Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How often to call your adult children?

120 replies

tiggerkid · 28/05/2023 17:09

Hi everyone,

To keep long story short, I’ll get straight to my question. I have a son at uni and it seems that he never actually has any time for his parents at all. Whenever I call him, he never answers the phone. Clearly, he must be able to see that he has missed calls but he never calls back. This is regardless of the time of the day or which day I call. And to be honest I wouldn’t say I am one of those parents who call every day. I have tried explaining to him that we just want to make sure that everything is fine and if he can’t answer the phone at a particular time, all he has to do is respond something by text. No success.

When I finally managed to get through to him this week, for about 3 minutes, he gave me just “yes” and “no” kind of answers. When I asked if everything was ok, he said everything was fine and he was just giving me short answers because I was interrogating him apparently. My questions, however, were generally about what he’s been up to, if the weather was good, if he managed to catch up with his friend etc. I was just trying to keep the conversation going amid his yes/no answers.

I don’t actually know what to do with this but his behaviour seems generally quite disrespectful. When we come up to visit him, we usually take him to lunch and after that, he wants to go straight away and doesn’t want to spend a second longer than lunch itself in our company.

He doesn’t remember either mine or his dad’s birthday and basically generally seems to not want to have anything to do with us other than for us to supply money for his university living expenses.

I am not at all saying I am the greatest mother in the world or has been the greatest ever but is that disrespectful or am I expecting too much here and need to tone it down? I generally don’t call more than, let’s say, once every 2 weeks or so. In his first year, I called weekly but then I thought maybe it’s too often, so I cut down on that and try not to hover too much. But even that seems like too much. What would you do?

OP posts:
Greenfree · 28/05/2023 20:18

I would leave it up to him to txt or call you. It's probably nothing personal. I'm in my 30's and call my mum almost every day unless I'm really busy. She would only call me if she doesn't hear from me in a few days

RoseRobot · 28/05/2023 20:07

I sympathise. I can feel that I want more contact than they do. Mine do call and visit but it feels more and more like duty calls. That's OK. They are just entering adulthood. It's healthy for them to want total independence and to break free from parental fuss. I'm trying to not mind. I send them food they love and texts. They call when they need stuff!

girlfriend44 · 28/05/2023 20:06

Hbh17 · 28/05/2023 20:00

He's fine - stop calling him! A couple of texts per week is sufficient. He's an adult, so you don't need to check up on him, and he definitely won't want to talk about the weather!

Just cos he's an adult dosent mean he can't call his parents, he's lucky to have caring parents, sounds like he's taking them for granted and selfish.
He also dosent bother with birthdays?

Just what is he giving or putting into the relationship?

Foodiefan · 28/05/2023 20:06

Mine are past uni now but I text them once a week and ask if they are around for a catch up, they then either call me there and then or say tomorrow would be better. Occasionally I have to remind them, by text the next day, not to forget about me! I get a bit of a shock if they ever call me without the weekly reminder.

Lemoncurd · 28/05/2023 20:03

I told mine that I wouldn't call in case they were busy. Just send a message every so often asking how they are/how an exam or something else they were doing went/what their plans are.
They normally FaceTime soon after I message rather than reply.

nokidshere · 28/05/2023 20:03

I have two sons. One I rarely have to call/text as he's very chatty and either messages or FaceTimes with exciting updates - like what he's had for dinner - multiple times a day. I know almost everything about what he's feeling/doing.

The other I never hear from unless it's a response to my (maybe fortnightly) 'are you still alive and ok' message, his reply is short and sweet 'ye all good'

They are both very independent and don't really need me anymore they've just got completely different personalities.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 28/05/2023 20:02

My DS is early 20s and lives locally with his GF. Didn't go to uni but moved out during Covid lockdown which was a bit awkward - we normally keep in touch by WhatsApp - message every day and see each other normally a couple of times a week . Possibly the enforced separation during pandemic helped him to appreciate our company? Possibly because he knows we'll normally pay if we go out somewhere together ?

I think it's harder if youngsters have moved away to uni and are trying to establish their adult identity away from you.

continentallentil · 28/05/2023 20:01

He’ll grow out of it hopefully

Don’t take it to heart - the world is just opening up at that age, and it’s very natural to be focused on your peers and v board by family - it’s a natural separating from the tribe to become an adult. He’ll come back.

Stop calling honestly, he doesn’t want to talk to you about this day on the phone. Just message once a week (I suggest ‘are you alive?’)

Remind him of your husbands b’day and vice versa. Don’t go up too often. Do take him out for lunch (somewhere fun) don’t ask him about his personal life unless he offers it - he doesn’t want to talk about it with you at this life stage. Do talk to him about life in general or whatever he’s interested in.

