Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog Breeders

83 replies

girlfriend44 · 28/05/2023 17:54

Aibu to ask is the only reason people breed and sell puppies is to earn money?

OP posts:
Wereongunoil · 28/05/2023 20:12

wetotter · 28/05/2023 19:47

If you want a well-reared puppy produced by a genuine breed enthusiast, you really need to look at the vulnerable native breeds. Because the commercial breeders aren't producing them, only those who really care about the breed

Totally agree with this.

Two of my dogs are vulnerable native breeds and both were bred by people who really care about their dogs

PauliString · 28/05/2023 20:12

wetotter · 28/05/2023 19:47

If you want a well-reared puppy produced by a genuine breed enthusiast, you really need to look at the vulnerable native breeds. Because the commercial breeders aren't producing them, only those who really care about the breed

I had a nosy at the list of vulnerable native breeds and was really surprised by some of them. Field spaniels, for instance, Old English sheepdogs, Welsh springers, even otter hounds… two or three of each around here. I must be living in a sort of Crufts offshoot.

Ylvamoon · 28/05/2023 20:05

@girlfriend44 People breed dogs for lots of reasons. It could be the next show winner or to keep a specific bloodline, some people just love dogs & puppies and enjoy raising a litter, while others see the chance to make extra cash.

So in the end, it comes down to money.
And why shouldn't someone who puts in their time and money be reimbursed for their hard work?

Florenz · 28/05/2023 20:01

Nobody should be making a livelihood by breeding dogs. It should be illegal.

wetotter · 28/05/2023 19:47

If you want a well-reared puppy produced by a genuine breed enthusiast, you really need to look at the vulnerable native breeds. Because the commercial breeders aren't producing them, only those who really care about the breed

Yerroblemom1923 · 28/05/2023 19:39

@newnamethanks hearing things like that just makes me feel ill. Don't these people read the papers/ watch the news? Every week there's another incidence of attacks by these dogs!

notquiteruralbliss · 28/05/2023 19:09

If you want a specific breed rescue might not be an option. 2 of ours are a large sighthounds breed that often end up in rescue so we were able to adopt via the breed rescue. However 2 are a rare breed that almost never end up in rescue. We bought those as puppies.

UsTwoAndThreeDogs · 28/05/2023 19:06

Florenz · 28/05/2023 18:07

Dog breeding should be banned. Anyone who wants a dog should get one from the RSPCA after fulfilling the criteria to own and keep a dog.

Oh yes, let’s ban it and no one will breed any dogs ever again. Banning it worked for heroin and cocaine, didn’t it? Oh wait….

Banning would mean even more dogs were kept in awful conditions and breed by irresponsible people. It would still go on, but in even more miserable conditions than now. Meanwhile professional breeders would lose their livelihoods.

Such naivety.

Lorrymum · 28/05/2023 19:05

Quveas · 28/05/2023 18:27

Quite apart from the fact that the RSPCA have some serious questions about animal welfare to answer themselves - exactly where do you think the RSPCA will source their dogs from if there are no breeders of any kind???? You do know how puppies are made, and that they aren't knitted?

I want a knitted puppy please! Sounds so cute.

LimeCheesecake · 28/05/2023 19:02

Dog breeders are running a business- either as a full time job or as a (forgive the hideous phrase) side hustle.

While the full time, KC registered type are generally a safer bet, they aren’t that much different to the back garden breeders. The dogs that have the best lives as far as I can tell are either the family pet, who’s owners decide to do one litter for various reasons that often boil down to wanting to get their money back from buying a pedigree, or the show dogs that win things and are bred as part of the showing business.

interestingly puppy demand and prices seem to have dropped dramatically- the breeder who sold us our puppy seems to have gone from having a long waiting list to struggling to find suitable homes for her latest litter. The prices she’s charging now seem a lot lower. (Not sure I can convinced dh we need another puppy)

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 28/05/2023 19:00

LakieLady · 28/05/2023 18:57

Not necessarily.

I know a few people who breed dogs that from breeds that are on the list of "native" (ie, British or Irish) breeds at risk of dying out. They breed them because they love the breed and they don't want that breed's unique characteristics to be lost. And I don't blame them, to be honest. The world would be a sadder place without (eg) otterhounds or Glen of Imaal terriers imo.

Then you have the "show breeders", who want to breed the best possible example of their chosen breed. Sadly, some of them take this too far and breed for exaggerated characteristics to the point that the health of the dog is adversely affected (yes, bulldog breeders - I'm looking at you!).

And some people breed working breeds with a view to improving their working ability, because they work them themselves. They will generally breed a litter every few years, keep the one they consider to have the best potential, and most of their puppies will go to other working homes. A guy who used to live near me bred a few litters of outstanding working springers, and he would never sell a puppy that wasn't going to a working home.

But the sort of breeder that churns out litter after litter of whatever breed is currently fashionable, or "designer mongrels", are generally only in it for the money imo, and are little better than puppy farmers.

Those last ones are puppy farmers. The fact they don’t raise the puppies in an actual shed doesn’t change that.

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 28/05/2023 18:58

newnamethanks · 28/05/2023 18:55

Had to call an electrician the other day. He arrived, said hello to me and my small yappy dog. "I love dogs, me, I've got three and a litter of puppies" Oh, bit of a handful. What are they? "XL Bullies. 2 bitches and a stud. Real softies, love the grandchildren". Made my blood run cold. Won't be calling on his services again. Disgusting, opportunistic idiot.

Completely agree, anyone like this is stupid. Plus no stud dog needs to be used more than max twice or three times in exceptional circumstances. It’s not necessary.

