was awake all night) so expensive that, in the end, we were advised to use a Nursing Home for his care

Was this recent? Sorry for your loss btw.

July/August 2022. 💙

luckylavender · 29/05/2023 08:28

mainsfed · 28/05/2023 21:06

Can you leave dd home with her dad and you take mum home for the weekend, with help from carers?

I think it’s more important your mum gets a path visit home than you dd making memories.

I do understand if it’s not feasible though, it sounds like a lot of work. I just don’t think the reason to say no is due to a 5yo if there is alternative childcare available.

Did you read the piece where the grandmother wants to see her granddaughter?

AdvertisementBoard · 29/05/2023 08:27

The OP is an exhausted mum travelling hundreds of miles every other weekend.

I do not get the impression that her mum thankfully, is on the brink of death just yet. The OP needs to conserve her energy. I’m sure if it came to her mum’s last few days, the OP would be by her mother’s side and possibly bring her home to die if that was felt best by everyone.

I do not think it is worth it for her to drag her mum home for 48 hours with all the hospital paraphernalia Which could be stressful for all involved. The OP may need training, carers might be absent or extremely expensive and the reality could be uncomfortable, undignified and extremely stressful. Every decision is a risk-benefit weigh-up. On this occasion, I’m not sure that the benefits outweigh the risks.

Many people in hospital want to come home for the weekend. That does not always mean that it is the right thing.

We can only guess what we would do in this situation. None of us really knows.

Mummyoflittledragon · 29/05/2023 08:27

FrostyFifi · 29/05/2023 08:18

If that's what my mum wanted that's what I would do. Clearly she doesn't have long and I'd do everything my power to give her the end that she'd like.

The reality, and I'm going to be blunt here given some of the sentimental cloud-cuckoo-land posts, is that a weekend in unsuitable circumstances might well kill the OPs mother, and not pleasantly. She needs two professionals and equipment to care for her adequately. So OP drags her home, and drops her, and then what? She dies waiting for an ambulance, in huge pain and distress and lack of dignity and all witnessed by her small granddaughter?

And you think that's somehow preferable to a visit in her safely cared-for surroundings?

Agreed. I thought the same myself. The risk far outweighs the benefit for all 3 of them and op is very sensibly coming up with a plan to balance everyone’s needs, rather than what her mum would like in an ideal world.

luckylavender · 29/05/2023 08:26

7eleven · 28/05/2023 20:49

‘It would also mean me and DD can't go out for the day’

It’s there, in your OP. I’ve been nice. Don’t pick a fight with me FFS.

Out of the house with a 5 year old.

MargotBamborough · 29/05/2023 08:25

Oh OP that's so hard but YANBU.

I think you just have to say that you aren't capable of manoeuvring her without another adult to help, so it just isn't possible to bring her home from the hospice when it's just you and a five year old there. Don't mention wanting to go out and do other things. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that either but probably best not to talk about it to your mum.

luckylavender · 29/05/2023 08:24

MarvelMrs · 28/05/2023 20:39

I think you should think about hiring some help and trying to facilitate something. A whole
weekend is too much but maybe one day and
night in her own home again. Enquire at the hospice about care agencies they recommend or Macmillian nurses?
I think with terminal cancer her needs trump yours but not by putting yourself in a situation that won’t be manageable alone. Also could you take someone with you to help with your DD? Your DM will likely never be stronger so don’t miss the opportunity completely.
Ultimately you can only do what you can do physically and mentally so known your limits.
I don’t think trips with your DD in between visits are really a consideration here. Your DM should be priority at this time.

Maybe the OP can't afford to hire some help. The travelling costs alone are very expensive.

Blossomtoes · 29/05/2023 08:22

lemonchiffonpie · 29/05/2023 07:03

So who on this thread egging the OP on to do an impossibly task, and showering her with guilt, is planning to drive for however long and volunteer their services for this weekend visit to help her lift her mother, do toileting duties, and so on? You may herniate a disc, but never mind.

Some sense at last. None of those guilt tripping posters has a clue.

FrostyFifi · 29/05/2023 08:18

If that's what my mum wanted that's what I would do. Clearly she doesn't have long and I'd do everything my power to give her the end that she'd like.

The reality, and I'm going to be blunt here given some of the sentimental cloud-cuckoo-land posts, is that a weekend in unsuitable circumstances might well kill the OPs mother, and not pleasantly. She needs two professionals and equipment to care for her adequately. So OP drags her home, and drops her, and then what? She dies waiting for an ambulance, in huge pain and distress and lack of dignity and all witnessed by her small granddaughter?

And you think that's somehow preferable to a visit in her safely cared-for surroundings?

Anycrispsleft · 29/05/2023 08:15

People are suggesting all sorts of workarounds with private carers. The OP has said upthread that she can't she can't afford the 50 quid petrol every week so shes not going to be able to afford a few hundred for 2 carers for a weekend. And I would be surprised if the hospice can spare carers for a weekend visit, unless things have changed a lot since my dad died 10 years ago when it was difficult for him to get a hospice place and he ended up being cared for at home. There barely seemed to be enough resources to care for people adequately never mind facilitate trips home. It took ages to get GP appointments to change his prescriptions as he got ill, when he had palliative radiotherapy there was no patient transport arranged and my mother had to rely on a kind taxi driver who helped him get up the stairs back home, and over Christmas he was dischargedfrom hospital once with nothing, no medication, no care package no nothing. Honestly if your mother is comfortable and her care needs are being responded to on a day to day basis then that is a lot to be thankful for.

StormShadow · 29/05/2023 08:07

Ladybug14 · 29/05/2023 08:02

""There is a massive shortage of carers, you can't magic them up""

I'm not sure where you live but where we are, we paid for care for Dad at home and could get care whenever we wanted it. Literally at an hours notice.

We found 24/7 overnight care (he was awake all night) so expensive that, in the end, we were advised to use a Nursing Home for his care

Was this recent? Sorry for your loss btw.

Ladybug14 · 29/05/2023 08:02

""There is a massive shortage of carers, you can't magic them up""

I'm not sure where you live but where we are, we paid for care for Dad at home and could get care whenever we wanted it. Literally at an hours notice.

We found 24/7 overnight care (he was awake all night) so expensive that, in the end, we were advised to use a Nursing Home for his care

Swipe left for the next trending thread