You sound a bit lonely and empty nesty, so it’s time to build up the next phase of your life and let him go a bit. He will come back, but it will be as an adult not a child, and you will need to meet him as an equal and develop a friendship.

verdantverdure · 28/05/2023 20:01

My husband works away a lot and we have a family chat to post funnies in and that.

When my eldest goes to Uni we'll just hope they continue to contribute to that and text when they need anything.

I will hate what you describe @tiggerkid, but that's the parent's lot sometimes isn't it?

Our relationship is up to them as well as us.

Hbh17 · 28/05/2023 20:00

He's fine - stop calling him! A couple of texts per week is sufficient. He's an adult, so you don't need to check up on him, and he definitely won't want to talk about the weather!

Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 28/05/2023 19:56

Called my mother every day when I was at Uni, my sister probably a lot less but still weekly. Am now in my 30s with family of my own, always txt daily, phone few times a week and see once ish a week. Regular pictures sent of DD to them.

I do think it's very rude of him not to even text on your birthdays and I would be disappointed at that.

I do generally think boys are worse for this DH seems to speak to his mother a lot more than he did before we were together. I always remind him to check in on her etc x

dottypotter · 28/05/2023 19:56

tiggerkid · 28/05/2023 17:09

Hi everyone,

To keep long story short, I’ll get straight to my question. I have a son at uni and it seems that he never actually has any time for his parents at all. Whenever I call him, he never answers the phone. Clearly, he must be able to see that he has missed calls but he never calls back. This is regardless of the time of the day or which day I call. And to be honest I wouldn’t say I am one of those parents who call every day. I have tried explaining to him that we just want to make sure that everything is fine and if he can’t answer the phone at a particular time, all he has to do is respond something by text. No success.

When I finally managed to get through to him this week, for about 3 minutes, he gave me just “yes” and “no” kind of answers. When I asked if everything was ok, he said everything was fine and he was just giving me short answers because I was interrogating him apparently. My questions, however, were generally about what he’s been up to, if the weather was good, if he managed to catch up with his friend etc. I was just trying to keep the conversation going amid his yes/no answers.

I don’t actually know what to do with this but his behaviour seems generally quite disrespectful. When we come up to visit him, we usually take him to lunch and after that, he wants to go straight away and doesn’t want to spend a second longer than lunch itself in our company.

He doesn’t remember either mine or his dad’s birthday and basically generally seems to not want to have anything to do with us other than for us to supply money for his university living expenses.

I am not at all saying I am the greatest mother in the world or has been the greatest ever but is that disrespectful or am I expecting too much here and need to tone it down? I generally don’t call more than, let’s say, once every 2 weeks or so. In his first year, I called weekly but then I thought maybe it’s too often, so I cut down on that and try not to hover too much. But even that seems like too much. What would you do?

It's selfish behaviour. Feel for you, he dosent sounds like a bundle of fun either.
Has he got much of a personality?
I didnt read anything positive or fun about him? No doubt your paying his uni too.

CuntingSheep · 28/05/2023 19:56

Also... I went to university in the days when you had to queue for a phone box and had to write letters. I think the internet has encouraged people to think they need to be in touch all the time. They don't.

Jeannie88 · 28/05/2023 19:54

When I was at university, before mobile phones and one analogue to block of 7 halls, I made the effort and wanted to call my parents at least once a week, mostly more if I passed a public phone box. They would of course call me but always a nightmare to get through or if I was in and someone had to answer and scale stairs to tell me. Sorry but it really is shit not to easily answer a call or even make one these days! As young students we are generally selfish but no excuse. He needs to buck his ideas up and realise how lucky to have caring parents, which is exactly what I would say to my own child if he does this! X

CuntingSheep · 28/05/2023 19:54

I have tried explaining to him that we just want to make sure that everything is fine and if he can’t answer the phone at a particular time, all he has to do is respond something by text

@tiggerkid In the nicest possible way, if you don't hear from them when they're at university, then you assume they are fine. Mine were/are always in touch with me if there's a problem or a financial crisis. Grin

It is absolutely normal and natural for children to want to separate themselves a bit when they fly the nest. It doesn't mean they don't love you or care about you - it just means that they are discovering who they are. Your job is to be the bouncy cushion for them to land on, if they need to.

It's also partly personality - one of my DC is coming to the end of a year abroad, and has been in touch with me every single day since October, just to say hello. I don't need that contact, but she does, so that's fine too.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 28/05/2023 19:49

I message my mum most days but we pretty much never call each other.

Most of our messages are arranging to meet up (around twice month) or sending random memes, TikToks or photos to each other, or passing on bits of gossip or news.