LakieLady · 28/05/2023 18:57

Not necessarily.

I know a few people who breed dogs that from breeds that are on the list of "native" (ie, British or Irish) breeds at risk of dying out. They breed them because they love the breed and they don't want that breed's unique characteristics to be lost. And I don't blame them, to be honest. The world would be a sadder place without (eg) otterhounds or Glen of Imaal terriers imo.

Then you have the "show breeders", who want to breed the best possible example of their chosen breed. Sadly, some of them take this too far and breed for exaggerated characteristics to the point that the health of the dog is adversely affected (yes, bulldog breeders - I'm looking at you!).

And some people breed working breeds with a view to improving their working ability, because they work them themselves. They will generally breed a litter every few years, keep the one they consider to have the best potential, and most of their puppies will go to other working homes. A guy who used to live near me bred a few litters of outstanding working springers, and he would never sell a puppy that wasn't going to a working home.

But the sort of breeder that churns out litter after litter of whatever breed is currently fashionable, or "designer mongrels", are generally only in it for the money imo, and are little better than puppy farmers.

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 28/05/2023 18:57

kitsuneghost · 28/05/2023 18:51

Of course. Otherwise they would hive them away.
I think most dog breeding should be banned.

People value what they paid for. Can you imagine the people that would turn out for “free puppies”? Plus, if people can’t afford my reasonable prices - no £3000 “rare” coloured bully breeds here- I worry they can’t afford to truly care for the dog.

that being said, I do give them away to friends and family, and to fellow breeders sometimes.

newnamethanks · 28/05/2023 18:55

Had to call an electrician the other day. He arrived, said hello to me and my small yappy dog. "I love dogs, me, I've got three and a litter of puppies" Oh, bit of a handful. What are they? "XL Bullies. 2 bitches and a stud. Real softies, love the grandchildren". Made my blood run cold. Won't be calling on his services again. Disgusting, opportunistic idiot.

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 28/05/2023 18:55

I breed occasionally. I don’t make money out of it. Ok, once I did, because I had a litter of six. I kept one of course, one paid for the stud fee (£1500), one paid for my drive to southern Spain for the mating (just shy of £1200 all in including hotels, eurotunnel (ferries cheaper but I don’t like leaving the dog in the hold), AHC and rabies vacc for euro travel etc) and one paid for the vets bills and feed and heating and washing bills associated with a litter. That left two of “profit”.

but the next time I bred, six years later, the bitch didn’t conceive the first time so that was £1400 wasted on chilled semen and AI, then had a litter and there were only three, and she had post birth complications which because I’m cautious, resulted in a £2800 vets bill. I lost money that time.

I don’t care: you should never breed if you can’t afford the complications of a 4am Sunday morning C section and no pups at the end of it. If you haven’t the cash to pay for that if god forbid it happens, you shouldn’t be having pups.

ElmTree22 · 28/05/2023 18:54

Honestly I'd like to breed my boy so I could keep a puppy, that way I'd be able to keep a part of him. I definitely wouldn't do it for £ but I can't find a female that's worthy! 🤦🏻‍♀️😂

LisaD1 · 28/05/2023 18:52

That should say actually not grisly!

Swansridinghorses · 28/05/2023 18:52

Although this is true of a lot (probably the majority) of people that breed it’s really not true of everyone particularly those in breed clubs or with sports dogs. They do breed to improve the line. Usually have another job, don’t make anything if at all from breeding and only do very occasional litters. It’s ridiculous to suggest this isn’t ever the case because the good breeders put a hell of a lot of thought into it. I have no interest in breeding but am very thankful there are responsible people out there breeding who care about function, temperament, and health testing (both mandatory and not).

LisaD1 · 28/05/2023 18:52

I think there should be much tougher and a grisly enforced laws around breeding and owning dogs.

I am not a fan of the RSPCA for my own reasons. They also refused us a dog because we both work full time. Yes we do but we also both work full time from home! We now have 2 dogs, they live a life of luxury along with our horses and rabbits. If the RSPCA had their way we wouldn’t be allowed to give our lovely home to a dog.

kitsuneghost · 28/05/2023 18:51

Of course. Otherwise they would hive them away.
I think most dog breeding should be banned.

KarmaStar · 28/05/2023 18:51

Of course it's about the money!how naive are you?
Get a rescue.🐕🐾🐾😃

Yerroblemom1923 · 28/05/2023 18:49

Yes. All about the money. All those saying we'd run out of dogs without dog breeders are talking nonsense, and less dogs isn't necessarily a bad thing if it meant taking those awful "xl bullies" etc out of society!

Densol57 · 28/05/2023 18:46

Yes Ive bought several pedigree dogs from “ good, honest, show breeders” and of course they make money charging £1,500 upwards for a puppy from several in the litter.
Utter drivel that they dont make a penny. Whatever fluffy chat they come up with, Ive always found most breeders have a hard mercenary approach to their business. I have met hundreds at shows over time. Thats not to say its wrong and that they shouldnt make money from their business, as long as they are not overbreeding / puppy farming. But I cant stand it when they lie in order to make themselves seem great.

Florenz · 28/05/2023 18:45

If there were no more dog breeders there would still be RSPCA dogs because some people would mistreat dogs they got from the RSPCA. But there would be far less cruelty to dogs than there is now. The RSPCA could redirect their resources to preventing cruelty to other animals. There would be far few dog attacks and antisocial behaviour related to dogs. It would be a win/win situation for everyone, including dogs themselves.