Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To spread awareness of the toxicity of plastic grass?

435 replies

DataNotLore · 28/05/2023 16:46

Here: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35948114/#:~:text=Numerous%20studies%20have%20shown%20that,%2C%20mutagens%2C%20and%20endocrine%20disruptors.

Not only is it bad for the environment but it's probably bad for your health too.

The issues are still being investigated, but:

"Numerous studies have shown that chemicals identified in artificial turf, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), phthalates, and per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), are known carcinogens, neurotoxicants, mutagens, and endocrine disruptors."

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
TinyTopknot · 30/05/2023 13:55

And again - I do not know anyone who has a special bin for garden waste so another crap reason.

TinyTopknot · 30/05/2023 13:54

MariaVT65 · 30/05/2023 13:28

I was pregnant during lockdown 1 so didn’t go outside at all. I stuck to walking circles in the garden and completely wore away the grass. Turned into a big circle of mud.

Also we don’t have bins for garden waste, we have to pay extra to have it collected and it stopped being collected during lockdown. So my DH decided to get turf down.

Seriously one of the crappest reasons ever for plasticking over your garden.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 13:51

There's some info here about "turf burn" plastic grass safety and relative costs plus alternative solutions to fake plastic grass:

capabilitycharlotte.com/TimeForTurf%20Artificial%20Grass%20Report.pdf

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 13:43

MariaVT65 · 30/05/2023 13:28

I was pregnant during lockdown 1 so didn’t go outside at all. I stuck to walking circles in the garden and completely wore away the grass. Turned into a big circle of mud.

Also we don’t have bins for garden waste, we have to pay extra to have it collected and it stopped being collected during lockdown. So my DH decided to get turf down.

Astro turf?

I would have bought grass seed and walked in a zig zag instead. Or round the block. Th we r was a bit of a heatwave in lockdown 1 wasn't there, grad would've come up lovely I would have thought.

We don't have a green bin either. We have a compost heap.

chupachucks · 30/05/2023 13:37

@IncomingTraffic I could write you full papers on a very wide variety of habitats and how a who range of species are affected in various ways backed up with scientific papers, but this is a public chat forum and I'm 100% next to no one is going to read it all.

Ecology is a science in its self, so to say its easy to break it down into chunks and provide more than vague explanations is quite disingenuous and dismissive of the subject. As I've said to others if you wish to dispute the science I provide feel free, but when people trying to defect from the science is not worth my time discussing with them any further.

DollyTrolly · 30/05/2023 13:34

IClaudine · 30/05/2023 13:23

It is so depressing. Sharing your outside space with other beings is such a simple and easy thing to do. I can't imagine sitting out on fake grass with fake plants is pleasurable. What's the point?

Really? What's the point?
I'm not the most imaginative person but I can still understand that, for some people, sitting outside regardless of whether it's real of fake grass can still be pleasurable.

I've lived in lots of different houses all with very different gardens and environments and I've still managed to find pleasure in sitting outside.

IncomingTraffic · 30/05/2023 13:28

@chupachucks actual evidence and explanations of mechanisms matters.

waving your hands vaguely about ecological effects is not useful.

Especially if people are going to imply and scaremonger about harming foetal or infant development with no actual evidence in humans. Because injecting chemicals into a chicken’s egg is not the same as people occasionally walking on fake grass.

Proper, detailed, evidenced discussion of environmental effects is important. Especially if we want to drive meaningful change.

MariaVT65 · 30/05/2023 13:28

I was pregnant during lockdown 1 so didn’t go outside at all. I stuck to walking circles in the garden and completely wore away the grass. Turned into a big circle of mud.

Also we don’t have bins for garden waste, we have to pay extra to have it collected and it stopped being collected during lockdown. So my DH decided to get turf down.

IClaudine · 30/05/2023 13:23

It is so depressing. Sharing your outside space with other beings is such a simple and easy thing to do. I can't imagine sitting out on fake grass with fake plants is pleasurable. What's the point?

chupachucks · 30/05/2023 13:21

IncomingTraffic · 30/05/2023 12:49

That abstract you’ve linked to tells us nothing useful about toxicity of fake grass to humans though.

Issue of toxicity related to leeching of the underlay affecting invertebrates are an environmental problem. Might be important environmentally, but we aren’t invertebrates living in the soul.

The other animal studies evidence there doesn’t say anything meaningful about health effects of walking or playing on artificial grass.

There are toxic chemicals in loads of things in your house and garden. But, because we don’t eat or drink them, they aren’t harmful to human health.

Injecting stuff into a chicken egg is a totally different scenario.

What is the actual risk to human health you’re trying to highlight here?

I could write you a full paper if you like on how this all ties into human health, but its obvious from me you fail to grasp how anthropogenic actions like installing fake grass directly affects our ecosystems and how they directly affect us and how were are dependant on ecosystems for our very own existence.

I'm glad you brought up invertebrates as thought they are an environmental issue and not related directly to our health or existence. FYI Insects and other invertebrates make up 94% of the world’s fauna, the UK alone support nearly 40,000 invertebrate species.

Every single one play a central role in all ecosystem services, pollination of crops ,wildflowers, soil creation, dispersal of seeds, recycling nutrients, natural carbon capture, creating clean water bodies and control pest species and they also assist in wider environmental areas, such as raw materials, flood defence, recreation, carbon storage and even provisions for creating clean atmospheric oxygen supplies.

With out these species there would be no food, no medicines, no clean water etc. The toxicity from plastic lawns also affects all these species and deprives them on habitat and affects their reproductive ability and survivability, which directly impacts all life including humans.

Loss of habitat and pollution is a number of cause of the loss of bee`s, but not fury bumble bees you most likely think of, 90% of the species of the bees in the UK are solitary bees with an estimated 250 species of solitary bee in the uk, that have seen a 52% decline in recent decades (PS Plastic lawns prevent them from mining in the ground and the chemicals releases and Nano plastics also affect them.

Claiming "Injecting stuff into a chicken egg is a totally different scenario." Just proves how scientifically dethatched you are from how every single part of this is tied together and important, Ignorance is bliss I guess.

The bio-accumulation of all the chemicals, micro and nano plastics from plastic lawns and the degradation and destruction they cause to underlying soils they sit upon which can house upto 10,000's of species of bacteria, fungi, amoebae, flagellates, other protozoa, nematodes, earthworms and microscopic insects, all factors into ecology and how ultimately they make our life's far more unhealth and unsustainable.

So to dismiss all this is pure uneducated, ignorance.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 13:20

Yeah @Lockheart I'd rather breathe in terpenes than plastic fumes.

My husband's five a side football team won't play on Astroturf. Injuries are worse apparently and they just don't find it pleasant to play on.

Somanysocks · 30/05/2023 13:08

My idiotic neighbours were measuring up for the fake stuff yesterday. I suppose some people just don't care about nature.

Lockheart · 30/05/2023 13:04

I'd be interested in the mental health effects as well as physical ones.

It is well known that being in natural, green spaces and having contact with nature is good for our mental health. We didn't evolve to live separate from nature.

I wonder about the long-term impacts on those who live in completely artificial plastic environments with no exposure to nature, and in particular the impact on children who grow up in such environments. I think there have been some studies done on the impact of growing up in e.g. high rise flats and it was considered negative in comparison to houses, but there were multiple factors at play there such as overcrowding.

TinyTopknot · 30/05/2023 13:01

Lockheart · 30/05/2023 11:01

It's sick to be honest. Destroying our natural environment so we can replicate that same environment with plastic and chemical scent. It's straight out of dystopian novels.

It is utterly dystopian. And people clearly do not give a shit.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 12:58

Phos · 30/05/2023 12:42

I guess I’ll have to just pave our entire garden then. Sick of the neighbours whinging that we let our grass grow too long and we have dandelions

Plant clover.

It never fried too high and crowds other weeds out.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 12:56

We're not bees either but if we kill them off we're toast.

IncomingTraffic · 30/05/2023 12:49

That abstract you’ve linked to tells us nothing useful about toxicity of fake grass to humans though.

Issue of toxicity related to leeching of the underlay affecting invertebrates are an environmental problem. Might be important environmentally, but we aren’t invertebrates living in the soul.

The other animal studies evidence there doesn’t say anything meaningful about health effects of walking or playing on artificial grass.

There are toxic chemicals in loads of things in your house and garden. But, because we don’t eat or drink them, they aren’t harmful to human health.

Injecting stuff into a chicken egg is a totally different scenario.

What is the actual risk to human health you’re trying to highlight here?

TheHandmaiden · 30/05/2023 12:47

Phos · 30/05/2023 12:42

I guess I’ll have to just pave our entire garden then. Sick of the neighbours whinging that we let our grass grow too long and we have dandelions

It's none of their business.

verdantverdure · 30/05/2023 12:43

America is probably one of the biggest contributors to climate change on the planet but what are the rest of us to do?

Just copy them?

Fuck up the planet for our children even faster by joining in?

Phos · 30/05/2023 12:42

I guess I’ll have to just pave our entire garden then. Sick of the neighbours whinging that we let our grass grow too long and we have dandelions

RoomOfRequirement · 30/05/2023 12:40

chupachucks · 30/05/2023 12:33

It made me realise my tiny contributions in the UK don't really mean anything.

Actually you could not be more wrong with this statement, your actions at home in the UK directly affect the Status of biodiversity and loss of species within the UK.

Wildlife in the UK is in trouble. The UK has lost almost half of its biodiversity since the 1970s. 15% of the 8,431 species are threatened with extinction and 2% are already extinct. That’s not counting the species we don’t know about, just the ones that we are aware of.
Overall 41% of species have declined. Of these, 26% of mammals are at risk of extinction and 22% of bird species have declined. Some animals have fared badly. Hedgehogs and turtle doves have declined by 95% and 98% respectively.

As well as that Micro and Macro plastics go directly in to our own ground water and food chain again localised issues.

This comment was about climate change. Global warming. The things that we need the entire world to change, but having become more well-traveled the last few years I've noticed the UK population is doing so much more than much bigger populations like the US. The politicians there often talk the talk, but ultimately multiple states of people don't walk the walk.

But this is a thread derail, just interesting the UK/US divide on that kind of thing.

Regarding your comment, I'm not disagreeing, it's just one of those things where ME having a plastic lawn isn't going to change any of it. There are many, many, many more things we do as a society contributing and causing more harm. We just decide those things are ok.

chupachucks · 30/05/2023 12:33

RoomOfRequirement · 30/05/2023 12:16

I'm not, but I spend time there for work so apparently picked up some of their words!

And you're absolutely right. Honestly, being in the US so much is what made me get disenfranchised about things like climate change. They do not give a shit there, no public transport, 4 cars to a house, driving a 10 minute walk multiple times a day, 800 carrier bags given per supermarket trip, either heating or air con all like 11 months of the year. It made me realise my tiny contributions in the UK don't really mean anything.

It made me realise my tiny contributions in the UK don't really mean anything.

Actually you could not be more wrong with this statement, your actions at home in the UK directly affect the Status of biodiversity and loss of species within the UK.

Wildlife in the UK is in trouble. The UK has lost almost half of its biodiversity since the 1970s. 15% of the 8,431 species are threatened with extinction and 2% are already extinct. That’s not counting the species we don’t know about, just the ones that we are aware of.
Overall 41% of species have declined. Of these, 26% of mammals are at risk of extinction and 22% of bird species have declined. Some animals have fared badly. Hedgehogs and turtle doves have declined by 95% and 98% respectively.

As well as that Micro and Macro plastics go directly in to our own ground water and food chain again localised issues.

RoomOfRequirement · 30/05/2023 12:23

IClaudine · 30/05/2023 11:56

It does make a difference to other people though, that is the issue. If everyone covered their gardens with plastic, it would have a huge effect.

Except clearly everyone isn't. Everyone is doing the best they can for their lifestyle, and what's important to them. There are a lot of things which would cause problems if 'everyone' did it, but they're not banned.

For everyone in this thread who thinks the plastic lawns look shit, someone else thinks their garden, or house, or car looks shit. Even people having houses in areas with lots of wildlife is damaging their natural habitats and killing them off. People buying and building houses in terraces, meaning no space at all for wildlife. Constantly building roads and shopping centers and pubs and cafes in rural areas etc.

Again, different priorities. Everyone is always happy to get rid of things that are not going to make their own lives harder/less enjoyable, when if they really cared about making a difference their lives would be completely opposite to everyone else's.

RoomOfRequirement · 30/05/2023 12:16

faffadoodledo · 30/05/2023 11:56

are you in america @RoomOfRequirement ? I notice your use of yard not garden. It would be interesting if you were because it could be that things are a little less nature friendly there. I speak as someone who lived there years ago and can see how that could be the case.

I'm not, but I spend time there for work so apparently picked up some of their words!

And you're absolutely right. Honestly, being in the US so much is what made me get disenfranchised about things like climate change. They do not give a shit there, no public transport, 4 cars to a house, driving a 10 minute walk multiple times a day, 800 carrier bags given per supermarket trip, either heating or air con all like 11 months of the year. It made me realise my tiny contributions in the UK don't really mean anything.

IClaudine · 30/05/2023 11:56

RoomOfRequirement · 30/05/2023 11:20

Nope, never. I just lay on it 24/7 in my cocoon.

Or you know, I was replying to the comments about people wanting to actively encourage these things into their yards. I don't. That's not a priority in my life and it doesn't realistically make any difference to anyone else.

It does make a difference to other people though, that is the issue. If everyone covered their gardens with plastic, it would have a huge effect.