LindorDoubleChoc · 28/05/2023 19:46

We speak to our 22 year old dd about once a week and can easily spend over an hour on the phone with her. We all message in our fam chat WhatsApp most days. She lives hundreds of miles away from us. I would feel I was harrassing her if I expected a phone conversation every day. It was the same when she was at University.

caringcarer · 28/05/2023 19:45

When my DD was at Uni she rang me once a week on a Sunday evening. She only came home at the end of the term. I went to visit her at each half term and took her food shopping and out for a meal but only for 1 day. Now she is married with 2 son's. I ring her once a month and she rings me once a month so we chat every 2 weeks but text each other every week. My adult son's ring me more often. One lives 200 miles away and rings me about every 5 days. He texts and WhatsApp me too. My other son lives a mile from me so comes by to see me and share a meal each week and takes leftovers for his lunch the following day, but still rings most weeks and text several times each week. None of my DC ring their Dad more than me at e twice a year. He only ever bothers to ring our youngest son.

PartnersInCrime · 28/05/2023 19:42

I can't answer it that way round, I speak to my mum once a week on the phone and text almost daily.... and have done that since leaving home 20 odd years ago.

I can see my DD being like what you describe once she leaves home @tiggerkid !

Onelifeonly · 28/05/2023 19:42

I had a friend at uni whose mother expected him to phone every Sunday at 6pm. The rest of us thought that was very controlling. When he got married a few years later, she refused to attend the wedding, which kind of bears that out. (Though we all thought the marriage was a mistake too and weren't surprised when a divorce swiftly followed.)

However I see now why the mother might have liked a regular call, since she could not contact him in those days except in an emergency (via the authorities).

TrishTrix · 28/05/2023 19:37

Oh and birthdays prompt him.

I still prompt my brother and he is a proper grown up with a responsible job in his forties!

All three of us tend to sign extended family cards from all of us. Leading our only remaining relative to get very confused as she appears to get three birthday cards from all of us! And sometimes even three gifts.

Pallisers · 28/05/2023 19:37

The best way to get a reaction is to post to the family whatsapp with photos of the dog. My sister says the same. He is finding his independence, OP, just let him off. Send the odd text that isn't about him or you. Last text I sent to my kids was a photo of all the tupperware one of them had returned to me after years of taking leftovers home from dinner here. most of the others are photos of the dog. I would only text to ask if they were ok if I knew there was something happening for them.

My dds called me nearly every day when at university - sometimes it was almost too much for me :) Ds probably called once a week or rather picked up when we called once a week. Now he is working he calls me once a week - he has put an alarm on his phone to remind him at DH's suggestion :). It's not that he doesn't like us - he has dinner with us usually once a week and will come away for a weekend if it is local - it is just it wouldn't occur to him. Whereas I get every bit of drama and thought that happens to the dds in real time - they do it to each other too.

ourflagmeansdeath · 28/05/2023 19:36

I can sort of relate, mine never calls and sometimes doesn't answer but he does always call back and responds saying oh i was a at the library etc. but doesn't always seem believable. When he comes home he's nice for the first day and then acts as if we're literal torture to be around and complains about missing uni life. 😥With like no consideration for our feelings. It does seem like we're literally there for money sometimes too but I think the one thing which I can get by is he does feel guilty and he does try, he just clearly has other things he prioritises over us.

Anyway, despite this, we call him daily and message him daily. Messaging seems to happen more but I'll take what I can get.

Onelifeonly · 28/05/2023 19:35

My two are still at home but back when I was a student, pre internet / mobile days, I'd write a letter occasionally (not sure how often) and only phone every few weeks. They couldn't phone me as I used public phones. I can remember not being greatly interested and I wouldn't have wanted to explain everything I was up to. I knew I'd see them soon enough in the holidays. I remember in the 3rd year deciding I'd better phone my mother as it had been 3 weeks since my last call, and she correcting me that it was 4 actually - I felt guilty as I realised she had probably felt neglected.

But otherwise didn't think of my parents much. I knew they were there if I needed them. I imagine I'd be messaging my own kids regularly though - probably not daily but more than fortnightly and can't imagine them not answering, so I can understand it must be quite upsetting for OP.

TBH I've never liked chatting on the phone to anyone. I'm fine with a call to make specific arrangements, otherwise I prefer to message. I was delighted when I first realised I could send texts! (I love chatting in person though.)

TrishTrix · 28/05/2023 19:34

After WhatsApp came along my family mostly messaged. But several messages a day.

Phone calls much less frequent almost always initiated by the children. My parents phoning usually meant something bad had happened. They are both dead now but my siblings and I continue in this manner with a bust WhatsApp group and sporadic actual phone calls. I spoke to my brother today, who has also spoken to my sister recently. But I've not spoken to her for weeks.

At uni my parents never phoned me. I called them probably once a week, more at exam time and texted after they and I got mobile phones. I had a dangerous hobby which also involved lots of rural driving and would text when I was heading back to Uni city after doing it and then again when I got back to my flat.

I also emailed my Dad in those days as he was the only one who had an email account.

In your shoes I'd switch to text/ WA messages and try to establish an expectation of response to "are you dead" messages everything is probably situation normal for university aged kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread