Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog Breeders

83 replies

girlfriend44 · 28/05/2023 17:54

Aibu to ask is the only reason people breed and sell puppies is to earn money?

OP posts:
Florenz · 29/05/2023 22:08

Farmersswife · 29/05/2023 20:30

Where would health tested well bred show puppies come from?

that’s like saying a farmer shouldn’t make his livelihood from sheep or horse breeders shouldn’t have foals?

There is no need for "health tested well bred show puppies" they serve no purpose unlike sheep or horses.

stayathomer · 29/05/2023 22:08

i don’t know what the solution is, obviously you ban breeding then in the long term you’re making breeds and breeds extinct, BUT the dog situation now is deplorable and isn’t going away anytime soon. ONE of the bigger rescues in Dublin has 157 dogs in it. 157! Their posts scream of desperation now whereas previously they were just telling you about dogs now they’re trying to really foist them onto people

Oh and an Example of the awfulness of modern day society: fb post where a rescue shows adorable puppies- tag after tag of people looking for them.

Fb post with less good looking/ older dog- comment after comment of people saying oh god hope someone takes her. People are so fickle

Wolfiefan · 29/05/2023 21:26

@Wildflowersinthemeadow no. It’s not. They don’t do this to make money. It’s like a hobby. It’s not a business. Or they would be having multiple litters a year to try and make money.

Farmersswife · 29/05/2023 20:30

Florenz · 28/05/2023 20:01

Nobody should be making a livelihood by breeding dogs. It should be illegal.

Where would health tested well bred show puppies come from?

that’s like saying a farmer shouldn’t make his livelihood from sheep or horse breeders shouldn’t have foals?

Farmersswife · 29/05/2023 20:27

I thinking a ban on dog breeders is unrealistic but what is realistic is educating the public. All breeders should be licensed by the council!
All dogs should be health tested
the kennel club need to be a lot tougher!

we are licensed “ breeders” we are very throughly checked x2 a year we show our dogs most weekends we are at a dog show we have bred two crufts placed dogs last year and have 4 homebred dogs qualified already this year. Dogs are our life we live & breath dogs both my young daughters show & compete in the junior handling competitions at shows. We are very passionate about our breed and are heavily involved in the breed clubs & trying to educate the public all our dogs are health tested to the highest of standards.

our puppies are well rounded educated healthy puppies that make fantastic pets they are bought up in our home around children and have a wonderful start we put the very best into all our dogs & puppies.
our dogs live in the house as part of our family and have the run of three acres.

backyard breeders most definitely need to be stopped! But surly regulated/ licensed home breeders is better than no breeders?

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 29/05/2023 19:49

That’s a business …

Wolfiefan · 29/05/2023 19:47

Freedom your breeders sound like mine.
They are passionate about the breed. Show and research extensively to try and make the best matches. They pay for specialist health testing (cardiologist needs to do a heart test prior to mating and puppies need to be liver shunt tested.) They only breed when they want a puppy to keep.
With giants the puppies can’t be left unattended with mum for a month. Someone is always there. So any profit made pays for that time. Or goes to the upkeep of her dogs. (They live VERY well!) Plus covers vet bills etc.
It isn’t a business. It isn’t done for profit. Sometimes a breeder makes a profit. Sometimes they make a loss.

Freedomfromguilt · 29/05/2023 19:37

I know someone who shows and breeds a litter every 3-4 years to get more dogs to show, usually keeps 1 and sells the rest. The lady was horrified at the cost of puppies during the pandemic and refused to have any then because she realised that people were buying puppies because they were bored.
We are currently on the waiting list for a puppy from a different breeder, who breeds for the same reason. We met her and her bitch in October 2022 and she will probably be mated in August, so if everything works out we might have a puppy in October 2023. We are happy to wait because the bitch is beautiful and has a wonderful temperament, we are confident that the litter is being bred for the right reasons (improvement of the breed and continuation of the showline).

Someone else I know has a cross of Rottweiler, Staffy and Mastiff, it is aggressive to people and dogs but apparently it's great with her children. Plans to use it for breeding. I know where I would prefer to buy a puppy from.

LakieLady · 29/05/2023 19:17

Speermint · 29/05/2023 19:08

Showing dogs costs a LOT. And the sort of people who show their dogs are usually spending a fortune on genetic testing and vet bills, taking breeding very seriously. Those sort of people aren’t making money - if anything it’s costing them money. If someone doesn’t show their dogs you don’t want a puppy from them.

One of my in-laws bought a labrador puppy from a non-show breeder. I'm not even sure if it's KC registered.

It's such a bad example of a lab that it looks like a crossbreed. It's over-tall, got a narrow, snipey head, is cow-hocked, has no tuck-up worth speaking of and its back is so square and flat it could double up as a coffee table. It's neurotic and anxious and is constantly having gut problems.

But they love it so much they're going to the same breeder for the next one. 😡

Speermint · 29/05/2023 19:08

Showing dogs costs a LOT. And the sort of people who show their dogs are usually spending a fortune on genetic testing and vet bills, taking breeding very seriously. Those sort of people aren’t making money - if anything it’s costing them money. If someone doesn’t show their dogs you don’t want a puppy from them.

LakieLady · 29/05/2023 19:05

PauliString · 28/05/2023 20:12

I had a nosy at the list of vulnerable native breeds and was really surprised by some of them. Field spaniels, for instance, Old English sheepdogs, Welsh springers, even otter hounds… two or three of each around here. I must be living in a sort of Crufts offshoot.

I couldn't tell you the last time I saw a Welsh springer or OE sheepdog. The last time I saw a field spaniel was about 18 months ago.

I see an otterhound quite regularly though, there's one living near me. If I was younger, fitter and had the time and the space, I'd love an otterhound. They are wonderful dogs ... apart from the buggering off and not coming back.

LakieLady · 29/05/2023 18:59

Wereongunoil · 28/05/2023 20:12

Totally agree with this.

Two of my dogs are vulnerable native breeds and both were bred by people who really care about their dogs

It's one of the things that attracted me to lakelands, as opposed to Welsh, border or wire-haired fox terriers.

Cherrysoup · 29/05/2023 18:49

There’s profit if you don’t give a shit about the health of the puppies and just slap together two random untested dogs and you tap into the current trends of poo crosses and xl bullies. Breeders should start with hip and elbow testing, std tests, genetic tests as a minimum.

currahee · 29/05/2023 18:07

The breeders of my last two dogs produce dogs for sport and work - I don't begrudge them earning money for their skill and expertise in doing so, but it is not their primary motivation.

allthewoes · 29/05/2023 17:29

Florenz · 28/05/2023 18:45

If there were no more dog breeders there would still be RSPCA dogs because some people would mistreat dogs they got from the RSPCA. But there would be far less cruelty to dogs than there is now. The RSPCA could redirect their resources to preventing cruelty to other animals. There would be far few dog attacks and antisocial behaviour related to dogs. It would be a win/win situation for everyone, including dogs themselves.

But there wouldn't be any dogs 😂

Cantthinkofaname2203 · 29/05/2023 17:23

RunningFromInsanity · 28/05/2023 18:39

Properly, ethically bred puppies don’t make money. yes they do. Might not be thousands, but they do make profit on the puppies.

Where did she get the money for this super luxurious motorhome and weekends away?

her and her husband’s full time job?

one litter every three or four years is not going to pay for her showing hobby 😂

Zebedee55 · 29/05/2023 16:05

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 29/05/2023 15:26

Yes let's absolutely ban dog breeding......the poor dogs who are farmed and abused by back yard breeders and puppy farmers will only have even worse times of it.
If you're a breeder you should be health testing and only breeding dogs with no health issues.
If you're looking to buy a pup, you should be educating yourself as to how to spot a dodgy breeder, the right questions to ask etc etc.
Remember that not everyone is suitable for rescued dogs. If you're going to take on a dog with potential behaviour issues, you need to know your shit about dog behaviour.

This.

Rescue dogs often come with problems - not suitable for all people.

Do research, look for a reputable breeder. Breed clubs usually have lists.

dreamonlucid · 29/05/2023 15:59

Forshameandyegads · 28/05/2023 20:37

We bred our Labrador many years ago as we absolutely adored her and wanted more of her. Her daughter was equally delightful. We did not breed the daughter.

We've very recently bred our border terrier as she's the most wonderful dog I've ever met and again, we wanted more of her. We'll keep one or 2 pups.

Both dogs were healthy and in good condition. Very, very much family pets (sleep in our bed, come on holiday with us sort of thing).

The Labrador pups went to family and friends and it'll be the same with the border pups. Yes we charge a fee, but we won't make much money.

We did the same, ended up loosing money as we only had one puppy, we would do it again in a heartbeat, loved the experience we have her son, we didn't do it to make money, simply to have our own dog from a known parent.

We won't breed from her again, but in the future if we ended up with a bitch I wouldn't rule it out.

There is a caravan park near us breeding and stealing pups, keeping them in utterly shit conditions, they are the cocker mixed breeds, they have been reported over and over again and yet fuck all is done, so until that gets sorted I'm afraid the problem will carry on. God know who's going there and buying from them but clearly there is a demand for small brown cute dogs!

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 29/05/2023 15:26

Yes let's absolutely ban dog breeding......the poor dogs who are farmed and abused by back yard breeders and puppy farmers will only have even worse times of it.
If you're a breeder you should be health testing and only breeding dogs with no health issues.
If you're looking to buy a pup, you should be educating yourself as to how to spot a dodgy breeder, the right questions to ask etc etc.
Remember that not everyone is suitable for rescued dogs. If you're going to take on a dog with potential behaviour issues, you need to know your shit about dog behaviour.

Florenz · 29/05/2023 15:19

there are already too many dogs, purposely breeding more is immoral and should be illegal.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 29/05/2023 15:17

I don’t actually have a problem with people making money, especially if that stems from a hobby or an interest. I don’t see it as reprehensible or as wrong in some way.

It is really sad there are animals in rescue, but a lot of them aren’t suited to being family pets through no fault of their own.

Babsexxx · 29/05/2023 15:12

Of course they make money but it’s definitely not easy money it’s around the clock care if done correctly I’ve noticed a big crash in the breeding market anyway people can’t sell them!

PauliString · 29/05/2023 14:21

I would add to that:
Taking back the now full grown puppies, according to contract, in cases of family emergency on the buyer’s part (as happened to a friend of ours, twice).

Groutyonehereagain · 29/05/2023 09:53

A list of what breeders pay for:

Stud fees
Extra food for the expectant mother
Gene testing
Pedigree certificates
Vet fees for the mother
Whelping boxes
Vet fees for the puppies, including vaccinations and chipping
Food for the puppies
Toys and bedding for the puppies
Adverts
Telephone calls

Time and effort involved:

Finding a stud dog
Arranging for the dog to be mated
Caring for your pregnant dog
Vet visits
Caring for the dog when whelping
Caring for new born puppies
Clearing up endless poos and wees
Vet visits for the puppies
Advertising the puppies
Taking calls from prospective owners
Having visits from prospective owners
Preparing all necessary paperwork
Handing over the puppies to new owners
Being available for aftercare calls
Being left with unsold puppies

Forshameandyegads · 28/05/2023 20:37

We bred our Labrador many years ago as we absolutely adored her and wanted more of her. Her daughter was equally delightful. We did not breed the daughter.

We've very recently bred our border terrier as she's the most wonderful dog I've ever met and again, we wanted more of her. We'll keep one or 2 pups.

Both dogs were healthy and in good condition. Very, very much family pets (sleep in our bed, come on holiday with us sort of thing).

The Labrador pups went to family and friends and it'll be the same with the border pups. Yes we charge a fee, but we won't make much money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread